Next Door Pub & Pizzeria Review

Really good pizza, looking forward to other food on the menu, seating indoors and out.

We all met here to talk and enjoy some pizza. A group of friends from school and I had a very nice time here. They had a very friendly staff and the fellow customers were very friendly to talk to. Very good items on the menu and what we ordered was very tasty. They do serve alcoholic drinks. The drinks were mixed very well as I could not taste the alcohol. If you are looking for a very good pizza place with other items to choose from then this is a good place to go. I look forward to going again in the future.

There on a tue for lunch was very busy but we were not rushed at all. The server was very knowledgeable and friendly. The staff worked very well as a team.
Thank You

Delicious! Pizza and home made lasagna were outstanding! Try the blood orange martini if you are looking for a great drink!!

Really great food, service and portions for the price.

Awesome wings and beef sandwich !!! Staff were excellent !!! I've been going there forever !!!

We were told this was the best pizza in town, so we had to check it out. This was one of the best pizzas I've ever had! The crust was so crisp even with a ton of toppings. Delicious!

Went here with my mom and got the Moo-la pizza and it was amazing!!

the friendliest staff never disappointed in the food

Not the best food, but excellent prices and service

Best pizza around, and other menu items are great too. Can't go wrong at the Pub!

Always love this this place. The food is great, the service is spectacular.
If you're in Lake Geneva and looking for a place to eat this is the spot.

Best Pizza in the universe. If you like cheese on your pizza, like we do this is the place to go or take it to go. Even Chicago pizzeria's can learn a thing or two from The Next Door Pub & Pizzeria.

Super friendly and knowledgeable waitress. Really good food - breadsticks were the best I have EVER had! Plus they have gluten free options.

This was the place of our first date 46 years ago and it's still the best food; the pizza is my favorite. And, our first date corner and table is still there!!!

Great food and pizza. Priced well also.

I will be back again.

They bring each kid a tablet to play games--so kids love it. Good pizza.

1st time here nice place good food moderate prices and great lunch specials. Our server was great very helpful

Absolutely loved the wings here! Very busy place that still has great services. Little hole in the wall local place with great food and a great atmosphere.

Slight supper club atmosphere which we love. We went on Thursday at 2pm. It was pretty busy, no wait. Popular times/days must be long waits (no reservations). Anyway, even at peak times, this one is worth the wait. Pulled pork nachos, mozzarella planks with panko breading, award winning burgers, amazing cake selection from the owner's bakery next door. OMG, I can't wait to go back. It was all amazing. The menu is huge and everything looks fantastic. Dessert menu is hiding in the tabletop wine and spirits book. And the icing on the cake is that the prices are incredibly reasonable. $31 tab for two soft drinks, 2 appetizers, 1 burger, 1 cake later. We tipped 30% because the service was so great. I applaud the owners for such quality and value and deliciousness. My new fave.

Great Service, incredible food, and easy to find. Will definitely be coming back again.

Great food, great prices, great people. BEST SAUSAGE PIZZA AROUND. great place to run into local people. (I just had to modify review to 5 stars, I unfairly rated it a 3 when thinking about how packed it is) They could fill up a restaurant twice its size... I guess a good problem to have. When your landlocked what do you do? (BTW, fair response from owner)

Good, not spectacular food for a good price. Decent service.

Great food. Waited an hour for food. But busy night! Nice drivers and very nice waiters!

Very friendly staff, excellent service and food as always

NextDoorPub is busy because it is the best place for tastey pizza, delicious wings, and beer!

It took a little long to place our order but once we did everything was great. Meatballs were undercooked.

Good food. They pack in the people. I just wish they had more vegan options. They had a great burger, but discontinued it.

Fantastic Food with great service... Sweet Chilli Chicken flatbread pizza was delicious.. cheap lunch options too...

Outstanding appetizers
Pizza was phenomenal
Great fast service

I've been here many times and is always my favorite place to eat when I'm in Lake Geneva. But today the service wasn't that great at all. The waitress only came over once to ask how our food was and only asked me once if I wanted a drink refill. Normally the service is a lot better. Now the young man who served us our food was great. He even boxed my leftovers up for me and the waitress didn't even ask once if I needed a box. I will say that it was getting a little bit busy when we left but not super busy. Just a little disappointed on the service this time. All in all a great place to eat!

