Garden City Hotel Reviews

Beautiful, comfortable, good service, good location.

Attended a Gala in the main Ballroom. Excellent service beautiful location could not ask for more

The hotel is beautiful. The staff is attentive and friendly. The rooms are spacious and very clean.

It seems that the Garden City area was built with a master plan, the environment is beautiful, and shopping and shopping nearby is very convenient. Hotel service is in place, quiet and comfortable, a wonderful stay. The fly in the ointment is that the air conditioning in winter is somewhat dry.

Friendly staff. Room is very comfortable and well appointed.

Had a company function there. SO SO food for banquet food

Loved room and very spacious rooms services was great and not a long wait at all

I attended this location due to friend's wedding.. the place is clean and beautiful. There's an outside patio to sit and wait before the reception. The food at the main dining area was impeccable. The seabass and filet mignon was absolutely Divine. The servers were accommodating. I would love to attend an event here again. It's right across from the LIRR, which was a huge bonus for transportation! I got in and out or there so fast.

Always a pleasant experience. Staff is helpful and great non chain luxury feel. From lodging to corporate meetings, a great LI resource.

Brunch is awesome and the food is amazing definitely will go again

Attended a professional meeting luncheon there. Great food, beautiful room.

Beautiful hotel. Very clean, updated, spacious rooms. The bed is very comfortable. Meeting and event space is classic and well maintained. The entire staff is attentive and friendly. They also have really good black and white cookies.

I was there for garden City senior prom. Food was great but the DJ was bad

This was the first time I had ever been inside. I was only there for a seminar. Gorgeous hotel. Delicious food.

Lovely venue! Great to have a nice hotel close to home in Long Island for events. Friendly staff. Clean bathrooms

If anyone is looking for bargain deals for hotels go over to . made a reservation for a hotel room on there and they had the best rates just about anywhere!

Large rooms. Updated bathroom with waterfall shower head. Upgraded amenities. Mini fridge in the room. Lots of natural sunlight. Picture windows...blackout curtains if you want to sleep. Service was impeccable! There is a fireplace in the lobby with cozy couches. You can dine al fresco. I would definitely stay here again. Tucked away but close to all! Great staff!

Decor is excellent. Went for brunch nice selection just wish the hot food was actually hot. Other than that it was great.

Beautiful, well-appointed hotel, excellent service, great location in Garden City, nice amenities, I highly recommend.

A great dining experience at the restaurant with perfectly cooked steak.

Went to the Garden City hotel for a wedding. Overall it was a good night, Great food. The hotel was under some renovations but still was very cleann I wasn't entirely impressed with the staff. A waiter spilt water all over my phone and instead of apologizing he tried to quickly just run away and avoid it. I didn't even end up saying anything since it wasn't damaged or anything, just found it rude. Thought the staff in general would be a lot more friendly/happier being that it is a high end location.

This place was very nice. Staff was super attentive, they care about old school service.

Very trendy and updated hotel with a large wedding hall. The food was above average with amazing cocktail hour and pretty decent filet mignon for dinner.

We had lunch there Sunday at the bar and the bartender Kyle was very honest, pleasant and attentive. We met one of the managers, his name is Gary and asked us if everything was ok and if we needed anything he was there for us. The food was excellent which included filet mignon and a ribeye. Grilled to perfection. We also met a very nice couple and became friends. It's a happy place. We will definitely be back.

Very nice,friendly high class hotel but priced nicely.

Best hotel in Garden City. Upscale, the staff is excellent. Definitely at the top of my list on Long Island.

Great hotel that is very comfy with everything you would expect from a huge chain

Went to an event here. Very nice decor. Nice open dance floor and stage. Little light on the pours. Food was rasty and well prepared.

The lobby of the hotel is very nice and spacious. You have to valet your car though even if just going for the spa. The spa is also very nice and the staff are so courteous and pleasant.

Good hotel won't go further than that. All the elements of a good hotel are there. What makes it 5 stars is the amazing, friendly, helpful staff. Especially the bellhops.

I was at the Garden City Hotel for a wedding. The venue was quite beautiful. The staff were incredible and very helpful.

Very good service I highly recommend them I am 100% satisfied

Classic "old hotel" feel, but completely updated. Service was great, room was large, and although the beds were small they were nice and firm.

Excellent location for a Long Island visit, and easy access to the city by car or by train, which is just across from the hotel!

