Mickey Mantle Steakhouse Review

Our go-to for steaks and cigars! They have some of the best service, food, and atmosphere downtown. We go weekly.

Not a huge fan of steak houses in the first place but my husband was craving steak...my husband said steak was good but not $52 good and his stomach was upset later,I got the shrimp fettuccine and my shrimp were way overcook they took then back and brought me different once and they were just not good tasting and kinda burned, they ended up taking them of my bill so I really appreciate that, there happy hour drinks are good and the orderves at the bar were really good, but would never go there again

This place is absolutely outstanding. The prices are well within reason for the quality. Makes me feel like I in Nashville again.

Pepper Steak was delicious. Perfectly cooked (Medium Rare).

Reservations for 3 couples - check
Limo service with coctails - check
Arrive 8 minutes early & seated - check
Order cocktails & wine - check
Drinks arrive 25 minutes later - BOO
Salads 10 minutes later - BOO
Dinner arrives @ 1 hour 28 minutes later - BOO
Two $47 Ribeyes - overcooked - BOO

WE WILL NOT BE BACK - EVER

This place is horrible. I took my wife the day after valentines to avoid the rush and her steak was half fat my redfish was old and very fishy. It's not worth the money. Ljs has better quality for way cheaper. They told me to message them to fix it and never did anything. Wasted 160. Never again.

Had a wonderful time there. Good friendly folks and good food. Will be back next time I'm in town.

Can't beat a bar that looks like the Rat Pack is about to walk through the door any minute. Just the pictures on the wall are worth the visit. Did I mention that the entrees are second to none. I like their whisky flights.

Mike the bartender was great. Great service! Will be back and will recommend

Good steaks overall, But nothing Spectacular. The shrimp Cocktail was bland and the Beef Cappacio was really good. Not the best but not the worse. I give the food a 3 star and the service a 5 star so 4 star overall.

Wow! One of the best steaks in OKC, you'll pay plenty for it, but oh so good.

I give Mickey Mantles a 2 cause of the server. She was amazingly perfect. But the food was horrible. For Valentines day $95/pp it was so disgusting, dont think ill ever go there again other than for a drink.

Great place and our waiter Drew was on fire he's a very nice guy . The steaks were a blast add to that the lobster appetizer.

Great food, high prices but worth it. I gave 4 stars because as much as I like great service the waiter was checking on us every 3 to 4 minutes, seriously!! And not just asking if we needed anything but making conversation while u was trying to have a another conversation, I may sound like a jerk but believe me it was pretty annoying.

EXPENSIVE- But went because we had a holiday XMas dinner with my work. The food was good.

Great experience with my fellow staff members for this visit. The ribeye was amazing.

visited near twelve, it was not full. next time i'll be back with my coworkers.

Excellent food and excellent service! Highly recommend

Filet mingon was impossibly disappointing, but everyone who ordered anything else were blown away. Great service.

Great steaks and fantastic seafood. Fun menu and good cocktails. We had a great time. Only complaint is the vegetables could have been cooked longer

Great place for luncheons and training/sales events. Good service with some pretty good food. Menu for lunch wasn't large but wasn't overwhelming either.

The food was great but the serveR, Denzel, treated us like second class citizens because our bill was only $165 for 2 of us. When he realized we would not be a big ticket everything changed. It was out first time there and well I won t go back being treated that way. Maybe my $190 with tip is not as good as the next person s but it was a lot of money to me. Exceptional food is nothing when you are treated poorly.

We went for our anniversary, and our expectations where blown out of the water! It was our first time at a fancy place and we where completely lost, but our waitress was extreamly helpful in explaining everything and making us comfortable. It was probably the best meal we have ever had and we will be back again, no doubt in my mind. Made our anniversary that much more special.

Mickey Mantle's risotto is literally "to die for", wish I had the recipe or that I lived closer !!!

My husband said it was easily the best steak he ever had. My chicken was perfectly cooked, I just wish they had more menu options besides steak and seafood. A bit pricey but very delicious.

We visited for the first time the other night and it was an amazing experience. Every single employee we meet was super nice and helpful. Our waiter stopped by multiple times during our meal to take empty dishes and check to make sure everything was still ok. It is a little bit expensive but everything we got to eat was awesome. We will definitely be going back and would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a good steak with a fine dining experience!

Amazing steak. Service was great. Priced accordingly.

