A New York Pizza House Reviews

Very good pizza. The appetizer of mozzarella dollars that we ordered was over cooked. But amazing Pizza we will definitely come back.

Fantastic. The calzones are huge! Big enough for a couple people.

Wow this is not just a pizza place, is an awesome Italian restaurant!! The stromboli dessert was amazing and so fun to share!

The gluten-free pizza was great The wings were great. Service was excellent! Would go back again.

Great new outdoor seating area and beer taps inside!

Drove a ways to get pizza before closing but they closed early cuz they weren't busy. Closing time says 10 pm even walked in but was denied

Today 09/12/18 -The manager at this Cocoa Beach store was the rudest Lady that I have ever done business with, we've ate at this place for years. Mainly pizza, however we tried the fish basket but the fries are horrible and when I asked the manager if we could buy just the fish only or substitute a side order. She yelled into the phone that her management would NOT allow price changes or to substitute the sides and then hung up on me. I would have paid the same price, I just didn't want them nasty fries with my food that I pay for! They think because it's a tourist area that they can get away with being rude to their customers, you, Well they can't because I am not a customer anymore!

The best pizza ever! Great wait staff. Huge portions. Omg!!! Great place to order for a party I'm sure.

This place is always amazing!! Our waiter Chris was very friendly and helpful! Thank you

If you LOVE you're pizza late and cold this is your place

Pretty decent place to eat pizza. Prices are fair and the service was great. Brandon you were an excellent server.

They offer a 26" pizza that's great for a group of 5 or so, a little slow on service and I've had better NY style pizza in the middle of VA!

Wow....horrible service, but my calzone was the size of a basketball--HUGE.

Good food. Super friendly server. Loved the Calzone. We ordered a small pizza with no cheese ($19) and a few veg. Very high $ for what that was. Had to take a point off for that. Good place to stop on the way to the beach.

Food was disappointing. Place was very dirty. Service didn't care

They have the best queso dip I have ever had!!! Service is great but is a little slow so be patient.

Great food. Waitress was very helpful in my selection. I got calamari and a Philly cheesesteak. Both were fantastic. Very reasonable prices too. I think the best part of the Philly was they make their own bread. Will definitely come back next time I'm in town.

A must stop for N.Y. Style Pizza. Outside dining area... (Covered patio with fans). Awesome service. Thank you TEAM N.Y. Pizza House.

Great pizza!! Great service! HUGE portions of food!! Shannon at the Bar, is awesome and quick service!! We came here during Spring Break, after leaving another pizza place, as we waited forever at the other restaurant. So glad we stopped here!! Definitely would recommend THIS pizza place!! All of the food leaving the kitchen looked amazing!!

After waiting about an hour for a fish sandwich and philly cheese sandwich .... We figured its the "paint job". Where's the brotherly love cocoa beach?

Best food ever! Always good! Decently priced! And these freakin tortilla chips, lemme just tell ya, me and my fiance drove an hour and half for these chips lol. Soo good! You must come here!

The stuffed meat pizza slice was awesome and filling. Price was great too.

Though this is a well known local pizza place, their cheese steak will blow any cheese steak place out of the water. Huge slices for like 2.75-3.25, beats any local pizza places, HERE IS THE PLACE TO GO

Fettuccine Alfredo is great. Pizza is also very good!

Service was sub-par and pizza was mediocre. I ordered the pie at 8:06pm on 26 Apr 17 and it took 1 hour and 20 minutes to deliver! The receptionist who answered the phone to place the delivery order was short and disinterested in explaining the menu (realize there is no pricing listed on their website).

I was staying in a hotel and asked if the pie would be delivered to my room or the lobby and she confirmed that it would be to my room.

At the hour mark of waiting, I called back to get status on the pie and was greeted by the same disinterested employee who properly stated that it was on its way and then ended the call.

The delivery driver delivered to the lobby contrary to what I was told my the restaurant causing me to change to retrieve it.



My overall impression was that this shift was heavily manned my young employees who lacked in customer service and care factor.

I will unfortunately not me returning.

The pizza and seafood stew was amazing! They give you a lot of food and it isnt unreasonably priced.

Awesome pizza and great service. Definitely recommend this restaurant.

