Fireside Theatre Review

Awesome food & good environment!
Seen 42nd Street great preformance

Great place. Nicely remodeled. Food well labeled for gluten free needs. Price is great for meal and show. Lovely shopping in between.

Arrive at 730p. Drink a few gin gimlets. Get seated for fish fry after 8p for free dessert. Order the fried chicken. Eat, drink and be merry.

Loved seeing Grease! The food was really good. The show was amazing!!!

I am a vegetarian and while yes they do have one option, one is not enough. they have penty of meat options, fish even, for meat eaters, vegetarians cant want the same lukewarm mushrooms with tomato sauce. I cant even enjoy a decent salad because the dressing has meat in it. I got a plate of wilted lettuce. I really do enjoy the the theater but, that's all i can enjoy. I wish they would have more than one option. Otherwise, good performances.

Nobody turns down a Mai Tai, or a Volcano drink! Yum! And fun!

The food was very good. The production value of the show was much higher than I expected. My only complaint is that there is too much time between the meal and the show.

Nice place. Good food
Excellent service

Saw Miracle on 34th Street. Great entertainment, food and shopping.

It was great. The food was good, I liked the gift shop, and the show was amazing.

Just saw Elf. The food was very good. LOVED the Coquille St. Jacques seafood appetizer. Waited a long time between courses. Finally got up and grabbed 2 of the rumchata cheesecakes sitting on a serving tray a short distance from our table. This a small thing, but since pop is extra $ -- when someone asks for a Diet Coke or Diet Pepsi, don't just bring the RC cola version without mentioning it. I honestly didn't know RC still existed. It shouldn't -- it tastes horrible. However, the raspberry ice tea I got this time -- since I am now smart enough to ask if it's still RC products -- was wonderful. The show was also very good. Especially liked Buddy's bell solo. The theater is pretty tired looking, but doesn't distract from the show. I really hope though they upgrade the seating in the near future. Spoiled by the seating in movie theaters these days!

Great Food; Great Show; Booth Brothers Gospel Group was FANTASTIC!!!

Went to a dinner and show with friends. Really enjoyed the whole time there! Buffet dinner was fantastic.

Overrated. Food was not worth the $$$ Belmont's fish fry was way better! And at way less cost.

Everything was great... personal go up and above the service and friendly

Went with a group from church. Had a fabulous time!

The food was excellent and the show was even better! Will be returning later this year!

Great food and wonderful show! My whole family loved the Fireside experience. Our opinion was that it was worth every penny to upcharge to the higher end dinner options but all the food looked great.

Went to see "The Little Mermaid" with my wife. The food has always been good, but when we were here a couple of years ago, the dining room was pretty dated. They must have recently remodeled because now it looks great! The show was top notch.

Saw little mermaid, the show was fantastic, food just okay.

As always in the past excellent show and meal. Great staff

Very enjoyable. Food was delicious. Saw Buddy Holly show. Very fun. Had pleasant experience in that our waitress, Danielle, returned some of my tip because I had figured out her tip incorrectly. She was very honest and I appreciated her honesty greatly. Love the Fireside!

Chicken was nothing special, however the fish was very tastey.

Legends of Country show was awesome and the food and service was also! Highly recommend!

Great fish fry. Had a great birthday dinner. Miss the free bottle of champagne

Elf was spectacular...great actors and actresses. A couple of poor comments written in by the writers....this is a family show. Not impressed with that. Love the Fireside and will continue to go....for now.

First class fish fry with excellently-trained staff.

My mother, two sisters and I were all newcomers to the fireside this year. We weren't quite sure what to expect but all ended up absolutely falling in love with the place. We wish there were more shows to go to this year since were not big "fiddler on the roof" fans we have decided to go see "Mary Poppins"...again :)

Incredible! Perfect evening. Outstanding show. Forever my favorite special place.

This was my our first time and it will not be our last!
This is the absolute best offerings of gift shops I have ever seen, it is modestly priced and the staff is attentive and very helpful.

The dining experience was to their statement "better than expected", we had the Basic dinner and it was great, the portions were appropriate and the staff was marvelous. Holly was our gal, and by the end of the meal, she was like family, very professional, never pushy, very informative, and generally very good at what she does, they are a team and everyone was on task and only concerned about our satisfaction. The experience was great.

Now for Momma Mia!!!
I have not enjoyed anything that much in a long time. The setting and staging was unique and very friendly, the leads were marvelous and you could tell they do this because they like to not because they get paid to do so. The ensemble was also very fun to watch and on top of their game from the opening notes.
For me, Rosie stole the show! She was beyond fun, and I thought she would be fun to know and her "take a Chance on me" was simply a showstopper!!!

As I said at the beginning, we had a special event, my Mother in Laws 86th birthday and everyone turned them selves inside out to make sure it was a special time.

We will be back, thanks for a great time.

Wonderful evening w family.
This place is a treasure. The production was top notch as were ALL the performers.
My granddaughter was enthralled.

We saw Church Basement Ladies here. Nice show. Very hospitable staff. Thought the food could've been better. Nice couple of gift shops. Maybe it was the show, but very much an older (I'd say about retired age) crowd, not that it mattered. I liked the old school architecture

The show was get the food was wonderful and our waitress was great.

