Sag Harbor Kitchens Review

Staff terrific and helpful. However, expensive for disappointing food.

Stopped by on a "road trip" through Sag Harbor for a couple glasses of Pinot Gris. Great sidewalk-side seat and view. Delicious wine. Will eat here next time I'm in town.

Great experience, but a bit pricey compared to other options. LuLu was an equally entertaining experience and our group felt it packed more bang for the buck. Brunched clocked in around $70 a person and the booze was minimal

Great French/Italian inspired menu and extensive wine list. Food and service excellent but be prepared to pay Sag Harbour prices. Bread with food would be nice considering the Mediterranean feel.

Excellent but overpriced food and wine. Pleasant service.

The place serves big portions and for fair rates. super nice staff. 5 stars.

Great dinner. We had the beet salad, freshly cooked pizza toast points, the Campanelle and Chicken. The pasta dish was excellent as the chicken too. Ordered bottle of house Sauv Blanc, also good. Son had the gnocchi with crab and that was the only miss, just bland. Highly recommend.....

Horribly rude staff, tacky decor, overly crowded feel.

Food was horrible. Overpriced. Rude host. Long wait.

We had a great experience in this restaurant. We loved the nice atmosphere and the menu. The staff were super personal. I am happy we finally decided to visit this restaurant.

Quality has deteriorated. Was reliably good food in the past. Had to send Fluke back. Steak had weird smokey flavor.

My wife got food poising from dinner was sick for 12 plus hours. We called the manager he didn t care told us to call Suffolk County health department. This restaurant is a rip off and food is mediocre. Their wines are good for summer drinking. I would avoid.

Great oysters...firm nice shrimp... professional service

Food was very good but service was pretty slow when I went for lunch. There were alot of things on thr menu I wanted to try so I would try again.

Attentive staff, great atmosphere open air restaurant. Good energy. A must visit

Noisy, tightly-packed tables in a too small space, hit-and-miss food, and very expensive. The wine is good, but that's not enough of a reason to dine here.

The food, dessert, and wine were to dieeeeeee for. I had dinner there last night, and not only was our meal great, the service was excellent too! I was very impressed :)

Food was fine. But nothing to write home about. Not really worth it if there's a wait. Kind of feels like they're just profiting off the Wolffer name in any way they can. If no wait, fine give it a shot. But don't expect a life-changing meal.

Fun restaurant in heart of Sag Harbor. Nice setting with excellent good and fine wine. Recommend

Came here for Christmas Eve with the family. The duck was delicious, the wine was fantastic and the service was excellent, and we had a lovely server. I can't wait to go again.

Excellent restaurant, with a nice atmosphere and great food choices. Had the bouillabaisse, which was delicious and well presented. Good choice for a Saturday evening.

very expensive and more misses than hits on the menu, staff is great.

Nice atmosphere and good food, but a little pricey.

One of my favorite spots in Sag Harbour! If you don't get a chance to visit the vineyard you still get to try all their new wine selections.

Wonderful little restaurant in Sag Harbour, food was simple but presented and tasted perfectly. The wines and Rose on offer all come from the Wolfer Estate Vineyards and are all exceptional. One of the most popular vineyards in the Hamptons, and for good reason.

First time coming to this Kitchen and I have to say I was pleased. It just opened this summer so don t worry if you think you ve missed your chance.
It s a nice cute spot to take your significant other on any occasion. Brunch is served there (pretty big deal to me).
The hollandaise sauce is one of the better ones that I have had and the potatoes were cooked perfectly.
The coffee is pretty good; if your looking for cocktails then you re in luck.
If you re planning to go to the family vineyard after, I would save the drinking for later.

I traveled 3 hours for this spot and will do it again. Until next time!

Awful service. Host was rude and refused to seat us. Would eat anywhere in Sag Harbor except this place

Great ambiance with a wonderful selection of wines to choose from. Stopped in with family to relax with a glass of wine and we were quite satisfied. Would highly recommend this place.

Exquisite cuisine, modern, clean dining area with lovely ambiance. Scrumptious menu selection and unexpected specials. My vegan daughter had several options to choose from and cleaned her plate. The modest pricing was a pleasant surprise...
4 ppl, 3 apps/4 entrees $200
(No drinks) I was pleased with the entire experience. Nice staff from Hostess & Waitress to bus people & bartender. I look forward to going back to

Food very fresh with nice menu selection. Good service.

Service was very average and attitude was snooty. Food was nothing special. Ordered the bass and sent it back without tasting it. Was a depressing looking serving and ugly plating. Changed to fish special which was good. They also gave me a discount on my entree. My first time there, but won t go back. Friends (locals) were disappointed yet again and won t go back.

Beautiful atmosphere and fantastic food. A lovely lunch spot and dinner is great too, very fun for people watching.