Our second time here and once again, a fabulous meal. We were also allowed to bring our own wine, which was great! We happened to have a bottle with us. Our waiter was fabulous and very attentive.
Food was good, got some attitude from the waitress when I wanted my pork well done. She told me well it is not pink, . We on it came out pink. I don't eat uncooked pork.
Excellent service, good and atmosphere.. Perfect evening
What a great evening. The food was outstanding service was great. Very quaint on the ocean. Always kept up beautifully.
It was restaurant week which created quite a bit of hustle.
Afterwards we spent time on the porch to this view
Everything about this place was amazing. The food..the atmosphere, the service was top notch. A special thanks to Meagan (our waitress) for taking great care of us!!! 100% recommended when in cape may!!!
Simply Extraordinary! We had our wedding at the Peter Shields Inn this past weekend. They graciously accommodated 100+ of our guests and provided extraordinarily professional service, extreme quality gourmet food, a scenic overlook that cannot be beat, and a feeling of home that cannot be matched. We are absolutely ecstatic with the outcome of the event.
Delicious, with a gorgeous view of the beach! Lovely piano music serenaded us as well. Elegant setting with a price fixe three course meal if you arrive before 5:30. Attentive service but BYOB, though we bought the Cape May Vineyards wine that they sell and it was fine.
Exceeded expectations! Top restaurant in Cape May. Bacon wrapped Monk fish and pork tenderloin blew us away. Wonderful job on service and compliments to the chef and staff!
Outstanding in all ways - service and food, the decor. This was the ninth or tenth time we have had dinner at this restaurant. Unfortunately, this time there was an obnoxious table of very loud people. Nothing to be done.
The food is amazing, the service is incredible, and the prices are reasonable! Easily one of the best places I have ever eaten at.
Service and food were great. For the price I really expected better. Food just didn't have a wow factor about it.
It was again a great evening. Russ, the new manager did a tremendous job. The food is the best in Cape May and the location is just magic.
The best food I ve eaten in South Jersey so far! Yes I am I am a chef myself for 22 years, been in the business a little over 30. In the 90s I worked in some of the finest gourmet restaurants Atlantic City had to offer.. Make sure you BYOB! Otherwise, they have a charming selection of locally crafted wines that they sell, not serve
We had our wedding at Peter Shields March, 2018. Amy, the wedding coordinator, was extremely professional and handled all details, and made the day flow seamlessly. The guests were impressed with the menu choices, the beauty of the Inn, and the piano music by Kahlil. I would highly recommend this venue if you want an intimate and elegant wedding!
Superb service and cuisine. I particularly enjoyed the grilled octopus appetizer, aged NY strip steak and cheesecake. Recommended.
Wonderful accommodations. Perfect location right across from the beach. Rooms are so amazing. Superb amenities.
My husband and I went here for our 10yr anniversary. Reservations were competitive due to Covid (around here restaurant reservations usually isn t that competitive during the off season). Our waiter was great - attentive without being suffocating and very knowledgeable of the menu. The ambiance was great for an anniversary dinner - with views of the ocean from a window at the front. The food was absolutely delicious - we didn t have room for dessert even though the dessert menu looking so enticing.
This was the best restaurant experience (food and service) we had during our time in Cape May. We ended up having the terrace to ourselves due to a late reservation and it was the perfect end to our small getaway to Cape May. Highly recommend eating here! They also fully accommodated Gluten free (The Majority of their menu is GF...)
Superb Dinner! Roasted Duck, 18 oz Strip Steak and Service 2nd to none!
Inn and restaurant are both excellent. Great food, accommodations and staff. Highly recommended.
Beautiful place! My godchild had her wedding there! Food was delicious!
Great food, service and music! I highly recommend their four course prix fixe! Every course was amazing!
Amazing. Absolutely love everything from the food to the service to the atmosphere.
We enjoy coming to PSI every year for dinner.
The ambience is just lovely. The cuisine is delicious. The service and presentation is excellent. Chris is a wonderful waiter and
makes our evening a special occasion.
BYO wine. Bon Appetit.
My husband and I absolutely loved our much-needed weekend getaway at PSI. The interior is absolutely stunning, with delightful antiques and beautiful common areas for all to enjoy. The rooms are absurdly gorgeous, even the bathrooms. The service from employees was friendly and wonderful, and the rates were a truly good deal, especially considering all that was included.
