A New York Pizza House Reviews

Don t go here. The waiter I m sure was high. The service was slow. The food was greasy and not good. $70 for some nasty food that I could ve gotten better at a fast food joint.

The pizza was amazing and there was definitely leftovers. This place is family friendly too. Service was weird because of some people acting funny... But the food was great!

Awesome place with great crusts. I've had the gluten free, regular and stuffed. Loved them all. Very reasonable prices and great food.

My last visit there, we got the smallest pizza slices, was just like any other pizza shop- huge rip off. Better off going somewhere else. Have been going here for years and have always loved their GIANT slices- was a great deal for the money, don't know what changed. Horribly disappointing.

Went out for dinner with my traveling friends.
The place tired to serve us under cooked bread three separate times, the manager did come out and tell us they cook the bread twice so it was cooked. Showed them the undercooked bread and they continued to deny. Never eat here they have a system of placing the Blame anywhere else but here.

Service 0/5 Food 0/5 Atmosphere 0/5 MGT 0/5

Absolutely terrible place! Skip this trash hole!

The staff were amazing. Super friendly and truly cared about us and what we thought of them. I highly recommend this place because they care about your experience at their restaurant

Dude, get a calzone. Wow. They were huge and so tasty. Great place for lunch.

We had the fish fry. The tartar sauce they have is really good! Very good food and service. Recommend!

Crappie service I visited with my Family 3/26/2017 at 7:30pm and a employee with a bad looking none trimmed bear saw my small group jump over us and told to others "I kick this othrs out" reference to my lil daughters which was sitting outside in one of the dirty tables. THAT'S WRONG SR! We just say Thank you for your CRAPPIE AND POOR SERVICE WE JUST LEAVED THE TINY PLACE. BAD SERVICE BAD EMPLOYEES. Never again.

Pizza greater than or equal to what I get at my pizza places of choice up here. Delicious. Great atmosphere in the restaurant too.

I had the most amazing experience with this place! I am in a long distance relationship and asked if they could make a pizza for me to have delivered to surprise my boyfriend on Valentine's Day. Not only did they make an amazing heart-shaped pizza, but I asked for a little note to be included on the box and they went above and beyond to make it adorable! So kind and really made the delivery special. Would totally recommend this place - and will be going there in person next time I visit!

Delicious pizza. Good prices. Free parking..Within walking distance of resort. Delivery service available. Will go again!!

Was in town for vacation, heard about this great pizza place. Called to order and was put on hold for 10 minutes and called back was put on hold for 7 minutes. Terrible services

If ever in Cocoa Beach A New York Pizza House is the place to go. Great eggplant parmesan! Great pizza!

Being from NY, their pizza is pretty good. Love the eggplant parmigiana meal! Great prices & staff friendly.
I am a late eater, wished they stayed open later but everyone needs a life out of work.

The 1/2 Harvey Cheese steak was AMAZING!!! So much meaty, cheesy, pepper & onion goodness! I won't wait another 12 years to come back.

They completely jacked up our orders. Party of 8 and 2 of the ladies didn't get their order at all. When asked if it was on the way, we were told yes, but when one of our party went inside to check, they found that they were just starting to prepare the missing food. Just not a good eatery... would not recommend.

Love their pizza by the slice! Really good sweet tea. Great service too

Love it! My family and I were in the area and needed something to eat while traveling. Great food at a great price! If we are back in town we will eat here!

Mac n cheese egg rolls are incredible! Calzone is huge!

The veggie dip and calamari are the bomb! So delicious!

Great pizza and really good pastas with fresh shrimps. The portions are large so perpare to take some home

This place was incredible, this has to be one of the most authentic New York style pizzerias in the state of FL. Having been born and raise in the NY/NJ area, I have to say I'm a foodie, a food connoisseur, having said that I've tried countless Pizzeria's that claim to be "NY style" in the SW FL and South FL areas, None come close to this place. I've traveled well over 3 hours just to eat that this location.
If you like fried Calamari, you have to have it from here. A New York Pizza House will make you feel like you sitting in the middle of Manhattan (just don't look out the window). Its a my go-to pizza place when ever I'm in the Cocoa Beach area. Its a must have!!

