mcnultys Reviews

Amazing selection of teas and coffees. Do yourself a favor and drop by.

Always great selection of loose leaf teas and prices are good.

Like stepping into a time warp, in a good way. Good service and prices. It's cramped inside but it's frankly part of the charm.

Flavorful teas, great variety. Definitely a return to store!

Staffs was very responsive every time I asked questions. Very good job! I should highly recommend your shop to all!

My favorite place to pick up coffee beans in Manhattan. Great roasts, good service, and excellent prices--can't go wrong here. Also, my wife absolutely loves the selections of tea.

I don't drink coffee but I buy it here for my mom and she enjoys it. I like the tea and the people are very nice.

Imperial Gold China Oolong is amazing tea for the good price of 15-8oz! Highly recommended :)They have as well good jasmine tea for only 6-8oz!

Excellent place to buy any type of tea you can imagine, all the jars can be opened and smell. They also have very rich coffee varieties.
What's wrong is that the bags only say the name of the blend but not what it contains.

Excellent coffee and tea shop from many parts of the world. We tried the Peruvian which seemed excellent

I love this place and go every time I am back in town. The selection is great and you can pop the lid on the glass jars to get a whiff, just remember to put it right back! The staff is knowledgeable and can answer any questions or help with recommendations if you don't know quite what you want or what you are looking for.

Came here to work for a while. Very chill vibe, good amount of seating. Coffee is strong, can't complain. Service was fast. And it has its own parking lot!!!!

Anyone saying this place is expensive doesnt know anything about weights and prices, and math in general. This place lists their prices starting at 1/4lb (or 0.25lb). 1/4lb=4oz. Thats actually a lot of tea. The most I've seen their pricing go for is 1/4lb of tea for $10.

Compare this to David's Tea. David's Tea has their pricing start at ~$11 for 2oz of tea. 2oz is their starting weight at David's Tea. 2oz =1/8lb.....which is significantly less than 1/4lb. Doing some math, 4oz (or 1/4lb) at David's Tea is gonna cost you twice as much as this place.

So people saying this McNulty's is expensive af, are actually retarded with math and need to go back to elementary school.

Also, the quality of tea here, is better. I can get multiple steeps out of my tea. With David's Tea, I could only steep once and go through tea (and money) faster.

A friend introduced me to McNulty's about this time last year, as we are both avid tea drinkers. My first visit to the store was like a kid in the candy shop, I was overwhelmed by the sheer variety and volume of tea, and how they let you take a whiff of all of it before you buy. I have yet to get a tea from them I haven't loved. When Covid hit and the world stopped, McNulty announcing it would continue business online was a light at the end of the tunnel. My first online ordering experience was smooth and my delivery came within a week, as promised. I admit I was a bit taken aback by the delivery cost at first but it is what it is. Yesterday I placed another order with McNulty's, and chose the most basic shipping option. I don't know what elves or fairies they employ, but the order made its way to my door in Jersey in less 24 hours. I can't promise this experience for anyone else but I am taking this as a sign from God that all my tea needs shall be met by McNulty's until I kick the bucket.

Disgusting lack of service! Two employees (two middle aged men) working inside this shop, not a single customer inside. We walked in, both employees looked at us, and said nothing and turned their backs to us. Yikes. We left immediately. Too pretentious for our intended purchase of $100+ ; we found a significantly friendlier, better quality shop down a few blocks anyway.

Hands-down best tea-and-coffee specialty shop in New York, with a large assortment that rarely goes out of stock, knowledgeable staff, and a beautiful authentic interior.

Been coming here for over 10 years - best tea and coffee shop in the city.

Quaint little coffee spot with a friendly barista. Coffee is straight forward and very enjoyable. They have alternative milks - a huge plus for me! A little hidden, but worth the search if you're like me and actively avoiding a large coffee chain and coffee that sucks. :)

Go-to coffee vendor. Knowledgeable staff. Super selection.

This place is so unique! The chocolate covered espresso beans are amazing, and the staff is super friendly. They also sell Mate.

This is a New York institution. A great selection of teas, knowledgable staff. This is what tea stores used to be like. If you are nearby or care about tea you must visit.

Not too hot. Not too cold. Frothy and smooth. Just the right amount of sweet!

I always get my coffee from here! It's great and they are always willing to help if I need it!

Such a unique tea experience! A cramped shop with tea overflowing the shelves. Staff was quiet but kind and incredibly knowledgeable. They answered my questions and then measured out my desired tea from its massive jar using this old-school metallic scale. Tea was enjoyed later and I can attest to its quality. Must visit if in the area & you re a tea lover.

