Fat Jimmy's Reviews

This place is awesome !! The food was good. They have an all day buffet at a very reasonable price. The staff was super nice! My nephew loved it. We will be back for sure !

Not many places to pizza buffets all day. This place still does and it's great when you're in the mood for one!

Buffet is awesome! Always fresh and plenty of choices?!

Great pizza buffet! Loved the food, clean place, great value. Comfy place and service is excellent! Thank you!

The place had great food and the staff was just perfect. I would definitely want to go back.

Good buffet and quick to get in and out. Staff are friendly.

We went to order a pizza to our liking and it was a very good experience they even showed us how our pizza was going step by step. The delicious flavor. Thank you very much

Great buffet with lots of variety of pizza to choose from. Includes a salad bar, and they have dessert pizza. Definitely the best pizza buffet in the area.

Great food and very friendly service the kids loved it and its very affordable if you have a large family. The day we went the kids buffet was 1.99 you will have to call and see what day of the week that was but loved it.

This was my first time here in probably 2 years. The restaurant is following all Covid-19 protocols. Each customer gets a plastic tong with their new plate on each buffet trip. It felt completely safe and the pizza was good. All employees and customers were wearing masks which is A+ in my book. Everything was clean as well. I actually mentioned these different things I liked and appreciated to one of the employees and he was very happy and gracious that I complimented him and the restaurant in general. I'll try to come back again soon.

Really good pizza. And they have fresh baked cookies on the buffet.

Lunch buffet was awesome and fresh buttery balls are delicious.

Great price and good selections. Just wish the Buffett was a little bigger.

Always a great experience. Restaurant is clean, food is great, staff is very friendly and excels in customer service. Thanks!

I've been going here for a few years now and have nothing but good things to say. I was there recently, and the pizza was fantastic as always. For a pizza buffett, it was a bit pricy, but the quality of food makes up for it. The buttery balls of dough and their cinnamonny counterpart are one of my favorite things here, that I believe sets them apart in the pizza business. I was very impressed by their ability to shovel out pizzas to keep up with the heavy crowd that I experienced. This is one of my favorite places to get pizza.

Food was okay, needed a little more flavor great variety however, kids loves it, friendly staff, restaurant was clean, bathrooms needed cleaning.

MY GRANDSON AND MY GRANDNEPHEW LOVE TO GO TO FAT JIMMY'S FOR PIZZAS AND THE CHOCOLATE CHIPS COOKIES. THEY CONSIDER IT TO BE A STANDING DATE NIGHT PLACE TO GO TO.

The pizza was really good and the people were really friendly.

Hadn't been to a Fat Jimmy's since college (used to frequent the Douglass Loop location when at Bellarmine). Came to this one on a whim to be quite pleased that the buffet was just as good as I remember. Good value for the price. Certainly worth seeking out!

Fast service, plenty of pizza out to choose from on the buffet. Even offered to make something specific if I wanted it. Without a drink under $8

Mmmmm good pizza and good people, you can't go wrong with that obviously!

Took the family here due to reading a lot of decent reviews. Food was pretty good, buffet was a little small but plenty of pizza choices. Staff was friendly and we were greeted when we came in and addressed when we left. Prices were very reasonable. The only real complaint I have is that it would be nice to have spaghetti added to the buffet and maybe more choices for dessert. Other than that, overall we had a decent experience.

This place was really good!!! We were in Louisville visiting our son and he took us to Fat Jimmys for lunch. We really liked it! The staff was very friendly...my husband kept teasing them because they don t serve coffee LOL we had been on the road for 3 hours and he REALLY wanted a cup of coffee.

Words cannot describe how legendary this pizza place is. Great service, great food, fun place to be at. We love you, Fat Jimmy s!

Wonderful, love that place, only 20 dollars, me and my 2 grandkids...

We love going to Fat Jimmy's. Jimmy is wonderfull and makes us feel like family. He and all of his staff are very personable and make it a very family atmosphere. Nothing is to much trouble for JImmy and his staff. They are very attentive and pick up out dishes when they see we are getting stacked up. Monday night is my husbands and my date night since out weekend is Tuesday and Wednesday. It is very seldome we are not in there every week. Jimmy has newly painted and the floor has been changed out it really looks great with the changes. All I can say is everyone has to go there - don't miss out of a great all you can eat/

Great little find. 1st time visiting and won't be the last. Fresh ingredients, Crust was tasty! If you like Calzones, they are great.

Good pizza. Lots of variety. Good prices. All you can eat.

Our favorite pizzeria. We have a family tradition to go there every father's day. It has become the place to meet when the extended family gets together. Great buffet with lots of choices. Great price too. You will never leave there hungry.

