Harbor View Hotel—Martha’s Vineyard, MA Review

I stayed at this hotel in early Sept. The location is beautiful and common areas very clean and nice, however I found the room in need of a very deep cleaning. There was significant build up of dirt in the corners and at base of walls, especially in the bathroom. The screen door to balcony was broken and did not slide on the track. The staff was friendly but dining room rather slow. Food was excellent once it arrived.

Very costly for what is offered. Service was nice. Parking was a nightmare. Very limited parking spots. Pool was very clean and nice. 10 second walk to beachbeach area.

The view at this hotel is amazing. Sitting on the porch with a drink is the best way to wnd the day in Edgartown.

The bus is nice, great location, staff is wonderful. Only problem it's a room mix up but there are worse things that can happen

Nice view. Pretentious atmosphere not worthy of the prices.

Communication was excellent from the beginning of the trip. We called before boarding the ferry and scheduled a cute golf cart pickup at the dock. Driving thru town our young associate answered questions about the island, gave local suggestions and managed to fit in all the amenities provided by the hotel. The drive was scenic and MV has such great old school architecture that it's hard NOT to imagine just picking up living there full time.

Pulling up to Harbor View is exactly what it sounds like. The hotel faces the harbor and a lighthouse. There's a path that leads from the front steps, across a quiet street and down a rock beaten path to the beach. Harbor View provides chairs, umbrellas and transport.

The lobby is homey, inviting and smells good.
Front desk is on point with welcomes and offers. Complimentary bikes and 3 styles of Mercedes Benzes to choose from as your own personal car for a couple of hours, first come first served, but still free. Restaurant around the corner from the concierge has a small but tasty menu. Blueberry pankcakes, avocado toast, fried chicken sandwiches, steaks and sandwiches all fresh tasting and filling.

We were situated in the new building in the behind the pool. Rooms very clean but nothing too special. I liked the energy efficient central air that shut off as soon as the balcony door was opened and resumed as soon as it was closed. Housekeeping, again on point, because they always managed to let me know when they were going to be headed into my room and if I wanted anything specific done.

After shopping near the marina one night, I took one of the bikes for a midnight bike ride, complete with a wireless speaker, across the island to Oak Bluffs with my cousin. Bit off more than we could chew BUT we did it. Found a bar still doing last calls and had a great convo into the night with some locals.

MV seems like its own world on its own island of which its inhabitants only seem to be looking for and exuding positive vibes.

There is so much to see and do that I dont have the energy to write about at this moment. But for my first time in MV, Harbor View hotel was the best start I could've made. I cant wait to go back.

Gorgeous view. Amazing location. Room was very comfortable.

Beautiful view. Staff response, but we had few things yha needed attention

The room I had was about noisy for a light sleeper, but it was very good. The restaurants in the hotel are very good, and the service is very good

We just left here a few days ago. It is probably the cleanest hotel ever. The facility is immaculate. The location is ideal. The staff is great. So why didn't I give it 5 stars? It is probably the loudest hotel I have ever stayed in. For the price, I was hoping to get more peace. We were on the second floor in the main part. The resturant is very loud (especially at night when people have had a few), and it seems people don't realize doors slam. There were a lot of families and kids. We would stay there again, but this time I would request a higher room or we would try a cottage.

Rooms were dirty. Hair on the sink, tub and toilets. Dirty toilets also. No hot water in the shower and not repaired during our 3 day stay. Good grounds and pool area. Friendly staff. Food mediocre

Had a great time hear. There was a problem getting overcharged on my bill. But they fixed it when mentioned. Ample parking in a semi-peak timeframe. Awesome to take a stroll down to the lighthouse nearby. Very comfortable and clean rooms.

First day of 3 but super nice, a bit expensive but worth

Not the fastest friendliest service we ve had here. But most times pretty good. Food was delish and the courtyard beautiful with beautiful views.

Michelle. She makes this place. Hospitality is her middle name. Located right on the harbor and to transportation to the islands. Will definitely go back just to see Michele.

