Uncle Pauls Pizza Reviews

*Racist Experience*
I came into the restaurant for two slices. Literally was ignored while standing at the counter as they stood behind counting money. I asked them to take my order they looked at me annoyed took it but never greeted me. As I stood there 2 white families walked in and were immediately greeted cheerfully and asked if they needed seats etc. A girl came from the back and took their order long story short they got everything before me. I won t be returning to this restaurant not only because the horrible service, but because the pizza is TRASH it tastes like $1 pizza

I just had a very unpleasant experience during my lunch. Right after we ordered I saw a massive cockroach crawl on the wall and flies all over my food. This restaurant has an A rating and I am utterly dumbfounded how that is the case. I would never walk near this place again.

Wonderful experience. Great service, reasonable prices, and nice atmosphere. The prosciutto and caprese pizzas were phenomenal.

If you haven t been here you re missing out their meatball Parm hero is the best !!

Its Uncle Paul's, you can't go wrong! ....order....eat....smile.

Had a fantastic experience in this spot with my girlfriend. The food comes fast and the service is just good. Prices are convenient.

Haven't had such a good slice in awhile. Tried four different slices and they all tasted great. My fav was the Lasagna slice.

Love this place. Been to NYC five times and always stay the weekends around midtown. After exploring the city all day you get back to the hotel and are starving. On a Saturday night it's hard to find a place thats not loaded with obnoxious tourists and needs a reservation. We were wandering around and noticed all different types, construction workers, police officers and regular people all coming in here and grabbing a quick slice. Sitting down the first time... And everytime since, the staff is great. All the meals we have had there are amazing and the place is cozy.. Great for a cold rainy New York night. The pizza... I dream about this pizza.... I can't find anything like it at home. It may be a bit off the main tourist drag... Like a little hidden gem tucked away in Midtown.

Popped in here on a rainy night and the place was packed. Ordered a few different pizza slices and overall were impressed. The grandma's and Neapolitan were our favourites. The Sicilian pizza wasn't bad. We also ordered a Caesar salad which was tasty, but had too much dressing for my liking. The rice balls were quite nice and cheesy, but not the best we had. Cosy place with okay service!

This place is amazing. We stopped here late night after the US Open. It really is true...all the good things they say about New York pizza. You buy this pizza by the slice. They had a variety of HOT pies to choose from. I had a slice of lasagna pizza. It had crumbly sausage and ricotta cheese. The mix of flavors really did make it taste like lasagna on pizza. It was so good!

Love the minimalist experience, great tasty pizzas, a bit pricey for a pizza joint, probably due to proximity to GCT

Their pizza sauce is amazing, take a pizza with tomato aauce no matter what. The cappucino is nice too.

I came there, craving good pizza, and not the Pizza Hut style pizza: real Italian pizza. The first bite was like a shot of heroin, not that I ever tried that... it was so good! Took another slice

Excellent pizza, very attentive the waitress, very well priced a place to return. Super recommended.

Great authentic brick oven pizza, nice place to sit, decent service.

The pizza was ok I guess, was very bland not my best first impression of new York pizza

Their spaghetti is good but their meatballs are absolutely delicious. You have to try them. I am amazed they aren't made buying an old Italian lady because they are among the best meatballs I've ever had.

Great pizza and a very friendly staff. Small place with a good selection of delicious NY style thin-crust pizzas.

One of the best places to grab a slice or pie in Midtown. The prices are competitive and comparable to the high-tourist area (i.e. overpriced) but the pizza tastes good and if you choose to stay and eat-in, the environment feels warm. My first time visiting, the owner came up to our table (just me and a friend) and said "Hello."

Waaaaay overpriced for average pizza payed 8 dollars for 2 cheese slices not including a drink or anything else....just ate thr pizza its very delicious

Really enjoyed the buffalo chicken pizza but also tried the grandmas sicilian and it was quite bland.

Pizza is delirious! The space is small, but cozy. Staff was very polite. Sangria was like overly sweet juice though. But ordered a pie and took slices home too!

Grandma pie is best. They're open 24/7. Service is always friendly and prompt. A hidden treasure.

They have a nice pizza and more than an extra flavor such as paprika or vegetables and freshness in front of your eyes settled .. A small restaurant, clean and excellent service and very close to the metro and the hotel Rose Felt

Food is delicious,service is fast, nice place to eat in, but tables are too small

We ordered pepperoni and sausage pizza and it was legit! Food came out hot and fast.

Service was horrible, however, the pizza was good. Got better pizza from corner shops though.

Really good pizza! Got two slices on our first day-late afternoon. Highly recommend it!

