Fat Jimmy's Reviews

Friendly staff, excellent service and yummy pizza!! Love this place!!!

Our favorite pizza place in Middletown. Great pizza and a great buffet, awesome staff too.

Yet another drooling Fat Jimmy pizza from Greg and crew. Shared with my neighbor who had never experienced the Fat Jimmy pizza here in Louisville, KY. A very fastidious cook himself he rated the Fat Jimmy pizza a "9" on a 10 point scale. Not bad for a first impression. Love the pizza. Thanks to Jimmy and the crews.

Super friendly. Good food. Fast service. It's great seeing someone working so hard to get through these crazy times. I will support.

Great place for the whole family, chalkboard and crayons for the kids. Pizza is always tasty and warm.

Buffet was good pizza is ok, but the effort they go into to make sure things are sanitized and safe is first rate

Locally owned, the best most consistent pizza buffet with a good salad bar, soup and desserts are the best to save room for cookie, cinnamon buttery bread bread drops.. clean and always well stocked buffet 7 days a week lunch and dinner, but will cook you favorite pizza and/or dessert. My family buffet in town.. make it your families today!!!

The food was good not quite what I expected. The workers were very nice and helpful.

They bent over backwards to feed our baseball team in time to get to our next game. Great pizza, great customer service!

This is a nice little family owned and run business with a pizza buffet and all very good food at a reasonable price and if you want your own pizza your way just asked them and they will make you one.

Great pizza and salad bar. Good value for the money. I have eaten there 3 times for lunch buffet. Very popular with working people like me at lunch. Always fresh and very good.

Pizza was hot and fresh. Great service and awesome music!! All around great experience. Will make the drive again.

Fat Jimmy's has always been consistent and deliciously fantastic.

Great pizza! Also doing a very good job on keeping things clean and safe

It was ok. But reminded me of a CIcis pizza for a slightly more mature crowd

Best pizza buffet in Louisville! Super affordable and friendly!

Great Pizza. Friendly service. Best Pizza I've had in a long time. Loved the dessert pizza too

Awesome tasting if you're looking for a pizza that has flavor.

The staff are awesome with kids and respectful it all. The food/Buffet was just what we needed after a road trip. It was not all pizza and had a variety of drinks. The building was clean which is often hard for a buffet place. The price for the buffet is very reasonable for all the kinds of pizza they put out. Would go again in a heartbeat.

If you want the best pizza in town, go no further. Nuff said!

An amazing pizza spot. They have a buffet or a take out option. Fat Jimmy is always on site, working in the kitchen to make sure his name and brand are kept up to par. Coloring sheets for the kids and also a chalk board wall for you and your kids to doodle on! TV's always have recent sports playing and make sure you try their Fat Rolls.

Very nice owner and employees very delicious food very clean never out of food, drinks etc.

Wow, just wow! Right here posting this review and the pizza is just awesome! I love the all meat pizza, the sausage, and the pepperoni pizzas. I like the cheese as well. My only problems with the place is NONE! The service was just nice, nice, and all nice. I like the Pibb they have at the drink fountain. Right up there with Papa John s. Wish they could do delivery pizza too. The cookies taste good. 10 out of 5!

My son and I have been visiting fat Jimmy s fairly often for a while now and my son and I agree that if your a local or even just in the area on vacation or for work Fat Jimmy a is definitely A must, so we highly suggest that you give them a try before you leave town.

Love the food and atmosphere. Good for kids if you have any.

I would give this place ten stars if I could!! Good prices, great food, and friendly staff.

This was my first visit to Fat Jimmy's and I would have to say it was very enjoyable and reasonably priced.

Great food and great service. The pizza is always hot and fresh which is awesome at a buffet, they will even make any pizza you want if it's not out. Great value!

Don t think twice, eat at Fat Jimmy s, you won t regret it! Small town, family feel and excellent pizza! Eat at Fat Jimmy s Pizza!

Amazing pizza! Super friendly staff and really good price for a all you can eat pizza buffet!

Enjoyed Fat Jimmy's buffet tonight! They did a great job keeping everything safe and sanitary. The pizza was fresh with lots of topping varieties on the buffet. The marinara sauce is excellent! They staff was very helpful in providing toppings for salads and other extras. Plenty of space between tables too.

