Seafarer Resort Reviews

This place is as amazing now as it was years ago, this is the only place I will ever stay while visiting Key Largo.

Very welcoming and clean. Friendly and helpful staff. Relaxing and peaceful.

Best little cottages in the keys!! I ve been there at least 10 times now and I have to say every time I go, I love it more and more. They have a little complimentary breakfast area, with muffins, frittatas, orange juice and coffee. It it a much more homey stay compared to the big hotels. Very quiet! Nice beach area with free kayaks and you can rent paddle boards for a cheap price! Will be back again and will continue to recommend!

The location was perfect for my wife and I. The rooms were also awesome as well. We stayed in the Redfish room the first night and then moved to one of the villas. The Villa was awesome but the neighbors were horrible..but it is not a reflection of the resort. The staff was exceptional.

Very nice relaxing small beach area. The staff are very accommodating and friendly. Make sure you book the room with the view to the water, only one! This picture is from inside looking out. Also have private grills, hammocks, and lounge chairs with two on a floating dock you wade too.

clean and cozy rooms. tight driveways. cozy beach in back with grills and kayaks. halfway point between Miami and end of keys. friendly and accomodative staff

What can I say.... The hotel itself is nice. It's in a quiet area and has a jungle vibe. The lizards are fun to watch. The beach is small and could use some cleaning of grass but still pleasant. Loved the free kayaking but paddle boards are 20.00 an hr. And 3 hammocks yay.
Bad part was the staff. Unfriendly and quick to yell at people. The cleaning staff didn't clean actually left sand in room everywhere. Beds are uncomfortable but TV is nice size. I won't personally go back here. Maybe try Marathon key.

Sadly the reviews here don't reflect my experience. I paid for a room for my fathers birthday. Once I arrived after 8 hours of driving in bad weather, they informed my that the room I paid for had been rented to someone else. The attitude from the hotel manager was pretty much "tough" and they tried to downgrade us to a smaller room. Even after I explained that I had paid for a different room and showed my reservation that they charged for 3 months prior, his answer was "they're not much different" even though the room was facing the parking lot and the other room I requested was beachfront and larger.

I ended up asking for a refund and the manager / office assistant seemed so angry about it that he was shaking. In the end, they did refund my money and after not being in the keys since 2014 it was a sad day for a trip that we had been looking forward to for a very long time. We ended up staying at Rock Reef a couple of motels down. It doesn't have a private beach, but it has water access/BBQ and the price was reasonable for a room with a full kitchen and separate bedroom.

I didn't write this review to spread negative energy, in fact, I never write reviews. However, this was a rare occasion that never happens with my family and the way I was treated at the front desk, I felt it was necessary to share my experience. Maybe I just had bad luck with Seafarer. Happy Travels!

Im a 20 something who was in town for a wedding down the street. Needed somewhere to lay my head and shower for two days pretty much. Absolutely no complaints, clean and cozy. Ac, mini fridge and microwave. Keep in mind no frills. But grounds were really cute. There was a real laid back atmosphere. I'd stay again. Loved the hammocks. Check out alittle early at 1030 but we overslept and checked out maybe an hour late. Owner was pretty cool about it. Oh our flight arrived late at night, office was closed but he left his number out for us. Also, he left the light on for us! I thought that was the cutest thing. Would stay again

Husband and I stayed 2 nights. Didn't have any issues with plumbing as mentioned in some other reviews. Clean, new bathrooms, and free tandem kayak use which we took advantage of. They have a private beach, with lots of shady and sunny seating/lounging, and a few hammocks. Good location. Very comfortable and quiet place. For what you get, you can't beat the price.

Loved this quaint hotel with its own private beach. Room very comfortable and quiet. Very peaceful and relaxing. Staff lovely. Good parking,close to our room. Decent WiFi connection. Loved the breakfast outside in the beautiful garden with a resident squirrel for company!

This small resort on the water is a piece of paradise. I love the relaxing hammocks and kayaks... My wife and I are in love with this place..

Very accommodating owners, quite relaxing atmosphere. Good old school keys vibe.

Incredibly cozy hotel with a wonderful location by its own small beach area. Breakfast was served outdoors.

It was a small place but it was accommodating I asked to stay another night without a reservation and they said it was all right so in my book I appreciated that thanks they were great

Seafarer offers economy, ie clean rooms, basic breakfast, good parking and a friendly staff that are interested in providing you with a pleasant stay. Beach access, tables with umbrellas, beach chairs in a self service environment. Bring your own snacks, drinks and a light tackle fishing rod to cast off the small dock if inclined. Unique place.

It was a beautiful place. Perfect if you have small kids. Staff isn't very friendly at all though. House keeping made sure we had fresh towels everyday without asking. Don't stay here if you have family in the area as there are no guests allowed to visit you.

A lovely place in paradise... the beds are horrible... but the location, people, staff, rooms beach, etc are absolutely wonderful. Thank you
..

What a gem! So glad we found this peaceful relaxing place to stay. Great for couples or families. Have a nice breakfast in the morning with tasty muffins and frittatas. The folks that run it are very friendly and helpful. Our room was spotless and comfortable. The small private beach area is great for launching the on-site kayaks (free for use) and watching the sunset. You will enjoy your stay here - we sure did.