Good food and price large servings casual atmosphere.

Our group of 8 all got different delicious food. I got the calzone which was the best I have ever eaten. We are headed back to Maryland but will be back in tje near future.

Delicious pizza and nice customer service. Love all the menu options and the staffs willingness to offer suggestions. Definitely a great place to stop for a slice!

Some of the best pizza in Cocoa Beach! We're from Atlanta, Ga and have to order when we're in town. We also love their Greek salad. The dressing is amazing and we get it by the pint!

Great food for the price. Sounds like it would be fancier than it is but delicious just the same.

This is the best pizza place I've been by far, I went here a few times and also got it delivered, delivery is usually super fast. They have some of the best pizza that I've had. I would definitely recommend this to anyone looking for a good slice in the area

The best part of this pizza for me was the crust. It was thin, brushed with olive oil, generously sprinkled with a salt and pepper mixture. Not overwhelming it was flavorful and it got all over my fingers so have wipes or towels handy.

The 16-inch pizza was a generous size. I ordered mild sausage, black olives and extra cheese. Cost was about $14 with delivery + tip extra. It took about an hour-and-a-half for delivery although I was only a block away. Mine was delivered last on a list of deliveries spanning quite a distance. Thought I had accidentally ordered from Kissasmee. After a quick phone call to verify it was on it s way, the pizza arrived warm and delicious by a very attractive driver.

The flavor was great. No promises on delivery times so don t order hungry or have pre-pizza snacks ready. Pairs nicely with fresh squeezed local orange juice or White Gold White Peach Wine from Florida Orange Groves Winery (100% made from peaches!)

Its so good! The food is great! The people are wonderful! I love the idea of the noodle straw!

All the 5-star reviews are from the old owners and cooks, NOW! It sucks, used to be great now forget about it!! A waste of time and money!!! Go to Bizzaros!!!!

Food was good and plentiful. Many gluten free options if that's your think.

Great salads and great pizza. The 26 inch pizza is huge and great if you've got a big family, or just want a lot of leftovers.

Yummy pizza. Slow but friendly service. We went on July 4th.

Was not happy the toppings did not cover the whole pizza it seemed like they were only on a third of the pizza

We ordered a stake n chess w/fries $8.00, slice pepperoni pizza extra chesse $3.00and a Italian sub w/fries 8.00... stake n chesse had very little meat. Fries where pretty good. Pizza was on point! It took 1hr 20min to get our food. Disappointed with that. Pricing wasn't bad. 2.50most slice of pizzaFountian drinks are 2.50. Have lots of dishes.

Philly cheese steak with fries $7.99, great price for really good food. Service was average at best. Well it's been 5 months since I was last here and I'll say not much changed with the service but the pizza had gone from really good to really bad, wet noodle bad. Super thin crust not even cooked though out. Don't think they can win me back after this

Loved my Waitress great food every time. Try there creamy balsamic vinegar it s amazing

Just sat down and waited to be served for 15 minutes no one came by... We left.

So far the best NY style pizza I've. Found in the area. Love the 26" pie

The food quality is amazing and the portions are worth the price...

A great NY style pizza the family enjoyed while in Cocoa Beach for a few days. Hotel had recommended this pizza place and we took them up on the suggestion. Enjoyed the Unique 26" pizza and a huge Italian salad. A great value place and some great greasy NY style pizza. Pizza crust was a bit burnt - but not bad - tasted great - and we've never seen a bigger pizza! Salad was very good and worth the $8.

Pizza was good. Not amazing but still good. Nobody care into the place the entire time we were eating (late at night. An hour or two before closing) so if you like quiet dinners that s the best time. They use noodle straws to drink out of which is cool but I m a slow drinker so halfway through my drink, the noodle was soggy and broke apart.

The food was OK really soggy to me, also the service was horrible very very slow. They served our salads and we waited 5 minutes before we even got silverware .. I don't eat here much at all and I'll keep it that way

Was very pleased with the service the portions and the price...went thinking I could eat it all and was proven otherwise...wonderful meal

We are here while on vacation! It was amazing! We sat outside under the tent. Out server was Mitchell and he was really good and helpful about what to get, refilling the kids drinks! Way to go! Sad we don't have one back home!