Joey Gerard's Mequon Reviews

Pretty great. Really nice view of the river but very pricey.

Mr. B's was formerly a supper club but changed its menu to concentrate on steaks. And I have to say it was probably a positive move. The restaurant STILL has that supper club feel and the new menu is very good. My steak was done perfectly!

We ordered 4 curbside dinners and they were perfection. Such a great way to entertain. Only
oblem was the website. It was absolute hell trying to order. You 9 minutes to place the order which isn't enough time and then it times out. Plus, the website took 6 times to finally work.

Happy hour is like stealing. Food and service were amazing

Food and service were great. A little pricier than some of the other quality steak places.

Great place for steak and seafood and excellent service

We decided to try a new place. We ve lived in the area for a year and a half and had a couple go-to places but I wanted to try a new place. After much debate we decide to go to Mr B s. I mentioned it to a couple people at work, I heard really good things. When we got there we had a drink at the bar. Yeah. Perfect lemon drop martini- the night was off to a great start. We were seated and things went down hill. The restaurant was not overly busy but the service was awful. We waited almost 40 minutes for our meals. The food was good, flavorful and tender. Not very hot, but tasted good. We had 2 lobster with a filet entrees, 2 filets w/o lobster and lobster Mac and cheese. Everyone was happy with the taste and quality. Unfortunately waiting so long killed the experience. After I paid the $400+ bill the hostess gave me a rewards card to activate. The next morning I thought about activating it but then thought, why would I bother? The quality of the food was really good but when you have waitstaff you can t find, food that isn t hot when you get it, and an experience that didn t even come close to expectation, why would I go back? I won t. There are a lot of other restaurants in this area!

Went there for Easter Brunch. Food tables, which were setup in bar, were crowded together and difficult to maneuver around. Food choices were somewhat limited. Not a place I would recommend for a brunch.

Great restaurant . The food was very tasty, the atmosphere was classy and romantic , and the service was great. The prices are on the higher end, but well worth it . A great place to go for that special occasion etc. .

Food was cold and very pricey. I been to plenty of Steak and Seafood restaurants this was one of the worst. 2 scallops a very small Caesar salad for a toddler and 16 oz. steak for $85.No bread.
Totally ruined my supper, very disappointed.

Our waiter had a dirty uniform, visibly dirty white smock. Our appetizer was great, lobster mac n cheese. We got our entree which was a large steak for 2 to share. It was great at first but then we got to a different type of steak. It was obvious this was different than the good part we ate just prior. The temperature was very different, much colder. The taste was terrible. After one bite i was done. I was sick all evening and the morning after. I will never return there. I expected better for almost 100 dollars per plate. But i should never assume.

Besides paying for gratuity on a pickup order, I was charged a service charge and an order fee. The bill was absolutely ridiculous for what we received. We used to come here every year for specials occasions when it was Joey Gerard s. I will never return to this restaurant again.

Excellent service! Food always perfectly prepared. Never a disappointment

Edited 12 months later: Our family of 8 visited again last night to celebrate 2 birthdays and the Holidays. Totally disappointing service. Food was very good but multiple comments made by the waiter had us wondering why he chose that occupation. Will not be returning next year.

Service was excellent and the food was fantastic. Ambiance was spot on.

Absolutely delicious! Fantastic service! Excellent french onion soup!!

Not as good as others Bartolottas restaurants. Filets are great! Butter is great! Everything else is horrible including drinks :(

Best steak around and great environment, knowledgeable hosts

Good food, but not amazing especially for the price. Service was slow even with two members of their staff attending to our party of 8.

VERY SUPREME EXPERIENCE!!!!! PLEASE COME SEE FOR YOURSELF!!!!! THE AMBIANCE AND THE FOOD IS IMMACULATE!!!! COLIN IS A SPECTACULAR HOST!!!!!!! I WISH I COULD LEAVE ONE THOUSAND STARS

Had the 8 oz filet. This was one of the best steaks I've had in a long time. The Bearnaise that came with it was a perfect pairing. Had a cheese plate afterwards and it ended up being a great palette cleaner. One of the better meals I've had in a while.

High end supper club/steakhouse. Excellent steaks and knowledgeable, polite waitstaff. Definitely on the pricier side, but an excellent choice for a nice steak dinner or to celebrate a special occasion. Moderate sized parking lot. Restaurant is handicap accessible. Variety of dining options available including steak, seafood, fish, chicken and vegetarian. Excellent selection of wines, fair selection of beer. Quiet, enjoyable atmosphere allows for quiet conversation. Small bar area with seating at the bar also available.

No review can do our dining experience justice. Everything was perfect. The food, the atmosphere, the staff, everything was spotlessly clean, presentation was spot on for everything. I had the best night out since my wedding. Thank you so much for such an amazing experience!

About six months ago we had a disappointing experience at Mr Bs. Tonight we tried again and were absolutely pleased with the service and food. It was lovely evening and will definitely return.