It was delicious and the staff kept fresh pizza and other stuff on bar the whole time. Great experience. Will go back when I am out that way again

Went for the buffet. The staff was very friendly & asked if I had any requests for a specific pizza. When I finished my salad, my pizza was ready. The salad bar is small & they only have a couple of pasta options. Anyway, it's really about the pizza, which is quite good. They kept at least 8 hot & fresh pizzas out. The butter garlic balls, hot bread with icing, & cookies were all tasty, too. The dining area is tables & chairs with a few booths. Nothing fancy, but it looked very clean & they kept the used dishes picked up.

Always had a good time and good food. Jimmy's has a nice selection and staff. Only go about three times a year but leave happy every time.

Love the food and the people running and working here!

Awesome! Small town restaurant feel while still being close to the city. Super sweet owners/staff, always checking in on the customers. Perfect spot for family dinners and lunch.

Food wasn't very good. Overpriced for what we got from a cold buffet.

The pizza was delicious the staff was friendly and they had Coke Zero on tap, what else could you ask for.

Great pizza, easy to get in and eat quickly. Buffett has a wide variety of pizzas and everything is always fresh.

Great food. Awesome customer service. Always a good experience. Best $10 buffet in town. SO MANY choices on the buffet other than the 8 pizza choices. Everything is HOT. Everything is FRESH.

We are here for the weekend an came across Fat Jimmy's. At first i was sceptical due to the price being so cheap, but surprisingly the pizza was good, plenty of choices to choose from. Staff was amazing, and they are really pulling this social distancing an making sure sanitation is being done as well! Would definitely recommend, an will be coming back..

A neighborhood gem. I don't know how I missed this place for three years. Very friendly people, super tasty pizza. I tried a little of everything, and it was all good. Ten bucks including tax. It even smells like the neighborhood pizza joint. I'll definitely be back.

As I'm walking out of here stuffed , yes yes yes, if you are thinking of comming here just drop what your doing and come here for lunch or dinner .

wow wow wow fresh pizza not the cheep stuff from other pizza buffets this is fluffy full good pizza full salad bar and the cinnamon balls and cookies .

Staff was super nice and friendly, place was super clean.

Your looking at a long time customer here I'm gonna need a VIP card soon.... I'll be back when I have my daughter keep them pizzas comming

I would give more stars but well I cant put any higher than 5

Also of you want a good laugh check out their 1 and 2 stars reviews. No real complaints just silly stuff

19 years they have been around and 9 in this bldg that says something right there ......

This is an easy one. Fat Jimmy's has been a family favorite for years. Great pizza and friendly staff.

Good buffet lots of different choices and a great price

Very good pizza for the price and Very friendly crew. Thanks guys!

My experience was absolutely incredible! Great food and great service all for just a low price of $10!! The ambiance of the restaurant reminded me of my one time in Sicily. Everything about fat jimmys is beyond extraordinary! Would highly recommend!! As Ralph Waldo Emerson would have said, it s not the destination it s the journey to fat jimmys.

First time eating pizza from there. It was awesome.

Nice price with good pizza, that's awesome, add all you cab eat and I am one happy camper. The crew is friendly and quick to server. Make sure to get some buttery balls and some sweet ball it is a good way to start abd end your meal.

Great pizza and family friendly, staff is always nice!

Owner is always there. Really nice guy. Good pizza.

I went here with my daughters & grandchildren. Inexpensive, pizza plus restaurant and very kid friendly.

Always good! Only problem I ve ever had was trying to find an open seat

Very good and priced very decent. I will be returning.

Friendly place. Great butter balls and sweet balls!

Hadn't been to Fat Jimmy's in a while. My mistake!!Pizza was awesome, salad fixings fresh and abundant,beer cold.Service awesome(won;t find a friendlier guy than JImmy). Will definitely be back much sooner. Way to go. Best Pizza in Louisville(and that says a lot). For some reason this is posting as a "google user" without my name. This is from Pat Carroll

If you are looking for an all-you-can-eat pizza place for lunch. This is the most quality for the buck!

Good variety of pizza and pasta. Salad bar was good. Cookies were perfect. Great value and staff was awesome! Todd was great kept checking on the customers.

Amazing food, amazing staff, amazing price. I never thought any pizza place would usurp Gatti s as my favorite local pizza place, but fat jimmys is sure giving it a run for its money!

Went there with family of 5 and everyone loved it. Price was awesome. Pizza was fresh and delicious. Salad bar was crisp. Kids loved the chalk wall. Staff was nice. Chocolate chip cookies appeared to be homemade which is pretty cool. This place is a favorite for us now. They also offer some really great soups and chili too.

Buffet is good. It included soup, salad, pasta and a drink.

Surprisingly really good. $10 gets you a buffet that includes the normal pizza staples, as well as soup and salad options and a drink. Even at 2pm the pizza was fresh, which is a nice change from other pizza buffets I've been to in the past. Really friendly staff, clean environment. Would highly recommend for a small group to go here.