A New York Pizza House Reviews

Pizza was good - but the staff was awesome. Really enjoyed my dinner.

Ate at this place twice on our 4 day visit to cocoa beach. Food was so good and the service was great!

The pizza is absolutely delicious. Great service with take out and delivery.

Food was delicious. Portions were generous. Will definitely visit again if ever back in the area.
Lucinda Barksdale

Amazing food. If you love a real NY pizza, dont miss this one. The calzone is just indescribable. Undeniably the best I have ever had and large enough to easily feed 3 people. (Seriously)
Had a mess up with delivery recently and they graciously addressed the problem. They really care about their customers.
What an asset they are to the area.
This is an affordable, high quality dining choice. Not a mixture of qualities that you find very often. Go. Now.
Thank me later.

Great food, generous helpings at a really good price.

Pizza is great, macaroni n cheese eggrolls awesome, spaghetti and meatballs not good

Great value. The cheesesteaks are bomb and worth every penny/ minute you wait! Pizza was tasty but I would have liked more cheese and thicker crust. Very nice staff.

Food was good and staff was friendly. My server was a delight to meet.

Pizza is the best in the area. Service is a little slow but pleasant. Today it was very good. I've never had a bad pizza and I love there salads.

Slices are huge, think before you order more than one. Waitstaff was friendly.

Awful, rude and unsanitary! Which is a shame because the food is really good.

Love love love the noodle straws! Good pizza, nice people.

Food here was delicious and in large servings so baked Mac and cheese was enough for two people as was the Chicken Alfredo. We ordered two pizzas that were delicious, but we also ordered the recommended baked ziti that never showed up. We were served in a pretty slow fashion but we surmised it was due to under staffing and busy time. We've had better service, but our server was quite nice. She did, however, never refill our drinks and I'm not sure if that was also due to unexpected manning. Would we return? Yes, definitely worth another visit considering everything.

The portions are crazy considering how affordable the food is. The pasta, pizza and calzones were all great.

Shout out to Justin who was a great server. He was on top of everything and super friendly.

This was our first time here but definitely not our last.

Excellent food! The portions were huge and everything was made to order. A bit slower than many places who have prepared common choices and parts of various items in advance, but worth the wait. It was so good we returned for a second night to eat here again! We tried a couple of different types of pizza (whole pie as well as the by-the-slice), a calzone, stromboli, the chocolate stromboli desert, and the (real) gelatto. It was all amazing. The only issue we had was that even after our food came out the service was a bit lacking the second night- the waiter seemed to disappear and we couldn't get drink refills or our check for quite a long time. Still I would come back because the first night the service was just as good as the food

Large slices and great pizza. Stop by if you are looking for good NY style pizza.

The food it's always delicious. I get the hunt Point salad and I kept the 26-inch cheese pizza for myself and my kids to share. You get several meals out of it. My beef this visit was there was a proximately 12 people in the kitchen and prep area. All close to each other not social distancing. Not one cook, food prep person, server was wearing a protective face covering in the entire restaurant.

The food was great but the atmosphere was maybe a little too casual.

Best Pie and sandwiches in Cocoa Beach, reasonably priced quality food!

People were friendly, but it was the sloppiest pizza I ever ate. Just constantly dripped and didn't taste very good. I was only able to stomach one slice.

So I'm going 5 stars because the food quality is always great. Their house dressing is so delicious! We have great luck with takeout and have had so so experiences with dine in, but they are one of the few places in Cocoa Beach that seems to be trying to follow Covid protocol. I am never disappointed with the Scampi or the Alfredo pizza.

Not bad pizza but, there were a couple of issues. The crust was undercooked, a little doughy. The oven it was cooked it clearly hadn t been cleaned properly in a while as all of the chunks of burnt leftovers were on the bottom of our pizza. The sauce is definitely good though! We have been here several times before and didn t have any problems. Maybe it s just a bad day.

Large basket of fried calamari - excellent. Sauce served with it was fantastic, not too spicy, not to sweet, just right. Pizza with works was the best I ever hard. 18" size could easily feed 6 people. Other item are wonderful. Service was exceptional. You have to try the place

The waiter was very attractive, the food was mediocre. I ordered Penne Vodka with chicken. The chicken was frozen and tasteless...

Can't go wrong with this place the food is always good here. The service is always a little slow and it always seems like they have problems with being short-staffed

They don't use bulk sausage, it's sliced like pepperoni....never saw that and didn't like the taste. I'm used to Wisconsin's clumps of meat on a pizza I guess

Was a very busy Saturday night and they were understaffed so things were slow. But the beer was cold and the pizza came out hot. It was worth the wait.