Rich, expensive, expanded, rigorous, closes early, large portions, ample parking, reservation

We had a wonderful dining experience. Upon making our reservation we mentioned that it was our anniversary. We arrived to a nice table with a hand written card congratulating us as well as two glasses of champagne. Our meals were exquisite and the service was absolutely fantastic. After we had our remaining dinners boxed up the server brought us a complimentary dessert to split as an apology for the food taking longer than they had hoped (which we never noticed as the ambiance was great and we had thought the food was right on time given how busy they were). A+ experience overall and 5 stars!

.Service was horrible. There was only 5 other tables occupied . If our server had 1 of them that was it. He had an assistant we saw her more than him but we still had to ask another server for him multiple times including right away to to put our order in. At least the food was good.

Had a steak which is now on my Top Ten list of best steaks ever!

Great place to eat! One of the best steaks I ever had. Top notch service!

Fantastic steakhouse. High quality dishes, well presented, and very attentive service.

Absolutely fantastic food friendly thoughtful staff.

Great service, great food. Nice dining experience, prices what you would expect for a nice steak house. Love coming here.

Good service; wonderful salads but variable prep of fish. My husband had good whitefish but my halibut was over done and dry.

Place was very slow and we were sat right next to the only other couple, would have appreciated a little space. Steak was very over cooked, drink was overly strong staff was nice, bathrooms were were very dirty. Disappointed. Bill was 150, expected much more. Crossed off our list and will not be back

This place wants to be good and Bartolotta's has a great name in the Milwaukee area, but on our third attempt at going here we just can't give it any more than three stars. Steaks are typically under done and drinks are outrageously priced. Onion strings and bacon potatos are must if you do dine here.

This restaurant forces employees to work sick or be fired. This is not only a violation of employment laws, but also a health hazard for patrons. It is good to know this is a Bartalotta policy ... I will be sure to avoid all Bartalotta restaurants in the future. I don't want to pay top dollar and go home with bugs!

Mister B's is a wonderful place to eat the food was excellent the people were nice and it'll go back someday soon

The Porterhouse for 2 was great but I have to admit I wasn't impressed with the atmosphere given the high dinner costs. I've had much better steaks, at a far better price, at some of the smaller local restaurants.

A fantastic restaurant! Delicious food! Wonderful service too!

The food and service ate always phenomenal. Well worth the price though. I will forever be a customer at Joey Gerard's

Great food and very, good, service! Fancy dinning and a nice restaurant atmosphere. My significant other and I celebrate our anniversaries here. Next week we are celebrating our 5year Anniversary, there. I am looking forward to going back there and enjoying the great food and atmosphere!

Great wine suggestion, excellent steak, good potatoes, good side dish, very good desserts. A little expensive, but worth it.

This place is elegant, sexy with male and female mixologists perfecting their craft. The ambiance is sooo relaxing..Servers, bartenders and service outstanding. Good food. Awesome atmosphere, Good music professional and courteous staff..A good place for brunch, dinner or after work stress reliever

Very nice place. Very expensive. Food was decent not the best and not worth the money.

Wow is all I can say, the prices this place charges for the there steaks is unbelievable for the least flavorful steak I have ever had. The side of potato that I ordered was the twice baked, it looked great but it was cold so I think they forgot the second bake. I will say the service was great until I said something to the wait staff about the steak and potato being cool, the response was I'm sorry instead of saying can I warm that up for you. Just a heads up they ask you what type of sauce would you like with your steak, that is the for sure sine that I should of known better.

Sorry Mr. Bs if you have to specialize in different flavored steak sauces for a cut of meet that your charging any were between 35 to 60 dollars for and have to add sauce to give it flavor, your not the Wisconsin steak house that I would travel back to.

Service was impeccable! The steaks were exquisite! And the key lime pie was sublime!

Great food, but the supper club vibe isn't quite there (they're almost trying too hard).

Excellent we were treated like royalty for our 5th year wedding anniversary. A beautiful hand written card and complimentary entrees with our meal. Superb service, the best we have ever received! Thank you Mr
B's!! Mr W.W. and Dr. Nina Cain

I feel any place that has a person walk around and hand out bread is cheap trying to look classy

An excellent evening with tremendous food, wife had swordfish and I had filet mignon.

On 3/22/19 we attended the wine dinner at Mr. B s in Mequon. It was outstanding. Executive chef Amber and her staff created superb food parings for each of the wines. General manager Zoe and her servers were attentive to our every need. We definitely had a fabulous evening.

What a charming place, food and service great. 5 stars.

Awesome food, great happy hour. Yes, it's pricey, but it's really really good.

The ribeye steak was good. The salmon had a fantastic texture but was the flavor was lacking. Our server had a very poor attitude and it resulted in a level of lackluster service. Although, the bartender and busser that helped us were very friendly.

As always, outstanding steak and exceptional service. The 12 oz filet was so perfectly crafted. There are no current rivals in the Milwaukee area.

A bit pricey, but awesome food!!! Great wait staff and atmosphere!

Phenomenal food. Friendly staff. Definitely returning.

We had a wonderful dinner. Great food great service.

Great food
Great atmosphere
I loved every bit of it.

It was bad!! Had the buffalo rib-eye for $55 and I ate not even half. Won t go back again... EVER!!