Uncommon Pizza Reviews

Great pizza. Cold beer. Friendly bartender and wait staff.

Good food. Pizza is good and calzones are delicious.

First time ordering from this place. We placed our order online at 5:45 on Friday evening, our pizza was delivered at 7:28. They claimed the delay was caused by fire and ice in lititz. I find it hard to believe, since their place is not near fire and ice, and our address was far enough away from the all the activities. Not thrilled with the service. The pizza was pretty good, but after nearly two hours, it arrived......not very warm. Might do better going to the establishment, so the jury is still out.

Easy, comfortable, welcoming atmosphere. Perfect for "hanging out" and visit with friends. Attentive, personal staff. Pizza was awesome! (see photo!) Totally uncommon and very special. (great for foodies!). Nice selection of beer and wine - just the right variety!

The pizza was great while business was slow due to COVID-19. Tonight they were busy and the pizza is not so great. The supreme pizza in the past has been phenomenal however tonight it was mediocre at best.

Great fresh food! Nice selection of BEER...fantastic service..would definitely come back here!

Fantastic food and service, kid friendly, and acoholic beverages available as well!

Never a bad experience here. Prices are good and service is friendly.

Dollar slice night made for an affordable, outdoor seating, pet friendly, family dinner! Looking forward to repeating, this is a dependable local eatery.

Very friendly atmosphere!!!
Great food and a wonderful place to bring family.
The staff are always helpful and welcoming!

Ordered pizza here for pick up. The place was packed and everyone looked happy. Pizza was pretty good too!

Horrible customer service and it seems to be made by people who half a** their job. The nachos (if that s what they want to call them) where just chips with microwaved cheese, the calzone was so soggy I couldn t even pick it up to eat, and you pay $3 for not even an entire pickle when you order fried pickles... everything is mediocre at best and highly over priced. Just go to an actual Italian restaurant, you ll get better service and much better food.

Gluten Free Delivery Driver here but this restaurant makes the best smelling food!! Good crew working here :)

Nothing special about this place. The spaghetti and meatballs was so disappointing. Frozen meatballs and the sauce just plopped on soggy pasta.

Food is always excellent!
Service was perfect
Thank you Tom !
Always a pleasure seeing Kevin

Cool unique place in a nice lititz neighborhood, compliments the peaceful town very well. My boyfriend and I enjoy coming here for St. Patrick's day where they dye their tap water, beer and wine green for that day, pretty awesome

The pizza tasted great! We'll satisfied with that. The service seemed to be fine, so 4 stars. I'll have to go again soon and see if I can raise it to 5 stars.

Always a great atmosphere. Everyone is super nice, always get my food very fast. The Wings are some of the best I've had.

Very cool little pub-like pizza place. Great food and atmosphere. Nice spot!

Great loaded fries and supreme pizza. Our waiter Mike was so nice

Good pizza and a comfortable, although sometimes cramped, location.

Got Grubhub from here. Absolutely phenomenal food. Fries were delicious and super crispy. Best honey mustard I've ever had. Loaded fries were even better. Garlic pizza was fantastic. Calzone was fantastic as well. The best part of UnCommon pizza is the amount of filling and toppings they don't skimp!

The pizza slice was large and the drinks were inexpensive and good! What more do you need to know?

Great food service atmosphere and dressed up Santa Helper was our server. BIG 10

Great hawaian pizza and very friendly, family oriented atmosphere

The food is usually good if they can get your order straight. If you call for delivery and get a woman who sounds like she's clueless, it's because she is. Just hang up the phone.

Recommended! Service was amazing, food was fantastic.
4 stars only due to sticky table!

Had a wonderful evening. Pizza was served hot and their but knots were just amazing with garlic butter!

We'll be back.

Wings, wings wings. They have nice wings and good pizza. Actually, never had any food there that we did not like.

Nice little bar and restaurant. Amazing pizza! Great staff.

Surprisingly good pizza. Not too thick, not too thin, not greasy, and not burnt. Ingredients seemed fresh and tasted great.

Good pizza! Good service, and beer selection. Not 5 stars simply because the crust isn't done how I personally like it, but good pizza all the same.

