Great location. Rooms are typically small as expected with Manhattan hotels. Generally it could do with some updating. No coffee machine in the room either. Security is good at ensuring only guests enter the elevator area.
I went to the bar/diner that's next to it. That was nice.
Can't fault this hotel and staff, right in the heart of all to offer in new york
This place is so cool. It s an old hotel so the rooms are small, but that should be expected. There is a hidden gem in this place, they have a little display of Nicola Tesla down stairs. It turns out he used to live there. The hotel is right I. The heart of the city and is walking distance to MSG and food options are everywhere.
Centrale vicino madison square garden, macy's e vista empire state building
this hotel is clean with a convinent location and friendly staff
Room was small but no complaints. Good location decent rate.
Very nice hotel. Could use some updates in rooms but overall great!
This review is going to be a little biased. I was only going to be in town for one day, so I could take my daughter around the city. We arrived in the city @10 am. I knew we couldn't check in, but we went to the hotel just to drop our bags off.
So we're standing in line an a lady approaches us and says she can help and points to a little desk and we sit. Told her what was up and she said hold on a second. She picks the phone up, calls someone and got us a beyond super early check in. Then because it was my daughter's first time, the lady made sure we could see the empire state building.
She went out of her way to make a little girl's first visit to NYC very special and for that I can never thank her enough. The hotel was amazing, a NYC icon, a must stay, even if only for a night. Some rooms can be quite costly, but I wouldn't skip a beat and pay it.
Great view of the Empire State building from 23rd floor
Recommended hotel, I have stayed 2 times and everything has been a good experience. The price-quality ratio is good and the location is excellent.
Great location and friendly staff. 2 of the best bagel shops, great pizza joint across from hotel and so close to Macy's. Carpet on floors and rooms are a bit old and worn out though.
Change tubs to walk-in showers and install a fan in the bathroom.
I've been booked here twice through work. Both times I ended up with a single hole room when I should have had a double. While the lobby is stunning, the rooms are small even by NYC standards. We could barely walk around the bed. There are far nicer hotels at lower prices. Keep looking.
Been waiting for over a month for $1,000 dollars in overage charges to be credited back to our Credit Cards. Went for a trip last month and no one will email me back or call me. Not impressed. I will keep trying everyday until they respond. Unfortunately, I'm accruing long distanced charges because I'm in Canada. Beware! (not happy I had to actually choose a star - undeserved.) Was told 10 business days - that was last Friday.
It's cheap. You can get a place for a reasonable price if you where anywhere else in the country for a good 4 star hotel. In NY though, this is not the case. The room was about 10 by 10 feet, and obviously very old and that showed. Old and dirty. And so small I couldn't even use the toilet because it was so close to the wall. Sink broke on the second day. Shower felt like I was being tortured by a fire truck water hose. Linens were suspect.
Rooms are clean and ok. But you can see and smell the floors are pretty old and should be renewed. Money should actually be there...
HORRIBLE HOTEL! Hottest days of the year, 110+ degrees and the hotels AC s weren t working in the rooms. Hotel staff could careless. I understand things happen, especially since this was a huge heatwave that moved through but have a little sincerity towards the people who were sleeping in 80+ degree heat rooms. Location was horrible. Homeless and harassing people with guest service doing nothing, even when they witness it. Hotel was filthy! Housekeeping never accommodated our needs when requesting towels and bedding etc.
Overall, a horrible experience at the hotel. Lesson learned, we won t be staying here again.
There are some places that are old and hard to use, but the location and cospa are the best.
Good location, good bed
But the desk, the TV cabinet and the atmosphere of the room do not match
Amazing staff. Small room. Hallways a bit unkempt. The room itself is clean and well kept.
Fantastic hotel In a great location staff were really helpful
This is a great hotel. The location is good. There is a subway stop around the corner and Madison square garden is close by. There are a few restaurants in the hotel. I recommend getting a drink at the butcher and the banker. It is located in a former bank vault. The building is older and the city noises do travel up to the rooms. I suggest earplugs if you are a light sleeper. The staff are very friendly.
