A New York Pizza House Reviews

Ooouuu that pizza took me back to my home town NYC the bronx pizza Mmmm

A lot more than just pizza. A lot.
Seemed hectic even though it really wasn't.
Food was great
Speed was adequate
Cost was higher than norm in area
Service was good

Themed as a New York pizzeria, this restaurant has been a favorite recommendation of Cocoa Beach locals for several years. This year I finally had a chance to try it.
The New York theme ends with the name. Neither the patio seating nor the indoor decor were very reminiscent of a New York restaurant. The atmosphere was simple, clean, family friendly and relaxing. Casual dining to the core. Trays of food passing by me look appetizing and the portions were large.
Two families were dining on the patio at the insistence of their children, all appeared happy but I could see and hear the parents wishing to be inside where the dining is air conditioned.
I ordered a seafood themed pizza for take out. The wait was reasonable and there is a bar area where I could wait. The pizza was good with a nice selection of shellfish and their "signature" marinara sauce. The sauce was tasty but their chosen cheese blend was bland. The crust was my main issue. While tasty. It lacked the crispness of a New York pizza crust. They claim a brick oven but the pizza showed no evidence of this. A higher cooking temperature would have provided the crunch this pizza soarly needed. A good pizza but not great nor was it very New York. The pizza itself was an honest seven out of ten.

Best pizza in Cocoa Beach. Try the vodka sauce pizza.

Great pizza and prices. Stick with the 16 inch. It will feed your whole family. The waitresses were cool too. I had the meat pizza and it was great.

Just ordered delivery to our hotel. They were 20 minutes over the estimate, no apology for the wait. The pizza was tasty but greasy. The biggest disappointment was the dessert they are known for; the mackin slice. Terrible. Not anything like the menu depicts. Decent pizza but avoid the dessert.

Pizza was just okay. Spaghetti sucked badly. Straight from a can. Dont waste your time or money

Pizza was absolutely delicious, however it took the waitress forever to take our order and she never came back to refill our drinks.

Ordered a pizza for pick up and when I went inside not one staff worker had a mask on , on the day that Florida just posted the highest new cases Of COVID for a single day For the entire nation

GREAT experience! the service was amazing, the seating was cozy and comfortable. THE PIZZA ...OMG DELICIOUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Insane portions of exceptional pizza/pizza variations. Make a reservation, this place is always busy.

Excellent service, prices and good enviroment. we will come back!

This place is great! We were looking to get pizza for lunch and stumbled across this place. The food is excellent and the service is fast and accurate. Could not get over how reasonable the pricing was. Totally recommend this place if you want good pizza.

we always receive excellent service when we come here. The house dressing is beyond amazing. My husband always gets the pizza and I get eggplant Parmesan or fettuccine Alfredo and both are so good. We love this place

If you want that authentic pizza/calzones from the tri state area NY/NJ this is the best spot in Florida.

I originally gave this 4 stars but went back a couple months later and the pizza wasn't cooked all the way through. We took it to go, so didn't realize it right away. I will say the servers are very friendly but it does take quite a while to get your food. They do offer a military discount :)

Great food, price, and service. Awesome pizza, wings, and lemon pesto mussels. Must dip your wings in the homemade blue cheese dressing.

Excellent food at competitive prices. They have the best pizza I've found since I came to Central Florida over 7 years ago! Plenty of TVs for watching sports games. Staff is always very friendly!

The food is Awesome !!!!
The waiters that you need to ask are either Brandon Or Alex they are best
The wings are to die for
Pizza are great
Atmosphere is great!!!!!!

I was there for an hour at lunchtime on a Saturday and i saw tables go unbused for a majority of my time my food was overpriced but ok. My sever didn't seem to be doing anything. The cook was the one who finally. Came out to clean the tables. Overall very disappointed

Delicious food and great service. They even have a gluten free menu! Our family had a combination of gluten free menu items and regular menu items and we were all very pleased and left very full and with enough leftovers for another meal.

Service sucked, very slow even though the restaurant was empty, but the pizza was really good!

