The Oldwick General Store

4.5 · 242 reviews
Write a review
G
Gardner Krag
Reviews 1
2020-12-24 07:01

Best restaurant in the area. Excellent food, no ma...

Best restaurant in the area. Excellent food, no matter the season. I am always blown away by the quality of ingredients and every dish is superb. This is my most favorite American restaurant, not only because the menu variety, but the because of the atmosphere. I love the old building and classic ye...

Read full review

G
Gerald Kalin
Reviews 1
2020-12-21 23:45

Ate lunch there yesterday, my wife both ordered so...

Ate lunch there yesterday, my wife both ordered something different, both came with bread that was well over done, wife mentioned it to waiter nothing done. As I looked at mine the toast was burnt (black crust) I took the bread off and started to eat filling. Waiter came by and I had him take the bu...

Read full review

D
Doug Milnes
Reviews 1
2020-11-19 20:38

We ate on the patio for lunch which was nice. The...

We ate on the patio for lunch which was nice. The four tops are a bit crowded, but hey it's a patio. Service was prompt and attentive. We tried the flat bread pizza and we did not love the tomato sauce. We sort of wish there was a kids menu...our 5 and 8 year olds made due on the regular menu bu...

Read full review

K
Kristine Gusciora
Reviews 1
2020-11-18 08:34

Delicious high end dinners. We had the filet migno...

Delicious high end dinners. We had the filet mignonvover risotto cake ...the best I've ever had. Professional friendly staff, especially Nigel...oh, I mean Roger. Great from beginning to end. Outside seating on a gorgeous night is the way to go.

Read full review

A
Ali Hobbs
Reviews 1
2020-09-27 13:32

Nick is our favorite waiter. He has literally neve...

Nick is our favorite waiter. He has literally never gotten anything wrong. He is always so pleasant and friendly. Nick makes us want to keep coming back to the Tewks. Nick is the best of the best. He truly makes the Tewksbury Inn an amazing experience.

Read full review

M
Mad Matt
Reviews 1
2020-09-20 08:57

Just had a delicious meal here with my wife. Ive b...

Just had a delicious meal here with my wife. Ive been eating here for the past 20 yrs and having recently returned to the area i have to say im still impressed. We sat outside by the bar, our server Max was good at his job, not too pushy, just attentive and cheerful.
The food was excellent, cinnamo...

Read full review

S
Salvio Finelli
Reviews 1
2020-09-16 10:49

There aren't many dining options in the surroundin...

There aren't many dining options in the surrounding area, so this is definitely a local hotspot in the Tweksburry area. However, it's not just the lack of other options that make it such a hot spot. The food is great, they make a good cocktail and the outdoor seating in the high country of NJ almost...

Read full review

I
Irene Blewis
Reviews 1
2020-09-14 11:13

Always a pleasure to visit this restaurant. About ...

Always a pleasure to visit this restaurant. About average cooking. Great salmon dish. Others are very good also. Enjoy eating in the bar area. Dining room is also enjoyable. Also offers Al fresco dining. Staff members are knowledgeable and friendly. Prices reasonable. Street parking. Love it

Read full review

S
Steve Lazar
Reviews 1
2020-09-08 18:01

Burgers looked fantastic, but I had a Nicois sala...

Burgers looked fantastic, but I had a Nicois salad, just so-so at best. Service was harried, still no reason to be rude as we waited for our third. Dirty looks and a verbal comment, "... You're still waiting?..." , we were early they couldn't find the reservation and decided to stay us anyway. Atmo...

Read full review

S
Stephen T. O'Brien
Reviews 1
2020-09-02 02:42

This is a lovely old Inn and the staff, food and a...

This is a lovely old Inn and the staff, food and atmosphere are all wonderful. The dishwasher is related to the guy at the gas station and the waitress knows your cousin if you live here you'd get it. It's a beautiful area and the Inn is a perfect setting there.

Read full review

J
Jared Caputo
Reviews 1
2020-09-01 22:35

Cozy place. I had an excellent salmon tartare and ...

Cozy place. I had an excellent salmon tartare and my steak frites were good, but the French Fries were (while themselves excellent) drenched in juice from the steak when they came to the table, which was rather unappealing. The dessert took a long, long time to arrive but was excellent.

Read full review

E
Elizabeth Gramer
Reviews 1
2020-08-21 10:20

I can only give this place a three star review bec...

I can only give this place a three star review because we had a 7:30 p.m. reservation and my sister and brother-in-law were traveling in from NYC. They had a delay at the tunnel and were running late. When my husband and I went in to sit down at 7:30 to have a drink and appetizer, they refused to se...

Read full review

M
Michael Christopher
Reviews 1
2020-08-12 19:37

Lovely name , brings a smile to your face. Lovely ...

Lovely name , brings a smile to your face. Lovely atmosphere, Each time we go we sit maybe in a different room and it always feels comforting. Great outside patio/dinning experience. **Even driving here is beautiful to see all the victorian houses/horse fields . the best salmon tartare never had ...

Read full review

M
Mac Enlar
Reviews 1
2020-08-06 14:59

Service and food were a major disappointment. Wen...

Service and food were a major disappointment. Went for the first time on our anniversary on a Monday night. Waited 20 minutes before anyone came to our table. Ordered the hanger steak and my wife got the Filet. Mine was overcooked and tough. My wife's was actually tied together to look like a...

Read full review

M
Maria Hadley
Reviews 1
2020-07-28 11:13

I love everything about the Tewks. The food is ex...

I love everything about the Tewks. The food is excellent, the staff is made up of friendly service oriented people and the wine list has a lot of great offerings without being overpriced. In addition to all of this the building has historic charm. One of my favorite places.

Read full review

View all reviews on Trustburn
AMP version. View on Trustburn