A New York Pizza House Reviews

Very accommodating. We were a large group and wanted to be served family style. Big bowls that we could pass around and share. Food was good, service great. This a a great restaurant for families.

Fraud Alert! After you go here make sure you check your credit card statement!

Huge portions!! Very affordable. Pizza was good. Nuff said.

The only thing good about this place was the service.
-The garlic knots were not cooked all the way through
-The Greek salad was loaded with pickled vegetables (cauliflower, carrots, red peppers, celery)(seriously, who does that?)and we weren't offered a typical salad dressing for it (They gave us the house dressing, which was maybe a creamy red wine dressing? I'm not a chef)
-The Italian wedding soup tasted like it was from a can. Legit Progresso brand with a single meatball.

They are known for pizza, so I imagine that would be good but I would steer clear of any other menu items.

Edit: We ordered pizza for delivery and it was good. +1 star

First of all I went to literally 9 tables before finding a partially clean to sit at then it took awhile for the waitress to come. The pizza was delicious but the hot wings were AMAZING. I am so happy I ordered them to go. The way I assaulted those wings did not need to be seen in public. Lol

Flat beer and the veggies on the pizza were out of a can. The muscles were great with the pesto sauce. And the veggie dip was out of this world. Just wish the pizza was better.

The BEST and very reasonable prices. My wife has celiac and they have the absolute best gluten free mac and cheese here. It's a meal and I steal her food too! Most of the time gluten free options are a compromise and over priced but here they are delicious. Lunch specials are cheap, tasty, and fill my tummy.

We shared a meal with family here and sat outside, which was great for young kids who need to move around. The location was convenient and right down the street from the resort we stayed at. Good food.

Awesome pizza and great service! Will definitly return!

A N.Y Pizza House was delicious. They had huge, yummy pizzas. The largest pizza you could get was 26 inches! The pizza was a little greasy but really worth it!!!

the best pizza in cocoa beach. Great salads too and nice fresh mozzarella. Only bad thing is that wait times for delivery/take out are sometimes very underestimated. Give it a try, but only if you've got the time.

The pizza by the slice could be fresher it was a little dry. Service was great.

Best pizza in town! Big menu with lots of options, great service, and the pizzas are HUGE! We go here every time were in town. You wont be disappointed. Be sure to get the mozzarella bites and mac n cheese!

Great food for great price! I am a pizza snob and I love their pizza

We went after the Falcon Heavy test launch. A friend that was with us needed gluten free. They had a very extensive gluten free menu. The gluten pizza was great. Review of the gluten free pizza was great also. Service was haste but very friendly. Will definitely go back.

Our server was very polite, pleasant and took good care of us. Unfortunately I forgot her name, but she is the pregnant one.The pizza tasted good but I am used to a softer, foldable NY pizza, this crust was crisp. We also had the chips and queso which had a descent flavor but the chips were extremely greasy. We are only here for a week and I doubt we will go back this resturant if we want pizza.

This place is worth your time! Huge pizza slices, amazing chocolate covered cannoli, and garlic knots are great too. Friendly staff and good customer service. Will definitely be coming back on my next trip to cocoa!

The very nice and familiar place, eco-friendly, the food super rich, has outside eating area and a bar inside. Supra clean balos, have wings, salads, pasta, pizza and more. All salsas are prepared by them. Luis treated us very well. And in Spanish. Thanks, Luis.

I've had good experiences each time I've been here. The pizza has always turned out fresh and delicious and the garlic knots are wonderful, as well. The only comment I would have is in regards to how long it took for us to actually receive our food, but it wasn't too big of a deal, as our family was enjoying conversing.

Food is amazing. Always fresh and just plain amazing.

The best pizza of the whole florida in quality service prices and delight.

Manager hung up on me, ABSOLUTELY NO RESPECT TO VETERANS. Was calling to inquire about lack of toppings. Very rude! Ripoff! Go to Pappa Vito's instead.

Slow service for a generic meal. There were 4 servers, we had the worst of the bunch, about 20 - 25 tables and they had problems keeping up. Avoid.

Fast service and delicious food, not to mention, the waiter was super friendly!

Amazing staff and food. We staid in Cocoa Beach for a cruise 2 times now and have fell in love with this place!!! Thank you again for the great dinner!

