Send a very nice location however it's not very obvious from the car. And it's more like just off the corner of Paxton st. Rather than directly along it . The staff here is very friendly and helpful. The food however was only so-so there's several other pizza places like this in the area that are much better. So unless I was a resident of the Apartments and Townhomes that surround the pizza place I don't think I would go back.
We all enjoy their food, and mostly find ourselves there on Tuesday for half-price wings and appetizers (which are big enough to be a meal)
Amazing atmosphere and the wings are great! The Employee's are very nice and the outside patio is nice in the summer. Love the fresh margarita pizza.
Not impressed. Won't be back. Pizza was mediocre at best.
I had my son's rehersal dinner here...and it was Awesome. The food was Great and the staff was so helpful and accommodating. I am sorry I don't live in the area because I would go back here all the time. Thanks everyone for a Great night!!
Food is amazing. Owners are good people. One of our meals was taking longer than the others. Without us expecting or questioning anything, they covered our bill. We d go back anyway because the food and atmosphere are so good,
Great local place! Friendly staff and terrific food!
Food is decent bar food. Employees are friendly! Especially Andrew and Tom. :) Only complaint some of our friends have that frequent Uncommon is they need to change up the menu. Maybe offer some dips,hummus, crab, buffalo just to name a few. Different salad options and more dinner options too. Also offer some non fried foods. Quesadillas would be an added bonus! Awesome place,with creative drinks just need to change things up a bit!
Went a few days ago with my friends. Good amount of beers, good wings and great pizza. Nice place to go for pizza
Pizza is ok quality however the freshness of their meats has been incredibly disappointing. My wife ordered a salad with grilled chicken and we found out they cook the chicken, then freeze it, then reheat it before serving. This made it like rubber. Based on the meatball sandwich I ordered I expect the same is done there, however that stood up much better. Unless you live in the area and need something quick, there are better options nearby. I hope they can improve their cooking.
Good service and good food for an everyday kind of place.
Not happy with them concerning COVID mandates. Went in on Oct. 30 for takeout, saw 3 employees with masks down, walking around pulling them up and down their faces while touching food. Will never get food from there again. Had I not paid in advance, I would ve walked out.
Friendly atmosphere . Everybody having fun
Food is super! Wait staff excellent. Don't mind waiting to be seated ...worth it.
And never too long..again , worth it.
Good pizza and even better homemade ice cream. Nice deck for cool summer evenings.
I ordered two single slices of pizza, great staff, cozy atmosphere, good pizza/filling. Large slices great prices.
It was my first time ordering from this place I never thought that it would take 40 mintues to make a single cheesteak then once I get home and opened the bag I realized I got a meatball sub instead. so i called back to let them know that I had gotten the wrong order and the server had no idea what was going on and said I either have to wait 5 mins on the phone to speak to a manager or wait another 20 mintues to have my order remade. so after a whole hour for a cheesteak it wasn't even good the bread was old and hard. Never again I'm wasting my time or money here
Had a chesse steak. For me no onions or mushrooms. Very good. Will be going back to try something else. Understand the meatball sandwich is worth trying.
A small neighborhood restaurant with a laid back atmosphere welcoming of kids and families.
Service is always great. This is our go-to place for wings.
What a hidden gem. Full bar, great menu, good prices. This place was PACKED on a Tuesday and I now see why. I would've never known this place was even here, had I not heard through the grapevine. Food was great, however -1 star for service because when it came time to pay our bill, we literally considered just leaving cash and hoping for the best, our server just disappeared after we had our food.. I think we waited like 30 minutes AFTER we finished eating to even ask for our check. But again, it was packed and the food was still excellent so whatever.
Such good pizza. One of my favorite places in the Lititz area.
Pros: Great food!
Cons: no beer menu, crowded and loud
Food was great...service a little iffy?? Maybe she was new??This was the first time i was there got a chef salad and it was very good.
Took home pizza and that was also good!
Love this place. Great service, friendly staff, full bar and amazing food at a fair price
Fries and pizza were delicious. I will definitely be back.
Cold beer. Great food. Amazing soups made fresh by Timmy. Homemade icecream and a friendly environment. Will definitely continue to go back. Cant forget about the awesome outside seating in a peaceful neighborhood. Just come see the place for yourself.
Friendly staff who made my nephew's day by chatting with him. Good pizza with a fun selection and plenty of parking.
This place never fails, and is so popular with the locals.
Great place delicious reasonable drinks I really enjoyed this place i was visiting from Texas I enjoy my time here
Great food and amazing staff! Best pizza experience in the area
It's a nice pizza joint. A little too dark but I would go back again. I had a Philly cheesesteak that I thought was really good. and the service is really good too. The staff seemed really friendly.
This time got the loaded cheese fries and 10" pie wth pepperoni, ham, bacon, onions, and green peppers. Very good
They have green olives as pizza toppings. The only place around!
