Next Door Pub & Pizzeria Reviews

Casual pub with incredible food. Every time we are in the area, must always stop in.

First time here and will definitely be back again! Adam was our server and was EXCELLENT!! Food was great and all the staff was very friendly.!

Love this place. Great food and prices. Just don't expect to be seated immediately during oesk times.

The Pizza is amazing. Very busy, but food was fast. A must go.

The #1 place to eat in Walworth County. Excellent pizza, don't miss Lasagna night every Wednesday.

Good atmosphere, servers very friendly and very very good food

Just moved here from Kenosha and I'm used to a variety of restaurants. Lake Geneva seems to be lacking in that aspect, Next Door Pub is an exception. Food is tasty. Even though the menu is huge, everything I've tried has been great. Best local restaurant out here in Lake Geneva hands down. As a side note, if there were more competition out here there would definitely be restaurants that could give this place a run for its money.

Often very busy, but for good reason. The food is always great.

Fantastic! Reubens are great!
Too much OREGANO in the Italian Beef. Mine is better but I use a different base of Fennel seeds and Basil. Tastes better - not bitter!

We ordered delivery to our hotel. The young lady that took the order couldn't have been nicer as was the delivery driver. And the food - WOW! Two orders of eggplant parm with salads and cheesy garlic bread. Some of the best I have eaten. Talk about portions, we did not even finish all the food (lunch for the next day). Considering what we got vs the cost it was amazing the cost wasn't more. You have to try this place if you're in the area!

The steak sandwich is amazing. Honestly I haven't had anything here i didn't enjoy. The cheese soup was magnificent. I love that they also have high chairs that are designed to set car seats in when you have littles with you. I love this place.

The best pizza around! The only place I can eat more than 3 pieces of pizza.

Nice! Big menu, nice staff, clean restrooms, and good food. Could of used more seasoning in the steak sandwich but it was tender and cooked properly, salt and pepper during cooking would of been great.

Busy place for a reason.

Party of 4 sat at the bar for dinner. My drink remained empty after my food came. Took several attempts to even get a water. It was obvious that if you aren't a regular, you aren't a priority.

We just left there. The food was good, but we are very confused as to what we did to irritate our waitress. We are here in Lake Geneva and heard the food was good. Our waitress, a tall blonde, just seemed irritated with us, and we really don't know why. we aEven thatsked for water seemed irritating to her. We were just trying to have a nice evening out, away from home for the night, and she made it rather unpleasant. She never came back after we got our food. We never got our soup. We sat there for quite awhile, never asked if we wanted another drink, and we ubered there so we could have a few. She finally came back with the bill, assuming we didn't want dessert or another drink I guess since she walked by us many times and never asked, and I mentioned that we never got our soup. She said, "it was included in the price of the meal, so nothing to take off...." But isn't it just bad service to not get your soup? Wouldn't it have been better service to discount something? We are perfectly friendly people, and she was friendly and thankful to other tables of guests around us, but never smiled at us, never thanked us... We still tipped her well anyway because we're nice people, but it sort of put a real damper on the evening. This type of mediocre/borderline rude service is not what we expected. Disappointed, but could see why others had a good experience.

Excellent reasonable food. Innovative menu. Cordon Bleu chicken soup was delicious. Great service.

Spent $86 and bought so much food. From Chicago and stayed at the Grand Geneva Resort. This place was so friendly, patient and nice. The alarm 1 and barbecue wings, pizza, fries, chicken quesadillas and mozzarella sticks were so good.

Great food and great service,I highly recommend this place.

We're staying at the Grand Geneva and had food delivered. OMG!!!!! The food was heaven sent!!! I had the most tasty cut strips of ribeye over garlic/oil pasta with melted cheeses. Not overbearing full of flavor meat so tender!!!! Everything was fresh, hot, and delicious. The pizza was great as well as a very fresh side salad. My go to place when we fly up this way again. Great Cooks!!!!!

Ordered 1 pizza for delivery estimated tume they gave 45 to 1 hr. After 1 hr 30 min i call to check on the order and while im talking they hang up on me. After being put on hold twice for 5 min each time. My food arrives shortly after the call. Barely warm not fresh at all. I only baught it because i was starving and ended up eating 3 pieces i could salvage then tossed the whole pizza in trash. This is twice in a row getting not fresh pizza. You cant send a driver with 3 or 4 different orders at once and expect the last persons food to be fresh. Very unsatisfied !!!! Also had other delivery issues. Missing salads and or wrong side dish. Done with next door pub. Good luck to you if you dare to try delivery

TERRIBLE. We waited over 2 hrs and the food was ice cold. It tasted like it had been in the delivery car for 2 hrs.
Very dissatisfied.