Ok, I hate to be a negative Nancy but there are pros and cons to this well known hotel on the island. It's not ALL that.

first the pros:
I was there for a week long course so I got a special deal per night at $399 compared to the $500-700 estimate in prime August season.

The pool was meticulously kept up and the servers and bar were well stocked and easy to access. Free towels and plenty of space to lay out. Yard games on the greenery in the back.

Two beautiful restaurants on location. Henry's and Water Street. You need reservations for Dinner and $$$$. Only went to Water Street for cocktails so no real impression.

Free Parking

Location, Location, Location across the street from the beautiful Lighthouse Beach in Edgartown, steps away from downtown eating and shopping and rocking chairs on the wrap around porch to view to the pristine scenery.

The Cons:
For $399 a night (a deal considering but still on the very high end) our room was clean but no over the top accessories or highlights. In fact our shower and sink clogged daily. Our pool view room had a couple of metal chairs I could have bought at Christmas Tree Shop but our view was semi-private due to the landscaping. Cool I like that, but it was loud. Too loud. Kids in the pool from 8am til dusk everyday. And landscapers started before that and being on the ground floor, we heard everything.

There was a mini-fridge but nothing in it.

TV was static - no premium channels.

Facilities for the course were big enough but they said power would be supplied at every table for computers - they weren't. And it was freezing. I needed a sweatshirt daily in August, which I didn't bring.

SO yes, it's beautiful and convenient, but there was nothing so special about this place that makes you feel like the price tag is worth it. But it was packed and goes to show people will pay what you set.

This hotel is beautiful, and the views equally beautiful

I love the Harbor View. The staff is so welcoming and the hotel is beautiful. What an amazing place!

I live in Iowa now, but I grew up in NY. I spent lots of summers on Cape Cod. I had an opportunity to go to Harbor View in February. I was there for a week and it regenerated my soul. It's a perfect place.

Our room on the 4th floor was fantastic, the service was great, and the food at Henry's restaurant was absolutely delicious. The room was very expensive but I suppose that is to be expected in Martha's Vineyard. The area did not have much going on because most shops and restaurants are closed after Labor Day.

Lunch selection was great. Staff was very attentive making sure our experience was exceptional.

Great view of the lighthouse on the island, nice accommodations

Went for a drink. Emma was our bartender. She was friendly and attentive. She made one of the best espresso martinis that I have ever had.

Stayed a spring weekend (out of peak season) and really enjoyed it. The rooms were clean, the beds were comfortable, and the location was perfect. Located near a nice collection of shops, bars, and restaurants as well as a beautiful lighthouse that is easily accessible. Enjoyed their lobster special at the restaurant and the nice rocking chairs on the porch overlooking the lighthouse and the bay.

This is a beautiful hotel. The staff is friendly & helpful and the rooms are clean and super comfortable. I slept so well both nights I wish I could take the bed home with me.