Very nice hotel, staff was friendly, entire place was clean.

We were at an engagement party. The room was lovely. The service was impeccable. The food was well made and plentiful.

went to the hotel without realizing it was the wrong location for the red door spa (there are 2 half a mile of each other)/

I was there for a company party. The staff was as courteous as always.

It's really the only game in town! lol If you need to stay in a hotel in Nassau County, there's no other choice. I recommend.

My grandson and I visited the Polo Lounge restaurant for a late dinner. The staff was friendly and attentive to all our needs. The food was great! My grandson loved his chicken strips and french fries (who wouldn't?!). And I savored my Lobster Bisque (Perfectly Executed) followed by tender aged filet mignon.... (I cannot rate dessert as I was too stuffed to eat it.).

Room was the perfect size, customer service was great

Classy hotel with top class customer service. Ellie is amazing and was so accommodating and competent

We were attending an event and it was great. Through property was beautiful, the staff couldn't have been more accommodating and the food and drinks were delicious. The property is about a 2 minute walk from the train so it's very convenient.

My favorite place to stay while on Long Island. Staff is welcoming. Planning a trip back and would not consider any other hotel.

Sunday brunch is my family favorite here. Everything is offered from fresh oysters, lobsters, steak, everything you can expect from the Garden City Hotel, just like a wedding. the only dislike is the lines, very long lines that for some reason I think can be improved.

The suites on the 6th floor are connected to each other. You'll have a suite with sitting area, kitchen, bathroom and bedroom and from your sitting area there's a door to the adjacent suite thats locked unless you get side by side suites. Sound carries through this door easily which can be annoying of you have rowdy neighbors. The patio bar outside is amazing

I stayed here for one night recently as I had a meeting nearby. The building looks ok outside and in. Our room seemed in good condition with a spacious comfortable room. There were two dated aspects of the room. The only way to switch on most of the lights in the room was reaching under the lamp shade to get at the switch, nothing on the wall or the base. Also, no table level power outlets that I saw. The WiFi is AT&T wifi and roughly $13/day. The location is good. It is across the street from the Garden City LIRR stop. Also, it is a few blocks walk from a variety of shops, restaurants, and other businesses. The service was friendly. We did not eat in the hotel, so I can't comment on that. The room service prices were expensive but perhaps typical for New York.

A lovely hotel, luxurious rooms & friendly staff...well worth a visit

Went for a wedding, very nice place. Right across street from LIRR

Really nice hotel. Courteous staff. Excellent brunch options. Great indoor and outdoor bars.

The place has seen its best days all behind them. Suggest the structure be reassembled and elsewhere at a later time. Putting me and my date in a parking lot and telling me it's an extension of KING'S Court GO GARY Staff food and service - 5x

I had the pleasure of staying at this hotel a few weeks ago. I was referred by a client and couldn't say enough great things about my stay. From the booking experience to when I left, I had a top notch experience. The rooms are amazing - the grounds are amazing - the restaurant is amazing - the staff is amazing! Would definitely return and would recommend to anyone.

Stellar service and attention to every little detail.

Great staff and large rooms. Could provide water in the rooms for such a high service standard instead of charging $5 a bottle

Here for the Rose Soiree. It was beautiful, well organized and the good and drinks were delicious. I will be back.

Not worth it all! You re better off at the Marriott! I wasn t pleased at all. The penthouse suites are awful I can only imagine the regular bedrooms. It s very outdated and unclean. Sometimes I feel as if hotels need renovation no matter how much they clean it. I didn t feel anything luxurious about the Garden City Hotel. Please don t waste your time or money!

Bedbug ridden place - Stay Away! When I approached concierge about this issue - I was told that they are aware and they recommend to sleep with my clothes on. The quote: "This is NY and bed bugs are very common even in Long Island". I left the next day. No way I paying over $200 per night to stay there.

Beautiful facilities, excellent and attentive staff, dining is very good.

Everything was beautiful from front to back the service was very good the workers a very good no complaints

Fancy Hotel on Long Island
Very nice banquet dept. Enjoyed a wedding last month

Very good staff were helpful, train station opposite the hotel which went into manhatten

The Red Salt Room was great. Very good service and yummy crab wedge salad...

Very nice hotel with a red door spa. Staff is very friendly.

The hotel was a great hotel to visit clean,employees were polite very and professional.The breakfast was great.