Currently shoving my face with this delicious pizza, I couldn't even wait until I was done to write a review! Food is great and the staff couldn't be friendlier!

Can't be beat for the money. Good buffet and the taco soup is great.

The pizza buffet was delicious and fresh. The staff made sure everything was clean and safe cause of covid. I highly recommend visit and stop in for some delicious pizza for lunch or dinner.

It was a pleasant surprise, as we were traveling and stumbled across this place , would definitely recommend it to anyone else in the area of its location.

I love this place. Every Friday (almost) the boys pull up and eat at this wonderful pizzeria. The staff is always Nice and the vibes are Nice. The food is wonderful and most of the dishes are hot and tasty. The pizza melts in me and the homies mouths. Definitely recommend a visit!

Better than your average pizza buffet. They don't offer as much variety as the chain buffets, but the quality of the pizza is far superior. Incredibly friendly staff too.

Amazing food, great service!!! My family will definitely be back!!!

Cheerful staff and great pizza. Was a great idea to eat here.

Awesome place!
I had heard a few good things before but never really thought to stop in. Now I'm really regretting not coming in sooner. Here are some highlights of my visit:
* Employees are very attentive and proactive
* Food selection is broad and accompanies everybody
* All food was excellent
* Extremely reasonably priced

We love Fat Jimmy"s! Great food and locally owned!

We have not been disappointed coming here. They keep putting fresh pizzas out. Salad is fresh and deserts are delicious. Worth the 14 mile drive and toll bridge charges.

The buffet is outstanding and very reasonably priced, love this place!

Hot food, well attended buffet, friendly staff.... Just a few reasons I'd recommend Fat Jimmy's

Fat Jimmy's Pizza is a great place to take the family good food great price What more could you ask for for $10 to get salad bar suit Pizza cookies that's the best place

Hot pizza at a reasonable price on the buffet, food was good

The buffet was great but the best of all to me were the chocolate chip cookies.
The staff were very friendly and restaurant very clean.

Had lunch here. They have a buffet with a salad bar and soup. And homemade chocolate chip cookies. Very clean and well stocked setup. 5 stars and for $10 all you can eat....I will be revisiting. Thanks fat jimmy

Great place to eat! Food is inexpensive, as well as the buffet. Workers are so nice and helpful. Food is amazing. Highly recommend.

I love the buffet everything is always clean service is always nice

Every time we have been to Fat Jimmy's pizza it has been very good. Jimmy does anything he can to please his customers and make pizzas people like.

Fire pizza spot oh I'll be back. $10 buffet is legit

They have a pizza buffet every day they're open - only place in town that I know of, other than Freddy Fazbear's Pizza (which is for kids).

Honestly the best little restaurant in all of Louisville. Portions are gigantic and delicious for such a cheap price. I used to walk there almost every day after school and the staff are bright and friendly everyday. Also sometimes the live entertainment brings a hometown smile to my face

Love Fat Jimmy's. Whenever in Louisville we eat here. Best is the Tito's. Good price, good selection buffet!

Nice laid back family atmosphere. Just the place for hungry kids and stressed parents. We didn t get any side eye looks or judged for being a little over messy and loud with a party of 8, 5 of which were crazy kids. I was impressed at the variety of options on the buffet, quality of food, and astonishing price. Staff was super friendly and helpful. Def would come back again.

Hands down best pizza buffet I've had at such a reasonable price. We will be back

Fat Jimmy's is close it's now a Mexican restaurant call Las Margarita

The food is great the sauce is real good.The people are so kind.

The Sweet Balls are the BEST!! They were delicious

Great staff, great food, great price. Always hot & fresh and multiple pizzas to choose from. Salad and pasta bar as well. Hard to beat for $10 with a drink !

People and staff are really friendly and out going. Food was fresh, and the whole place was clean. Very welcoming place to go.

My husband and I love this place! Tasty pizza, awesome cookies, AND they don't mind when we bring our case of magic the gathering decks to play. :-) Awesome service and great atmosphere.

Tried the buffet only but it is excellent. Much better than Hometown.

I ordered the Tito, a spicy buffalo chicken pizza, and it was amazing. The crust was excellent, and it had the perfect amount of toppings. The staff was very friendly and the atmosphere is fun and nice. This place is great!