They've been to my home multiple times. I went through the ordering process. They ran the card, and as soon as they ran the card I was told I am just outside their delivery area and the order is 'Up in the air' whether it will make it to me or not. Really? Up in the air....after payment processed? 2 Thumbs down for the waste of time. Uncommon Pizza has Uncommon sense.

11+ years and your cheesesteaks were consistent and awesome.....what happened????
Both peppers and onions were raw and taste was way off. What a shame!

This is one of our favorite places to go!! Love sitting out on the patio.

Only order from here if you would like to wait almost 2 hours for garlic bread, ice cream, and beer. Especially if you prefer beer that's never been chilled. Ordered here at 4PM and had to call and do status checks on my order twice before it was received. When I finally received my order, the garlic bread was cold and the beer warm--apparently it had never been in the refrigerator. I called and spoke to the manager who informed me I conversed with someone regarding the beer never having been chilled. Nope no one ever said anything. Oh. And the manager told me he "had to go" when I voiced my complaint. Wonderful customer service.

I've been here a few times now. When first opened it was great. An easy 5 stars, but each trip in seems less clean. Sticky tables for example. The food is 9/10 and cant beat $5 strong long islands. The staff also seems to have gotten progressively worse this being my 10th visit, but not enough for me to stop going.

Terrific pizza; great flavor, not too thick a crust - great portion of toppings on a pizza, so it never feels like it's just sauce and cheese - oh, and craft beer on tap! One of my favorite local pizza shops, and a great "hidden" gem!

Limited menu options. Good for half priced apps on Tuesdays.

Uncommon Pizza is a lovely, uncommon neighborhood restaurant.

Very good food!
Such nice people, including their delivery people.

Always friendly service, good food, good vibe, nice outdoor seating area

Super good pizza and fast. Arrived early and driver was very friendly, thanks!

Friendly staff, delicious pizza and wings. Good beer specials and selections.

Good soup and pretty tasty pizza. I got one of the lunch specials - of a cup of soup and a slice of pizza for $4.99. Great deal and the pizza slice was about twice as big as a normal slice.

Great food, service, atmosphere, and long islands.

Love it. Dollar a slice night. Bacon pizza is my favorite and was better than ever last time we came.

A little too expensive for what it is; an average pizza place. Surprising good nachos though.

The smokefest pizza. It's all the meats and it's cooked to this amazing crispness. I get it Everytime and after awhile I'll crave it and come back for more. It's just damn good pizza

Great food, great beer, great service. This place is definitely an A+

Great and friendly service, comfortable nice place to grab a bite and a drink.

This is our go to pizza place, great service, great food. We are here probably once a week! Can't beat daily$5 Long island!!

Great variety, friendly staff, great ice cream made in-house

Im bummed to say something changed here, we visited last summer and it just did not taste like it used too. The ambiance of the location in summer was great the food not so much. Dont know what happened but prob wont go back :(

Tucked away seemingly in the middle of a housing development, this little joint is worth the hunt. The pizza was very fresh and tasty. Not a thin and greasy style of pizza, more of an in between pan and thin. The sauce, cheese and toppings had great flavor. I especially liked the crust, something about it tasted nice but I couldn t place it.

I also had a side of Loaded Fries and they lasted about 2 minutes around my family. They were very good.

Service was great for an early Saturday lunch. Dining room was very clean. The prices are average, 16in pizza w/ topping, loaded fries and 1 soda costs $26.

Overall, worth checking out when in the area. They also have a full bar but I don t drink, it looked very clean though.

You have to try the cheese fries with hot and sweet peppers and a side of ranch. Sandwiches are delicious. Pizza is good too

one of my favorite pizza places. The brick oven taste makes them one of my top 3.

Best pizza I have found since moving here 7 years ago.

Good service and fun food. Great Old Bay wings. Nice, covered outdoor seating a a few indoor tables available before 5pm. After 5 seating is outdoors only. Becky was delightful and patient in waiting on my chatty Cathy husband and I.

A hidden gem! Great pizza, cheesesteaks & calzones, etc. Always good service too. Nice patio for outside dining.