Uncle Pauls Pizza Reviews

Pizza is ok. Don't order a large one, unless you're not three or even more eaters...

By far the worst pizza I've eaten in New York! The taste of the pizza there is definitely not worth the money. In winter, an extremely cold breeze moves through the pizzeria as soon as someone opens the door (as if you were eating the pizza outside on the street). The staff was nice and that's the only good thing about this shop. We personally will not visit this pizzeria again or recommend anyone!

The most delicious pizza I ever tried. The crust is very thin and crispy. Loved it!

My wife and I found this spot on our way to her job, we grabbed a quick slice each, I had the buffalo chicken and she had the Sicilian. For a spot near grand central it did the job,

Small, but awesome NY pizza and open 24hrs. Try the grandpa, and all their specialty pizzas are delicious!!

Well first off , let s start off by saying this place is owned by an Albanian SO it has to BE GOOD. Was it good ?! ABSOLUTELY. The service was excellent. The food was delicious && the restaurant was very clean. . We got the calamari and 2 pizzas.

These guys are the best. Never closed, worked hard to serve great food and provide a little oasis when the rest of the neighborhood was shut down. Calzones and pizza Is fantastic.

Pretty good pizza. The atmosphere is excellent. The Buffalo Chicken pizza was very good, and had quite the heat kick. The prices are very reasonable. I'd eat here again.

The waitress lied about the small pizza being tiny so she got is to buy a large one which was too big for 3 people.

Tis a nice and cozy place with great fast service. All of the food was incredible and they even make gluten free pizza which Talia rated a 6 or 7 on her scale of gluten free pizza. This in comparison with the scale ranks 1 point higher then Domino's gluten free pizza. There is a large selection of snapple and wine as well as some soda options. I cant much touch on the quality of the wine, but I can confirm the snapple was exceptional. I recommend this place to anybody who likes good food, good mousse, and great pizza, gluten free or otherwise.

Solid late-night pizza joint with friendly staff. The Sicilian dough is particularly good, if you're looking for a change from the classic NY style slice. The salads don't shine as much as the pizza, but let's be honest, we're you really looking for anything but pizza at 2am?

Excellent neapolitan pizza, great service and friendly staff ! Prices are very reasonable.

A must! We took our first family trip to NYC and had to try NY pizza. We were referred to Uncle Paul's and we enjoyed it.

Extremely delicious, a small space but well attended, the prices are quite normal and the place cozy

Great experience for my family I our trip to NYC...terrific food and excellent service...pizza was special

Next to our hotel, small and unpretentious place but with great pizzas. Good cover, great sauce and big apple type size. The price is very honest and the service is very friendly. Whole pizza or individual piece.

The pizza was good but, for being an authentic Italian pizzeria... I make much better sauce than what was on my ziti... taught by great grandma from Sicily! The young girl that was serving NEEDS retraining! I finished all my pasta before I had to get up and ask the cook for my slice I never got!
WON'T be going back... EVER!

Best pizza I ve had during my stay in NYC. Service was good menu was priced fairly.

Food was good, service was good, Caesar salad was excellent!

I wasn't going to write this but she hung up on me when I called. I looked on the website and there are no beads of clear liquid on the photographed pizza, there were on my slice it was flavorless. Also their delivery guy and two customers harrassed me every time they passed by so I was harrassed continuously.

The location is great to run in for a quick bite. People working behind the counter are friendly and provide quick service. Pizza is excellent but a little over priced.

I had a calzone, which looked good, and I finished with diarrhea that night. Plus, who puts ricotta in a pepperoni calzone? That tasted disgusting

Cozy place, the pizza is made at the moment and as a result of that very good pizza, good service and price

Really really good. Just got spaghetti and meatballs and small pizza...waitress gave me wrong pizza and was going to make new one...but the spinach and mushroom pizza she gave me was delicious. Small place, super cozy. Order to go or get there before rush.

Great NY style slices, fast service, reasonable prices. Around the corner from The Roosevelt Hotel.

Good food for a quick meal. 10 tables to sit. Most take out. Beer and wine available.

Excellent pizzas and friendly service, reasonable price. Fully recommended

very bad attention, they overcharged us for pizza and beer and when I went to clarify the situation, they were decompressed, there are definitely better places

Awesome place, very quaint. Our server was very nice and very good. Food was hot and tasty. We had pizza.

Fine location for pizza. Great place to chill, get away, eat some good food. I had a cousin come into town and she asked me to go back here. It has a great feel to it.

The pizza was good but the service needs improvement.

Good pizza. Quiet place right near the craziness of Grand Central. Friendly staff who doesn't rush you out. Can be a little warm on hot days.

Small place, GREAT FOOD, cool atmosphere. We wanted a quick bite of pizza. It smelled great in passing, so we stopped in. We ate the Lobster & Corn pizza, TRY IT. Service was good. Food was Great. Location, 1 block from Grand Central.. Go try it.