I stumbled across it by accident but it's a lovely little shop with an amazing amount of choice. The staff were incredibly knowledgeable and helpful. It is actually quite reasonably priced too, given its a specialist. If I'm ever back in town I'll be sure to visit again.

We have been buying our #coffee for #gaggia #espresso #chemex here for years; great selections for any flavor preferences and origins. . Love this neighborhood gem . Also always take our friends from out-of-town; a good friend visited always ask for chocolate-covered hazelnuts and their hazelnut coffee

I stop by McNulty's every time I visit NYC. Great variety of teas that you can look at and smell before buying, as well as a knowledgeable staff. The loose leaf tea is always fresh.

They have a great selection of bulk teas. The owners are very friendly and helpful. It's my go to place for great teas.

Best tea shop I've ever been to, I try to stop in every time I am in the city. A tea lover's heaven, the selection, quality, and prices cannot be topped, especially in NYC. Go.

Best selection of every type of tea your little heart could possibly yearn for AND the best pricing in the entire 5 boroughs. Forget T2 (they should have stayed in Australia and called it a day -- $13 for a little bag of tea, give me a break! PASS!)
Don't know what I would do without McNulty's...second best place in the entire city of New York for tea is Fairway.
Check it out -- you are sure to be pleased.

Lot of teas and coffees to choose from. Have patience to know about the tea/coffee by smelling it. #letsguide

Amazing teas at very reasonable prices (depending on the tea) in a quaint shop. Really knowledgeable staff.

This place has all the tea. That's right... ALL the tea.

McNulty s has such a deep collection of coffees and teas and the employees gave me answers to every question I had. Their prices are very reasonable and their coffee is superb. We bought a quarter pound of freshly ground Sumatra and Vanilla and they ve produced some of the best cups of coffee I ve brewed. I d highly recommend going to McNulty s to learn about coffee and tea and the best way to make a cup at home.

While I generally prefer to go to Porto Rico for coffee beans, McNulty's provides a better shopping experience (never crowded and always helpful) and their tea selection is fantastic, bridging the plain East Asian teas and European-style blended teas, both loose and in tins.

Mecca if you're a coffee or tea lover! (So, just about anyone.) This store smells wonderful, and the coffee (or tea) that you choose is measured out carefully and lovingly. They will answer any questions that you have and make recommendations if you're unsure about what type to get. It's always a treat to come here, and if you're lucky enough to live nearby, don't buy your coffee anyplace else.

Great place. Friendly knowledge staff. Great smells of coffee and tea.

Incredible selection of coffee and tea from around the world. Coffee is much more reasonably priced and tastes better than what you'll find in those fancy new latte art places. Very knowledgeable staff. A local institution.

A Pittsburgh landmark. I was introduced to a variety of teas and coffees here at a young age. Still smells wonderfully inviting.

A very welcoming little cafe, fun and friendly staff, good bakegoods, simply delicious. place was cool as cucumber. A bit pricey. Good place to visit for breakfast or morning coffee.

The best place to get your coffee or tea; 100s and 100s of different kinds and brands. The staff is very friendly and ready to help. Last time I got the strongest espresso roast they had, and it's delish... Visit, you won't regret.

Walking in here you feel like you're stepping back in time. The selection us amazing. Literally every available inch is taken up with amazing coffees and teas. And, the service and prices are great as well. This is a great little piece of old New York and I hope it stays around for many, many years to come.

This is a wonderful place to buy coffee and tea in the neighborhood. A store continuously running since 1895 full of charm and knowledgeable staff.

I love this place. The aroma puts you at a calm peace as soon as you walk in the door. The staff is always friendly and very helpful. Great prices too!

Wonderful coffee! Surprisingly fast for a pour over joint. Nice ambiance and design too.

Excellent selection of teas. Greens, whites and even pu erhs. Friendly and knowledge staff as well. Great spot.

NICE VINTAGE ATMOSPHERE,,GREAT TEAS AND COFFEES. FROM THE MOMENT YOU WALK IN YOU ARE EMBRACED BY THE WARMTH AND WONDERFUL AROMAS.

It is always a good place to start your day. If you want to meet 'n friend for coffee and a treat or a nice lunch, I can highly recommend this place.

This is my Togo place for the good variety of loose tea. Love this little shop and people who work there are very nice

Best place for largest selection. Fresh.
I lived across the street for 15 years-still mis them!

