Tellers Steak house Reviews

Excellent atmosphere with good service and great food. A little on the expensive side but the quality is well worth it, went for lunch and it was particularly crowded,the portions could have been a little more generous for some of the entrees, but still satisfying.

One of my go-to places to eat. awesome location, neat, and great service. I recommend this place!

Go for the signature tomahawk! You will not be disappointed! Excellent staff and service as well

My husband and I went there for our anniversary and it was fantastic.

Food and service both excellent, I highly recommend

Went for my birthday, the food is absolutely amazing! It is an expensive restaurant but it is worth every penny! Our waiter Steve was incredible

Food was great, with the exception of my wife's steak coming out under the requested temperature and when they gave it back it was over done. My steak was perfect. The wait staff were super nice and very attentive. They provided free desert to make up for my wife's steak- great business in my opinion and we will definitely be going back.

This is an outstanding steakhouse. Never fails to impress me with the service food and atmosphere. The attached bar is great for a pre dinner meet up/drink spot.

Loved Restaurant Week menu with wine pairing. Outdoor seating was beautiful

Waited 45min to get seated even with a reservation, it's happened more than once to me. I know things get hectic but at least comp a drink or something, so disrespectful in that aspect, great food, and great service though, obviously will come back like always, but maybe the owner will see this post. Dropped the review to a 3 star, these SLOBS can't even write back!!!

I never post about places I go but this is one of the best dining we ever had!! I always take clients out and this has been a great experience. Our server was great and the food was excellent! Highly recommend!!

Excellent good, great service, and we really loved sitting next to the fire place.

Went here for my birthday with my wife. The staff was wonderful, and the food was perfect. My wife didn't know what she wanted to drink, and said leave it up to the bartender. What he put together blew her away!

Great steaks and seafood as well as an amazing atmosphere!

Top notch service from front to back. Everyone was very nice and professional.

Glorious. The most beautiful dining room on Long Island; and, when you're done looking around, a sensational wine list and the best 21 day aged strip steak you'll ever have. I swear, the chef is a sorcerer. Fantastic duck fat chips too.

Always a great choice for dinner. Friendly staff and great steaks.

Very nice atmosphere I went there.to apply for a job

Very unhappy with the service and length of time that the food took to come out. I'm talking about 45 mins on a Thursday. Sorry, Prime it is.....

Great food, great service would definitely recommend!

Loved the atmosphere of this place the waiters made it better felt like a gentleman's club that i slipped into food was great

Good food great service and tasty cocktails what more can you ask for

The best aged steak that I ve tried in my life was the best there, the service was great the appetizers the drinks everything was amazing

I was taken to Tellers for a combo birthday Thanksgiving meal. Not only was the food amazingly delicious, but the staff were friendly, cheerful and upbeat. When they brought my surprise birthday dessert, they were not only discreet about it, but it was presented very classy to me and elegantly on the plate. The manager came over to personally to wish me a happy birthday and not only did he then tell me that my dessert was "on them", but he presented me with a gift card as a token to use toward my next visit with them. Tellers is one of the rare places left where one can go to enjoy a really nice classy dinner out. A+++++

Tellers is always dependable to provide a great meal with wonderful service

Great lamb chops; best ever.
Mike the waiter was great

Nice place for that special occasion but quite pricey. I mean, really expensive! I don't think it has to cost quite that much for a good meal. Drinks are totally outrageous in price. I would go much more often if I wasn't getting so taken advantage of.

Always amazing food. Staff is always friendly, knowledgeable and helpful.

My favorite place. The food is fantastic and the service is great!

the staff is amazing, our waiter was great but 90 dollars for kobe beef that was so fatty it was hard to eat. that kobe beef really sucked and that price tag made it worse. sorry will be ordering just drinks and basic stuff on the menu from now on. WARNING: DONT ORDER KOBE BEEF! :)

Just had best meal with family. Fantastic from start to finish. Highly recommend.

Great steaks service my family pretty much lives here

Beautiful outside dining and of course Amazing Food!

The food is always supreme along with top notch customer service

Excellent evening service was great, food was excellent. Looking forward to the next time.

Teller s is my go-to restaurant! They never disappoint. From their huge wine selection to their 50 day dry-aged Steak specials to the decor/ambiance of an old time Bank (which it used to be) if you are looking to celebrate something special, Tellers is where you need to go

5 star bottom to top...service ,food impeccable. ..never had a bad experience ever

When I moved to Long Island from the city 15 years ago, Long Island food was a huge disappointment for me. Over the years many great restaurants popped up and Long Island is catching up. However, Tellers was always incredible. Been there over 20 or so times and never disappointed. My favorite is the ribeye. Huge, delicious steak that looks like a dinosaur serving. For years now, when I m asked what I ll have I just say I ll have the T-Rex medium rare ...and they always know what I mean lol. All kidding aside, this old bank turned into an incredible restaurant is simply the best of the best in Long Island. The steaks simply melt in your mouth forcing you to have dreams of the flavor and experience a few nights straight, and the service is second to none! You will NOT be disappointed...not a chance!

