A New York Pizza House Reviews

Massive ABSOLUTELY MASSIVE!! shrimp and scallop Stromboli!!!!

Macaroni and cheese egg rolls with pineapple salsa Superb!!!!

OMG perfectly poached shrimp in the shrimp bisque

And the chicken cheese EnChilada s aren t shabby either...

These folks do mad business and they hustle hustle hustle all these waitstaff and cooks pizza makers are bustin A !!!

The menu is huge the prices are way better than the average especially for the area It was a blessing to have my Sunday meal there.

Had an awesome gluten free pizza. Really good sauce!

Had dinner at the bar on a Wednesday night. Place wasn't too busy food was great. Try the cheese bites, they are hand made not frozen

The housemade sauce for marinara was very good and they were accommodating for taking cheese out of my baked ziti and garlic knots. The garlic knots were OK enough, but being from Nashville, TN, I would change up the bread to something closer to our pizza place called five points pizza. The garlic bread was more like garlic rolls. They were good, but just needs to be 'tighter'? The nachos left something to he desired, as the cheese seemed to be simple grocery store shredded cheese and too well baked onto the chips instead of melted.

We re from out of town and wanted a late dinner. This place was close to where we re staying, so we gave it a shot. The food was really good (we ordered the mac n cheese egg rolls and a pizza), the server was really nice, and the experience was great. And their prices are really fair. Definitely recommend.

Went with my family to celebrate a birthday.I got baked stuffed shells, they forgot the garlic knots that wasn't a big deal. The birthday girl got a pasta dish with shrimp, and field greens. Can't remember the name of it, but the shrimp were extremely overcooked tough and the field greens were like the greens you get for a salad and they weren't sauteed or anything they were just thrown in there bra it was very tough hard to eat. she doesn't like to complain so she wouldn't let me say anything to anybody. Service was good I guess it just depends on where you order

Always stop in here when at the Beach. Great pizza.

Great pizza-- really good product. Inconsistent with service.

We love this place. We come here every year. They have the best pizza in Cocoa Beach. You must stop here on your vacation!

Pizza was great! Service was good. Portion for entrees was large. No complaints

Service was excellent. Eggplant roll was delicious. Local beer. Price is right.

This place is a little slice of heaven. You can get a pizza the size of an SUV. They have an extensive menu of pretty much anything anyone could want, and it's actually delicious. It's amazing.

Not bad but not great either. Place is a little run down and did not look too clean. I would probably pass on this one.

They turn away costumers that come off the beach because they are in bathing suits! No posted signs! Will not return or ever recommend to any one.

Food was good and portion sizes were large. Service was a little slower due to it being quite busy, but very friendly. Gluten free options available. Walking distance from several hotels for a convenient dinner or lunch option with covered outdoor seating area.

Food was very good, customer service was fantastic!

The pizza was amazing!! And the calzones were HUGE!!!

Decent Pizza though not the size of New York's, still good Pizza.

Very good pizza melts in your mouth seafood Delicious

Food was so bland and service was horrible... The sauce for the pasta had zero flavor and just the overall experience was far below average.

Calzone and pizza are great with big portions fairly priced.

I thought this place was amazing value for what you get. Their price was cheap and their pizza was HUGE!!! No exaggeration. My pictures don t even do it justice. The create my own was killer, but the white pizza is why ingave this place a 4 star they put wayy to much ricotta cheese on it. It looked good but when it came to eating it, it didn t taste good. I would easily go back to this place again hands down.

Awful awful awful service.... food was just ok. Too bad you can't put 0 stars

The food was amazing and the staff was as good as the food. Everyone was nice and my beer was never empty

Awesome customer service, the pizza taste great and they got big chicken wings

Good pizza and good service can be found here. We were a group of 7 and we were seated fairly quickly; pizza was hot and tasty. If you're planning on visiting Cocoa Beach, plan on eating here at least one time.

Very rude when answering the phone. Clearly did not want my business. All I wanted to know was the weekly specials. During working hours 830 PM I was told were closed before hanging up.

Without a doubt the best pizza and the best Italian food in Brevard County.

We came during spring break this year. They were incredibly busy, and it took quite a while for us to be seated & even approached by a waiter. I was just about ready to leave when I saw the food come out for the table next to us. It was Unbelievable. The portion size of the pasta, pizza and stromboli!! The bread was homemade and fresh out of the oven. SO glad we stayed! DELICIOUS! A MUST for anyone who loves pizza, Italian or just really good food.

Good sauce! Don't skimp on it. It seems that toppings of peppers and onions are more for their artistic garnish effect rather than gastronomic satisfaction, and they do look nice, but a little larger on these toppings would make them taste AND look good. Love the meatball sandwiches and white pizza! You will also find the antipasto, as well as looking exceptionally good, is as good and accurate as its Northern cousins'. a rare thing in The Sunshine State!

OMG!! THIS PLACE IS SO GOOD UNBELIVABLE GOOD NICE SERVICE AND THE BETTER PRICES!! THE BEST HAPPY HOUR EVER :)

Waitress was awesome food was amazing. Will def be back if we ever come back to coco beach!

