Hamilton's Pub Reviews

Service was a little slow but food and atmosphere were good

We come here on Sundays to watch football due to our home team being in Minnesota and not usually on local TV. Usually the service and food is good. But today has been a disaster!! Horrible service.... wrong food....cold food. And it was happening throughout the entire restaurant. Absolutely awful. Not sure if we'll be back or not.

Before I moved fron NA, Hamilton's Pub was our go to spot for after work beer and eats. Now visiting Columbus, it's still the great place for both. Summer Shandy and a Reuben....anytime!! Love the atmosphere, the bigscreens, and the friendly staff.

Service was excellent came here after having a terrible experience somewhere else & left extremely happy we decided to give it a try the entire staff was great & seemed to work as a team

First time visiting here. It was seat yourself when we walked in so we choose to sit at the bar. Bartender greeted us as soon as we sat. Small but easy to read menu. He ordered the Ham and Potatoe Soup to start with, and it had a nice smoked flavor. Really delicious! I got the chili to start with, and it had a kind of spicy Chipotle flavor. Also delicious! He ordered the Reuben Sandwich with a side of Cottage Cheese for his lunch. He said it had great flavor, and the sandwhich was stacked full. I ordered the Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich with a side of Cottage Cheese. I opted to add lettuce and mayo. It had good flavor, wasn't too dry, and was also stacked full. We ended up leaving with about half of our lunches lol. Servixe was great! Drinks stayed full and staff was pleasant!! COVID guidelines were being practiced with masks, social distancing and cleaning. Restrooms were clean, smelled good and were nicely decorated. Totally dig the light pieces!! Nice Sports Classic type theme. Very comfortable atmosphere. Definitely would return!

It's most definitely a pub. Trivia is fun, good beer variety, food is fine.

Amazing chicken fajita quesadilla. Fries were a little undercooked, but won't take a star away for that. The service makes up for that plenty!

It's an okay bar. They have an outside bar/patio that is partially covered. Not a lot to do there though...no pool, no darts.

Typical Sports bar. Lots of TVs, good bar food good prices. Get the half price wings on Wednesday. Mediocre beer selection, but fairly priced. Outdoor patio is great in the summer.

Their wings are fantastic!! Hamilton's is one if my favorites!

Rick was my bartender for the night, he was great. Check it out sometime.

Good service, solid selections for pub grub and a charming atmosphere.

Food was ok but the service was horrendous. The server thought he was being funny or something by making smart ass remarks. We had a party of 4 on a Thursday night so it wasn't too busy. 2 of us got our food in a timely manner however, the other 2 had to wait an additional 20 minutes for their burgers. Probably would rather for to another local pub with better service.

All the food was very good. Service was great too. Definitely will be back.

the waitresses are very nice and it's a good atmosphere!

Evening of Trivia and we made top 20 Our name is Hawaii

Food was good, service was very efficient and they pour a "STOUT" drink...ENJOY

First visit. A very nice layout and tvs. Great menu and great food. We will be back.

Pretty bland bar food menu where nothing great stands out. Save your dollars and go somewhere else.

Rude. I was charged for drinks that were not mine. When I asked about the charges I was told they were from someone who ordered on my tab, from my table ( group of about 8...). When asked around the table, they were not ours. However the waiter refused to remove the 2 drinks...

I had Buffalo Grouper fish tenders and they were very good! Very hard to find Grouper in any Restaurant let alone a pub. My wife was very pleased on her birthday with there Reuben. Very nice staff and 20 big screen TVs. I only wish they had a Grouper fish sandwich but I will be back soon to try some more of the different varieties of food on the menu!

Only one time out of many have I been served something that I felt was too greasy. Anyone makes a mistake once.

More often than not, the service is great. Odd thing to say but I like the bouncers. They're cool people who just keep the peace and that's what they should be there for.

Great place to walk when I don't want to drive and watch sports. I've been a patron going on 1 1/2 years and will continue to frequent it. Their quesadilla appetizer is a full meal and when other pizza places close, theirs kicks some serious ass and they whip it up as you like it in no time at all.

Nice in between bar. Not a hole in the wall but not overpriced and overcrowded.

I guess I'm giving it 2 stars because they have the alcohol and it's pretty clean. If you want good beer and good food though, don't come here. 3 appetizers and 2 sandwiches.. the appetizers were simple and tasted like the were bought frozen and thrown in the fryer and the sandwiches were extremely bland. Service was subpar with only 1 person at the bar and 1 person working tables.

Great casual place, great food, friendly staff and atmosphere.

They have a large patio with a bar outside. The main bartender there is great and is obviously on top of things. I hear they have great live music, too.

Great service, friendly staff, good selection of beer and alcohol, good cooks tasty food selection and plenty of clear viewing large screen TVs

Terrible service. I would put 0 stars if it were an option.

What a great experience our server Maddie was amazing

Katherine is always a great server and does a good job especially on trivia night!

They allow dogs on the patio. Saw a big dog and medium sized dog with a couple on the patio. Big dogs tail wiped the table and medium dog was on a chair. Where is the health dept???? How clean was my chair and table???? Left feeling ill!!!! Wondering how sanitary the place is???!!!!

Libby is the best of all the rest!!! Food is amazing and atmosphere is great! Love you Libby!!!

Love the place, cheapest prices in the area good atmosphere and good bar food what more can you ask for

Service was terrible!!!! Nice place, the waitress stands in the back of the bar talking, instead of checking on customers.

Good food service was a little slow but not that bad but a great atmosphere

Food here is amazing. Menu is extensive. Many trips in my future to try it all!

Food was good, atmosphere was cool, service from "Ashley Nicole" was awful, as was the service from the other bartender :/ we drove 20 mins here because we heard it was a cool spot to watch all of the football games. Maybe we will try it again in the future, who knows.

The food is alright. The drink specials are very good. I have been couple times.

Fun place to have a beer and chill. Food is always good.

This place is a usual haunt for a friend and I for Happy Hours. Food is typical pub grub and it's no gourmet meal, but the beer is always cold and staff always friendly. I feel you could bring kids here, even though I never have.

Outside dining exceptional. Food very good and reasonable. Good place to eat. Try it! You will like it.

Great night time bartender shes friendly and will have a conversation with you! This is definitely my bar.

Nice place to chill. Has an outdoor patio and good food.

Keep an eye on your bank account after credit card transactions. I had several different unauthorized transactions and waitress gave herself a $6 tip after I had already tipped her in cash. Never again! Thank goodness I kept receipt but still got the run around....

Fun atmosphere good food great people and cold beer what else do you need

Got up on that veggie burger along with those skinny fries. Drenched them in malt vinegar of course but didn't want to go too overboard and make people think I was cray cray. Plus the Blue Jackets game was on and it was crazy packed. So I just did shots of malt vinegar in the bathroom like a normal person. High-class joint high class entertainment oh yeah and they have Keno so I left out of there down $50.

Most triumphant pub dub and their homemade fries and chips are awesome. My only complaint is that they did not keep a good list describing their rotating draft beers.

Enjoyed my only visit to this establishment. An Oasis in the desert that day. Car broke down and I was in walking distance to it. Waitress was friendly and the beer was cold as I waited for my tow

Went here on buckeye game day and was pleasantly surprised! Great service, food & drinks

Fun place. Would have given it more stars if they had a better craft beer selection. The food was pretty good and arrived fast. Good pic if you are looking for a place to go for a late lunch with quick service and a beer.

Great food in service is impeccable. Keep up the good work.

Their club quesadilla actually changed my life. I've always had good service here too!

Bartenders are nice had a few awhile back that weren't great but lately they have been perfect. Good food