Fat Jimmy's Reviews

Called in order to go so not sure how it is eating there but was friendly and everything while there picking up order.

Just moved to Louisville and I may have found my favorite pizza place already.

Great locally owned establishment. Good food from good folks.

Stopped in to try the lunch buffet. The man working the register was friendly but, unfortunately, the pizza was bland at best.

I gave Fat Jimmy's 3 stars because of the friendly staff and the chocolate chip cookies, but I could never be a repeat customer.

I suggest that you try the Hometown Pizza place just down the road.

#saynotofatjimmy'spizzabuffet
#cici'spizzamaybebetter

Best all you cab eat pizza buffet in Louisville that I've found so far. Highly recommended people check this place out.

Affordable pizza buffet with something for everyone. Very cozy place with a friendly staff.

Great buffet. Always a good place to take the kids for lunch.

Everything was hot and fresh and friendly staff. Handling the pandemic well with new serving utensils each trip, employees and customers required to wear masks, and sanitizing. Would ve paid $15 it was that good. Support this local business.

Best pizza buffet in town love the Buffalo pizza. To die for. Maybe I will after 14 pieces

Fat Jimmy's is an awesome local gem. Friendly service and fantastic all you can eat homemade pizza. Great for families!

Great pizza buffet! I always try to support small business, I'm really glad I took the family here, everybody loved it!

Great service but it was cold in there. Great pizza and wonderful workers

My family and I eat here almost every week. And, every week we look forward to our pizza day. This is hands down the best pizza buffet for the money that you'll find. The staff is alway super friendly and of course the pizza is great!

Great for lunch & dinner with family or friends.
All you can eat pizza, salad, soup, occasionally chilli, pasta and dessert!
"Isn't it about time you got full at Fat Jimmy's?"

^ That needs to be on a T-shirt

They keep out a great variety of pizza, and it's very reasonably priced.

Good food buffet could be bigger since it is the only thing offered.

Top notch pizza pizza, great price and super friendly service.

Absolutely wonderful!!! And due to Covid, you get your own tongs. I feel like they are doing everything they can! Probably going there tonight!

Great food and great people! The buffet even had taco soup and we requested our personal faves. It was delicious!

The place has a clean, cozy family atmosphere. Caters to school kids into sports. Can get crowded accordingly. Overall is a nice hangout with a friend or two. Mostly 70-80s rock music playing not too loud. Now the food and prices. We go there at least once a week. Buffet and 2 drinks from the fountain $20. Salad is fresh as if you would make it at home. They have soup of the day and pasta too. Pizzas of different types, plain, pepperoni, beef, vegetable, pineapple, etc. Not the greatest but good. Dessert choices are cinnamon bread sticks, choc chip cookies and choc pudding. Haven't had any other food as buffet alone is very good overall. The staff is friendly and attentive. Great place.

Our family loves fat Jimmy's and will continue to go here because of food and service

Fair prices clean Place good food what more could you ask for.

Place was clean. Food was alright. Pizza a little dry disappointed Been before and was good.

Been here 4 times now with the family, and the food is good and fresh, the staff is super friendly. This place consistently hits the mark. Happy to give this place my business.

Place was yummy and it was cheap!!! 19.99 for a buffet for me and my wife. They have salad, pizza, and these cinnamon bites on the buffet. Everything was so tasty!!!!

Excellent food, very friendly, very reasonable prices, and clean. Some of the best pizza I've eaten. No doubt that I'll be back.

Great food (incredible pizza) and chocolate chip cookies. Staff very courteous. Came all the way from La Grange to eat here! Will definitely visit again!!!

I like the family style buffet a we had a birthday party there is went off very smooth and all where happy and full of pizza

good food taste like Mr Gattis but a cheaper price.

Just left 12/21/20 after eating buffet and it was great! Plenty of pizza, tasted great, friendly staff. Will be back!!!

Amazing pizza. Great staff. Best value in Louisville

Fat Jimmy's is the best!!!! My kids absolutely love it as well.

The pizza is good, the buffet is well stocked. And the place (bathrooms included) is clean

They have some good pizza and customer service is excellent

Nice, little family restaurant that has a comfy atmosphere

Love eating here. Jimmy is great and the pizza is awesome.

Nothing fancy but wonderful buffet for a great cost.

As always the greatest pizza buffet around! The place is small, with a small town, family owned vibe to it. The pizza is always yummy and the icing rolls and cookies are THE BEST.

