Seafarer Resort Reviews

Clean, low key, and amenity rich! The crew is awesome too.

Charming four unit resort, swimming pool, bikes to use on the island. Staff super friendly close to the beach and other amenities that the island has to offer.

Great ambience with a cute beach where you can enjoy the sunset. Very well maintained area with almost tame Sqirrels, iguanas like muffins. Very clean rooms.

The bed was uncomfortable and the room was small, however we chose the small garden room sothe size wasn't a surprise. The waterfront amenities we're nice. Plenty of chairs of many types and hammocks. The office staff were nice and helpful.

This place changed ownership about 1 yr ago - the new owner Henry is really top notch and this place has a really charming flavor to it. Our family of 4 rented a villa and it was clean and well kept. If you want to pay sub 200 for a suite with kitchen, you cannot expect Hiltonesque amenities. The location is good with access the bayside beach and free kayaks to boot. Staff is helpful and responsive. We love hidden gems like this that are harder to find as over development squeezes out small owner/operators. Seafarer is about 5 mins from Pennecamp park, and some great restaurants (Keys Backyard Fishery, Denis Latin Cafe, Ms Macs Kitchen). If you want to access a decent ocean side beach go to Sombrero Beach which has free parking... We would stay here again for sure and are looking forward to our next trip back to the keys!

Great reception. Room upgrade. Old but super clean maintained and maintained in a great location. Unfortunately only for one night. It was really great. Breakfast is different but adequate and good.

Very accommodating, clean, friendly squirrel on premises, breakfast is amazing

Lovely. Tranquil surroundings. Everyone is very nice. Rooms are clean and comfortable. Great location. Nice beach!

awesome place to enjoy! kayaking is free in the back Waters!!

Zenith of barefoot elegance! I wish I could bottle this place and take it with me wherever I go. Super clean really wonderful staff fun guests it doesn't get better than this guys!

You get what you pay for and some great customer service too!

For me, the hotel is very rich, it is more than a hotel, it is a second home, it is very rustic and the attention is excellent, very good price and everything is very good.

A hidden gem in Key Largo. Please don't pass up the opportunity to stay here. We absolutely loved this place!

We stayed at the seafarer resort and beach because our usual place was remodeling and I am so glad we did. The seafarer resort was so clean, the rooms where large and the breakfast was an amazing added plus.
The staff at the seafarer resort and beach go above and beyond to make you feel like home. They offer a continual breakfast with fresh baked muffins, homemade frittatas, fruit, coffee and juice! Kayaking is free and paddle boards are available as well.
I wouldn t hesate to stay here again, very clean and cute resort with amazing views!!

Great private beach. Management is friendly. Hand cooks muffins and eggs every morning. Very relaxing

From start to finish it was an amazing experience. The staff were extremely friendly and nice, especially Guy. He was a hoot and helped familarize us with the area and where the best places to eat and see were. The view was beautiful! They served fresh cookies every day, snorkeling and kayaking, supplied beach towels, room service every single day with a fresh supply of towels. Overall a wonderful experience. The only reason I didn't put 5 stars is because they dont serve coffee until 7:30am and we are pretty earlier risers. It would be nice to have had a coffee pot in the room or serve coffee earlier.

We loved this little Eden right off the main path! The staff was wonderful and the small beach area were more than welcoming. This was also a great budget friendly option for a beautiful sunset viewing from the dock.

it's the right place to stay with your family.they have kayaks,stand up,delicious breakfast,and the service is great.

Really cute place to stay! The room was clean and comfortable, and right on a private beach with lounge chairs, tables, a dock, and grills for use. There's free kayak rentals. The staff was super friendly, the location was great, the price was super reasonable - would definitely book again!

Very cute place! It has a nice little beach with hammocks, tiki huts, free kayak use, and a dock where we were able to tie up our jetski. The staff was unbelievable! The rooms were very clean and the beds were comfortable. They also had fresh baked muffins, coffee, orange juice, cookies ect... in the morning! And each room had a little bistro table outside where everyone was having their breakfast. Such a relaxing weekend. We are definitely staying here on our next trip down. Hopfuly next month!

Old Florida! Surprisingly enjoyable with a great breakfast. Just don't expect glass and chrome or electric outlets everywhere.

This place has become one of our favourite places to relax. It is quiet, you can do bbq right next to the beach. It is nothing luxury, but it is very comfortable and relaxing. Amazing for people that lives in cities.

It was the most beautiful place I have ever been. The staff was great, the free breakfast was great, and it was quiet. I will most certainly be back every year. Not a single bad thing to say!

This is a wonderful little resort. Everyone has been friendly. Our room was wonderful. Bedroom living room bathroom and kitchen. Outside is a great sitting area with each unit having it's own grill. We only stayed one night. The room was very clean. We stayed because of reviews saying it was a 70's kickback. It is but rooms remodeled and comfortable. But kept the 70's charm. Better then those big franchise hotels. Highly recommend this place.

One of the staff members was a very rude kid! Stingy on the breakfast, was there for six days, and one day I was able to get breakfast and OJ. Looking to swim? Don't go there, it's sand and a lagoon, not a beach at all. If you want to read a book and relax it's perfect for you. Got kids, and want more of a beach environment, not for you at all.