Food was delicious. The 26 inch is HUGE. Will def. be back.

The best ny style pizza around,huge pizza and calzones

Alot of food and it's was so good!
The calzone was gigantic!

Doubt the owners are from New York. A New Yorker would know how to make a proper cheesesteak, with American, not Mozzarella, and no green peppers. So sick of these places putting cheesesteaks on the menu when they don't have the proper ingredients. Stop cheating your sandwiches by putting pizza cheese on them. What a joke! If your from up North, eat somewhere else. You won't be satisfied with this phony. Zero Stars.

Should be renamed A CoVid Pizza House. Egregious lack of compliance with Cocoa Beach mask law passed on July 8th. Greeter did not have mask on, kitchen staff either lacked masks altogether or were not fully covering their face with them. Basically was a weak, half-hearted attempt and in hindsight we should have just walked out immediately. Pizza was decent but no coronavirus worthy. Buyer beware their coronavirus droplets could be all over your pizza.

We loved this place!! The pizza is awesome and the service was great! If you want an authentic NY pizza, come to this place and hit the beach across the street!!

Our experience was memorable but for all the wrong reasons. The pizza was pretty good.. But it took an hour+ to arrive. Poor service, mediocre food.

This pizza is incredible!
We had a wonderful dinner before our cruise.
This being our first time visiting. We had no clue what we were about to enjoy. Was not for our server. We would had order way to much for 7 customers.
We will be back to try so many other items on your menu......

Food was great. Try the garlic knots that are not in the menu. Sat outside and service was horrible. Computers went down and was told would have too wait until they fixed then, close to 20 minutes later.

Always a wonderful place to go. Great food, portions, price, drinks and also big for my family (GLUTEN FREE). #lovefl

Didn't get a chance to try the food because the staff completely ignored me for at least 20 minutes before I finally left. They were too busy chit-chatting to notice me in the nearly empty restaurant.

My friend and I decided to sit outside because of the beautiful weather. The tables weren't washed when they were bussed, therefore they were super sticky. The waiter took 5 minutes to take our order, an additional 15 minutes to get our drinks out to us and 34 minutes to bring our pizza out. I started the timer after I my mouth started to feel like sandpaper. I was staring at 4 dip pouches because people are gross & the staff isn't cleaning. I saw a guy try to change tables just to get service because he also was not receiving timely service. The party behind us was so loud, that I LITERALLY couldn't hold a conversation across the table. My friend had to switch her seat and sit next to me just to converse. If you let horrible service happen it makes me question the kitchen and the stuff we can't see. The stoner who served us made us feel unwanted and we felt cast off. He is an example of why people won't leave tips. I don't even know his name. He never told us or maybe he forgot he had one

Service was outstanding and the scallops and pasta was awesome

THEY DONT WEAR MASKS DON T COME. Used to love coming here. Food is not worth the service.

Food was made to perfection and service was awesome! I will definitely visit again.

Stopped in for a quick slice of pie and beer. Great service and pie under $10 meal!!!! Great job NYPizza I'll be back

The pizza was delicious and the sauce was great!!!!

Their eggplant Stromboli Oh what a great Stromboli

Food and wait staff are great! It took some time before we received our meal and ticket, but the wait was worth while! The portion sizes are ridiculously large for a great price. I had the meat calzone, after I finished laughing at it's size, I got to enjoy it!

I ordered the meat calzone and it was so good, I would recommend this place if your tourist or aren't around the area because they are quick and very good with their food. 5 stars all around

Great pizza and the antipasto salad dressing is awesome.

It was good the pizza was huge. Waitress was kind and helped with the menu. All and all it was a great lunch and had plenty left over for the evening.

We had the Greek pizza and it was delicious!!! Very generous portions and toppings! Highly recommend!