We stayed in a two-bedroom cottage and I just want to say everything was impeccably appointed. The staff went above and beyond making sure all of our needs were met. The room service was wonderful. We have an amazing breakfast... the food is just outstanding. Pool was lovely and additionally they offer a yoga class and boot camp in the morning. I have been to the Vineyard many times and in my opinion... this is the only place to stay! Edgartown is absolutely beautiful. Highly recommend!<br/>Trip typeVacation<br/>Rooms5.0Service5.0Location5.0<br/>Mark Kuenzi<br/>5/5<br/>a month ago on Google<br/>top notch service and concierge! newly renovated and very cozy. super nice hotel with awesome location!<br/>T<br/>TripAdvisor Reviewer<br/>2/5<br/>a month ago on TripAdvisor <br/>The Harbor View has new owners and management and what a disappointment. My daughter and her new husband spent their wedding night there. My husband dropped their bag off in the morning telling the hotel staff it was their wedding night. <br/>READ MORE ON TRIPADVISOR<br/>T<br/>TripAdvisor Reviewer<br/>4/5<br/>3 weeks ago on TripAdvisor <br/>My husband and I stayed here for 3 very lovely days after heavily researching all other hotels and bed and breakfasts.|We know now we made the right choice. The renovation is beautiful and the staff is so kind and helpful. |We stayed in the <br/>READ MORE ON TRIPADVISOR<br/>T<br/>TripAdvisor Reviewer<br/>2/5<br/>2 months ago on TripAdvisor <br/>If the price is not a concern, you can find fine food. We called for dinner thinking our reservation was for the dining room only to find that the bar was the only option. We were quite surprised to find that the renovation of the bar area <br/>READ MORE ON TRIPADVISOR<br/>T<br/>TripAdvisor Reviewer<br/>5/5<br/>2 weeks ago on TripAdvisor <br/>I am a travel agent and my husband and I spent three wonderful nights at the Harbor View hotel and we LOVED everything about it.||||The hotel is under new ownership and they are doing a terrific job.||||It is in a wonderful location walking <br/>READ MORE ON TRIPADVISOR<br/>Peter Lindsley<br/>5/5<br/>a week ago on Google<br/>Elegant hotel with the best views at the good end of town. Many fond memories here during the 1970s and 1980s.<br/>T<br/>TripAdvisor Reviewer<br/>2/5<br/>a month ago on TripAdvisor <br/>We stayed in the hotel for two days in a suite with panaromic view of the harbor and light house that costed us $750 per night . The view was no question spectacular. We were celebrating our Anniversary and we told them way in advance <br/>READ MORE ON TRIPADVISOR<br/>T<br/>TripAdvisor Reviewer<br/>5/5<br/>2 months ago on TripAdvisor <br/>Excellent food choices, very creative, cannot find anywhere else just here delicious-amazing quality.||fresh pressed juices or smoothies while you watch the sunrise from veranda and end the day with an appetizer and vibrant ambiance in second restaurant.<br/>READ MORE ON TRIPADVISOR<br/>T<br/>TripAdvisor Reviewer<br/>5/5<br/>2 weeks ago on TripAdvisor <br/>A gorgeous luxury hotel in perhaps the most scenic location in all of MV. The hotel has recently reopened after a total renovation which preserved the historic character in every detail. The staff was super attentive to every need, <br/>READ MORE ON TRIPADVISOR<br/>T<br/>TripAdvisor Reviewer<br/>5/5<br/>2 months ago on TripAdvisor <br/>Wow, this hotel just reopened and we got a chance to be some of the first to experience it. We have stayed here before and it is clear that this place has been infused with so much style and care. The room had an amazing view and the staff <br/>READ MORE ON TRIPADVISOR<br/>$611

Had lunch on the porch overlooking the harbor, clam chowder and truffle mushroom flatbread pizza. Both were excellent. The view and gentle cooling breeze made it a special afternoon.

The Harbor View Hotel is located in Edgartown near the lighthouse. Several friends joined me for lunch in Henry's, the casual bar at the hotel. The service and the food were great. The view is exceptional, the windows overlook the outer harbor.

Went after dinner for drinks on the deck. Bar was a little slow and way over priced. Chocolate chip cookies were very good, but also expensive.

Amazing location. The views are spectacular! As the name says... You are looking at the harbor and also a light house.

Nice location, excellent staff. Facility does show signs off needing repairs, but still very nice.

The Harbor View Hotel is a great property. It's near enough to Main Street to walk and far enough to feel private. Some of the rooms have great views, but most have nice property views. Admittedly, my biggest complaint is that the rooms seem to have very little soundproofing between rooms, but because it's a quiet place to begin with (when we visited) it wasn't much of an issue.

Haven't stayed at the hotel but looks very intresting

Jury is still out. Have an issue with our room regarding the heat which has yet to be resolved.

Fabulous location, amenities and friendly staff. Gorgeous porch overlooking the harbor. Cabanas at pool.

It was suggested by our hotel to swing by here for drinks at sunset. Great views, very expensive. The wait staff was courtious and helpful

We passed through there, and it seemed like a clean, nice, luxurious place.

No valet yet, server named Tyler 5 stars, view blissful, food good, not great.