Peter Shields as one of my favorites restaurant in Cape May Ferry romantic food is excellent and consistent prices are reasonable for a place like this
Finest dining on the island, even in the county. Fabulous dishes and the head chef is a true artist. Worth every cent.
Beautiful place, excellent food and service. Top notch!
Nice place to come at the shore. A bit overpriced but not bad
Elegant fine dining. Can't wait to make a return visit.
Well prepared food with excellent service. We did the fixed menu and the selection was good for us because we would've ended up picking the same items from the full menu.
Finally dined at PeterShields and so glad we did! Service, food, ambiance are all 5 star; can not wait to return. We now have a memorable night to remember celebrating our 48th anniversary.
It's was great place for date and fine dine. Nice ambience.
Cozy little place in Cape May. Food/service is outstanding.
Highly recommend
This is one of the best places to eat in the crest don't miss it!!
Restaurant Week in Cape May. Peter Shields Inn is a great place to come for dinner. The food is always very good and the staff is excellent. We had the Potato Leek Bisque and Lightly Grilled Tuna with Shrimp Risotto. Thoroughly enjoyed the meal. This is one of our favorite places. We enjoy dining on the front porch when available to sit and look out at the ocean. Restaurant Week is a good deal and makes the meals very affordable but we'll be back long before the next restaurant week. PSI is also a BYOB. Many restaurants in Cape May area are BYOB which helps keep costs down.
Amazing place. The duck was beyond great as was the foie gras. Even the pianist played some great, light tunes.
Good service, five star food! (Some nats flying around but great experience nonetheless)
Had a wonderful time here. Place is amazing, wonderful prefix, if you are in Cape May, you have to try this gem out! I d say this place can hang with Eleven Madison Park for food quality and presentation!
We stopped here for dinner when almost every place in town was closing. They were extremely accommodating and the food was amazing. We got the summer corn soup and the burrata salad for appetizers. For the main course we had the chicken, roasted pork, the mushroom fusili and the gnocchi. Best food during our 2 day trip.
We miss this magnificent establishment. Listening to Kahlil Gunther on Facebook Saturday nights at 6pm is the only constant- the same wonderful concerts we always enjoyed while dining are heard on line. Other than that, my hosting pales to that of Amy and her front of the house crew. I have been told to take lessons from Kim, Kris, Peter, RJ, Sean, Dillon, Dottie, Megan and the balance of the wonderful waitstaff. Our food during these hours with Kahlil has been good and we are among the lucky- but compared to Carl and Jeremy our entrees are mere child s play. And don t even go into the end of meal mode, I totally lack compared to Chris, Martine, Tyler, Ben and crew. If you want to have a vivid Covid-19 dream, think of your last experience at this restaurant. This, too, shall pass, Be safe. Stay well. And hold tight for PSI s return!!
Phenomenal food and atmosphere. Front porch looks out on the ocean. BYOB makes it even more worth the visit!
A group of friends visited Capriccios back on December 9th. Our experience was top notch!! From the selection of fine wines and various fine Italian cuisine, to the outstanding service. We will definitely revisit!!!! I highly recommend.
Our anniversary meal was so delicious and romantic, that we walked right out to the beach after dessert and got engaged! ;) Thanks for setting the mood for a memorable night!
The food, atmosphere, and service are impeccable. A wonderful place to share an evening with friends!
Excellent food. Really nice ambience. Great feel.
The best restaurant I have tried! We were 3 and we were naked that this is the best restaurant we tried.
Excellent service, highest quality menu; everything delicious!
The Peter Shields Inn is perfect for a romantic dinner. I took my girlfriend there for Valentine's Dinner and we were impressed from the minute we arrived. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. They had rose petals all along the window sills with roses on the table and they had a piano player playing their grand piano in the main lobby. We started off with ordering the Butternut Squash with Smoked Trout and it was unbelievable. For our main course we had their Tenderloin and Scallops and both were out of this world. Their desserts were a nice ending to our meal. The sorbet is house made and delicious and their creme brule was just as good. The whole time it felt like we had four waiters as we never had to ask for fill ups on our water or wine. From start to finish this is one of the best restaurants to go to in Cape May. We will be going here again the next time we are Cape May!