We were in Cocoa Beach for 2 days and ended up coming twice as it was across the street from the Sheraton. The first night it was busy but we experienced good service and I ordered the lasagna which was a huge portion and very reasonably priced but more importantly delicious. We also got the garlic knots which were very dense but tasted great. Order slices of pizza the second visit which was less enjoyable but huge slices for cheap.

This is the BEST pizza in Brevard County!! I've been a Bizarro fan for years but am now converted. A NY Pizza is hands down the BEST

Big serving sizes but all very delicuous. Closest to NY style since moving for NY. Tortillas were fresh and delicious and good flavor cheese dip. Calzones were HUGE. Pizza Slices are HUGE. Highly recommend

I have never found a pizza I didn't like until today, our food was awful! Even my 6 and 10 year olds refused to eat it. :(

Great food, low prices, and staff member was child friendly!

AWESOME PLACE!! Fast service, clean restaurant with ample seating inside and out. Beware most menu items will come to your table with LARGE portions. Prices are excellent! We review this as having the best pizza, calzones and wings in all of cocoa Beach! We highly recommend this place to anyone and everyone. We look forward to returning on our next adventure to Cocoa Beach!

Food was good, they may want to rethink the quesadilla.

Really enjoyed the pizza, but salad was filled with unexpected pickled veggies - way too spicy. Wife did not like. Decent prices. A bit run down. Friendly staff.

Went there a couple months ago. the girl who served us was extremely nice and the food was amazing! Definitely worth going to again !

Would love to tell you about the food but we were never seated. Waited 15 minutes at the door and were finally spoken to by a server as they rushed by. Meanwhile that entire time there were multiple people in the kitchen area standing around doing nothing. We left and went to papa Vito s had an excellent pizza there with great friendly service.

Awkward setup. Large slices, but the pizza itself left a little to be desired.

The five stars are mostly for the service although the pizza was great too. My waiter was attentive and friendly.

Best Pizza on Coco Beach. If you get time I highly recommend you stop by for a slice.

We loved our food here! Everyone's plate of food was much bigger than expected. My calzone was enormous. Everything tasted good and the prices were low for the amount of food we received.

EH, not even close to the pizza places google said were comparable. The eggplant parmisan was really aweful in practically every way. It looks GREAT but falls short on quality of the bread, sauce and the fact that the eggplant itself was completely tasteless. If not for covid, I would have sent it back, but i want to support small businesses. My kids enjoyed the pizza but they will eat practically anything. ETA : the pizza sucked, too.

Best pizza I have had in Florida so far had a slice and it was great everything tasted fresh was a perfect hand tossed crust will for sure be back when ever I am in town

Best salad dressing ever! I ve been ordering the house salad with the house dressing for YEARS! Can not get enough! Don t ever take this off the menu!

Best place ever. Thank you all for outstanding service and help with my 4 year old granddaughter not feeling well. Very caring people. Thank you again for all your help.
Your friends from NASA/ Langley, Hampton Virginia.

Seriously GOOD Wings & Pizza. Can't wait to GO back and try the rest of the food..

Excellent food wish there was one in Clarksburg West Virginia!!

Every single variation of Pizza Slice I tried was so good. Excellent staff as well.

Awesome food, Great value, some of the best staff of any restaurant I have ever been to!!!

The food was alright but the service was lousy. We ate outside and our waitress basically forgot about us for an hour.

Pizza and mozzarella dollars are amazing.... Everything is huge!!!

Very delicious food! Wish we lived closer so we could go back.

The food is great and the staff awesome. Good prices. Will definitely be back!

Every time I come to Cocoa Beach on vacation, I come here and get a calzone, they never disappoint

Bought 2 slices, 1 tasted like it was made hours ago
The other wasn't much better. Never going back.

We drove from Cocoa to eat the early bird special which we had been told was from 2-5. We got to the pizza house at 4:50 and when we asked for the early bird menu was told it was 5:15 and past the early bird. We showed them it was 4:50 so our waitress went back to get the menu and was told they weren't having the early bird tonight without an explanation of why. We asked her to check again as we had been told earlier that there was an early bird. She came back again and said no early bird tonight. How strange and so pitiful that the manager didn't come over and explain why. So we left and went somewhere else. We were disappointed and probably won't drive over again as there are plenty of restaurants that honor their specials and are happy to have customers. I can't imagine the restaurant owner is too happy with his manager, that is, unless he is the manager as well. So sad, as we use to enjoy eating here but won't be again.

The size and taste of their pizzas and calzones are out of this world

Calzones are amazing. Great portions great prices !

Pizza was awesome but the place could use a good cleaning

We were a little hesitant to try this palce, it is not big or flashy by any means. But MAN are we glad we did! The food was amazing, the service was friendly. Portions were big. I would for sure get the queso and chips and of course, a New York style pizza! Want to try something new and a little different? Get the queso and mozzarella bites, dip the bites into the queso=flavor explosion! We will def stop back by on our next vacation through!