Very classy, upscale steakhouse that hits the mark on food and service. that's probably why the thunder go there after the games to enjoy good food, drinks and of course mingle with all the attractive women which happen to be everywhere at the bar. They also have a cigar menu and doordash delivers from here

One word: !!AMAZING!!
One of the Best Steaks I ve ever eaten. Do not pass up on Mickey Mantle's. I was pleasantly surprised by the eclectic mix of people enjoying themselves...

Great food, the sea bass and seafood is exceptionally good for a steakhouse.

Me and my wife thought this was one our best places to eat. But not on Sunday nights they must bring the servers that night because the service sucks and had send my steak back because it was cold and it came back cold and they didn t even ask me it was better plus I think my waiter but. Desided that I was not good enough for him . Saw him take by drink and I was not done with it then he was gone. After we done eating we seat there for 30mins wanting desert and he never came back . Not the place to take your wife out on Sunday night

This is the best restaurant in OKC. I regularly entertain clients and vendors here and have never had anything other than a 5-star experience. The food is outstanding and always prepared perfectly. The waitstaff is excellent, but Lana is a cut above. She is simply the very best, most professional server I have ever known. Robyn is outstanding as well. Ask for them! You can't get a better dining experience.

Shout out to Michaela, Allison, Ashtin and Monica too. These waitresses are the very best you could hope for. Best place in town!

Most of the food is great just don't order the steak!

The absolute best food I've ever had in my mouth! We had a large party and ordered almost everything. It was all excellent! Drinks as well. Fabulous service and don't forget their amazing desserts! The crumble cheesecake is to die for! Best $1300 my brother and I have ever spent for our mom's 70th birthday party!!

Great atmosphere have only popped in for drinks, but the wine list was excellent.

Nice looking place. Very crowded and too noisy. Steaks were okay. Not the best but okay. I had hope to see more Mickey mantle stuff maybe at the entrance to look at but there were only pictures u can only look at from a distance because people were sitting in the booths. Expected more with all the hype. Had the 10oz filet mignon $44.00. This is for the steak alone with a choice of soup or salad. Sides are extra. Here I have a pic of the steak, asparagus, mushrooms and au gratin potatoes which 4 of us shared. Just okay.

Expensive but good. Pity I am so NOT fond of Bricktown in general.

Total cocktail drink fail. Didn't have GnT drink makings, so let me ha ginger for 15 mins before letting me know while rest of party finished up their drinks.

The food was pretty terrible. I ordered my steak Medium and received it Rare. The service was very nice however.

To be fair to this establishment, this review is quite late, as I went in April of 2014. However, the bitter taste of a certain dish was so horrid that the rest of my meal could no longer be given the benefit of the doubt. The server that day was very busy, I ate during prom season, so I can give no qualms about how well she took care of us. To begin my meal, one of the best appetizers was served to me in the form of crab cakes, which to this day I have not found a match in flavor or texture, either in the kitchen or at any other restaurants. If I was to return it would only be because of this dish. The second part of my meal is where the good tidings end, however. Unfortunately I was the one at the table to recommend the lobster bisque to everyone, having had relatively good experience with the dish in the past. And I am sorry to say I may have in the process scared off 7 potential clients for the restaurant that day. The lobster bisque can be only described as 5% lobster, 5% bisque, and 90% sherry. I felt as if I would have to inform the valet that I would need to call a taxi instead. Even the well seasoned crab legs and long forgotten dessert could not remove the taste, as the alcohol-infused soup was all we could discuss the rest of the night. Whenever I recall this restaurant, this is the first thing that pops in my mind. At least the soup would be great for wild parties.

Pros: +Extraordinary crab cakes, Portion to price ratio is favorable
Cons: Lethal lobster bisque, Very dark lighting for a 4PM Lunch/Dinner
Neutral: Staff and servers did well for a busy night, but still slow

Excellent food and excellent service. Will definitely be back! And if you're ever in bricktown you definitely need to give this place a try!

Let's start with the drinks. We ordered our drinks however the waiter only took my mother's drink order but almost forgot to take mine. We ordered lobster cargot for appetizers and it was excellent. Our salads were also good however after I finished the waiter took my plate and both side dressings even though my mother was not finished. I ordered the chicken stuffed with spinach, served on mushroom sauce, which was one of the best dishes I've had before. Highly recommend the chicken. My mother ordered the black pepper steak, which was also excellent. Overall the food was outstanding however the wait staff could take it up a notch.

I was at a Sinclair fuel dinner this evening. I ordered a well done New York strip. I received a medium rare! The wait staff was not interested in getting my meal correct. They never came back by me! I did not create a scene. After not eating my steak and then getting a desert that had dryed out and was crusty, the air system started pumping cigar smoke from the lounge into the diningcat a behind the lounge. This is the third time I came to this restaurant and the second time that the service and product was unacceptable. I did NOT go home hungry... I stopped at McDonald's! The ownership and staff of Mickey mantles restaurant should be ashamed!