Outstanding food and service. Ambiance is really special.
Wonderful place great food great service great staff should have 10 stars
The gratis food ever and the best service of all time
I've been able to get subs from White House a couple of times and they were great. I would've gotten more during other visits if the line wasn't so long. White House Sub Shop is a very small place where you have to be in and out quickly. Believe me, they make great subs but be ready to order.
Hands down was one of the best restaurants we ve been to in town. Had the 7 course meal and we spent over two hours eating and enjoying the atmospheres. The piano player was heavenly and the staff always kept our glasses full. If you truly care about quality, details, and good service this is the place for you. Make resverations long in advance as seating is extremely limited.
Wonderful service and people who will exceed your expectations.
A wonderful experience. I treated my boyfriend to the $40 prefix price menu and the items on there were so delicious for the price. Wonderful atmosphere, professional staff, beautiful views, and a lovely evening of fine dining for less than $100
We had an excellent experience for our anniversary weekend. The food and service were exceptional. Chris our server was amazing. A true professional. We will be back.
Thank you for a great dinner! The steak was delicious!
Very nice B&B although more of a hotel feel. Staff was super nice.
Great place for dinner. Excellent service and perfect execution of the dishes.
The ambience is excellent. The decor is well done and the tables are spread out so the noise is at a minimum. The food and service were wonderful. We had a appetizer from the nightly special list which was Ceviche. This was light and tasty. My wife had the Halibut and I had the special fish, both dishes were excellent. She had the Creme Brulee for dessert and that also was excellent.
I could seriously write a novel on our experience with Peter Shields Inn, Amy and the entire staff at PSI are absolutely amazing!! They went above and beyond in every single way to make our stay, our wedding, our reception and our entire trip absolutely spectacular for us! From being such a gracious host to our vendors, the private lounge space in the basement, waiting on us hand and foot, to tying up every loose end for us, keeping the venue very private the staff even kept pedestrians on the street from stepping into the ceremony, managing musical cues, catering to our food allergies, and so much more!! Amy did a really good job at managing everything minute by minute in the background, making everything run smooth for exactly what *we* wanted, without ever getting in the way.
best meal I've had in years...
no reviews hold any merit because you cannot possibly taste a meal like that and have any concerns.
Fantastic food but the group of purveyors ruined the atmosphere.
When you dream of a perfect date night restaurant on a pleasant beach town. This is the place for it. The chef tasting four course meal is just mind blowing.
Best fine dining experience in south jersey. Excellent food and service. Beautiful setting. Love it!
Had a great evening at this restaurant. We took advantage of the $ 40 menu for those arriving early (5:30 pm). There were three choices for starters, main course and dessert.
The tuna tartare appetizer was particularly successful.
What is very rare in this type of restaurant is that you CAN BRING YOUR WINE! There is no extra charge to unclog the bottle.
If you feel like it, you can finish your wine on the terrace at the front (sea view).
Awesome atmosphere...food is out of this world...everyone is very attentive...
Absolutely great! My wife had the prefixe menu and it was delicious while I had the duck pesto pasta. Everything was great and good prices considering the quality! Definitely will be coming back when in the area
This restaurant is quaint and romantic. The food is spectacularly delicious. The wait staff was appropriately attentive. Did I mention how delicious dinner was? This is a perfect spot for a special dinner out to "get to know each other better"
Charming lovely B&B that was just a joy to stay at. The rooms have so much character but are all appointed with perfect amenities for a stay. The bathroom was a particular plus.
Awesome Thanksgiving Day meal! Waygu beef the way to go!
Awesome. Slightly slow service but food was awesome!
The restaurant is the best. Food was very good. The inn is also very nice. The room we stayed in was sufficient. Clean. Good amenities. The staff was all good. The cheese, fruit and wine snacks in the afternoon was a nice touch, but they could use a few more crackers to match the amount of cheese. And, maybe try to keep up with the wine demand, as the wine and crackers seem to get gobbled up in the first five minutes. I would reccomend and will go back. We enjoyed our stay.
Very good, priced as one would expect, good service, would definitely recommend this restaurant.
Amazing food!! I had the duck, it was cooked perfectly. Service was great. Gorgeous historical manison, make sure you take a look inside.
