The Good Pie Reviews

Way overpriced quality is good but not at that price

Great customer attitude,cool front end people and behind the products offered.keep it up.

My name is Tom and this my story lol.
I was going to the physical therapist next door to JW Pastry. I arrived a little early so I figured I would grab a quick bite and proceeded to look in my GPS for nearby restaurants. As I was looking I noticed a place called The Good Pie Company/JW Pastry (2 stores in one place). When I went inside the first thing I noticed was the beautiful smell of freshly baked goodies & how clean the place was. The Good Pie Company is one place and JW pastry is another. The Good Pie Company have some amazing pies from spinach pie to apple pie, Cherry Pie, Artesian breads handcrafted pastries & custom pies just a phone call away. I mean I am Extremely impressed how organized they are. However I was more intrigued in the Sweet Tarts that I saw before my eyes (In the picture). I spoke with Jonathan who is a executive pastry chef and owner of JW pastries about how he crafted the Sweet Tarts. He really impressed me with the details on how he crafts these works of art. I decided to buy one sweet tart and let my taste buds and stomach do the judging. Let me tell you what, I fell in love with it, my stomach fell in love with it & my brain is now addicted to it lol. It's freaking Amazing!!! Just so you are aware I live about 40 minutes away from JW pastries and I come here 2 to 3 times a week! When something is that good and that cheap ($8.00), you cannot go wrong. The executive pastry chef Jonathan is a wonderful and honest person. Something you don't find a lot these days. Take my word for it, This Place Is Amazing. I promise you you will not be disappointed.

The best people the best smells the best pies and cheese cakes and just the best place ever. Lol I love going here on break my fav is smores pie!!!

Best pies
..lovely owners

My husband and I accidentally stumbled into this place a couple of years ago. Best mistake we made in a long time. Have tried many pies. Whether savory or dessert, pies are without exception excellent. Often buy one savory pie and one dessert pie. Prepare a salad if you like, and dinner is served. Owners/bakers are friendly and open to new ideas. Should be named The Great Pie Company. That's what we call it!

Awesome quaint little shop with 2 businesses in it. I usually get the pastries from the other business, but I bought the blueberry pie from these guys once and it was delicious!

Small space..but the pastries and pies look absolutely FABULOUS. This place is a hidden Gem. Product is fresh...the double espresso I had was great. Cant wait to go back.

I ve wanted to check this place out for a while & finally had the chance. Bought a very small 3 inch individual peanut butter pie for 12 BUCKS! It was good but not any better than Pie s from Publix, Doris, Fresh Market, and Whole Foods etc. & their Pies are half the price. Don t think I ll be back; it s just not affordable to me or worth it at all. They were very nice inside & they gave free sample but again, I try to support mom & pop places but they make it so hard too.

Delicious pies and baked goods, plus an excellent cafe bar. All rave reviews from family for the chicolate pecan pie .

Fabulous, quaint little Bakery right in the heart of Davie,Florida Delicacies, homemade goodies and an Ambience that will knock your socks off.. 5 star

I was driving by with some friends and saw this cute bakery and decided to stop to check it out and it was a great choice the pastry are amazing and the servers is amazing too the owner gifted me and my friend with some really amazing pastry s I definitely would come back here. I got the butter croissant and bananas bread both really good.

Pickup order plus. It was a short waite everything was great.

Amazing Pies and amazing service! Staff was courteous, helpful, and extremely nice. I got the cranberry-apple pie and it was delicious! I highly recommend others visit this cute shop.

Fantastic bakery, one and the same with JW Pastry. Just go! Buy baked goods there! Delicious!

Execellent! I was just driving by with some friends looking for a place to have breakfast, and we foukd this place, SO DELICIOUS! At the end we got something FREE. Coming back for sure!

Incredibly open, friendly staff with insane pie and baked good selection, even stayed open late just for us and even heated it up for us properly in the oven 10 minutes. So dedicated to pie, people, and the pursuit of happiness through their trade! Local coffee too!
THEY HAVE PIE EMPANADAS PEOPLE! THIS IS NOT A DRILL.