Perfectly located with a very welcoming and smiling team, large room for us with an exceptional view of the city and the Empire State Building, a very good value for money, we will come back!
Do not take breakfast as you will DEFINITELY find something better and more typical in america
Neat rooms, good location friendly staff. You don't need more!
One of the historic hotels from around 1930.
The entrance hall is amazing! The service is good.
The rooms are ok but do need some improvements. The floors need much improvements...
The try to charge a ressort fee (around 60 dollar!) from every new customer. Be sure to check if it is included while booking a room at your travel agency or over the internet.
Back to positive: if you want to see a match or a concert at the Madison Square Garden, you just have to choose The New Yorker. It s just across the street!
The hotel is very in the center of NYC and well connected via Penn Station to Subway and LIRR (Long Island RailRoad) .
Rooms very small the bath water ran brown at times hotel very run down all corridors looked tired only 3 out of the 6 elevators35 minutes at times to wait for an elevator outside rotating door not working ques to get in and out but received letter saying they was sorry for the inconvenience
The only saving grace is its location
Think of a TOP hotel with an excellent location! Very good, I recommend!
It's ok, very small room and dated but it's very New Yorkie, extra charges when you check in.
The location was nice, it was right in the middle of all the places we wanted to go on our trip. The rooms were great, they had a homey feel to it. The rooms didn't look too amazing but that's to be expected. The service was great, it was reliable and nobody really bothered you, only coming when you were gone. It was an all in all great experience, and if we go to New York again I would be okay with staying at this hotel again.
Staff was very rude and not very occomidating. The Tic Toc waitress was also very rude and begged for a larger tip after she was terrible to us. Room was small, bathroom as well, over all bad hotel experience.
I think it is a fancy interior, tidy, comfortable, nice location.
Very clean and orderly. Available all times. Very busy halway though
Small rooms, not in the best condition. But it's one of those things where you get what you pay for..
Not bad, but the facilities are old.. but quite cozy enough and it s spacious
Madison Square Garden, Empire State Building
Facilities are also suitable.
I wish there is option for 0 star!!!
I went to New York for a business trip last week and booked Wyndham New Yorker Hotel. I went there by train.
1.When I arrived at 3pm, they said customers cannot check in before 4, they would call me when the room is ready. Then, they called me on 5:10pm without any apology.
2.There was a spider in the bathroom, and the sink didnt work well.
3.When I checked out, I was in a hurry to catch a train. It took the concierge 20 minutes to find my luggage, made me very anxious. After the concierge slowly walk back as chatting with others, I asked him if he could write me a receipt faster. He said: Do you mean I m too slow? Then he wrote deliberately very slow. It took him 5 minutes to finish it. Should I be treated roughly because I m an Asian? He treat other people polite and neat.
4.After I checked my bank account, I found that the hotel charged me $60.00 for parking fee. I don t have any car at New York, I don t know how I can park there.
I have been to New York a lot, and have stayed different hotels. I understand some hotels may not that perfect, staffs may not that polite, but this was the WORST hotel WORST staff I have ever seen.
I will never come back. This kind of discrimination made me really mad.
I was many years ago in this wonderful Hotel.
The location: EXCELLENT.
All very glamorous, to highlight: its fluffy rugs, its impressive chandeliers with lights, the friendliness of its employees.
I hope to return one day.
Rooms can be small, but that's normal hotel rooms in NYC. Still gets 5 stars though because the staff was excellent in all areas, 3 very good onsite restaurants, and I had amazing hot water every day for a week. Close to Times Square, MSG, and lots of good restaurants - and subway right outside the front door. Would stay again without question.
Strategic position, metro just near the Hotel. Just 10 minutes walk from Time Square.
