Fat Jimmy's Reviews

Best pizza buffet in town ! Well... the only one. And I love it ! The owner is a great guy and the food is AMAZING !

We got there during a dead period the pizza was old and so the chef popped us in fresh pizza and bread sticks during our wait I ate some of the older pizza and so my opinion is that if you eat here you'll enjoy the food and service what brought me here is I heard it was better then Mr Gatti food wise and it really is better even cold it's better than when Mr Gatti is fresh

They had a really nice variety of pizza on the buffet and they kept bringing out fresh!The pizza was hot, fresh and tasty! The salad was good, spinach! The soup was really good. The chocolate chip cookies for dessert was a nice touch. Good value and friendly staff!

Everything was very good. Honestly outstanding pizza for a very good price. Would eat again if I had a bigger stomach.

Good spacing and process for buffet. Support your local restaurants!

Came from Wisconsin for Run 4 the Roses.
Was close to hotel. Amazing!!!
Everyone was friendly. Food was awesome.
Well priced. Good family spot.

Good selection of salads, hot pasta and pizzas. Perfect for lunch.

We've been coming here for a long time, and we will keep coming back. "Fat Jimmy" is a real nice guy, and the food is great. The music is nice too!

Good buffet. Good selection. Including specialty pizza's. And for $7.00 you can't complain. Try their sweet balls for dessert.

Great pizza, salads, and the only pizza buffet I know that has amazing soups as well! Fat Jimmy's is A1 in my book!

Very friendly resturaunt go there every friday with my friends
Not very packed and usually family couples of all ages and sometimes school teams come by for something to eat

Pasta was terrible pizza was subpar but the place was clean.

Excellent customer service, great food, awesome prices highly recommend!!!!

Definitely better than your average pizza buffet. Great price, super friendly staff, and good pizza.

Great food, great people and great atmosphere. The staff were so nice and attentive.

Great pizza, good selection on the buffet, family friendly with friendly and helpful staff

Pizza is awesome and buffet is even better when it's open.

Went there for the buffet. I've never been more disappointed in a buffet. One guy working who couldn't care less about everything. There wasn't ANYTHING hot. The noodles were Brown from sitting out. The sauce was cold. The taco soup was greasy and gritty. Plus he only gave me enough to fill my spoon three times before it was all gone. The only thing hot was my pizza I had to custom order. The cheese potatoes were cold and flavorless. By far the worst pizza buffet I've ever had. Which sucks because I've heard good things about this place.

We tried Fat Jimmy's Pizza yesterday and it was SOOO good you guys. For the buffet plus your drink it's only $10.

Fairly good pizza. Quite a few different options including a pizza bar. Service was friendly and had good atmosphere

We love this place and will drive across town to have it. It's simply the best "value" pizza in Louisville and it's hard for a person with my, uh, appetite to not crave the buffet once a week. While I'm able to temper my consumption to less often than that, it's only because I don't want to explain any health issues to my doctor.

EAT THIS PIZZA!

My favorite pizza on the planet chickenbaconranch is the bomb

Overall, a good experience. $10 for buffet and drink (as of this posting). Salad, soup, cheese bread, pasta, and several types of pizza available.

Give Fat Jimmy's a try! I plan to visit again soon.

The food was JUST OK! Most of it was cold the pasta was like ice... The staff were very friendly..... The pizza on the other hand I just wasn't impressed at all everything had pork except for the veggie and cheese pizza but who wants only cheese ? Ooo did i mention EVERYTHING WAS COLD UGH BUT IT WAS FAIRLY CLEAN BUT I WANT BE RETURNING!!! WASN'T WORTH MY RIDE OR 10 BUCKS!

Great food and staff. We take our team when in the area.

Relaxed and kid friendly. Good buffet with pizza, salad bar, pasta, awesome cinnamon and icing balls and don't forget fresh baked chocolate chip cookies.

Full five star establishment. Enjoyed service from top to bottom. Genuinely impressed and will definitely be back

Not as good as the pizza used to be from the old highlands location, but it's okay.

I am a bus driver from Detroit, I was looking to feed my group...the Great Cass Tech High Band returning from The Liberty Bowl in Memphis TN. Found Fat Jimmy's online, the food was outstanding, hot and fresh! Jimmy and his staff were great! Jimmy every bus driver and company will know about your restaurant... Thanks

I would've given 5 stars for the food but the dining room was so dirty.

We had the buffet and it was only $10! It featured many different pizzas as well as cheese sticks, pasta, salad, and the most amazing cinnamon balls ever. The staff was excellent, they even made us our favorite pizza, bbq chicken, by request. Highly recommended, we will definitely be back!

Great people... Great food super fun environment. Fantastic service

Overall good family experience, good service, pizza was not bad, clean establishment.

Love eating lunch there. Great place and great pizza.

Been here like 200 times in my life. Amazing staff, Great food, Very clean, would suggest over any other pizza place in Louisville.

Love this pizza go on a date with my co worker there as much as I can

The hostess was amazing! Very sweet young lady! When we first got there the bar looked like it had not been refreshed in a bit. However before I had finished my salad, the pizzas were rolling out. The slices I had were good. The dining room was clean. The bar area was clean. I have only two issues one the sweet balls need a dipping sauce. Also u saw a girl go up to the pasta bar to get it. She looked on her plate and found something on her pasta and threw it back into the water. I was going to say something to the hostess but her mom came and fixed another plate. So she got whatever it was in the pasta. We will definitely go back!

The pizza is pretty good for the money. Fast serve yourself buffet. It was busy so the pizzas were hot and fresh.

Food is always on point. They even take pizza requests, which is awesome. Staff is very friendly and funny. Best pizza place in town. And who doesn't love a buffet?

Went for the buffet at lunchtime. Normally wouldn't suggest a buffet during a pandemic, but Fat Jimmy's did it right. Each person gets their own tongs and serving spoon, the tables are spaced plenty far apart, service was exemplary, and the food was hot and delicious. Only thing not great was the salad was pretty soggy and didn't seem fresh. But otherwise, very happy!

Absolutely the best pizza buffet I have ever been to. I'm from South Carolina so I am by no means a local, but my family and I really liked the food here and were very happy with this place.



Pizza is fresh with a nice thin crust. Ingredient quality is superb. And they have Coke Zero!



The guy working there greeted us with a smile. I wish I could move this place to SC!

This was the BEST. The main guy Jimmy was so welcoming. Food was awesome