Decent motel with passionate and kind staff. Has private beach and feee kayaks to use. Not damaged by Irma,

Great location. Has the seaside feel we were looking for. A little pricey but you get what you pay for. Has dock, kayaks, lounge chairs, everything you need.

We give this hotel 5 stars because everything about it was AWESOME! Starting from the moment we stepped into the lobby with the aroma of muffins baking in the oven to when Henry walked in to greet us! The walk to our cabin was enchanting, under the shade of mature trees and over little wooden bridges. When we reached the cabin, it was comfortable and had all we needed to spend the BEST two days that turned into four days 'cause we just did not want to leave! The hotel is centrally located (for activities and dining) and Henry and George are happy to give recommendations on where to eat and where to go to enjoy and learn more about the island. The free kayaks are super fun and the little beach/cove where the hotel sits is perfect for lounging on a float. Family friendly, couple friendly... it's just a great little place for when you just want to get away and enjoy life.

Great small resort with a private beach. The rooms are clean and spacy

Quiet (if you are not too close to the road), simple but clean. Owners and the team are very handsome and careful. If anything gets out of order is been repaired immediately.
In respect of the spirit of the keys, i found this place very pleasant fot me and my family. This is much more relevant to stay in the keys in this kind of place rather than a marriott or holiday inn, more luxurious but without the soul of the keys as Seafarer is. And it s more affordable. Five stars rating without hesitation.

Nice place
No pool

Antiquated, rustic and cute. Very Key West. Could use a couple shelves in the bathroom for items to place. LOVED the delicious muffins and egg frittatas. Didn't like the unexpected wake up to the tearing up of the roof to repair, but overall cute place for a nice weekend getaway.

This one of our home away from home destinations! During Hurricane Irma volunteer/donation trip we came across this quaint place. Very quiet & kept clean. They do a magificent job capturing the island atmosphere! It is very evident that the staff & owner truly give 110% of themselves to keep this a slice of paradise. Located in the midst of so many attractions and excursions, we were just as happy spending our days lounging around, hanging by the private beach & just enjoying the peaceful relaxation. They also go above & beyond for their customers, offering a nice breakfast. We love their Furtado's & home made muffins! The customer service is superior - thank you, Henry, Karen, & Juan! Irma brought you into our lives, but now you're part of our hearts!

Nice hotel, very hospitable staff, we got a separate Red Fish house. Simple but tasty breakfast, nice beach, there is a kayak rental and paddle board.

We were received by Craig as old friends! The place is beautiful with a platform on the water to lay back and enjoy the most beautiful sunset. Impeccable and clean rooms. We used the kayaks and also saw a manatee! Highly recommended!

Having spent 3 nights in Key West we headed to Key Largo Seafarer for 3 nights, before flying home to the UK. On arrival, Seafarer staff were welcoming and showed us to our room. They could not however prepare us for tranquility and outstanding views. Free use of Kayaks, hammocks and loungers allow you to immerse yourself in tropical lifestyle. Breakfast (freshly baked fritatas & muffins), coffee fruit and yogurt start your day. Trip advisor can help find great places to eat within a few miles. Each night after sunset watching lightening over the Everglades whilst chatting. Had I stopped at Seafarer first, I would not have continued on to Key West. The rooms are basic, clean and comfortable with A/C, TV, Wi-Fi.

Had a great experience here. The rooms are clean, and affordable. The staff is friendly and helpful. There is a small private beach with chairs and hammocks set up. Kayaks are available for no cost to use during the day. A light breakfast is set up outside. We drank our coffee on the beach and enjoyed every moment of the peaceful atmosphere. We also had a great view of the sunset here.

My wife and I came here for our babymoon (She assures me it's a thing and I don't argue with the pregnant lady) in early May and had a great time. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, the beach was tiny but peaceful and beautiful, and the kayaking was fun to boot.

It's a great place to get away quietly. There are some cool little bits like a small charcoal grill in front of each little house, some awesome sunny and shady spots on the beach area, kayaks to borrow, paddle boards to rent, and again- a genuinely awesome staff.

Four stars because our cabin (redfish) had some plumbing issues (inconsistent hot water in the shower and a bit of smell from the drain) and the continental breakfast was grocery store OJ and some pre-packaged cookies. The AC units in the cabin were pretty loud too. Breakfast wouldn't cost a star as you get a good amount of kitchen space but that with the wonky plumbing and noisy AC are enough to cost a star for me.

The wife and I are in agreement that we'd come back in a heartbeat. You should give it a go.

This is a wonderful resort! We stayed for 2 nights and enjoyed every minute there! The staff is amazing and friendly, the rooms are cute and clean! The beach is beautiful and we had fun taking the free kayaks out for an hour! There is free breakfast with muffins, quiche, orange juice, coffee, yougurt, and fruit. It is right across the street from Ballyhoos restaurant which has amazing food! It is a laid back resort and a much better option than the high rise hotels! We will be going back again!

Finally a quiet place in Florida.
This place is relaxed, quiet and family friendly. It has a nice little beach with beautiful sunsets friendly staff. No luxury and no stress.

