Great place to get parts and gear. Awesome to see a place that has parts for older bikes. Thanks for everything!!!
Haven't used Preferred mutual yet?
Ask AI
What reviewers say about Preferred mutual
Reviews are sharply divided. Several long-term customers praise the responsive, human service and smooth claims handling, while a notable share report being cancelled after filing claims or describe claims experiences and customer service as poor, leaving the overall average rating at 3.3 out of 5.
What does Preferred mutual do?
Preferred Mutual offers home insurance, auto insurance and business insurance, and customers can request a free quote through Preferredmutual.com. Based on the available information, that is the full scope of what the company does on file.
What are the most common complaints about Preferred mutual?
The most common complaints come from reviewers who say the company cancelled their policies after a claim, sometimes citing claim frequency rules the customers felt were unfair. Others describe difficult claims handling, including low settlement offers and poor customer service.
Post your question publicly — other visitors, and whoever manages this page, can answer. It will be visible on this page.
Want to hear about this company again? Follow it and we’ll email you when a new review appears.
AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.
10 Reviews
Buyer beware with PREFERRED MUTUAL. I have been policy holder for many years. I was just cancelled because they don t allow you to make 3 claims in 3 years. I only made one claim in 3 years but they would not reinstate me. I asked for the proof that I made three claims and their document shows only one claim paid. And it was for about $250. So with Preferred Mutual you will be cancelled if you use it. I will be filing a complaint with the NJ Division of Banking and Insurance. What a terrible company.
Terrible experience with this company. Paid our premiums for over 15 years then when we file a claim they find a way to low ball your property in order to avoid paying what its worth. Had to fight with them and provide a unreasonable amount of detail to prove the worth of the damaged items. After that train wreck, we left for a more reputable company and actually saved a bunch of money and received more coverage.
They paid me for my damaged car hit by their insured customer. And they provided me with a rental vehicle until my car was completely fixed.
They have terrible customer service and cancel insurance at the drop of a hat. I would not recommend this company.
Fair pricing and no issues getting paid on a claim.
AN INSURANCE COPMANY TO AVOID .. sure I can go on and on to explain why ..but that would just waste your time .. Since you insist I have to edit this review ..and give you some more info ..The freedom of speech or opinion is guaranteed under the US constitution .. When a customer that is in good stands (payment wise always been ) ask questions about a claim you are supposed to give answers not hang up.. Tell that to KAREN G . BAKER at the No Fault claims. I advive any consumer reading this review .if they have money to throw away on monthly bases ..they should donate it to charity .like ill children or our wounded heroes .. and simply go with a different insurance company ..And may God bless this great country..
First and foremost you always talk to a human immediately, and they speak clear English. At the most they transfer you once, to a rep who can help you personally. They are very quick to handle any claims. They always put you at ease, and make you feel comfortable, they will explain anything you need to know. I also got recommendations for my insurance to make my coverage even better at a really low cost! If you are looking for insurance for vehicle and home, I suggest you look into Preferred Mutual.
I've had there insurance on my house and vehicle, very good to deal with.
Questions & Answers
No questions yet — be the first to ask.
Sign in to post
Your text is saved — you'll come right back to post.
or with email
Don't have an account? Create one
News & Press
No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.
About Preferred mutual
Preferred Mutual offers home insurance, auto insurance and business insurance. Learn how to get a free quote at Preferredmutual.com.
Preferred Mutual: Your Trusted Insurance Partner
Are you looking for a reliable insurance company that can provide you with comprehensive coverage for your home, car, and business? Look no further than Preferred Mutual. With over 125 years of experience in the industry, we have established ourselves as a trusted partner for individuals and businesses alike.
At Preferred Mutual, we understand that every customer has unique needs when it comes to insurance. That's why we offer a wide range of policies that can be customized to meet your specific requirements. Whether you need basic coverage or more extensive protection, our team of experts will work with you to find the right solution.
Home Insurance
Your home is one of your most valuable assets, and it's important to protect it from unexpected events such as fire, theft or natural disasters. At Preferred Mutual, we offer comprehensive home insurance policies that cover everything from structural damage to personal belongings. Our policies also include liability coverage in case someone is injured on your property.
Auto Insurance
Whether you're driving to work or taking a road trip with friends and family, having auto insurance is essential. At Preferred Mutual, we offer a variety of auto insurance options including liability coverage, collision coverage and comprehensive coverage. We also offer discounts for safe drivers and multiple vehicles.
Business Insurance
Running a business comes with its own set of risks and challenges. That's why having the right insurance policy is crucial for protecting your assets and ensuring continuity in case something goes wrong. At Preferred Mutual, we offer customized business insurance solutions tailored to meet the unique needs of each client.
Our Policies
At Preferred Mutual, our policies are designed to provide maximum protection at an affordable price point. We believe in transparency when it comes to pricing so there are no hidden fees or surprises down the line.
Getting Started
If you're interested in learning more about our services or getting a free quote on any of our policies visit us at preferredmutual.com today! Our team is always available to answer any questions you may have about our products or services.
In conclusion,
Preferred mutual offers reliable home insurance plans which cover everything from structural damage up until personal belongings; auto insurances which include liability coverage; collision coverage; comprehensive coverage; discounts for safe drivers & multiple vehicles; Business insurances which are customized according clients' needs & requirements.
With over 125 years experience in this field they have established themselves as trusted partners who believe in transparency when it comes pricing so there are no hidden fees.
Visit their website today if interested!
- Website
- preferredmutual.com
- Phone
- 8003337642
- [email protected]
- Address
- 1 preferred way
- Categories
- Insurance
People also looked at
Prn10 Reviews
Progressus therapy16 Reviews
Prolacta bioscience9 Reviews
Queen creek unified school district13 Reviews
Questex11 Reviews
Penske media corporation13 Reviews
Pick-n-pull, a division of schnitzer steel industries13 Reviews
Phoenix elementary school district #19 Reviews
Personal touch9 Reviews
Peoplesbank, a codorus valley company8 Reviews