Pretty good pizza, great service and 10 dollar all you can eat

Good value, particularly for families. Not a destination for pizza aficionados, though.

The staff is friendly the pizza is great. My son and family love this place.

Always been a fan of fat jimmys pizza. Keep up the good work.

I love this place. Great pizza, salad, cheesy bacon potatoes and more on a buffet. Many TVs and great friendly staff!! I'm a return customer!!

The food was great maybe more selection for the buffet needed. Would definitely return, hospitality was on point.

Love Fat Jimmy's Pizza, anytime or everytime we do pizza for lunch at work we go to FJ buffet. Great pizza and a good selection. They also do a good job of keeping the buffet stocked during busy lunch hours.

My first time here. We arrived around 4:30, only one other customer there who was finishing up. Salad and soup were fine. Pasta looked dried out, so didn't try. Root beer syrup/CO2 mix wasn't quite right; sweet tea was fine. Cookies were good.

At least 7 pizzas on the buffet, all full or nearly full, plus cheese bread (a lot for few to no customers). How many hours old were they? 1, 2, since lunch? I don't know, but they certainly looked and tasted dried out and old. I should have asked for fresh pizza, but for my first time here, I wasn't certain what the standard was. As we were finishing, more people came in and fresh pizzas showed up. I tried a slice. Much improved and more cheese than the pizzas they replaced, which gave the appearance they cater to meal time crowds and slight those in-between.

How much contempt do you have to have for your customers to let them pay for and eat horrible pizza. My advice: Instead of making 7 or 8 pizzas for the dead time between lunch/dinner, make 2, quartered with the toppings of the 8 pizzas, or halved with the toppings of 4 pizzas. And throw them away every hour and make new ones. Ask the few customers you get between meal times what they like in order to augment the few pizzas on the bar with specific half & half pizzas. Or don't offer buffet pizza outside of mealtimes.

And though I admit now that I should have asked for fresh pizza, (Fat Jimmy's) please don't tell me that that's what I should have done (as you've done in other reviews). It's not just the customers responsibility to ensure they get quality food, it's primarily yours. And you didn't.

Buffet is well stocked and with specialty pizza, not just pepperoni and cheese like a local competitor. Also has all day buffet.

My friends eat at Fat Jimmy's often, but I personally dislike the pizza more than any other pizza I've eaten. It's too thin, not enough toppings, and bland, not even a bargain at $10.00. But, then again, you might be more like my friends. Try it, and decide for yourself.

Awesome food! The pizza was very good. Definately recommend!

Good was good at a good price. Had a wide variety of pizza,and salad. And he made us our pizza we asked for!

Always very good food with friendly staff and a clean Restaurant.

I enjoyed everything about my experience here. Took my son here after a fishing trip, and for 15 bucks all you can eat pizza, salad, soup, and bread... Awesome!

LOVE this place for meeting w friends and family! Also LOVE that they take my kids allergies seriously. That alone deserves 10 stars.

One of the best pizza joints around. I could drink their ranch grill chicken pizza if it was a smoothy

Fat Jimmy is a great guy with great pie! Thanks again for the 15 paper plates bro!!!

Great price, nice selection of pizza with a good salad bar really enjoyed my visit would definitely go back

Employees were super friendly
Food was good/hot

Seems like a great place to take kids but since I don't have any it was a bit loud and chaotic for me. Pizza is good but not great.

Friendly people. Enjoyed hot buffet. Good value including salad bar

$10 for all you can eat buffet with drink are you kidding me what a great deal

decent pizza all you can eat buffet and very well priced

Stopped in this afternoon for my nephews birthday. Everything was absolutely delicious, service was excellent! Food was fresh and hot. Price is very very reasonable and I honestly don t think I could find a better deal in town. I will definitely be back again and again! A++++++

Great attentive customer service, and the pizza is sooo good. Pretty fresh for a buffet. Visited 4/27/21

The best calzones around and the sweet rolls are amazing!

Amazing food and even better people!!!!! I drive from out of town just to eat their food!

Best pizza buffet ever! The staff are so friendly and helpful! You have the classics but also plenty of different flavors like bbq chicken (which is my favorite). You can even request they cook a pizza, and they will gladly do it. You also have pasta and salad to choose from as well as garlic knots, cinnamon knots, and cookies.

Good food friendly service very reasonable price love it