Best friendly value place around- the calzones are amazing

Beware. You get big portions for the price. Great service. Great food.

We planned to order a large pizza for the two of us so we could have leftovers to eat the next day, but the server judged us and talked us out of it. This lowered our bill considerably since we just ordered a couple of slices, it reduced her tip. 20% on a $35 pizza would've been a lot bigger tip than 20% on $10/2 slices. I guess she makes enough with customers just ordering slices?

This is the best pizza in Florida. I look forward to eating here every time I come to Florida. Great calzones too.

Brandon was an awesome waiter. Great food. Look forward to it every year.

Greatest food especially for the $$$...huge portions and the best pizza in the land. Service people are friendly, courteous and create a great atmosphere. A must if you are near Cocoa Beach...house dressing to die for...huge pizza, thin crust for me personally...did i mention a Key West Amber Ale!!!!!!

Good service & good food. Tried a NY pie, the stick with chicken & alfredo, & chips. Sauces are delicious & they had drafts for $2. Family friendly & clean restaurant. We'll be back whenever in Cocoa!

not from the area but everytime I'm in the area it's the only place when it comes to Pizza in the Canaveral area I would eat plus it's worth the money in the large slices...
The crust was perfect the slice was to my opinion great and well-done flaky crust it wasn't one of those thin type slices like paper had a good thickness.

Great chicken cheese steak, nice outside seating and dog friendly

Great food, large portions, friendly staff. Love this place.

Went after a rocket launch and let me say, this is an absolutely awesome Pizza joint. Comfortable environment with incredible food at a low price. They also have the largest pizza i've ever seen! When the waitress brought out the 26" pizza the entire restaurant gathered around some customers table and started taking pictures of it! It was monumentally large. They also have a fantastic gluten free food selection and they are very careful with people who have gluten intolerance. I would gladly make an excuse to drive all the way out to the coast just for some pizza here. I will definitely be back.

Ok pizza, staff was kinda slow, nor so clean as one would like, but I was late in the evening

The pizza was great the waitress was the best I have ever seen

HUGE PIZZAAAAS Awesome people work here! You guys Rock!

Giant portions of great food. The Hunts Point salad is a beast.

If you know ny style pizza you will love it. I live in Indiana but come here every year for the pizza. It's phenomenal. If you have never had NY style pizza you will soon love it too.

Our pizza was amazingly good at a fair price fed 4 for under $30

I purely come here for the house salad dressing- pizza is decent but only when the salad dressing is dipped with it. It s the best salad dressing I have ever had, and I can t seem to replicate it so I ll have to come back every time I m in town. I try and learn a little about the recipe and how it s made but the recipe is an iron clad secret. I completely understand because it s really a gift from heaven. Thank you owners for endowing my life with the creamy balsamic or whatever it is (literally every waiter has always told me something different) Delicious! Don t ever change it or I ll freak out and you ll just have to send me the recipe. :) Thank you!

The food is really good if you can get past the filthy floors, dirty smelly restroom, sticky filthy tables and chairs, oh and our waiter for the last two visits was filthy! He looked like a freaking mechanic with dirty clothes and also had flour all over his clothes. uuuugh! It's so bad now, I won't even order take out. If the public places are so dirty, what the hell does the kitchen look? yikes. they don't care, either, because I have told them 3 times the place was filthy. No longer a customer.

This place is a must try for our stay in Cocoa Beach we ate here twice the food was awesome the atmosphere is great will be back.

Amazing food and great service!! My daughter and I had a great time here.

Called at 9:30 on a Friday night and were told they were closed even though it says they don't close til 10pm.

My go to pizza place by the beach. Been many times, never have had a problem. Pizza is really good. If I remember correctly they had a lunch special which was one huge slice of pizza and a drink for like four or five bucks. Great deal for a great pizza.

These pizzas were HUGE, ordered a 26" and only 4 slices of ot could fit in 1 box. But the food was great, I didn't dine-in however.

This came recommended by someone at our vacation condo. We went there and were never served. In fact we stood waiting to be seated for 4 minutes as one employee after another walked past us. The employees behind the counter sat there and looked at us. WTH? We left.

The staff is getting bitchier by the week. Why is that?