Best pizza in Cocoa Beach, slices so big you won't believe your eyes

I went here last night for a pizza & wing fix and decided to come back for lunch because I loved it so much. Pizza was amazing, wings were delicious, ordered penne vodka for my toddler and it was very flavorful. Staff was great too. Food takes a while to come out, but i imagine thats just because it's freshly made.

I literally waited over the 45 minutes for my food which was told to me how long for my order to be deliveed,it was an hour I ordered a small extra cheese pie it was ok but needed more Italian seasoning in the sauce.I also ordered a ham and provolone which barely had meat or cheese on it had no onions,or oregano like I asked and the tomato & lettuce looked like they took it off the salad bar.I did not ask for a hot sandwich plus the guy who answered the phone said I could not get a half of sandwich that's not good business,the fries that did come with that I did not ask for plus they were wet & soggy.Before you make food for a customer ask if you want it hot or cold smh it was hot & utterly disgusting was this sandwich and I only took 2 bites,the dog enjoyed it better than myself.You would think for $24.36 I should have had a better quality sandwich,the delivery guy was nice and friendly so he get 5 stars for his excellent customer service.Well I had better pizza on last night when I just had it by the slice oh well I've won't try it a 2nd time nor will I waste money like that on food I didn't enjoy..I will stick to the restaurants I know & love in Cocoa Beach my taste buds are screwed I can get better with a Publix sub!!!!!!
Not happy at all and it would be a waste of time trying to get a refund so no more of my business will you ever get rip off.I WOULDN'T SAY THIS PLACE IS INSPIRED BY THE BIG APPLE I'M FROM NY/NJ THAT'S AN INSULT TO THE PIZZERIA SPOTS UP NORTH!!!

Very friendly staff. When I asked for iced tea, the server brewed A new pot so it would be fresh. Pizza was some of the best I've had, and I've eaten a substantial amount of pizza. One of my favorite foods. We ordered a full pie. Nicely cooked crispy crust. Not too thick or too thin. The sauce was delicious! Nothing to complain about at all. I absolutely recommend this to anyone in the area and would stop in again!

From pizza, pastas and salads , this place is great. Food with flavor ,color, and big servings.

Food was just fair. Crowded and not very clean. Waitstaff were very nice though, and tried hard to provide good service under adverse working conditions.

Love the pizza here. Me and my husband come from Orlando just to eat the pizza or the calzones. Both are HUGE! And the price isn't bad either. Keep up the good work guys.

They over the top rocked it during a hurricane. Thank u for the hospitality and home town service. U made a stressful time good.

The pizza was pretty good. The garlic bread was excellent. The service was terrible. No one came by for a long while after our initial order. The place was busy, so it's likely management's fault for not having enough staff.

We ordered a 26 inch pie. Good pizza - great price.

Long wait decent food, that's all that needs to be said.

Great food reasonable prices good service. All the tv stations

The rudeness here when ordering for delivery would make you think they have more business than they need. In fact, this exemplifies what has happened to this once fine restaurant. Do not be hungry when you order your food - because you don't know when you will get it. And the quality gas suffered in the last year. Customer, be forewarned.

We stopped here while in town for spacecoast marathon. Ordered stuffed shells and a side of meatballs...
Order was ample to split with two people, great for a date night!
Red sauce is not overly spiced...
Employees are friendly!
We ll be back to try more of the menu when we are back in town....
Thank you Brandon for the great service!

The pizza was good with a great crust. You have to try the Mac and cheese we rolls, the best!

Pizza do good, we yearly drive from WV just to eat it!

Super good! The macaroni rolls are deadly. Service was also good.

Really great pizza from a little store. The pizzas are gigantic and they deliver!!! Excellent!!

Good NY style pizza. Fried calamari were really good. Service was great!

Totally AWESOME food, great prices and incredible service!!!! Best waitress (one of 9 kids in her family ) we have had in such a long time. Sat outside, enjoyed the cool weather, and some family time together!

Love the phillycheesetake pizza and the mackin slack dessert!

This pizza place is delivery, carryout, and dine in. They serve alcohol also. If you come here bring your appetite they serve huge portions. The food is very good. I am from Chicago originally so I am more of a deep dish person. That's why I gave it a 4. But I don't think you will regret it. I would recommend the calzone. If you bring the kids their pizza slices are giant.