Great ambiance and very good steak. Good service in top of that. Needs better craft beer selection (even bottles). 4.5/5.

Definitely a fine dining atmosphere. I did not try any of the wine or drinks. The food was good but expensive for my tastes. High 20's and above for pretty much everything. The steak was served plainly by itself on the plate. Plenty of other food choices in bricktown.

Beautiful food and customer service. If you are looking for recommendations, the beef carpaccio is at the top of our list. As for entre the sea bass was without words. Amazingly spiced and served on lobster risotto. What a great atmosphere!

The sea bass and lobster risotto were the best I have ever had. The redfish was not very good, it tasted very gamey. The service was impeccable and the ambience was perfect. Excellent!!!

Came here for a work function, had a private room and the food was excellent. Got the 16oz dry rub ribeye. There was a fair amount of fat on the steak but overall wasn't too bad. Wouldn't mind coming back here again.

They promote Prime beef
The steaks we received were barely choice. Management agreed and comped, but would not trust them again. Not worth the aggravation.

Good steak and drinks. Smoking at the bar is nice. If you want to get full fast and cheap, get a loaded baked potato.

Their peppercorn filet is one of the best steaks I've ever eaten. Love the atmosphere, drink selection and appetizers, too. Have been there at least three times and everything I've eaten was fantastic. Pretty pricey, but every bit as good as Ruth's Chris or Morton's, in my opinion.

Wonderful dine in experience. A must go for a romantic dinner.

Great service! The cigar bar is very cool, surprisingly does not smell smokey.

Had a great experience, my first time there. Love the service! Keep up the awesome job.

The Cigar Selections are on point! I reccomend both the smokes and then food!

This place is pricey but delicious. Beautiful atmosphere and waiters were attentive.

"Seeking a long wait, but the food and service us so worth it"

Great happy hour and an excellent menu. Will visit again when in OKC.

Loved the bar EXCEPT I couldn't stay very long because it was a smoking establishment. I couldn't breathe! Sad we came to have a few drinks on our date night, but had to cut it short.

Good food and steak in downtown OKC. Good for the town

I wanted to put 0 out of 5 stars but wasn't allowed. I would NOT recommend this place to anyone for any reason!! The server had an attitude with members of our party from the start. We all ordered the tips trio which included 3 pieces of steak in 3 sauces. 1 piece of meat out of 9 was consumed. The rest were not edible. I ordered lobster bisque as my side with the steak. It had 3 overcooked pieces of lobster. I'd also ordered a lobster tail and made the mistake of not asking the price. $74!!!! That was more than our entrees put together! I'm not sure if the steak with gristle was worse or the rubbery, way overcooked, over priced lobster! The bill for 3 people was over $300. The best part of the meal was the water. We were celebrating my mother's birthday, her first one after my father's passing as well as their 49th wedding anniversary that would be tomorrow. It was a let down to have such a terrible meal on a sensitive occasion! I wish it was possible to get our money back.

Very yummy and very very expensive$$$$$.
Service was top notch very good experience in all.

Much more expensive than I thought it would be....but the food and service were superb!

Every time we experience Mickey Mantle's, it's an experience! Sunday evening our steaks were cooked to perfection (will be nibbling on them for a day or two). The service was exceptional, as always. And for Father's Day, we got a small tin of their steak rub presented to us. I don't know why there are any negative reviews about this place. Always a pleasure for a special occasion ... Our server was D'Shawn (Spelling ?) ... Love it!

We had an excellent meal here. The service was somewhat lacking, with a very curt waiter serving us that night. However, the prime ribeye steak was buttery and melt-in-your-mouth tender, and perfectly cooked and seasoned. The okra was very good, but not sensational. The fries were forgettable. All in all an excellent meal with somewhat lacking service for the price expectations.

Our server, Taven, was amazing. Definitely a request for him when we go back in. Attentive and respectful! Guy needs a raise. Everything was great, the mushroom risotto was excellent. The filet, not so much. The management team definitely took a point in making corrections to the issues, but all and all, I would go back!

Last time i visited here with my friends for food and i had nice experience. The place was super and the way they serve their customer was appreciable. I like the way they understand their customer need. if i talk about the food was tasty and healthy too. The price were also decent. Overall good place to eat.

Fantastic every time we've been , we will enjoy many future date nights here!

Fantastic service and food! We had a wonderful evening and the waiter was superb.