The place sux. Too expensive for a postage stamp size room
This is a well-established hotel. A hotel that represents New York with the history of New York.
It was a first-class hotel, but now it has a reputation for being a popular hotel with excellent cospa and easy access.
Best of all, it's located in Midtown Manhattan, close to Madison Square Garden. Overall, there is no better hotel.
Good value, rooms are small but not too small, clean and well decorated. Shower could have been better but opted for relaxing baths instead. Staff were helpful and friendly with the exception of one receptionist, who was just a bit blunt in her manner.
Windows could do with better sound proofing.
Would stay here again!
Great location. However, the rooms are a tad small. House keeping is also very good.
Great location, convenient to Newark and Penn Station, very clean and nice staff
Excellent central location. Clean rooms, price too high for the room offered.
I've stayed here on my last 4 visits to NYC. It's and around fantastic hotel. Location is excellent, staff are great, rooms are a great size with comfy beds and the original art deco features are fantastic.. It's a hotel full of history and charm. And if you get a room with a view you won't be disappointed. I recommend the new yorker to anyone that's going to NYC
Close to where I needed to be for office. Room was super small even for NY and the bed was super saggy.
The steakhouse is nice, food while not great is above decent the ambience is fabulous and the cocktails are heavenly
Very nice hotel room. Great view from the balcony. Very nice staff. Very very very nice room service. The beds are better than mine at home. Absolute recommendation. Room 2623 from the balcony view the madness.
Outdated. Small. A little run down. Very cramped. Good location. Comfortable bed. Nice fitness center.
A free breakfast would be nice and a bigger room(lol)
Great hotel close to everything, clean decent size and own bathroom, could do with breakfast included.
The hotel has hidden fees and the room we had was nothing like the picture. Outdated old and a rip off. Only reason for 2 stars was for the location and lobby.
I found the hotel absolutely fine especially the location. Yes , it is old and dated but it is clean and security is very good,you have to show your room key before you get on the lift. It is opposite Madison Square Gardens and 1 block from Penn St. The subway is on both corners, Highline is 3 blocks down West 34th St, Macy's 2 blocks away with loads of other good shops. Empire State Building is also 3 blocks with JC Penny's and Manhattan Mall just around the corner. Rooms small just like New york bathroom small but clean. We got a room with 2 double beds and 2 bathrooms and it was massive but no view. Well u can't have everything. Tick Tock is OK but there r plenty of places to eat to the left of the hotel especially for breakfast. PAX was great for breakfast and rolls for lunch, it's left out the front across the road and 3 blocks down.For 7 nights it was 220 dollars extra in tax and services but all the hotels charge this, although your really paying for nothing. Staff r great at helping you with advice and how to get there especially what train to get and which subway station to use. Would definitely go back. The pics r left and right of the hotel and on the corner at tick Tock looking up towards Empire State Building.
I have just had a week here. Great location in the hustle and bustle of NYC. You're just a short walk from times Square, Macy's and MSG is just across the road. The hotel it's self is nice. The rooms are a good size, clean and tidy. That's all you need really as most of the time you're out and about sight seeing. Staff were polite and the hotel was well priced and as expected. Would stay here again.
Room was pretty normal but the hall is very beautiful
Homely
Enjoying
Bye bye
Awful experience with the security staff here, would recommend booking elsewhere for a hotel in NYC
Excellent location. Close to the Empire States Building, Macys and Time Square. We were in a double room with 2 Queen size beds. The rooms were clean and the beds were really comfy.
Lovely welcoming ambience, unbelievable views from the room, Fantastic Midtown location- opposite Madison Square Gardens & Penn Street Station, And Empire State Building visible from outside the Hotel! The room is good & the bed Very comfortable. Really happy with our stay here so far!"
Excellent venue for the Tax Course that I attended. Large room, EXCELLENT audio visual situation.
If you want to stay in Manhattan at a better value hotel, this is the place. I recommend.
newyorkerhotel.com