Food is average, some selections are better than others. Service was rather slow despite the amount of staff I saw working.
We got meatball subs they were great I like more sauce but I also like that they didn't feel like they would fall out I'd also attribute them being cut in half also helping and then they dont feel like they are drowning in bread nachos were also good real cheese no whiz
Best pizza shop around. Unique location with great community minded ownership. Highly recommended!
Great food, prices, and staff! Love the look and area here! Very nice!
Excellent pizza, subs, homemade ice cream. Nice environment, good service.
Gets noisy very quickly. Good calzones. Good specials every night of the week.
Employee's are great.. wings are awesome.. and 5$ long islands all day everyday, can't beat it
Great place! Consistently good service, friendly staff, clean dining room with a cool, small bar. Daily dining specials and plenty of beers on tap. Definitely recommended.
I go there all the time and they are like family my whole family loves it there.
Hidden Gem! Great food, reasonable prices, beautiful scenery! Offers outside seating.
Top 5 pizza in PA. Best things to get: honey Old Bay Wings, buffalo chicken pizza w blue cheese or ranch to dip, pepperoni plus pizza.
The service is always good. They are busy Friday and Saturday nights. Good beer selection, pizza is good.
Nice little place with good specials and food. The wings are good and drink specials are pretty good. Not a bad choice.
Pizza was amazing! Not too greasy. My family and I dined inside. Table was really sticky. Service was ridiculous. He was too busy talking to another employee whom came in on her day off to refill drinks. My grandfather had to refill it himself!
Sadly the service has gone downhill since I was there a few years back. We sat there half of the time without getting service. Food used to be really good too, but it's not as good as I remember it. Granted I didn't drink this day either.
I had a delivery from this restaurant for the first time. What an awesome find! The staff was nice on the phone and the delivery driver was kind as well. The only thing I wish was a little different is that I wish the wings were a bit more saucy! But they were great anyway. My Philly cheesesteak was really good and the fries were awesome too! I live in downtown Lititz and they told me that my food would be delivered in 30-40 min and they were right on time! This place is so much better than the pizza shops right on my block. Why settle for less than mediocre food when I can have the best. I will call uncommon pizza my go to spot. Can't wait till next week to order a specialty pizza!
Went for lunch 1:00 service was poor
Pizza wasn't that good taste like a frozen tombstone pizza salad was fresh won't go there again very disappointed for a place with a name Uncommon Pizza this was less than common
Our entire family's favorite place. Great food at a great price.
We ordered a Super Supreme Pizza, custom veggie pizza, loaded fries, and hot garlic parmigiana wings. They were all excellent!!! The delivery was fast, and the food was piping hot when it arrived (and less expensive than most pizza chains). I highly recommend Uncommon Pizza!
Honestly some of the best food I've had, had a calzone from them last week, and this week had a buffalo chicken pizza, being from buffalo; They do truly hold up. Thanks from making my home away from home a hell of a lot better!
Great service, super friendly, very accommodating.
Great pizza at a great price!! Super supreme is where it's at!! Great job guys!
Great buffalo chicken pizza and friendly staff. Delivery available.
Food good, delivery good. But prices were not the same as menu above. I had 14 inch pizza... charged for more than the 16 oz. charged more for every item. When I called, I was polite with just the question. Was told by man who answered that I must have been looking at an old menu. Showed it to delivery guy who verified I was on the correct site. Asked manager to text me link. Said he was doing that right away. Never received text. A shame because food was good and I would have paid those prices except for the big discrepancy on the menu, on this site.
I've never had anything bad here. Plus they deliver beer!!
We tried this place for the first time today. It arrived when it was supposed to, looked, and tasted great. We asked for it to be thinner, to save on the calories. Really good sauce, and nice grilled flavor. Can't wait to try some more of their pizzas!
Family type atmosphere due to the friendliness. Also the food is great!
Cute place but really disappointing product. $9 sub w next to nothing on it, very sloppy. Save the tiny bag of chips and learn how to make a sandwich like its not a complete afterthought.
Great food and prices are fair. Very small dining area
BBQ chicken pizza wasn't that good in my opinion. Also, delivery took way longer than expected and the coffee was cold.
Great food and drinks. Great service and atmosphere.
Food is decent. It's kind of small and really out of the way. Unless you live close, not worth the drive as far as I'm concerned. But I've never been disappointed there.
Food is good. But as usual during busy time, they are not up-to par in service. They forget things and when you re-ask, they don't like it and do fake apology.
Their subs and pizza are very good. Got their lunch special, $6.99 for a 6 inch sub with chips and a soda. A side of fries will cost you a little over $2. We split a basket of fries for $3.99, which was just enough for two people. Their fries are excellent and battered! They have a nice selection of drinks and a very nice atmosphere inside and out.
uncommonpizza.com