Joey Tomato's Review

Love this place, great pizza, especially the sauce!

Sat at an outside table with my newborn baby while my wife went inside to get a few slices. A tall young man came to wipe the table and I said thank you can he just looked at me and gave me a dirty look and didnt say anything and after wiping table he wiped the dirty cloth towards me and my baby. After my wife came back we saw another worker at the next table and that young man went over to her and they looked at us and gave us dirty looks. Management needs to straighten this out with their workers because this is terrible how we were treated. Terrible

There is good food, but they were sold out of chicken parmigiana and sicilian pizza

Best place to get a quick slice or two while walking around the boardwalk! Probably the best place to even eat on the boardwalk! Every time I ve been there it s amazing!

Fun pizza place on the boardwalk. Pizza is fast and fresh.

Worst customer service ever on 8/2/19
Answer from manager after requesting 3 slices of Hawaiian pizza was: we don t make what customers want, we make what we want ... I said you have 2 slices there, I want 3 slices,.. isn t this a pizzeria ?
He rudely answered: yes but we don t do what customers want ..... I hope the owner of this place reads this.

Pizza was really good! Nice atmosphere and friendly staff!

Sunday 9/17/17 the pizza was really 'extra chewy' and very disappointing. Previous encounters were satisfactory, so what happened? 'OFF season?? New pizza guy?? $14.96 for 3 slices and a ice tea. Whats up?? Very disappointing!! Staff seemed not to care when my wife voiced a comment at the counter. We were repeat customers for a lot of years with family and grandchildren, but after today, we are done.

Pizza sauce is sour and too many drunk men coming from jenks acting reckless

Great pizza and staff. You can't go wrong at this place.

Average overpriced boardwalk pizza. 50 dollars for a plain pie that was just ok and 5 fountain sodas.

The pizza was amazing, I'll definitely be going back.

Pizza was decent. Better places up and down the shore.

Charged $60 for two pies one was plain. Horrible customer service and the young busboy they had working for them was arguing with customers the whole time. What a terrible place to eat 0/10 would never go there again.

Best pizza. We go there every year not too cheap but that should be expect. Classic NYC style pizza much better any pizza offered in ohio.

Great pizza!! Plenty of seating, and reasonably priced

Lemme tell ya tuts, Joey matoes is the best slice in jersey.

We've been having pizza at this place for years the food is really good the quality is really good and the help always has a smile

Family vaca brought us all to the Point Pleasant beach and boardwalk. My sister had been here before and INSISTED we go here. The pizza definitely was pretty delicious! Price was not too bad, considering it's on the boardwalk and they are decent size slices. I think it was $3.75 for a single plain cheese slice or $20 for a large (definitely large!) pie which had 8 slices. There were 9 of us, so we ordered 2 larges to split. Service was quick, plenty of plates/napkins and seasoning items were brought out to us. The bathrooms are relatively clean (considering it's right on the beach) and are single bathrooms (no stalls) so you may have to wait in line if you're female.

I have been coming to Point Pleasant for the majority Of my life and I've always had good experiences at joey tomatos,But i ordered a PLAIN pie and a small mt dew and the bill was almost $30.00!!! The pizza was OK but it definitely wasn t the best pizza ive had, the pizza was soggy and dripping with grease. Never in my life have i heard of a $20+ dollar plain pie. Service was not the worst but not the greatest.

Good Broadwalk Pizza...sauce was a bit sweet! I love it.

I have been eating this pizza for many summers now, and much like current times, it has gone downhill. $4 for a less than average size slice with a much less than average taste. It was cheese piled on top of thin burnt cardboard. I get it s the boardwalk and the prices are a little more jacked up, but the quality and quantity also has to go up somewhat with price. Next time I will save my $20 on three slices and three drinks and go elsewhere.

Third class pizza at a first class price
OVERPRICED

Pepsi on tap
:-(

I don't know what all the fuss is about. Just mediocre pizza.

I'm not sure why this place has such high reviews. I've given it a shot several times and the pizza and service is terrible. Upon visiting this past weekend, my wife ordered a plain pie and requested it well done. One of the employees quickly jumped in and said they can't take that type of request when its busy. There were maybe 3 people on line! Additionally their English was so broken it was difficult to understand. The pizza itself was lousy and my stomach was upset the whole next day, probably from it being undercooked. I recall my previous experiences being similar. Living on the Jersey shore there are plenty of other excellent pizza restaurants to chose from and I will be going elsewhere.

The pizza and service are excellent.

It's must pizza place if that is where your taste buds are.

Huge slices, taste was delicious, great meal after hours on the beach

Food was good, but service was slow. Also, very loud group next to our table. Had to shout to have a conversation. Finally gave up.

Overhyped, wouldn't let me order a half plain half chicken parm. Rude, soggy, bland. Candy's pizza in Sussex is 10x better

The bathroom was a little bit not clear and that's it I loved it

Pizza is outstanding and the staff is extremely nice. Didn't have to wait they are great.

Best pizza at the Jersey Shore ,half pepperoni and sausage to stay!! a must try!!!

I had the glorious privilege to consume a Pizza at Joey Mato s and lemme tell ya toots it was amazing 10/10 best Pizza in Jersey

The pizza is absolutely amazing and delicious with perfect sauce to cheese ratio. I just wish there was one closer to home

This is our favorite pizza place in point pleasant!
The pizza is fresh, lots of variety, the restaurant is clean, we always find a seat, and the service is fast!

Pizza is not so great when they take the previously made and reheat it

What a horrible place to eat. Ordered two pies for $63 and it was barley edible. On top of everything one of their 16 year old employees (probably off the books) decided to chime in when I voiced a complaint about a $30 plain pizza. Highly recommend avoiding this place and encourage anybody to go across the steeet for better food and better service.

Love their pizza! We always stop for a slice when we go to the beach

Never spent 24 dollars for a pizza before, but damn it was good

Just Delicious.....!!!
Great service!!!
Taste.....AMAZING. We tried 3 different slices.
the plane, Eggplants & the Veggies...all successful!!!
The place VERY clean.

Thank you for a great experience!!!

The pizza was good but way to expensive, don't know if the lady that attended us was the owner but she was not helpful at all, in fact she was a little rude. And we weren't even finished yet and they are kicking us out at 539cause the were closing.