Rusty Rail Brewing Company Reviews

Amazing food with an amazing environment. Drinks were really tasty too

Great beer and food come see for yourself 2 thumbs up

We are from the Toronto area, and stayed in Mifflinburg for a week. We had a great dinner at the Rusty Rail. Great, casual atmosphere, good food and of course great beer. A must see if you are travelling through this rural part of Pennsylvania and want to enjoy the local scene.

Beautiful building and outdoor eating area. The beer and food were very good.

Just had a light dinner and drinks. It was great as usual! Delicious food, efficient server and terrific busboy named Landon. He is a keeper! We will be back soon!

The beer is really great and the food is about as good as it gets for the area. Unless your waiter has a bad day you shouldn't leave disappointed.

Attended the John wedding at the rusty rail. Place is hands down amazing. Great staff and great food, top notch service. Highly recommended!
Corey & Sabrina Dreese

After our first visit to the Rusty Rail, I can gaurantee that we will be going back. The atmosphere was laid back an relaxed. The service was friendly and attentive, without being overbearing. The food was delicious, well proportioned, and for the meal you get reasonably pried. All and all a wonderful dining experience.

I thought everything about this place was great. I can t wait to go back. The staff was fantastic. The food was excellent.

Great place to get a beer. Ordered a shrimp po boy sandwich and the bread was somewhat stale. Not cheap eats. Ate the shrimp and left the bread. Nice deck area to hang out on.

Excellent food and a vast selection of beers, all wonderful.

Fog monster beer was excellent. I had fish and chips however chips were cold french fries. I had two fillets of fish which was excellent. The garlic sauce made the meal. The hush puppies were fresh and good. Do your self a favor hire an excellent executive chef. The food has to be better than the beer. A limited menu was also an issue. I was very disappointed with the food.

Great beer selection and nice food menu. Indoor and outdoor seating. Recommend stopping.

Really great place......love ever aspect of it.
Really good beer, atmosphere, fast service & the food has always been on point for me.
No need for Gordon Ramsey to visit here.....lol

This isn't my first time eating at rusty rails and it won't be my last. I am truly a fan of this place for more than just the atmosphere ,which is great. The service is 5 stars and the food is absolutely delicious. You won't have a shortage of great food options and drinks.
When we are here this time we got Rachel as our server. She is very sweet and knowledgeable in the menu items. I have a gluten allergy and she would double check ingredients and recommend good options for me. I was greatful to have such a great server and she made the experience even better. We will be back for more meals!

Stopped in here while on a trip thru Pennsylvania, it was recommended to me thru the proverbial grapevine. Cool old building, nice scenic decor and ambiance. Food was ok, prices were ok, wait staff was ok, service was ok thus the middle of the line three star rating. The highpoint to my visit was definitely the rustic decor. Dont forget to tip your waiter/waitress for their service.

Always friendly service and delicious food. Highly recommend treating yourself to a evening out with friends and family.

Outstanding accommodations, great ber, food and service. Highly recommend!!

Very attractive place. At bit pricey, but the food is good.

We sat at the bar. Staff was great. All of their beers are very good in their own right. Cheesesteak spring rolls are fantastic.

Very impressive. Free game play upstairs. All 5 of the different beers that I tried were outstanding. The smoked brisket was so tender and tasty. Can't wait to return and try another dish!

A must stop place. Great mcycle ride up from H-burg. I had the bison meatloaf small plate, Debbie had ravioli vegeterian. We did lunch, break on price. Craft beer v good, $6. Its not a cheap lunch, but v v good. Amazing building.

Great food. Great service. Great server. Danielle was awesome. Beer as always is awesome.

Excellent atmosphere, food, beer and servers; especially Aimee Sullivan. The part that puts a bad taste in your mouth is the long wait for food. The cooks do a great job, the speed is something that will come eventually. They need to speed it up though. A 1 hr. Wait for food is too much though.

Been to twice. Food takes a while but service was good and food was rather tasty. I will be a repeat customer.

The building is great. Nicely restored beams and brick work. Friendly staff but the food was meh. Nothing to write home about.

Great food, I tried 2 different beers and they were fantastic, and the service was great. If you like good beer and better food this is a place to try

Best food and beer around. Their suites are the best also.