The Plum Tomato Review

Thin crust pizza - wood fired - what else do you need oh yes sprinkle on the great service

Website is deceiving, thought it was a nice place to meet for a first time date but was more a Mom and Pop type restaurant, other then that I would go again for lunch sometime if I were in the area.

Food was good service was very good and selection of beer was surprising

Although I see many people raving about the pizza, our experience with a take out order last night was different. The Sinatra pizza was supposed to have sausage and roasted red and green peppers. We also asked for raw onions which looks like we paid approx. $2.00 more that. The base flavor of the pie was good BUT we saw scant sausage, peppers and onions. What was on was thrown onto one side of the pie. Had a similar experience with the Salem location on a white clam pizza. Won't be anxious to do their pizza again.

We love TPT! They always have the best combinations for pizzas and any of their grab and go salads in the take-out section are always fresh and tasty. They also have a great beer and wine selection. One of our favorite pizzas was one that was a special; it had sweet potatoes and caramelized onions - there were other toppings but those stuck out and were SO GOOD! TPT doesn't disappoint and there is something for everyone :)

Great food, great portions, great prices, great service

Stopped in for a quick bite after a lacrosse game nearby. Great wings, amazing wraps and some of the best pizza I've had in years. Worth going out of your way for if you're not in the area, and if you're in the area it's a no brainer.

In all the years I have been ordering from plum tomato I have never been treated so poorly....Damien who claims to be the manager and work there for 9 years was extremely rude and said he made our food him self......not only did we get made the wrong size order and ca and complain about that.....but then cut into our food and it doesn't even the same toppings we ordered......then we get told our refundwas processed AND IT WASNT ...........for starters our order was over $100 for a family of 4....... and we ALL WAYS tip well and appreciate our plum people. But they have gotten sloppy and try to justify it.......SO disappointing....my whole family is!

The hours posted are not what they follow, I would have ordered earlier if they had posted their hours correctly. This will affect my future patronage. 8:30 Thursday night.

They were ok. We have been to other pizza places where they pile on toppings and the crust is much tastier.

Hip and trendy seems to E the driving force, no Italian dressing.

Their woodfire & brick oven pizza & sandwichs are AWESOME, everything is so fresh!!!! Best wings ever !!!! & Good beer

They take pride in their food creations...this is in reference to taste not appearance. The atmosphere is as dressed down as can be and the staff are good natured people....at least the 4 people i have encountered so far.

An amazing variety of creative pizzas, many with creative names. Some of those names harken back a few years, like the "Buttafucco"! Don't be fooled by the somewhat humdrum exterior -- great food inside. And reasonably priced.

Absolutely the best pizza around period. Everything on the menu is fresh and great tasting. Go here every chance I get.. Simply awesome.

2.5 only because service sucked and the bathroom was gross.. We were ignored for 15 minutes while tables and incoming customers were taken care of. Had to actually call the restaurant from our seat to ask why we our table was ignored. Food was good but disheartening to be ignored. Made eye contact with the hostess 5 times. She knew we were there.

This is an excellent restaurant with some interesting and tasty ingredients. The option of getting any sandwich as a salad is one huge selling point for the Plum Tomato.

Great consistantency and wonderful service, certainly the best pizza in Colchester

We went here because you saw it reviewed on TV thought it would be a great place to try after hearing some of the reviews, but boy were we wrong. The food had no flavor whatsoever and my husband's meal was so salty he might as well have ate salt right out of the container. The only good part about this restaurant was the wait staff.

They actually give you sauce on their wings. THOSE WINGS!!!! AMAZING!!!!

I'm going back for them wings.

The pizza was on point too.

A delicious dinner for our whole family....salad, pizza, wings...all excellent. Super easy online ordering and payment and easy pick up! Cant wait to order again....pizza was still crispy when I got home!

Got there not too long before close but the staff still treated us with patients. Food was incredible. Decor is fantastic

Menu had a wide variety of foods to select from.. Not just pizzas. The Anthony Sandwich is Excellent!! "Eggplant, artichokes, onion, tomato, provolone and feta cheese, spinach with creamy garlic dressing". Stop in.. Enjoy the food and pleasant staff.