Beautiful, meticulous with a beautiful veranda for ocean view

We have been staying her 2 times a year for 9 years. We love the location but I've noticed over the years we pay a lot of money but the rooms have appeared worn. For the money we spend it has become an ok place to stay the last few years. Last night we were woken out of a deep sleep at 12:30am to the fire alarm going off. It appeared to be a glitch with the sprinkler system. One would think when your guest is inconvenienced in the middle of the night maybe breakfast would be on the house but that wasn't the case. I have become very disappointed with the Harbor View over the last few years..I hope they turn it around for my next visit or I may seek another venue to patronize!

Great drinks on the porch, well worth the long wait at the bar!

Wow, what a amazing hotel. I love everything about this hotel. Wonderful staff!!! She gave us room on the 4th floor facing the lighthouse. It was more than we ever imagine.

Beautiful hotel.Just across the street from the ocean and light house. Nice porch with rocking chairs.Full bar and lovely dining room. Very historic.

An excellent place to stay. Good beds and pleasant atmosphere. Take a walk on the local sandy beach and feel the ocean breeze on your face.

Wasn't a customer, but they let me use the restroom and I was very grateful. Very courteous employees.

Top spot with dog food and even better service. A bit pricey though.

Very good for mid to large size gatherings. Food moderate. Pleasant staff. No knowledge of lunch/dinner. Wonderful walk in the town.

It gives off a home-like vibe making me instantly comfortable. The main lobby is nice suited with couches, a fake warm giving fire place, as well as multiple board games to entertain. It also has a large variety of room selections in different buildings which I imagine is better for summer weather. Once you're settled from the ferry ride you may become hungry or filled with the need to travel both are included. Two restaurants are located inside the central building both with good overall taste and presentation as well as a great view of the nearby lighthouse(great photo opportunity). With traveling not only can rent a car from a place in the town, but you're given a booklet with information on buses and taxis. I spent some time with taxis leading to great conversation moments definitely enhancing the experience. Overall this creates a four star rating.

Outstanding Experience, starting the wonderful aroma of the lobby, the way everyone is trained to offer the best Customer Service ever!
The food was Amaizing, the filet Mignon out of the world, the Clam Chowder is one of the best I ever tried. Oh! The Blueberry Pancakes just perfect!
The rooms very clean and update! We stay at the topnfloor looking at the pool... it was magnificent!
We took a ride on a brand new Mercedes SUV complementary of the Hotel......
Overall one of the best Stays... totally Recomend it if you like nothing but the best!

Great room, everything looked newly renovated, staff was great and helpful. Temperature control in the rooms was dated and not really functional.

Extremely unimpressed. Rooms were terrible. I don t mind paying extremely high hotel rates in season but these rooms are more like a bad motel

Though I did not stay here, I needed assistance while in the area and popped in. It is gorgeous inside, has a beautiful wraparound patio and excellent customer service.

Accommodation not accurate in the conferece (meeting) rooms. Not much space to flow. Bar did not carried Riesling wine.

Concierge Darlene was all-around terrific during our recent stay! She was very well-connected, very responsive and had great ideas to make the trip to Harbor View fantastic, including arranging hard-to-get restaurant reservations and organizing a picnic on the beach. She was in tune to our party s needs and interests. She was very friendly and a pleasure to work with. It s clear that it s not just a job for her; it s a passion!

Great views and the drinks at the bar were reasonably priced.

The food was spectacular. The view was amazing. Very relaxed atmosphere.

Went for dinner, good food and nice choices. Comfortable seats.

Not quite geared up for the season, but they're getting there. Nice common spaces. Some areas need attention and maintenance.

Great view of the ocean to rest, relax, and have a drink from the porch! Walking distance to downtown Edgartown!

This place is a great place to go and visit and air on the porch.

Hotel was very picturesgue, but the service was poor. Waited 2 and a half hours for a room in the Off Season, when the hotel was virtually empty. We were there for an affair that started at 4p.m., and were hoping to gain entry to the room earlier. No heat in the bathroom......after two phone calls and a 27 hour wait, a maintenance man came and plugged in a portable radiator. The front desk clerk said he left messages-no message on either my cell or on the room phone. I could go on, but this gives you an idea, that they just didn't care about the customer.

Loved loved loved EVERYTHING about this hotel!!!!!!!!