For claiming to be new York the pie we ordered was average not really special and not bad either. The menu contained 0 beverage options causing everyone to ask what they had. There were no lunch or dinner specials. A local woman who as she stated many many times was in no rush, harassed customers by attempting to promote the resteraunt but was really just interrupting and obnoxious to the group across from her.
The workers claimed to be from New York and while the slices were large the pepperoni was thick cut and sauce was bland. Waiter was attentive.

Had a 16" pizza with our favorite toppings, and a couple beers all was very good ! Waitstaff was very helpful and very friendly!

Food was wonderful. Staff very friendly. Walking distance from our hotel. Was able to watch the football game on TV, there were many. Prices were also great for what you got. We couldn't finish it all and had to take to go! Have noodle straws!

3.5 too much sauce for me, not quite N.Y. style, but close

never had a bad meal here,, the pizza and subs are very good

Great salads and garlic knows. Mozzarella cheese is awesome too, a must try!

Great pizza, fair prices, cheerful, knowledgeable staff! They even know where the closest nude beaches are. LOL

Very rude manager. Shouted at me and said they don t deliver that far and before i could say its okay i can go pick it up she hangs up the phone

We went here tonight. I ordered lasagna and a kids portion for my grandchild. They came back and said they didn't do a kids portion so I asked that they take my portion and cut it in half put it on two plates and bring one for me and one for her. When they brought mine out (My husband's food came out WAY before mine did) it was only half a piece, but they didn't bring My grandchild's. When we pointed that out she said she was going to go get it. She came back and said they JUST made my portion but didn't make Make my grandchild's. She said they were heating it up right ten and then walked off. I had taken a bite of mine and it was ice cold. It took us 15 more minutes to get our waitresses attention. By that time I was DONE. We told them my food was cold but not to worry about heating it up or getting our grandchild's food. At that point she said oh well, I guess the manager can take it off the bill...ummm you think! This use to be one of my favorite places to eat but the last 3 times it's been horrible. Three strikes you're out. I've learned. Never going back and I'll try to keep everyone else from going there too.

Many celiac friendly options and staff is very knowledgeable. Lasagna was a big serving and very tasty. Pizza wasn't bad. A bit greasy but overall pleased with flavor. Would definitely recommend and visit again if in the area.

Really good food at a very reasonable price. The place itself needs a little love and could use some updating.

Really go pie. Had to order the 26" just to see it Great crust and sauce

Awesome place!! Will definitely be back and highly recommend!!

One of the better pizzas I have had since moving to Florida. Reminded me alot of the pizza from back home. The price was fair, the staff was great. Overall a great small little place. Highly recommended!

We come from Cape Canaveral for lunch every couple of weeks and really enjoy it. I usually order a slice of pepperoni or two and sometimes a side salad. They have an extensive menu covering pizza, salads, pasta, sandwiches and more. The only issue we have run into is service can be slow. Lately that has been rare and we'll keep coming back.

I hate to rate this so low because I normally enjoy this place. However, today I had a pretty bad experience all in all. I ordered pizza for delivery which I received an hour and a half later. I called an hour into waiting requesting an update and was told that my food was ready but they had no driver. When the pizza finally arrived it was cold and the cheese seemed to have congealed oddly being left out for so long. Very very disappointed...

Placed an order last night for a medium calzone and a 10 piece. I should of known that doesn't Total out to 35.00 +. But it didn't dawn on me until I received my order and there was an 18' pizza with my order (did not request one). Called to try and fix this mistake . I ended up on the phone with the lady who took my order originally and she was just plain out rude. I tried to inform her about the miss communication, and all she did was insist that I did indeed request the pizza. If I have an intend on order 2 particular ideas, why would I say I wanted an 18' when I never did??.. she wasn't patience nor kind. As a front desk agent at a hotel where I'm close to your establishment and the amount of guest I recommend to your restaurant. I here by further will no longer send any of my guest to you a n.y pizza. Your customer service is horrible and because of your employer, I'm out 18.00. May not seem much to anyone but now a days , I must save as best as possible. Thanks for not understanding!

Largest slice off pizza and the seaside on our is awesome.

Pizza was ok. Too soggy and wattery . Portion was big and service was great! A little bit on the pricey side though.