If you don t enjoy the food and hospitality here, you re too picky. Great Good. Awesome service!

Food was good, loved the mozarella medallions. Brings out pizza dough for kids to play with.

We ordered delivery on 10/27/2019 at 5:30pm. The person answering the phone did not seem happy to be there. I can recognize the voice, but do not remember her name. On this order, very simple Eggplant parmigiana dinner with side salad and a Harlem Philly with unseasoned fries and no sub roll. She said we will get it there as soon as we can. In fact, I called at 6:36 as a follow-up call to find out when it was going to be here and the same person who took the order said it will be there in a couple of minutes. I really do not know what the point is to take a phone number when they do not call you and follow-up and let you know that your food is going to be delayed. The food arrived at 6:50pm. One hour and 20 minutes later. When the driver arrived I had to check everything. The salad was supposed to be just romaine, cheese and house dressing. It came with croutons. He read the ticket back to me regarding the salad and it was not noted no croutons. I paid the driver and then we opened everything up and it was not piping hot. It was lukewarm. As a test, I put butter on the Harlem Philly and it would not even melt. The fries were soggy and not at all crisp. The eggplant did not have enough sauce to it. Highly disappointed. There was no point in calling back and get another bad attitude. This is the second time ordering delivery and a second failure. The last delivery order was missing a salad. Prior to that, the last time that I did a pick-up order (almost identical to the delivery for 10/27), the sauce was overflowing out of the container and spilled on my clothing which happened on the way to the car. I went back in and said something and they did not care. This used to be our go to place during the last 4 years, especially on Wednesday, but all the problems we have had recently outweigh the good that they used to be. And we used to really enjoy this place. Previously rated 5 stars, but no more.

Best calzone I ever had. Went here while at Cocoa Beach for the day (stopped on a cruise). Pizza is excellent, a really NY slice but calzone was the star. Amazing bread, great cheeze flavors, and gigantic. Wish I could finish it. Would definitely recommend. Service was also friendly and quick. We sat outside with family and it was very comfortable.

Much more than just pizza! Awesome calamari, delicious mac and cheese eggrolls, great stromboli. Large portions and phenomenal prices and great owners. Make this one of your go-to's!

We have been to Cocoa many times and never happened to stop here. That was a huge mistake! The food and service is amazing! The prices are very reasonable! They do wear masks. We will always come back here!

Food is delicious. Our favorite place to go when in Cocoa!!

Great tasting pizza and salad! Awesome customer service!!

Superb pizza in whopping sizes. Pizza slices are huge but incredibly delicious. The decor may look a little tired but overlook that for great pizza.

Great server, quiet atmosphere, family friendly, reasonably priced food at a great quality!!! May become a regular spot for me

This is an amazing pizza place I love their cheese the crust got fresh portobello mushrooms Seafood that goes on Pizza is awesome they have calamari side orders this places

The cocoa beach store is delicious. This store on the other hand is awful. Not only is the store dirty but we have been served old slices 2 different times we went there. Called and spoke with one if the managers and he didn't seem to care much. This is the last time we will go there. I'm not writing this to bash the store but I don't want people spending thier hard earned money there thinking the food might be good.

Best freaking pizza I have ever had. I was totally shocked. The sauce and the crust are done right! The people were very nice to us. Yummy!

We enjoy this place, and has become a family tradition. Every time we come to cocoa beach, now about 8 times from Miami, we eat here. Sure it is busy and we may have to wait for a table, but staff has always been friendly and nice, plus we love the calzone and pizza.

This is a great pizza place! They have many tasty specialty pizzas, including pizzas up to 26". Their pastas and salads are also very well made and filling. They offer inside and outside dining, and have a curbside pickup option if you dont feel like eating in.

The Calzones are huge! And thank goodness I didn't get extra cheese. These things are loaded! Service was excellent. Very friendly atmosphere.

They make a decent house pie. Especially for a beach environment pizzaria

Disgusting!!! Roaches in the restaurant!!! Contaminated!

Pizza was delicious. We ate outside. Husband went in to pay and there were cochroaches crawling everywhere. Used to be our favorite pizza place. Wont be going back now

Pizza is extremely floppy for a "New York Style" thin crust. Anyone can throw sauce and cheese on dough and call it a pizza. Might as well be called pizza hut.

Stay away from this place , unless you want to wait forever with unprofessional customer service with a business that could care less about providing you with timely service. I waited two hours for a.pizza that never came.

Soups are amazing here, salads are yummy and big. Haven't had anything not amazing to eat at this store!