Excellent pies with lots of variety. Please open another store in Western Pines :-)

The nearest I've found to real country pie in this area.

We ordered seven six inch pies for a birthday party. Everyone loved them. The presentation was elegant and they tasted great! Jake was very nice to work with. He took time to answer all my questions and never rushed me even though he was the only one working at the time.

So specia and worth the 30 minute drive and every penny! Even came end of day at the end of their week and they kept apologizing about the lack of selection.... which was still plentiful and I ended up walking out with 6 different sweet and savory options.

Jonathan super nice guy and everything he does looks great and tastes even better. no need to look any further, Like a old time bakery that you just dont see here in South Florida and personal service and can get things how you want them. Just try it and you will be glad you did!!!

Their pies are awesome! Incredibly delicious, I highly recommend them. The lady who help us, was so nice also and for sure I will come back!

Tried their lemon chess pie, chicken pot pie, and French almond croissant. Everything was excellent. Pies are available in three different sizes.

We try the Aussie meet pie, wow simply delicious, the Quiche: bacon, onion and Swiss cheese it is so yummy, the basil, tomato quiche, oatmeal cookies, the bread pudding, let me tell you I am not a fun of bread pudding but after I warm it up in a convection oven at 300 degrees farenhieth for 5 minutes, they give me a sauce to put on top of the pudding before serving, well I love it I'm going back for second, ohh forgot to tell you we are so pl ease with everything we try we order a Coconut cream pie, I'll let you know who was it, but I can take a guess...
The lady who help us, was very nais she gave my son a small meat pie which he love by the way, this place is a most stop for artisan bread, you can also place an order on line or over the phone.
It is $$$$ but it is really worth it.

Jake owns The Pie Company and I'm telling you the pies are absolutely delicious. I got the butternut squash with caramelized onions and Gouda and the Aussie meat pie, I took these pies to children who ate the pies and asked for more! Sign of a good cook is the ability to give unusual food to children and have them love it! Good job Jake. Definitely following you in Instagram! Total Yum Yum Yummers!!!!

Had the apple pie for dessert on Easter Sunday! It was a hit.
Update: We had the white nectarine-blueberry pie on the Fourth of July, that too was delicious. You can tell the ingredients are fresh!!

Drove here cross county for pecan pie on a Saturday and they closed early at 330pm with no message on their voicemail wth! They responded kindly, so I will try another day!

Fresh deserts all the time and an awesome staff who is friendly and cordial.

Great bakery. Nice selection and very nice people. Everything we bought was delicious

Today, my mother took my father, her best friend and I to this pie company boasting about their pies. While there, my father took a few samples to try. Contrary to popular opinion, according to this establishment, you are NOT to sample their food. A man who worked there, who I can only presume to be the owner, with no regard to embarrassing patrons told my father that "he'd had enough samples." Despite the fact that my mother purchased 3 pies and her best friend purchased 2 pies, this was not enough to equal my father consuming a few samples. Needless to say, we will NEVER be returning to this place again, and if you decide to go DO NOT EAT THEIR SAMPLES or they will reprimand you as if you are a child and not an adult.

Excellent! It's a little pricey. But you get what you pay for. We had the chicken-pot pie and lemon chess.I Will get both again and again and......

My wife and I found The Good Pie Company online and figured we'd give it a shot. Walking into the shop is an experience, so many different pies to choose, savory, sweet and different other assorted desserts. The owners are super friendly, and were happy to answer my million questions about the different menu items. If their passion about their food didn't come through just talking to them, wait until you see them box up your pie. The pies are really a work of art. The lemon meringue pie was something out of a magazine or food network show, really just stunning.

The reuben pie was our favorite. There are caraway seeds so it you taste the rye, sauerkraut and the thousand island dressing in every bite. This was 100% the best thing I've eaten in a long time. The prices of the pies are really worth it considering they are stuffed to the brim with meat. There is very little filler, its all so well balanced. I would certainly recommend this to anyone who is looking for good eats, and wants something a little different. Five stars!