Broadway Paper Reviews

I only get my cards from here. Usually $5 each and a lot at Drug Stores are more than that now! They're always so creative and well received. This is also a great store just to waste some time looking around.

Unique yet classy cards, wrapping paper, seasonal items like calendars, memo books, but also themed party goods. Shop here for fun Milwaukee & Wisconsin memorabilia!

Inviting and fun. There is something for everyone here. Whether that's cards, knick knacks, journals, or notebooks; this stores got everything!

Prices are a little high here but worth the visit for some custom and local vibes.

I'm not sure where to begin with how much I adored Kate and her staff's service at Broadway Paper for our wedding invitations and thank you cards. Kate helped guide us through the design selection process, offered advice when it came to etiquette and wording of our invites, helping us print and design our wedding ceremony programs, and all sorts of final printing details that were last minute to me. Kate involved us through all finalizations of the invitations, programs, and gave us realistic time frames as to when our printing jobs would be completed (which were always in a timely manner). We were also able to order letterpress invitations & thank you cards as part of our design.
I shop at Broadway Paper quite frequently for their selection of stationary, gift wrap, cards, books, etc. I love the design aesthetic of the store, and I also love that Kate showcases local artists and their work. Not to mention, she is one cool lady to work with.
I would completely recommend Broadway Paper to anybody who requires a beautiful selection of designs by local and national artisans, great service, and attention to detail when choosing wedding invitations, shower invites, or whatever you stationary needs are.

Love all the cute gift options and all of the pretty patterns and colors on everything. Great vibes!

Such a fun place, novelties, paper, cards, you never know what you'll find.

Broadway Paper is a great store full of unique gift ideas. I love visiting every time I come to Milwaukee.

Great local shop to purchase unique cards and gifts!

Nice clean store with a little bit of everything regarding paper from stationary to wrapping paper. This place has a friendly and inviting atmosphere. The prices are a bit on the high side though.

Tons of neat stuff. Pricier than Amazon, but way more selection.

The sales person spent a lot of time with us. Explained all options.

Would reccomend. It is expensive though.

One of my favorite places to shop for paper products and gifts!

A cute little paper shop with all kinds of fun crafty shop. It's not cheap but there are a lot of unique cards and journals and small gift items.

The kind of fun, artsy boutique Milwaukee needs more of! Great selection and constant rotation. Good cards, good wrapping paper, good gifts.

This store offers so much, and all out of town friends and family always talk about how much they love this store. From quality art supplies to thoughtful MKE unique gifts, I rely on this store for many thigsy.

Great selection of greeting cards for a variety of occasions. Also has great gifts and knick knacks. Make sure you get a stamp card if you buy enough cards from here.

Great store for fancy paper, stationary and notebooks etc.

Wide selection of paper, ribbon, boxes, etc. Can be pricey but worth it for special occasions.

Great selection for wedding invitations. Staff very nice and professional.

A really cute selection of cards, paper, cards! There's also a really good amount of small gifts for folks that are mostly local artists and stuff. This place is awesome for last minute gifts for friends. I nabbed some supplies for Valentines. My only complaint would be I wish they had a bigger printed design paper selection but other than that I experienced some awesome service.

Cute but most of the things are a bit expensive. For gifts and cards is great ( quite fancy)

Truly horrible service, Broadway Paper! Truly!

I came into the store with high hopes, and purchased two cards for a wedding and an engagement party later in the month. I asked about the return policy, since I knew that one may be returned if my friend did not want the card. I was told by staff that as long as I had the receipt, it would be fine. I came back a month later, after the engagement party, to return the unused card. Staff told me that was not possible, and said that what I was told previously was wrong. I asked to speak to the manger, as the card was overpriced, $10, and staff told me she was busy. I left my name and number to be called back. It has been four months, and I was never contacted. I always try to support local business, but the insolence of this company has deterred me from ever coming back.

Truly horrible service, Broadway Paper! Truly!

Coming here is a treat because they seriously have the cutest things. Love the local goodies, too!

This store is so adorable! It is a perfect balance of trendy and traditional. The staff is super friendly, and service is always top notch. They have a very wide variety of things you can get there, and I always have such a wonderful and fun time shopping there. If you are in the Third Ward, this is a shop you CAN'T miss.

My favorite part was the trendy large poster-size prints they offer. A really fun place to browse!

If you are looking for wedding invitations, go elsewhere. There are so many lovely options for wedding invitations throughout Milwaukee and online, Broadway Paper will only cause you stress.