A truly wonderful experience from the moment you step through the doors!

The theatre is great and the food and dining are wonderful! We went for a Christmas show and particularly loved all the small shops to look at while you wait as well! We will definitely be back!

Food was great and the wait staff goes above and beyond. Really a lovely place.

I haven t loved every show I ve seen (and I ve seen many) but i still give it 5 stars because they do such a good job there. The food has been superb every time I ve gone. Personal favorite show there: singing in the rain

A thoroughly enjoyable way to celebrate a birthday! Plenty of parking. Great food with plenty of options. Friendly, attentive waitstaff, no delays, even though hundreds of meals were served with military planning and precision.

After the meal, there's plenty of time and places to shop before the show. The professional performance was amazing. Vocals spot on. Actors enthusiastic. And, all with limited scenery and space. Add costumes, and you transcend to a tropical island, years ago and thousands of miles away in the "South Pacific."

1st time and absolutely loved it. Elvis lives was outstanding!

OMG!!!!!! Beautiful place once you walk into. Much bigger in inside then it seems from outside. The woods painted on the walls are interesting. If you look around, you'll find Big Foot hiding in there. You'll see couple of kids playing. Craved initials of a couple on a tree. Etc. Food is top quality. There is a theater when walking to restaurant area. Didn't see inside, but heard alot of GREAT shows are put on in there. Beautiful Place

We had an incredible experience! Look food was homemade and delicious and the show was 1st rate! I would highly recommend anyone going to the theater. If I had any criticism it would be that it is a lengthy experience when you include the meal and the time getting ready for the show.

Beautiful place, great food and the show was fantastic. Will definitely come again and will bring my family.

They are so awesome and attentive at dinner and every group is personally escorted to their seat in the theater. Delicious food, great surroundings, friendly staff.

What a wonderful place. I did not get to see the show, but the experience was great! The food was yummy! The atmosphere was wonderful. It's amazing when you walk into the place, it is a lot bigger on the inside than it looks on the outside. They even have a couple of gift shops. All in all I would recommend this place!

Great food and the show was fantastic
(Season ticket holder for 20 years)

Great shows, wonderful food. Can't wait to visit again.

I have been a season ticket holder for almost 10 years. Always a great buffet on Thursday and always great shows!

THERE ARE NOT ENOUGH WONDERFUL COMPLIMENTS I CAN LIST. THE BEST EXPERIENCE YOU CAN SHARE WITH FRIENDS AND FAMILY TO CREATE LASTING MEMORIES.

Dinner and theater were very good as well as most gift shops, however 2 in our party were treated so rudely at the clothing and jewelry gift shop, being accused of counterfeiting and of making up an offer which was clearly posted on signage. This same salesperson made such a scene in both cases it was embarrassing and not one we are likely to return and experience. Tainted the whole evening.

The show was outstanding from the sets, to the lighting, and of course the performers. Eat beforehand, as the food came out so late we barely had time to eat before the show, despite waiting in line to be seated right away. Management does not visit tables as is done in so many mid-priced restaurants. The meal consists of vegetables so over cooked that they look canned, expect your medium rare steak to come out medium well, and the pretzel chicken to have a mushy breading, while the chicken is a hockey puck and you a side of wilted potato wedges. The house salad come out with greens dotted with melons and a drizzle of 1,000 island dressing. I gave it the old college try, but it was not for me. Dessert was acceptable, but didn't make up for the rest of the meal. We will go again, but will eat beforehand and expect the included meal to be a sad source of entertainment. Management was contacted before posting this.

Words alone don't describe it you have to experience it

Only after making reservations for people out of town for their first experience to the Fireside Restaurant in Fort Atkinson on a fish fry Friday only to leave in disappointment as the fish was la the fries were cold any have to send the waiter back several times to get items

I have never been disappointed in a Fireside production and this 1 was one of my favorites! The performance was spectacular and the food was great as always! we took our 4 year old granddaughter to see Little Mermaid and she was mesmerised! Can't wait for the rest of the season! I'm pretty sure I'm going to get season tickets for Christmas again this year the gift that gives all year!!

For a small venue they put on a fantastic show and meal.

Saw the 50's rock and roll show and had lunch. Super bread and tasty salad.

The Fireside Theater is a great place to go with the family. The plays are second to none, and the buffet is fantastic! BEST CHICKEN EVER! This is a very classy place that you will enjoy. Very friendly staff as well.

Tip: Ladies, choose a play that your husband will enjoy and he will be much more likely to want to go back.

The theater was awesome! Loved the play. Highly recommend them. The dinner not so much. Felt like we were nickeled and dimed throughout the dinner.

A great dining experience. They must have five star chefs working there. The customer service is always excellent. The shows are wonderful. I have laughed and cried. If you have never been there, you are missing out on a wonderful experience. It is a little pricey, but for the quality of the food and the show, it is worth it.

Always a pleasure what's not to love primo food and drinks and the plays are always exceeding expectations

Fantastic production of My Fair Lady! Wonderful atmosphere and great brunch and terrific staff.