Fireside Theatre Reviews

Elf the Muscial was one of the best shows we have seen there. Very funny! The food is always great.

Food and show decent. They need to do a better job handling the time between dinner and show. No place to sit and wait. Seems to want you shop in their boutiques while you wait. Benches in the hallway would be a nice addition or open theater earlier.

Wonderful dinner and an awesome show. The talent was amazing. We all had a great time. Looking forward to our next visit.

We had a wonderful day everything was amazing from the food to the show and are waitresses Dana was the best .

Loved the peaceful atmosphere. Wait staff was very polite and did not feel rushed through dinner. Food was delish and good selection of wine. Musical was amazing....laughter to tears the whole way through. Excellent Experience!

We love this cozy theatre with it's cute shops.... great food and awesome shows!

Good was great with nice presentation. Slow service, but we didn't have to rush. Plenty of time for shopping. The show was fantastic. Super great vocalists and band.

Always a Pleasant Experience with Wonderful food and Awesome shows!

Newly remodeled and updated. An annual family tradition. Good was better than ever. Such a great all day event! Well done fireside!

Nice meal and show. Arrived just after the suggested start of dinner but still had plenty of time to eat. Lots of souvenir shops we therefore didn't have time for which was a pleasant side effect for our tight budget.

The service here is excellent! We have been to several performances in the past and enjoyed every minute! Mother's day was quite different this year as my mama is recovering from a bone marrow transplant and we are self-quarantined away from the virus. The curbside service for the brunch was a fantastic offer. Mama was very surprised and so excited! Her appetite was wonderful which was a huge relief since her leukemia diagnosis last fall! A huge thank you for giving us valuable time together!

wow what a great time...Henry Higgins and Eliza were absolutely delightful. We did the buffet...YUMMY

Awesome experience. Great 5 course meal followed by a great presentation of Grease.

Its more than theater, and more than delicious food...its an experience!

We've been to the Fireside many times and have always had a great experience. The food is always amazing and the shows are high quality.

Show was great, food was great, service was less than great.

We went for Sunday Brunch and a Matinee performance of Newsies. Food was good and the show was fantastic. Great singing and dancing. Would highly recommend the Fireside but especially Newsies!

I always love going to the Fireside. The food is so delicious and the shows are always excellent. I highly recommend visiting the Fireside.

Love this place!!! Been there several times now and am always impressed with the performances, service, and food!!!

Friday night fish fry is amazing. You can not beat the steamed fish and sauce.

Opening night for the Buddy Holly show was such a great experience. We were impressed by the ambiance in the dining rooms. The buffet had exceptional choices.And the show was incredible. We can't believe the talented musicians!!

Fantastic buffet, and fantastic show. Can't recommend it more highly!

What a place!!! The price seemed a little high at first, even with a meal included. But, after having a fantastic dinner, I was starting to think it may actually be worth it. Then the show was amazing, and it was TOTALLY worth it. The set/scenes were well planned and organized, with phenomenal actors that could sing and dance with the best of 'em. Real pros, as good as any I've ever seen. We saw Newsies, and I'm definitely going to be back for another show. Bravo to the Fireside owners and management, their staff, and all the actors. Thanks for a great night.

The play Elf was wonderful.I have been to the fireside many times.I was VERY disappointed in the food this time.I always looked forward to the food.

Absolutely love coming to the Fireside in Fort Atkinson Wisconsin. Reminds me of all my high school choir trips to see the amazing shows they put on here. Would recommend visiting to all ages.

Amazing venue and excellent fish fry. The staff is friendly, cordial and well trained. There s a swanky bar lounge to have a cocktail if you arrive early for your reservation. I would recomendad the fried Atlantic cod. The dish is served with potato, cole slaw and house baked bread. The venue is spectacular (see picture and video).

The only downside on my latest visit was the freshness of the fries, they weren t piping hot and could have been fresher.

Dinners are sometimes a hiy or miss but the shows are always good.

The food here is exceptional! They have pleasant staff that is attentive to your every need. Clean and has a unique atmosphere. Be sure to notice the lighting in the upper level. Super sharp!

Shows and musicals are fantastic. The. Food is awesome. Service is super.

Wonderful food is always good and the Show was great

Fabulous food, wonderful show, will definitely be back.

Love the atmosphere, the food, the theater. I don't generally like the Christian music the bring to the Fireside, but that's totally personal preference. Their music groups are usually all men or mostly men. I'd love to see a women's group.

Performance of Singing in the Rain was wonderful. Buffet wasn't that great.

The food was great, the shops are fun, and the show was entertaining for our 3 generations.

Great shows. Great food and kid friendly at fish fry.

As usual, wonderful performance...brought me 'back in time'. Food, scallops and salmon were delicious and served with great condiments. Of course the shops were full of holiday bargains!

Over cooked pork....undercooked vegetables, and they the gift shops with cheap junk.....

Great time with family or friends, well worth the $$!

If you've been here, you don't need to read a review. You know how amazing everything about this place is. The dinners are always fantastic and enough courses to feed a small horse. Even for a picky punk like me. And the shows are phenomenal. There's barely a bad seat in the theater. Whether you're up in the balcony or stageside. Since I proposed to my wife at our very 1st show, our family loves trying to get here at least once a year to see a show. We've never been disappointed! And I guarantee you won't be either.

5 star dinner as well as 100 star performance. The actors deserve awards.

OMG, what a special place. I can't wait to go again.

We had another enjoyable evening. Food was consistently great, the service was excellent, and the play was FANTASTIC. Great food choices at the Thursday buffet.

Great food, great service and the show was AMAZING!!

Easy to get to! Leave early enough to beat the traffic. If weather conditions are bad call ahead to change your date. They are very accommodating.
The buffet is wonderful! More importantly the performance is always wonderful. If you have a hearing aid with T-coil they are set up for that. ENJOY! ! !

The dinner was astonishing in quality. The show was energetic and the actors were gifted at bringing the audience into the show with them. Our host stopped at every table to greet his guests making the extra effort to ensure the satisfaction of his customers. Well done Fireside!

Elf was fantastic! Our daughter loved the show. Dinner service, however, was terrible. It took over 30 minutes for drinks to arrive at our table - which is a long time for a kid to wait for a glass of milk. We were one of the first tables seated and seemed to be the last to receive our food. When it finally got to our table, we had to rush to eat to make the show on time. The waitress didn't even take my mom's order, and then served my dad a dish with shrimp after we told her he had a shellfish allergy. Dinner was rough, show was great.

Always loved the fireside! Very professional! They make great use of the stage. We always choose the balcony and are never disappointed with the productions. Food is superb, especially the Thursday buffet!

Just saw Menopause the Musical on it's last day before a new show rolls in. Vocals were amazing. I laughed so hard. Brunch buffet was delicious. Dessert was a simple ice cream dish but for just right. So Fun!

Great food and the shows are always absolutely amazing!

Food was excellent! Service SPECTACULAR! Play, saw menopause the musical, EXCELLENT!!!!

Food was great and the show after was good too. I had a great time and would reccommend the fireside for sure.

First time at the Fireside, thought it was very nice . Everyone was very friendly.

This place is such a hidden gem. Great decor, great food, great talent

Food buffet amazing,our server so fun and polite,the anne show amazing cast and what they can do on a small stage soso cool.

Excellent food and a great show. We saw Annie. This was one of the best shows I've seen there.