Uncle Paul's was right around the corner from the hotel I was staying in, and boy was I glad it was. I stopped in just to get a slice to go but ended up also getting a calzone, some wings, and decided to eat in house. Yes, wings at a pizza place. They were fantastic. Staff was really nice and had no problem making a spot for me. Thanks for the delicious pizza Uncle Paul.

Pizza was awesome. Ordered the 18" for a family of 5 at lunchtime. First time visiting NYC. Actually went back for dinner the same day. it's that good!! Liked the service and the cozy atmosphere.

I bought three different pizzas. Base of pizza is soft and tasty and good texture. I like those.

Pizza was great, service was great, had a place to sit and enjoy a nice lunch

Nothing fancy, fast food type .. Paper plates on a tray.. But still reasonably good...

A good place to stop for pizza at night, after a play in Times Square. It's on Madison Avenue, so it's not your typical Times Sq place with lousy service and bad food, however it's pretty close even passing through if your hotel is in East Manhattan.

If you want excellent New York pizza, this is the place to visit. Just order a plain cheese pizza and you will not be disappointed.

In my top 5 of all time pizza joints. You know it's good when you have blue collar and suits motorboating pizza pie at the same place. Buffalo Chicken good, lazagna fanominal.

Best gluten free pizza I ve ever had. Came all the way from Portland for this.

Last night in New York City I found this little hole in the wall, The food was good Marinare Sauce was good can't complain everything was great. The waitresses were awesome. Next time I visit New York I'm going to try the pizza.

Great pizza by the slice. Buffalo chicken pizza filled the void too many times late at night. Couldn't go past it! Can't wait to get back.

Overcharged for our pizza (35$ US in comparison to the 25$ US it should have cost for two small pizzas; 5 locals in front of me didn't pay more than that). Our pizza was not the same quality that was displayed or given to others. We had a bad experience, you may not. The restaurant did smell great and had a great atmosphere.

One of the richest pizzas I've tried, the small but very cozy place. Very good service

Ordered 3 pizzas and they were all great. Love the Chipotle chicken one the most!!!

I've left review before, but deserves another! Amazing place all around!!!

Delicious pizzas. Very nice people. If all albanians where like them, americans would love to become albanian citizens.

Great late night pizza. Easy walk from Times square.

Great food, great service! Came with my 2.5 year-old, and the whole staff was wonderful and treated him so well, despite him running around like a mad man. Made him an honorary employee!

Nice pizza. I am Italian and I can eat pizza here. Not a in Italy but more than decent. I could even come back. Approved :-)

Uncle Paul's has GREAT Pizza. Located near my office, we're often here for lunch and we have never been disappointed. I've had many flavors of their slices along with Chicken rolls, Chicken parm sandwiches, etc. And if they're not too busy, the guys will even make what you like, if they don't have it on the ready to serve counter. These guys really know how to make flavorful and delicious Italian fare.

On the corner of the Roosevelt Hotel, great ambience and very reasonably priced for where it is. And Great food!

Old world friendly service. I felt like i was in northern Italy having dinner at night. there was lots of exciting choices to choose from for style and toppings. food was served supper hot :) and the staff was very helpful and friendly. I saw lots of regulars coming in to pick up dinners or stacks of pizza which says a lot about their quality and reputation. My family would go back on future trips to NYC for the great experience next to Grand Central station. BC from Long Beach Ca. :o )

Excellent New York style pizza and affordable. If you find yourself in New York, don't hesitate to give this place a try.

If you want to experience NEW YORK this is the place to go. And not too expensive either!

Pizza was burnt and so disgusting. I couldn't even finish both of my slices.

Not the most amazing place. The food was okay, hit and miss with the taste had to cover it in other continents. The service was lacking, a bit rough and inattentive, I wouldn't go back especially with all the other choices around. The arrow and box around the tip option wasn't a great end to the night either.

I came from California to visit, They didn't provide me with explicit information, no Parisian cheese...

Small pizza joint, kind of tight in the seating area, expect a bit of a wait at the door depending on the time you go. I had a slice of the caprese (mozzarella, tomato, and basil) pizza; boyfriend had the sausage stromboli, both were very delicious. We also had two Blue Moon beers. The total for all of that was $30 but I thought it was worth it. The service was a bit less pleasant than I would have liked but in their defense they were slammed. All around a good, quick food stop. Would do again.

Excellent service. Pizzas and dessert were terrific. I will sure come back!

They have the best spring mix salad I've ever had, they serve it with nice roasted red bell peppers I think they're marinated. I loved the salad. But the pizza was not good, the sauce was way oversalted.

Most ass back pizza place ever. rude people behind counter. No pizza ready when they open then have specially ready before plain slices...

Great Pizza and friendly staff. Absolutely loved their double anchovy white pizza..... Best I have ever had.
Highly recommend

Good place in midtown to sit down and have a slice or two.