Every little thing cooked to mouth watering perfection. Definitely will go back when I can afford. I was there for business holiday party.

Very very overpriced got sick after eating meal. Very dissatisfied and disappointed

Everything exceeded expectation. Beautiful restaurant and great service. I love the outside seating for having cocktails while we wait for our table.
Food is great except for the interesting "burnt over broccoli", exactly what the name implies, a flashover burnt broccoli. Can't wait to return and try the signature steaks.

Love the food and drinks here! Porterhouse for two is excellent. Our waiter Chris was great!, and had all of our food out promptly.

Lovely experienced staff is excellent, I must recommendation anytime inside Islip Long Island..

What a nice way to treat yourself to an exquisite dining experience. From the time at the bar talking with the highly experienced bartenders, to sitting at our table for dinner, the experience was just outstanding. We had the crab cakes (2)'small but delicious served with a white sauce, the octopus which had to be the most tender octopus that I ever had, delicious and the duck fries, crunchy!!!

Fit dinner we had 2 of the tellers special ribeyes....huge to say the least, very juicy and tender. The scalloped potatoes were cheesy and full of flavor, the burnt broccoli was amazing, crashed spinach just creamy.

Lisette took great care of our table. It was a wonderful dining experience. The outside was all lit up, very romantic!

Duck fat fries, everything else pretty great too

Started coming in 2002, never dispointed. Mosty fantastic, yes its pricy but here you really get what you pay for

Big bold steaks

19 dollar lunch menu, talk about getting more for you paid for

Great price fix lunch, delicious dinners. Some of the best steak I've ever eaten and I come from a family of butchers from Brooklyn. Excellent service as well.

Great food and great atmosphere. Great steaks!!! The steak that I had was perhaps even better than Peter Lugars. Highly recommend!!!

The atmosphere was beautiful the staff was delightful and the food was probably the best from any Steakhouse I've eaten at throughout the Long Island metro area. I highly recommend this beautiful establishment.

Good quality food. Fantastic service. The restuarant is gorgeous and I will definitely come back

Service was wonderful from the time I walked in until I left
Adam was our server,excellent,
Food delicious. Presented beautifully

This place, Pace's and elbow room are the best steak houses on Long Island hands down. The food is amazing.

Good food +great service(great chef)=Excellent restaurant

A group of us went there for the price fixe lunch for $19. The caesar salad and chopped vegetable salad were very good. Raves for the crispy skin salmon, crab cake sandwich and fillet tips Diane. The desserts were very good, with the vanilla creme brulee leading the way, also the key lime pie and NY style cheesecake. Service was very good very attentive. Highly recommended for lunch.

Decent food, well the wellington was good at least.. the burnt broccoli was terrible and the service was not that great either. I went several times, but the last I spent my anniversary being ignored when there were only three other tables.

Always a great meal with great service. Porter house for two is unbelievable as is the sweet potato brulee!!

Great atmosphere, great food. Our server was very nice and very attentive.

Service and food was great! We mentioned it was my son's birthday and the brought him a special dessert and gave him a $25 gift card.

Attended an engagement party here. They presented themselves as a very well established and classy restaurant. The whole affair was conducted in a friendly and efficient manner. My steak was perfectly cooked and seasoned and the oysters were very fresh.

This is a special place for my wife and I. Great food, awesome bar and atmosphere.

Food is excellent. Steve the waiter is always on point and very friendly

Absolutely to die for.!! Our waiter Willie was very knowledgeable, and had made the night even more enjoyable!

Saw write up in Newsday that astronomical prices had come way down. They did not tell you that they were not cooking it adding 20% to that price and then adding on 20% to that. The girl told me my $65.small steak would be cooked it was not. They advertised $25 steaks. So 3 $25 steaks and 1 small steak uncooked. Almost $200. Good thing it was not regular price or it would have cost me $600. For a few small steaks. Rock bottom pricing for Corona? This scamming establishment should be taught a lesson. They also write their own reviews. Lesson learned. Don t be fooled.

I was thoroughly impressed by the food, service and aesthetic. I'd recommend Tellers.

Didn't blow my doors off. Don't get me wrong, it was very good but not for the amount of money it was good. For a $300 dinner, (per couple) no drinks included, I would expect to be gobsmacked. It was a steakhouse dinner. I could have had the same for less at Bryant & Cooper or even Prime, and that's owned by the same group. Also the service was meh. Not at all what I was expecting after reading the reviews.

Great food, nice bar good service. $$$$$ very expensive but nice place.

Excellent restaurant. Food was excellent, service exceptional. Highly recommended. They have also expanded their outdoor seating and moved into the Verace location next door (which they owned) and renamed it to Tellers Next Door. Hopefully Verace will return after restrictions are lifted, it was an excellent Italian restaurant.

The menu was hard to read both online and in print. The food was excellent though, I recommend the duck fat for sure. Excellent service.