Fat Jimmy's Reviews

Very tasty pizzas. There are salad bars. Very affordable price. 100% recommendable.

Amazing pizza, and you can order your favorite if don't see it in the buffet. Pasta and salad bar are delicious.

I go here every Friday with a group of friends. It is a great place for groups of friends.

Just good food. Well stocked buffet and you are made welcomed as soon as you walk in. Nothing real special but food is good

My husband took me here for the first time tonight and oh.my.gosh am I in love. First of all, the super casual interior is fun, cozy and welcoming...there's a chalk wall for kids, and a table with coloring sheets and crayons to take to their table... The pizza was seriously some of the BEST I have had on Louisville, and I've lived here for almost 11 years now. The Tito's pizza was my jam. But, beyond the food, the affordable prices, the awesome selection, the atmosphere and the fun family friendly environment, was the AMAZING customer service. The manager and the owners son were the two working tonight and they were so sweet and kept checking on everyone in the dining area making sure there weren't any types of pizzas they needed or wanted, asking if everything was good, they even sent us home with some pizza since they were about to close. The kindness and charm and attention to customers was by far the most wonderful thing about Fat Jimmy's. We will definitely be back!

Great food and service one of the best pizza places in town very friendly they'll make you whatever you want pizza wise nice place to take your family

Very good pizza Buffett that is always kept fresh and tasty

Great selection and has it covered safety wise with all this Covid stuff going on!

Good food, good prices, mellow music and friendly staff!

Very good buffet and the best taco soup I've ever tasted! Great food for a great price!

Excellent food and nice, welcoming staff. I'll return often!

This place is awesome. It's a great pizza buffet for a good price. The people working there are always really nice and welcoming. It's a family owned place, and it shows in the care that they put into it. Easily one of my favorite pizza places in Louisville. Check it out!

My time at the Fat Jimmy's was probably the peak of my existence. It is the epitome of what people look for in a time of existential crisis. It is heaven on earth and you should take your future wife here on your first date. As Gandhi would have said, "Fat Jimmy's hits different."

Fantastic mom n pop pizza joint. The buffet had a great selection of good hot pizza. Desserts, pasta and soups all delicious. Very affordable and everyone was friendly. Would absolutely go back.

Great place. First time I've eaten here. Good value

First time vistor..Affordable and reasonable price. The selection of pizza and sides are a little short on variety thats why the 3 stars but , you get what you pay for..They served chilli which i thought was a unique touch considering its a pizza buffet. Customer service was friendly everyone greeted and smiled decent place for a bite to eat and the atmosphere is inviting for family and friends..!oh and the chocolate chip cookies are very good!!

Great pizza buffet. Down to earth and friendly staff. The atmosphere was homey. They have a giant chalkboard wall that my kids covered in drawings. Pizza was great.

Best pizza I've ever had in my whole life! Good service too.

Very good food and atmosphere. Always a good time whenever I come. Everyone is always smiling and having a good time.

It's hard to beat their buffet. Always loaded and fresh.

Our family loves the pizza, service and staff at Fat Jimmy's! They're always kind and courteous to our children, the pizza buffet is amazing!!

Everything was fresh and good, I had one problem, I ate to much! Thank you Fat Jimmy's for the good pizza!

Fresh food, lots of variety on the buffet. The staff is friendly and they keep the dining area very clean. A favorite for my family!

Great buffet and great price. The Fat Jimmy and the meat lover pizza are to die for.

Great local place to find good pizza! I especially like the fact that they have a buffet all day long. You don't find many pizza places that still have a good buffet. They keep their selection fresh and rotated. Clean restaurant including the restrooms. Come here if you want good pizza, because you will be sure to leave full. Good value for the money.

Pizza is fantastic. Pasta is also great and the salad bar is super fresh. Prices are very very reasonable! Family of 5 for under 30 bucks - can't beat that.

Standard pizza buffet, but kind of skimpy on the toppings.

Good food, nice pizza buffet selection, quiet atmosphere and very friendly staff.

Great local pizza buffet the owners are super nice.

The atmosphere was like a mom n pop retro dinner vibe.. some pizza was cold but it was the last slice on the tray but the hot fresh ones they put out simply AMAZING ... oh and the cookie were the whole shizz lol

This is such a great little pizza buffet!! The prices can't be beat & the pizza was great!! Everything was fresh & had wonderful flavors & different varieties to choose from!! I will definitely be back for more!

Great place for lunch. High quality with great service.

Always smiling and friendly service plus their food is consistently delicious! Highly recommended.

Their buffet isn't something I would go miles out of your way to try, but it is a great place to stop if you are near by. $10 is a little pricey for how much i am able to eat, and it is hard to find a better deal than the lunch buffet when it is going.

Came here on 3/9/19 while in the area on a load with my job. For the price you can't beat it $10 for pizza buffet and drink. Pizza was great and so was the taco soup. Never once while I was there did I see a pizza pan with only 1or 2 slices left on it, unlike some pizza buffet places I have been to our even empty spots for that matter. The Veggie pizza was awesome with the Oregano on it. Cheesy/Bacon potatoes could have had more cheese on them. Staff is very friendly and place was clean even with it pouring outside on day I was there. I would recommend this place to people most definitely.
Keep up the great work Fat Jimmy's, I will be back when ever I am in area and want pizza that's for sure.

Post says Google user but my name is Scott Giles and I am in the area often due to my job with XPO Logistics Express.

Pizza taste GREAT! Super nice caring employees. Fresh tasting ingredients , dough cooked just right, a family hit!!

Great service, food is good for the price, pizza is pretty good

Love the pizza here and you can't beat the price! Iv been going here for 5 years, the food andwait staff has always been amazing!

Best pizza in Louisville always leaving to that place stuffed

Great food, great pizza, great time, especially for the kids.

The pizza is good (you must try the Chicken Bacon Ranch), and the staff is friendly. And they have cookies too.

The pizza was excellent & the customer service was the absolute best!!!

Great pizza! This was our first time eating here and it was great! It reminds me of Cici's pizza minus the brownies. We will return!

Food is always hot and fresh, and soup, salad, pasta and pizza always out. Great price and atmosphere!

Great food for a good price, staff are always friendly. Would recommend!

Great pizza and atmosphere !! From the time you come in the door till you leave they are making you feel at home !!

Great price good food just stay away from the ice tea (stale & tastes like tin) and the ranch dressing (tart like it's set out too long).

Great flavorful pizzas that are unique. The pieces can't be beat and the selection is very impressive.

Family had the buffet. Pizza was okay but tasted a bit dry like it had been out for a bit. Did not notice new pizzas being put out while we were there. Sadly, it smelled better than it tasted.