I ate here several times in 1980 and loved the garbage special pizza, left the area for 35 years ,finally made it back! The Pizza is still the same. Spectacular!!!

My burger was okay. I should have ordered something else. My girlfriend ordered the buffalo chicken salad and said it was one of the best she ever had. I will definitely go back to this place though.

Try the heater burger! It has some heat to it, but definitely the best burger on the menu. Call ahead for wait times, they are a very busy restaurant, but the food is worth it. Waitresses are kind and attentive.

The food at this restaurant is very tasty and the pizza will knock you out. It is the best.

Very good place, extensive menu! Will be coming back!

Service was good even though it was very busy. Very good food

We have been there several times now and the Service is great, the staff is really friendly. The food is fantastic, we have tried something different every time and have not been disappointed.

We always get the brucetta very good. Any beef sandwich is very tender and juicy. Pizza is excellent. Only thing I had here that wasn't that great was the fish fry.

Love Love Love Love There Cheesy Pizza. If you Love Lots of Cheese on Pizza, this is Da Place to Go!

Everything was amazing, food, service and drinks!
I never eat leftover cold pizza, the next day, I ate cold pizza! Will definitely visit again.

Great wings and pizza make this a must stop if you're in the Lake Geneva area. The added history of this being a favorite haunt of the creators of Dungeons and Dragons can make even the most hardened nerd nostalgic

Food is good but it's just way too loud to enjoy a meal. Wait staff below par .

The Next Door Pub is friendly, often busy, and has a great assortment of food. Reliable and tasty, I recommend it for sure thing comfort foods and a good time.

We go here often. The food is always great and the service is very friendly.

Food is always good! Service adequate. Not as comfortable as it could be. Parking a bit awkward.

Fun place aand good food. Great service. Very busy but accomodating.

Excellent food, Italian, pizza, burgers all delicious. Service can sometimes be a little slow. Our go to place in Lake Geneva.

Good food, nice prices, fun atmosphere. Didnt try any but the pizza looks really good

Great food. Great atmosphere. Always busy, so you know its good

Had the Yuengling Fish Fry. Excellent ratio or breading and fish. Breading was crispy and not greasy. Perfect portion sizes.

Love this place friendly bar staff. The pizza is great.

This place was so delicious and the staff was extremely nice. Best bbq chicken pizza I've ever had. Will be visiting again!

Had a great lunch hope to return for dinner sometime

Stopped in for the first time, (we will be back). Food was amazing. So many things on the menu looked delicious!!. Service was phenomenal, took time and answered questions and gave thought out recommendations. Spinach artichoke dip highly recommend. Pizza was great! Pasta was great.

Food is good for the $, love the fireball chicken wings!

Good Italian beef. Terrible french fries. I ordered onion rings, but got fries. Pizza is pretty good.

AWESOME food, people and service! I could not say enough positive about this place. When we got there we had a 30 min wait as they are so good people flock there in droves! Needless to say it was well worth the visit each time. Best pizza I ever had in WI. Stop in and enjoy the food and service!

friendly staff, *awesome* pizza, good beer selection. what's not to like??

Wen ever you order pizza ,we order minimum to minimum topping but the pizza has water alwaz,itsssss the worst thing wen you say the server ,relpy too many topping ,so i think you make the worst pizzza

I generally don't care for places with a huge menu - but this place is an exception to my rule. Over multiple trips I've had the ribs, the pizza and the chicken - all were good. This is our go-to place when we visit Geneva!

Great Pizza, love their Garbage Pizza, fresh veggies and lots of cheese!

This place is very clean and people are awesome. When we went they had live music. Love the food and very reasonable.

Good food, good service, great prices, great drinks

Food: Primo-Pizza-,Cheezie Garlic Brread 5* !! [TIP-IF YOU LIKE YOUR,CHEEZIE GARLIC,BREAD, A BIT MORE JUICY & NOT TOO CRUNCHY, ASK THEM TO "SLIGHTLY UNDER-TOAST IT!" ROCK