mcnultys Reviews

Wonderful place to buy tea and coffee, the store is ancient and wonderful, inexpensive. And you find everything

This is my favorite tea shop in NYC. I've been coming here for years now. The loose leaf teas are reasonably priced. You're looking at the whole range of teas, from $ to $$$. It's a great place to buy 1/4 lb of different teas to try things out at home. I'm not sure about the coffee, but I've once encountered a couple that comes here regularly from upstate, just to stock up on coffee. So that says something good about it.

As for the service, they're an excellent NYC establishment. There's another review that said the service was terrible, but I strongly disagree. If you're looking for a white glove establishment that will wait on you hand and foot the moment you walk in, this is not the place (maybe try Te Company). If you're looking for a place that lets you shop, smell, and peruse in peace first (then follow up with help when you're ready), this is the place. This is absolutely my preferred tea shop for the variety, knowledge of staff, and atmosphere. It's relaxing and no fuss but with the high quality tea I've learned to love and enjoy.

Great local place to find quality teas. Nice selection of both staples and more exotic varieties.

Attentive, friendly staff, a wide variety of beans from all over the world, reasonable prices.

More like McNutty's....yeah I got teabagged @DirtyRod7

I get all my teas and coffee beans here. There's a spectacular selection of loose teas from all over the world and a wide variety of coffee sold with whole beans or ground for you. They even have fair trade coffee beans.

Charming tea ship with lots of interesting varieties of tea and tea paraphernalia.

We moved across the street and could not ask for a better neighbor store . They are knowledgeable and honest and make the best recommendations. Never want to live without them

It was my first time visiting your Coffee Shop and I was very satisfied with the service that you provided. Your staves were all very professional and friendly. The place was also very cleaned and organized. I must strongly recommend your Coffee Shop to all of my family and friends. Cheers for more customers!

Excellent selection. A delight to walk in the door and experience tea in all varieties and quality levels. Don't miss this little shop!

An impressive selection of coffee beans and teas, plus knowledgeable, courteous staff; I hope that this place survives the unwelcome changes in the area

What a gem! Excellent variety of fresh teas and coffees!

An amazing selection of tea and excellent, friendly service make McNulty's one of my favorite places in NYC.

Best coffee shop, that does not brew coffee in shop.

Wow! The aroma of coffee and tea are almost overwhelming.

Old school tea and coffee shop. Excellent selection of green, black and herbal teas. I got the "1001 Nights" blend, which was amazing.

Best tea shop in NYC, knowledgeable and friendly staff

Ordered the cookie monster latte, which while very pretty tasted watery and did not have a strong espresso flavor. I'd recommend giving it a try if it's your first time, but I personally probably wouldn't come back with so many other amazing coffee shops in the city.

One of the best tea stores I've been to. Lots and lots of teas to choose from. Good prices, excellent customer service.

Historic tea shop with tons of unique teas. I like coming here when I'm in town to try something new and get some old favorites. This is a cozy space that takes you back in time.

Wonderful place, knowledgeable staff to help you. Great teas and coffees.

The best coffee and tea selection around! Always fresh teas and beans of a high quality at great prices. Highly recommend the Old Judge s Secret Coffee.

The smell you receive when you walk through the doors is a sign of the quality of the teas and coffees in this tiny tea shop in the west village. Not very expensive and extremely high quality of teas. Worth a visit just to stick your nose in some of their teas and get a whiff. I purchased enough tea for 50 cups of tea and only spent 10 dollars. Amazing tea shop and coffee store.

A wonderful old shop, crowded with all sorts of loose and boxed teas as well as coffee. The staff is friendly, but there is no self-service, so there is usually a wait to get your selections.