Second time here. First time I got a take out. Today we sat in. AMAZING PIZZA topped off with a couple of cold beers. Perfect

I went with my family and we loved the Pizzas, good service and very fast. We ordered pieces of Pepperoni, Buffalo Chicken and a vegetarian pizza, everything was delicious. We could not salads or anything other than extra sodas. For a fast, quiet, economical and rich meal, it is a good place. Very close to The Roosevelt Hotel which was the place where we stayed.
Highly recommended

I had an amazing in this place. We loved the amazing ambience and the menu. The staff members are very friendly. I m happy we ultimately decided to visit here.

I ordered $80 worth of food from them to my hotel while I was visiting New York... It included 3 desserts worth $10.50. They called to say that one of the three deserts was out of stock and asked if I'd like something else. I said no, and then they said "wait, it just came" and hung up. The food came, they handed me the bags, and they left. Then I notices that instead of the $10.50 worth of desserts, they had put in 3 cookies that they claim are worth $2 each. First of all, $6 worth of stuff doesn't replace $10.50 worth of stuff. And secondly, we didn't want chocolate chip cookies! I called slice, who called the pizza place and connected us. The pizza place said that they were out of the cake and just forgot the other two. I said I don't want the cookies, they can issue a refund or bring me what I paid for. They said they would come back to pick up the cookies and then issue a refund. Well they didn't come back or issue the refund. Two days later, I left the cookies in the hotel as I checked out, and I filed a complaint with my credit card. This company is crooked and petty. They think they can just cheat people and get away with it! If they fight with me over the credit card refund, I'll copy this review to every site out there.

Great pizza, great service and a great price! Would recommend adding this to your holiday itinerary if you're looking for a good pizza near Times Square!

Service is good staff a nice. Pizza is super expensive and not worth the money.

Worst customer service ever. Food takes an hour and half to deliver and my order was incorrect. When I called to ask where my order was they got nasty with me.

Great New York pizza !!! A little over priced got two slices of pizza with spaghetti and meatballs for $29

Great there .. good food but if you want normal pizza you can order the small ... I didn't even get it on the service is great and the prices for Manhattan are not too bad .. so highly recommended !!!

Very good food. Service was a little slow, but overall, we would go back again!

Place is a little grimee
pizza & canoli R good

I constantly stop grabbing some food in this place. I enjoyed the speedy service and well cooked food. They never disappoint.

From out of town, but got to try a few pizza joints in manhattan and this was our favorite. Great, thin style pizza! Very nice, quick service as well.

Great pies, although a fairly limited selection of premades. Very cozy atmosphere with attentive service

The service was very poor. While we were seated, we were given an attitude because we forgot to put our outside drinks in our backpacks. The service behind the counter was sub-par and seemed confused when we tried to order food. As we were eating, parties were seated based on the size of the party and the convenience of the restaurant, rather than by the usual first come first serve method. Overall, it was a very strange restaurant with average pizza.

I had never tried the New York pizza until I ordered here to take it: either my palate is very exquisite and demanding or just pizza is not a strong American culture, as one sees everywhere. The caprese pizza was not such, it seemed more a rejunte of ingredients than anything else. While the size of the pizza is huge and that may be a must for most, when I asked the seller for advice, she suggested that I bring a whole pizza for two people and ended up being almost half full, when the most convenient thing would have been That he recommended me to take loose portions and not a whole pizza. The setting is nice, but when I bought to go I was more thinking about the quality of the pizza, which ended up disappointing me, as much as the saleswoman.

Hands down awesome pizza! And the staff is super friendly!

definitely worth a visit very busy lots to pick off the menu staff very friendly NYPD picked up a take away so locals use it which says it all pizza I had was very nice will definitely go again

The variety of pizzas really nice. I think aome things in the menu are a bit prizy but overall really good pizza. It small and not suitable for handicaps.

Great little spot! Pizza is great, service is great too!

This Buffalo chicken pizza is FIRE!!!! Excellent service, fast and good! Recommend stopping by for a slice.

In an entire city full of restaurants we went 3 times.

This was the first place we ate on our first trip to New York and we were not disappointed! I got the lasagna pizza and my husband got the meat lovers. It was absolutely delicious! The only downside is they serve canned sodas but that s not enough to keep us away. We will definitely be back if we ever come back to New York!

Great pizza, friendly service, and the house made tirimasu was very good!

Talk about delicious pizza!!!! I had this place in my bookmarks and when my sister asked for a pizza place I immediately said: let's go to Uncle Paul's Pizza NY!! Service was phenomenal.

Chipotle chicken slice is fire real talk I low key love this place I go here after work when I'm treat yoselfing myself that's a 5 slice rating