We chose to purchase our invitations through BPC because we were amazed by their personal touch, and they went through all their many options with us in person. However, shortly after we made the decision to order through them, the woman who had impressed us so much must have left, and was replaced by Amanda. Though we picked out the invitations 8 months before the wedding, Amanda assured us that we should wait another 2 months to order them and that they would arrive with plenty of time. However, three months before the wedding there was still no sign of the invitations. After many emails which went unanswered, we finally received our invitations with just over 2 months before the wedding. This meant we had to rush to stuff and stamp all the envelopes in order to send them out immediately. Amanda had stuffed all of the invitations herself without being asked, however this meant that we had to undo each one in order to place the stamp on the RSVP envelope, and wrap them in the ribbons that we had chosen. Furthermore, Amanda had incorrectly placed the order, and it was printed on different paper from what we had chosen. With so little time, there was no way to place a new order, so we had to go with the incorrect order. Nearly all of our 500-person guest list lived out of town, and so most of them received details of the wedding with very late notice, which also meant that we received RSVP cards quite late.

Throughout the course of our work with BPC, Amanda was highly uncommunicative. We often had to email her multiple times or call the store to try to get an answer. She was not at all knowledgable about her products or the companies with which they work. As a busy bride-to-be, with many details to manage, you do not want the headache of working with this company.

Great store for locally made and local themed gifts! Friendly staff and great selection. Would return

Always have a fantastic selection of well-crafted, unique, and creative cards and gift bags made by artisans

Adorable shop with tons of fun gifts. Very easy to access from the third ward streetcar / hop stop. Always like to check here when shopping for a gift.

This place is filled with lots of amazing paper and cards.

Great shop with a huge selection of crafting papers, greeting cards, wall art, books and project kits. Highly recommended.

I love this place! It is beautiful with a fun mix of items. I would have bought a lot more if I was local since I didn't want to mess anythi g up in my suitcase.

Staff is so genuinely friendly. The coolest selection of pins, pens, and some great books

Super fun place to get upscaled wrapping paper for those really special gifts, for really special people in your life.

Visited right around Christmas. It was busy as could be. Greeted as I came in. I was able to find help from staff immediately. They helped me find what I needed. They knew exactly where my items were in store. So staff was totally knowledgable of merchandise. Able to buy my items right away and out the door. Will be back next time in neighborhood

Many selections-lots of my favorite Cavalini and Co

Great store with nice collection of gifts and stationary

Beautiful shop filled with all my favorite things...wrapping paper, bows, cards, and unique gifts. Just loved looking at everything.

Adorable store. Items for sale are unique and decently priced. The employees are friendly and very helpful.

Good selection of funky and traditional cards. Interesting gifts of the book/print and calendar nature as well.

I am lazy, lets start there. I work in the third ward and whenever I have a gift that needs wrapping I walk over and always get them wrapped at Broadway Paper. They have an awesome selection of paper and cards and the staff is always very nice. I really don't know what I would do without them.

Great spot for gifts. Not inexpensive, but cute thoughtful items.

If your spouse/significant other hasn't already clued you into this location, they are missing out ;) A great little place with friendly staff and great selection for any season or reason when you want something fun, unique and clever to let those in your life know that they are special to you.

Friendly welcoming staff, beautiful store, well stocked, lots of paper related products to close from. Great experience. High quality paper and envelopes I'm using for my own businesses gift cards.

Bright and airy atmosphere with an eclectic selection of goods.

Cool store with novelties as well as quality stationary. Dropped in after a few drinks and picked up some gifts for friends while in town visiting.

We ordered invitations from here are were very disappointed with some of the customer service practices. In the initial meeting and follow up meeting, Kate was super kind and helpful, answering any and all questions we had. However, once we placed the order and Broadway Paper got the down payment things changed...emails and phone calls were not answered/returned. It was so frustrating. There were lots of excuses as to why no one returned calls or answered emails. In the end, the invitations turned out pretty close to what we imagined but the stress it caused was not worth it and we would never order anything from this store again. Cute enough store to shop and carry but wouldn t recommend ordering any custom invitations.

Great selection of stationery, papers and cards. Again, wish they'd offer a mailing service.

Very well stocked paper store, kind of expensive, but not ridiculous. Lots more beyond paper- Wisconsin chatchkies: mugs, posters, etc... fun to putter around in, even if you don t buy anything! No complaints