Food was good. Large portions at reasonable prices. Friendly service.

Eat here!! Eat here!! Driving around trying to decide where to stop just got shorter, this place has the best tasting mixed foods in town. I was totally blown away with the layered careful preparations. The stuffed slice with everything is decedent and with the sweet marinara delectable. The meat stuffed slice almost melts in your mouth. The fish and chips were presented with near perfect seasoning and a spicy tartar that was the best I've ever had. The queso was delightful and cheesy perfection with thick smooth dip that hinted of a fine gouda cheese correctly seasoned, presented at the perfect temperature dipped with crunchy crispy almost flaky chips that are a glorious combination. I am complete again. Travelling so much that when excellence presents itself I will tell others. I urge you to come out and try these slices of heaven, I got mine to go, and it rocked my world, friendly staff. Call in and order some, I promise you will not be sorry. ***** flavor beyond my expectations.

Yummy pizza, fast service and a cute, young waiter. What more can you ask for? :-)

Food was bad. Had pizza and was highly disappointed. Should have got me a frozen pizza at the grocery.

Best pizza in Cocoa! By far! And they have a chocolate stromboli!! To die for! Erynn was the best server! Efficient, attentive, not overly in your face. Great service!

Stromboli with extra sauce was great! Pepperoni slice was definitely not fresh.

A N.Y. Pizza House- Cocoa Beach, FL- 3.5 stars

After watching "The Untouchables" for the hundredth time the other night, I was channeling my inner Al Capone and cravin' some Italian grub. After donning my fedora, I headed up towards Cocoa Beach. I know what you're thinking. Really? You are going to get authentic Italian style food in Cocoa Beach, Florida?Fuhgeddaboudit! However, you would be mistaken. Sitting rather unassumingly just south of 520 on Hwy A1A is a quaint little piece of Goombah heaven known as, "A N.Y. Pizza House."
While not much to look at on either the outside or inside, they sure know how to cook up standard Italian street fare. I entered and sat at an open table. Soon a young obviously overworked server approached my table. She stated in a customary way that her name was Ava and followed that up with the cursory, "How may I help you?" I started with a Philly Cheesesteak Roll, followed by an order of Baked Ziti and ended the whole shebang with a slice of deep dish pizza. A few minutes after she left she reappeared with my order. Within a few bites of my Philly Cheesesteak, I was looking around to see if Rocky was jogging by as I swore I had been instantly transported to The City of Brotherly Love. The roll was fresh and delicious and practically oozing prime cuts of aged steak and cheese. I then moved on to the Baked Ziti. While the sausage was fresh and flavorful and the peppers cooked to a perfect al dente, the red sauce looked better than it tasted. It seemed bursting with freshness but was exceedingly bland. The accompanying salad was the standard Italian one with a side of fresh blue cheese dressing. The tomatoes were fresh and crisp to the bite and the blue cheese was real. The jewel to be found here was the freshly baked homemade garlic roll that would make me consider running whiskey down from Canada so that I could eat some more (that's not illegal anymore, right?). With my mouth bursting with the joy of their garlic rolls my eye spied a slice of Heaven still perched atop my table, the feta and spinach stuffed deep dish pizza awaits! I eagerly dug in and was not disappointed. The sauce was a perfect mix of herbs and spices, the inside was overstuffed and exploding with real goat's milk feta and garden fresh spinach. Big Boy says if you pass this place up for lunch, you're a real mamaluke!

The food was very flavorful and so much of it! I got the Daily Special which let me choose Soup or Salad, Appetizer and Main Course for $13.95. You have got to try the Fulton St Fried Clams with homemade tartar sauce. Our server Jake was very attentive without being intrusive. Will definitely return to try other items on the menu.

Great pizza at fair price. Staff is extremely friendly! Come here every time we are in Cocoa Beach!!

Huge pizza slices, fresh bread great for families! Patient and accommodating

The pizza is next to none. Go there when you have a good amount of time to kill and an empty stomach.

Best pizza sauce! I love N.Y. style pizza and this is great N.Y. style Pizza.

Great selection of delicious food. Waiter was knowledgeable about items on menu and was attentive

They have the best calzones. They re not just any pizza!

Love the pizza eat here every time we are in Cocoa Beach.