Cute, clean cottages, kayak rentals, fishing, breakfast included. Super relaxing!

The place was very clean and tranquil and the staff was very nice except for an old gentleman by the name of Guy who is so rude and bipolar.

We are having a great time here. The rooms are older but have been updated. This is a great location.

We stayed here 2 nights and it was a great experience. The staff was friendly and the place was very clean. Everything was perfect. Loved the frittatas they had for breakfast. You can eat your breakfast outside or take it to your room. The location was well kept and the atmosphere was amazing. We grilled out in front of the beach for my birthday and laid in their hammocks. The kayaks are free to use.

We only stayed one night but should've stayed more. Very relaxed and neat atmosphere. Very clean and private areas.

The place is super quiet and i like that and the people are super nice ....but they wont let you enter even a visitor

We stayed in cottage #5 with our kids and my brother in law stayed in #7. We had the most amazing trip. Our kids were in awe of all the animals on the property, the rooms were simple, cozy, and very clean, the staff was friendly, and the views from the beach were incredible. It was a magical experience for our family and a great place to bond. There were little touches of charm everywhere I looked. We would come back in a heart beat for a romantic getaway without the kids, or do it all over again for a family vacation. Don't expect luxury or fancy linens, but do bring peanuts for the squirrels, take advantage of the boat dock for sunset viewing, and don't be afraid to take a day and just stay on the property to relax by the water.

Nice casual place, small but has beach and boat dock.

Great location, free kayaking, very friendly hosts, free breakfast

Love this place. Friendly quiet awesome sunsets and new residences that are around the dock, a baby sand shark and manatee daily. I stay here at least once or twice a year to go diving

the Seafarer is a clean and quiet place to spend a relaxing day or two. would definitely recommend and would stay here again. they offer many extras included in the room rate, which makes it even sweeter.

For the three weeks I've been in America, this is probably the best place to watch a sunset that I've seen. It has some great places for snorkling close to the resort too. Also the owner lights torches all over the terrain every night and the combination of these torches and trees gives a jungle like expression. There is this floating pallet with 2 beach chairs on there and when I sat there at night I could even see some very small fish that lighted up whenever they swam a small distance which was a really cool and romantic thing to watch!

Great place. Overlooked by many, loved by all who venture in.

Is located directly on the US One and reveals itself as terrain that reaches to the water (golf side). The resort is very well maintained and lovingly furnished. The rooms are okay for two people, with more people it could be tight. Small but good homemade breakfast, muffins and frittatas. Nice and very friendly staff. If we are in the area again, we will gladly come back.

It is small but four one person it is ok but a family of 5 it is small

Clean quiet rooms, with good service. The beach is not very clean but good to relax next to and watch sun sets. Upgrade to the cottage if available.

It's like a small paradise. Unfortunately the road gets loud at times. We were sad we had to leave after a single day. We could have easily spend 3 days there. Awesome place!

Super nice little hotel / motel. Nice rooms. Good location with sea. Free canoe. Very good breakfast.

Seafarer is quaint, clean motel, a true island paradise.
Took advantage of the free kayaks and cruised the bay to the mangroves. Enjoyed a beautiful sunset sitting at the dock.
Juan is a polite and pleasant host.

Will definitely come back again.

This was our 2nd time here and it was as great as the 1st time, kayaks and paddleboard are included, private beach, grilling area, plenty seating areas great place to see manatees when you go out kayaking and overall a very chill place. Staff is helpful and informative and funny. Definitely a great place to stay!

Hotel driveway easy to miss, functional very clean rooms, delicious little things for breakfast free canoe rental small hotel's own sea access with free beach chairs and hammocks. Very helpful staff Parking directly in the room The only downside right on the 1 located in next neighborhood only Denny's

Simple but cozy rooms, great value for money. Class hotel beach

So peaceful, calm, quiet nice resort. Very well organized.

Cute place, very helpful and friendly staff. Guy was extremely caring towards my children and went over and beyond sharing with them about the squirrels, lizards and even about the coconut trees. Free breakfast was awesome. Everyone working here are so sweet. Will return:)

Quiet, AWESOME views, great private beach and staff

Great place, clean scenic & relaxing. Enjoy yourself laying on comfortable, huge hammock under palm trees.Bring charcoal you can bearbeque right next to you cottage.
Can t wait to come again!!

Amazing!!! The room was clean and nice. Scott was so accommodating and friendly. Love the island feel of this place. The price for the room was good..I definitely recommend staying here! I'll be back often! Thanks!

Quiet, beautiful calm waters. Bungalow style huts. Management great.

Wonderful place with clean huts and friendly atmosfere and staff. We where so lucky to swim with 3 manatees for several hours just 3-4 meters from the beach.
I hope to comeback back !

Cute, quaint, functional. Has everything you need for a multi-night stay. Warm, complimentary breakfast. Kayaks. Nice little swim area. I would stay here again.

Location on beach w free kayaks is great homemade breakfast mudfibs were frezh baked as well as the egg frittatas! Basic room but nice patio - try to get cabin back from road- coin washer /dryer cute place!