Love this place. Been to NYC five times and always...

Love this place. Been to NYC five times and always stay the weekends around midtown. After exploring the city all day you get back to the hotel and are starving. On a Saturday night it's hard to find a place thats not loaded with obnoxious tourists and needs a reservation. We were wandering around and noticed all different types, construction workers, police officers and regular people all coming in here and grabbing a quick slice. Sitting down the first time... And everytime since, the staff is great. All the meals we have had there are amazing and the place is cozy.. Great for a cold rainy New York night. The pizza... I dream about this pizza.... I can't find anything like it at home. It may be a bit off the main tourist drag... Like a little hidden gem tucked away in Midtown.