Love this place! Food is fantastic and reasonably price. Great atmosphere too. Very friendly, hard working staff. Highly recommend.

The food was delicious. We had wings, burgers and pizza and everything was great. I would have given five stars except they don't change or alter anything on the menu.

Clean restaurant and polite waiter, sadly the crispy chicken came right out the freezer box, and was very poor quality. I understand that you can't do everything from scratch but you can find better quality if you try... Ex restaurant owner!

Wait staff is iffy depending on the high school girls taking your order . I have had s few messed up carry out orders . To small no room makes for uncomfortable dinning experience . Overall just ok nothing special . Bar is filled the usual drunk in regulars.

Very busy place but there is a reason. Great food, service and prices. Can't wait to return and try the pizza they are known for. They looked delicious!

Always a great place for pizza. Longtime customers.

I think it was one of the few places open during the polar vortex. Affordable and friendly staff but nothing stood out about food.

Not big enough for the amount of business they do. Always a long wait

This place has the best pizza in Wisconsin! Their boneless chicken wings are amazing and their prices are just right! The atmosphere is friendly and inviting and every time I've been there, I've never been disappointed. It's always a "go to" place for me.

Great pizza and usually decent service. Unfortunately tables are crowded together and it is a very popular so it fills up fast and usually a wait.

Amazing food, drinks and service. The atmosphere is so calm you almost feel like you're at home. The food is so delicious and all the drinks are worth their price, although they're not expensive. Love it!

Big menu and friendly staff. Everything I tried tasted amazing. Glad I stopped in for food.

We love the casual atmosphere and awesome food. The servers are always so on top of things and friendly. The menu is versatile, something for everyone. A great neighborhood restaurant!!

I love the pizza and wings here, but apparently so does everyone else. This place is ALWAYS packed, no matter if it's a weekend or 2:00PM on a weekday, the lot is full and the restaurant is loud (I can't handle loud restaurants, which is the only reason why I dinged them a star). We always get our food to go, but even then it's hard to get a parking spot and get in and out of the restaurant with all of the people waiting in the entrance for a table to open up.

I suggest marking off a few parking spots for pickups only.

Because of this and we have the opportunity for the rest for us and our community and we

This was supposed to be the best place to get pizza in Walworth County. Service was awesome the pizza was NOT the best in Walworth County. I won't be returning.

We managed to get in for dinner on a Thursday night. No wait, and parking in the front row! If you know anything about this place, you know that if they're open, there's a good chance it's packed! Had the short rib ravioli and it was delicious! They have a gold mine here! Prices and food are both good!

They accommodated a group of 12 and we enjoyed all our food and the atmosphere

Good service, ambience, cold tap beer, and great pizza.

Ok, being from Chicago and having the pizza from here made me feel like I was in the heart of the big city. It was cooked to perfection with the cheese darkened but not burnt. What a beautiful pizza. I usually prefer my toppings on the outside of the cheese to cook but this did not matter. It was amazing even cold as I could not stop eating it. I can't waitvto go back and have more once the apocalypse is over. Keep up the good work

The best pizza. We drive fifty miles just to get the pizza and go home.

Food was excellent, but the service was really bad. We got the wrong size pizza and had to flag someone down in order to get a box and check after waiting for about 10-15 minutes. If service isn't a concern and you have extra time to waste I would definitely recommend going for the food.

Casual place with very good food. The ribs were fantastic!

Good local pizza! Can get loud on a busy night and you might have a wait. But the food is worth it.

Yummy pizza but they have certain areas they don't deliver to in Lake Geneva

Great people. Met owner outside by chance. Friendly as all get out. I had the lasagna. It was great.
Needs more space. Crowded and long wait. But we waited and it was worth it.

Pizza is good, soup and salad dressings are fantastic. Food is good and the place is usually busy.

Great place to eat. Food was delicious and service was good. We go there every time we are in lake Geneva.******

Yumi Pizza, great customer service.
It's about couple of miles from downtown and the lake, which is impossible to find a parking spot down there, but Not door Pub has tons of parking spots.