Fireside Theatre Reviews

The Fireside never disappoints! The meal was amazing, and the performance was top notch! The shops are unique. The staff is the best of the best!

The Rock and Roll performance was awesome. Cast was superb.

My first experience here and with a musical. Great food and service and "Elf" the show we saw was very good and funny. Highly recommended!

Fantastic play! The actors really did a great job. The food was great, as always. The staff there go the extra mile to make you feel pampered.

Loved my first experience here! They are remodeling and had one dining room area not finished but that did not detract from the beautiful atmosphere. If I were not moving to AZ I would definitely rerurn! The food was superb and the show, My Fair Lady, was very well done! The American cast have the English speech and accents down perfect!

The Country Legends show was just amazing, probably the best show we ever saw there.The food us always great.

My dover sole was amazing. Service was good show was wonderful!

We have been coming to the Fireside for over 10 years. It is always an enchanting evening. The meal is always an elegant 5 course meal. The staff is incredibly helpful and friendly snd the shows are very entertaining. The Fireside is located in Fort Atkinson Wisconsin about 2 hours from Chicago. The cost is about 80 dollars per person. That includes the dinner and the show. There are hotels nearby which make for a nice weekend getaway.

A fantastic walk down memory lane. Food was good and service was excellent! All 3 Elvis's nailed it. Zach was my favorite though. Don't miss this one!

Great food and even have gluten free. Show was good.

I have had season tickets for 3 years and take a bunch of friends as a lady's day out. The food is superb, fantastic shops and wonderful performances.Can say enough. We always have a wonderful time and look forward to the next show. Hope they bring back Steve Watts.

Great venue, very unique, could use some updates in point of sale options and online capabilities though.

Long night after eating so much food, bit worth it!!

The brunch was excellent, and the 50,s musical was very good. We had a great time. Like the gift shop also.

Food delicious. Theatre has intimate setting and performances are always top-notch. Never been disappointed. It is always a treat to go!

Grease was one of the 3 best I have seen at the Fireside! Fantastic job!

The meal was flavorful & the servers were attentive. The shops have fun & unique gifts. The show performances were entertaining.

I cannot recommend the Fireside highly enough. Have been there 3 times so far and it has been so enjoyable each time. Was there today for The Little Mermaid and we are going back for Grease!!

The church basement ladies was funny and the meal was super as usual.

I really can't help but to think that the other reviews listed here are somehow associated with the Dinner Theatre itself. Our family of 4 attended the Fireside Christmas production in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin. ALL of us were struggling the entire time not to fall asleep. It was incredibly boring. We will definitely not be going back. Certainly not worth the money. Hands down the worst production that any of us had ever attended. It was painful to sit through. We were very tempted to leave half way through the show. The food was not impressive or memorable for that matter. I am incredibly shocked that this place is still in business.

Great meal & production. The actors were great, but no one can come close to John Travalta! Their taped music is too loud to hear the singers clearly--need to turn it down a notch. Otherwise worth the 3 hour+ drive!

Elegant dining, professional musicals.
Amazing staff, and a great staple to our community in Fort Atkinson.

Miracle on 34th St was a terrific! Thank you for a fantastic preformance.

Saw the Buddy Holly show with dinner. Food was very good night and the show was great. Not a bad seat in the house!

Fabulous food; fabulous shows. Expensive but so worth it!

Food was excellent, but our service was another thing. Half our group of 24 was finished eating before we were served. The play was FANTASTIC ( Christmas Story). Would love to go there again . Had chicken cordon bleu, beef short ribs, scalloped potatoes, tomato bisque with grilled cheese slider, dessert was ginger bread frozen custard pie

The Fireside is one of Wisconsin's hidden gems. Plan to make it a unhurried visit. The shows are well produced and staged. The Christian concerts and productions uncrowded and very enjoyable.

Delicious food, beautiful surroundings, wonderful wait staff and very good drinks.

The food was excellent and so was the service. My husband and I saw the 1:15 show of the Legends of Country and they put on an excellent show. We would see that show again in a heartbeat. I hope they bring them back next year.

Hands down the best biscuits and gravy!! Enter a contest, and you'd win.

Best fish fry around with a peppercorn sauce with the baked is something you'll never forget! Fresh warm bread and very professional staff makes you wish Friday was every night!

Great service with attention to detail. Fantastic experience! Delicious gourmet meal and fun show with talented actors.

The Fireside is a fantastic place to visit with family and friends. The atmosphere is magical. I always look forward to having a delicious meal and seeing a magnificent show. The staff is so kind and helpful. I highly recommend paying a visit to The Fireside!

Amazing! Took my daughter to see "Little Mermaid" out of this world!

Disappointed this time. The food was beef again so I had to pay more to get chicken. The show was boring. $84 a ticket and we left at intermission. It was the basement church ladies show.

As always a great show!! Superb talent. Dining was not as good as in the past.

While on the expensive side, we've always enjoyed our visits. Delicious food, attentive staff and wonderful entertainment

I went for the shopping lots of silly little trinkets and such. Recommended as there isn t much out in Janesville for shopping, restaurant is cool too. It s a destination!

A bit spendy, (I'm cheap) but ALWAYS a great time. Our family went 12/15/18 for the evening production of "Elf", and, as expected, the show & food were outstanding. Our servers Josie, Jessica and Stephanie are worth a special mention, as they went above and beyond to make this a wonderful evening! Wonderful enough that I didn't mind the late night drive home, even though I get up at 3:15 am for work! Most highly recommended!

Dinner was just ok, the room where we were seated was odd and not very atmospheric. Service was good. The show (Elvis Lives) was outstanding. I'm not even a big Elvis fan and I had a great time.

We always go for the fish fry on Fridays! It's amazing the sauce with the steamed fish and vegetables- delicious! I recommended it to all my friends!

Family tradition! Love the plays and Thursday night signiture buffet meals.

Excellent show and always excellent food. The service we received was top notch. Always a great time at the Fireside. Never been disappointed in a show here or in the food. Highly recommend, especially for special occasions!!

Delicious food, great show and lots of good stuff to purchase.

I saw Rock-in-Roll show. I was blown away. Such talent I couldn't believe it. So worth seeing. Dinner was an amazing piece of chicken. Service was amazing. See this show!!!!

We go to three or four shows a year and always have a great time and an excellent dinner

Dinner was ok. Show was below average. I have been coming to Fireside for more than 20 years. I don't think standards are as good as they once were.

Very pleasant, friendly staff. Food was great show was entertaining. Very much enjoyed it. I would recommend it to family and friends.

AWESOME service,Awesome food,Awesome show!!! I am always very impressed with EVERYTHING!!!!!!!! HECK!! 5 stars...nah...try 100 STARS!!!!!!!!!

I absolutely love coming here! It's pure magic every time. The food is great and the entertainment is top notch!