Awesome restaurant! You have to get the calzone, its humongous. Friendly staff and very clean.

Great food, reasonably priced. You will not be disappointed.

Good amount of options. Good service and like almost all American restaurants, a good amount of food.

The closest to Brooklyn pizza I've had in a very long time!

Great pizza but the waitresses wear too much perfume...overpowers the wonderful food smell. One girl was training and she had way too short shorts on !

The only thing about your new york pizza this placed your kithen and bar area and dinning are cealind tiles are disgusting fly and roaches some body need to call city inpectors or the news to report this dirty placed so sad i pick up pie got home staight to the garbage (0) stars please major clean up here so sad than they can run business that way

Great New York style pizza and many more excellent Italian fare. This is a great family owned restaurant with excellent food, service, and prices

These pizzas are huge. They taste pretty good as well. Tip: if you're watching your sodium levels, this isn't the place for you. The service was ok, although our server disappeared midway through. After asking about refills and the whereabouts of our server we discovered that she had been sent out on the delivery and no one had told us.

Great food .Great service .Great prices . I recommend this to everyone!!! You won't be disappointed

I completely love this place the food is amazing its really clean and it's not expensive.I had a perfect family time in this restaurant I would recomend this place for everyone and any ocation.

Best pizza in Brevard County! This location is truly epic. Right across from ron jon surf shop, these guys make amazing food. Soup pizza desserts everything has always been great. Over 5 years I've been stopping in, never a bad experience. Lots of good conversation takes place here, check it out. Prices are fair for the great tasting food.

Wonderful food and service! Very friendly, fast and large portions for low prices! 10/10 recommended to anyone in the area!

Great food and large portions. Service good and attentive. Great place to bring the family.
If your hungry you will not be disappointed.

Always a great meal. We drive from Rockledge to go there. Food is always awesome and the prices are great

The food was good but I paid $12 for a gluten free pizza and it was a little bigger than the size of my hand. Way too expensive for one little pizza

A New York Pizza House, 3850 N Atlantic Ave, Cocoa Beach, FL 32931

Disappointed with my latest visit here. I've had the pizza here many times before and it's always been delicious, but it was not as good this time. The crust was thicker than usual and overcooked on the bottom. I was happy to see they offered delivery but when I asked about delivery times, I was told that they will not quote delivery times, which makes it hard for planning a meal for the family. It would be great if they would post the full menu including the regular pizza and the prices. I couldn't find the pizza sizes or prices online anywhere.

On Friday March 13, 2015 my sister and I took our kids to eat a large pizza. From the moment we walked in and sat down, we were not greeted properly. Our server blond hair green eyes young lady, was horrible to us. She was rude in the manner she spoke to us and even said she will be back to us when she is done elsewhere since she was busy. Mind you that at around 6 in the evening there was only one table in addition to us and two other tables arrived a few minutes later. You were not busy. It was obvious to all 7 of us that she did not like to serve Hispanics. It is a shame that you have someone like that in your place since my sister has been there many times after spending a day at the beach she only looked forward to your pizza. Not only was your Cesar salad horrible, did not taste like Cesar at all but it even made my sister sick. I was so angry at the way your server was acting towards us, that I almost had my family walk away and left the order sitting. But we do have manners and class. I cannot say the same for your employee. My family lives in Cocoa, Merritt Island and Cape Canaveral and they are very well known by the community, I would hate for this kind of behavior to be spread around. I will go to your place of business again and if I feel the same way of the treatment I get from your server, I will make it a point to call law enforcement for racism.

I have loved their food ever since they opened years ago as Abitinos on 520! All of their food. From a slice of pizza to a full family dinner.

Great food, large portions & Mary our waitress was so awesome! My kids loved her, she was friendly & inviting!

I asked the waitress if the owner was from n.y., she said yes.. I'm embarrassed !! The tables out side were disgusting , even after we asked to have it cleaned, the bathroom was gross! The pizza was a half a step up from Pizza Hut . It seemed to be run by teenagers (they were working hard), the owner needs to spend more time taking care of things and training the employees correctly.

They had great hot wings and the pizza was really tasty

Ordered a pitcher of beer and 3 sweet teas, 20 minutes later , no beer , no tea
We left to the astounded looks of the workers... Pick it up guys ! We ate here 2 years ago and the food was GREAT!
Too bad the service is NOT!

This little place sells a little bit of everything but guess they do it well. The seafood soup I had was fantastic filled with shrimp, squid, mussels and clams, the giant homemade meatballs were off the hook, the seafood platter was okay. My son had the pepperoni pocket was huge and fantastic.