Just an incredible place, that goes back to a very different New York. Best selection of loose teas, tea accessories, and fine tea tins I've ever seen. Great selection of scores of whole bean arabica coffees from all over the world at variety of roast types, fair trades and organic designations, and some varieties which are fairly rare. It's also the best smelling store in New York, if not the East Coast.

An amazing old world coffee and tea haunt. The smell in the store is also wonderful. They sell bagged tea, but the emphasis is on the incredible selection of loose leaf teas that are sold by weight. They also sell coffee from all over the world, which you can purchase as whole beans or have ground on the spot. Lean on the store's knowledgable staff to help you find varieties that match your tastes! I've really enjoyed everything I've ever bought from this store.

That was my first time at that store. Nice, but 2 blends of fruit tea that I bought had some kind of medicinal sub taste that I wasn't getting when I smelled them in store, so I assumed it might be the packaging, but three green tea blends that I got are quite good, although slightly overpriced (well, that's Manhattan). I probably will give it another shot. I live in Brooklyn so travailing there is a bit time consuming.

Yum! The coffee is so good. I love the lavender latte. I was hanging in the Avenues when I popped into this cute cafe, and I'm so glad I did! The space is open & modern, the people are friendly and the vibe really contributes to the sense of community .

Great collection of flavors and genuine people who knows the trade!!

Been shopping here for decades. New owners but the quality standards set years ago are being maintained. Charming.

Superior for coffee and tea lovers, plus one of the rare handful of places left in nyc that has not been forced out by mega developers.

This might be my favorite place on Earth. When I go to McNulty's, I feel back.home in NYC. It is like stepping back in time.

My only location to purchase coffee for home and gifts. A tradition. Excellent coffees.

Best place to buy your coffee and tea. Old establishment (beautiful and old inside) with the most knowledgeable owners!

I was delighted as I visited this shop for the first time. The coffee and foods were yummy and OK. Also, the place was captivating to stay, for it was clean, stylish, and comfortable to study and chill. Honestly, for my first visit to your shop, I was completely happy and satisfied. I will surely come back from time to time. Thanks for the service!

There aren't many stores like McNulty's in the world, certainly not over 100 years old. I can't begin to imagine how many varieties of loose leaf tea they have or whole bean coffee, which is blended and ground to order. The staff is incredibly knowledgeable, and can speak to every product they sell. I can't recommend McNulty's enough.

Addition: ordering online is very easy, and the staff is very responsive to the "contact us" emails if you mix up "the bill to ship to" addresses for gifts and and forget to specify the correct grind for each coffee you order. I speak from experience.

Another heart of Village place. Not what it once was but still top of the line pick of teas

if you care at all about how your tea or coffee tastes, this shop cannot be missed.

I love Reborn coffee! They have such cute furniture and I'm in love with what they stand for

This place rocks. An independent coffee shop. Fresh in house made pastries everyday. FREE WIFI. A pleasant place to relax, check out the original artwork, enjoy a great cup of fair trade coffee. I overheard a comment. This is the best latte I ever had. This may just become my go to place to chill and enjoy a Coffee in Uptown!

Excellent selection of loose leaf teas of all types, blacks like nilgiri, greens including pearls, Moroccan mint, oolong, reds, etc.

Every possible coffee bean is available from anywhere in the world. Coffees from Ethiopia, Hawaii, Jamaica, Turkey, you name it, they got it. Many uncommon and rare teas can be found here. Friendly service and ground to order. Just the smell of freshly ground coffee makes you want to come back again and again. Near number 1 subway and the PATH. Will that be one or two lumps?

Entering this shop is like travelling back to 19th Century. Lovely family-run business, wide range of tea and coffee and very reasonable prices. Friendly staff.

World famous tea shop in business since 1895. Huge variety of tea, everything is straight off the tea farm fresh. Staff knows everything you ve ever wondered about tea. This place is just fantastic and one of those New York institutions that can never be replicated anywhere. They also have a great coffee selection and sell a wide variety of accessories. Note that they do not sell coffee or tea by the cup.

Fantastic place to get coffee or tea. Great selection from all over the world.

Amazing selection and knowledge. This is what the tea stores at the malls strive to be but are unable to duplicate.

Excellent service, friendly staves, and a cozy coffee shop! I am so thankful to be one of your customers. Every time I came here, I always have your mochaccino and red velvet cake. Your staves always served my order immediately, and I thanked them for that. I should highly recommend this shop to everyone who loves coffee!

In addition to excellent coffee, the sandwiches were delectable. Fabulous decor and atmosphere. Give them a try.