Excellent gluten free menu. It's our go-to restaurant when at the beach. Always consistent and wonderful service!

The tomato sauce in my chicken parmesan was old and there was hardly any cheese

We had a great experience here. Food was terrific We had a calzone, cheese dip, and hot wings. All three were terrific! Portion sizes were huge. It does take a little while to get your food but it s very fresh and well worth the wait. The only complaint I have is the cheesecake is awful. I mean really awful Try the brownies instead. overall we would eat here regularly if we lived in this area.

Our families favorite! Service is great! Friendly people with great food. Price for the amount of food you get is unbeatable. We eat here several times each trip. You will leave full & with leftovers. My Favorite is the Philly Cheesesteak Calzone! Pictures don't do it justice.. this thing is huge crust bubbled up with massive toppings inside!! And of course garlic knots. We've never been disappointed and will keep coming back.

Checked them out online May 2018 when we were in Cocoa Beach. Sounded good. Came back Feb 2019 and decided to give them a try. AWESOME Pizza. Tried the Fried Mac-n-Cheese Won Tons. OMG. They were AWESOME! Our server Travis was also AWESOME! Fast service and the placenwas pretty clean for 8:30pm in a Monday night! Keep it up guys! Great place to eat!

The sign when you walk in says seat yourself, so obviously that's what I did. I sat down and for 10 minutes the employees looked at me and never said a word to me. Nothing at all. Horrible service, next I'm in town I'll go somewhere else.

Pizza was undercooked and did not taste fresh. Mozzarella balls inedible and fries soggy. Kids wouldn't touch any of it... a real disappointment!

Pizza was ok, but the time that the cashier quoted, was a bit optimistic. Love the bar and pizza all in one package.

Really great pizza! My favorite as a local! I get delivery most of the time, dining room is a little out dated. But I highly recommend the Pizza!

Amazing food, service & I promise, you will leave with a midnight snack..Thanks Kyle Martin great service

I would not even give this pizza place a star my Greek salad came it look like it was in the fridge Frozen waterlogged, the tomatoes were fresh but the Other Tomato looking thing was - well let's say I had to spit it out- the pizza was soggy and well the only thing that I really liked was the shock top and that was draft. I would not recommend this place sorry you guys have to do better. The salads shoild be fresh and the mushrooms should not be out of a can! The other thing I had to give this a one-star or I couldn't post this text but it's really a no star

Don't order the enchiladas. Bleh!! Said it came with beans and rice. It didn't. I asked about it and they brought me beans and rice soup. The soup had green peppers. They tried to tell me it was celery. It was not celery. The pizza was good.

We always have pizza here when we come to Coco Beach

This place has the best pizza in town! YUM! Everything on the menu is REALLY VERY good! The jalapeno ranch dressing is really good, but get a pint of the house dressing to go, coz you can't get enough of it!!!
The people that work there couldn't be nicer and they have TV's to watch your sports. It's just all around a great place to eat or pick up your food for your room or on the way home from work.

Low quality pizza! You can notice that they use cheap ingredients, making it absolutely overpriced.
We took the leftovers home and the next day was just awful !

To waiter Juston - only brought 20 dollars with me. Didnt expect drinks to be so much. Sorry, I owe you one! Next time I see you I'll have a big tip. Thanks for the excellent service.

Great food.. huge portions..very casual vibe. Loved it.

Perfect! We ordered Sicilian slice and Veggie Foccacia, really delicious. The tomate sauce was incredible and the crust was crispy, and the price is very reasonable. A good NY pizza!

I was pleasantly surprised by the menu variety at A NY Pizza House. Usually when a place has too many options, the food ends up being mediocre. We started out with queso that was amazing. It had a secret ingredient that we couldn t determine, but my kids demolished it. My spinach salad was excellent. The Philly cheesesteak was delicious and the fries came out hot and crispy. The pizza slices are ginormous and loaded with toppings. This place looks unassuming on the outside but it s worth a try. Food was excellent and we will be back.