My Tomato Pie Inc Reviews

Always amazing food here. Pizzas are always fresh and delicious. Love it here!

Thank you Tony from one restaurant owner to another. My wife and I were just in and thanks for everything

I've only eaten here once, but it was with a very large group of people, and we all had separate checks.

Despite this, the staff was very friendly and attentive, the food was excellent, and good times were had by all. I still recommend this place to people.

A surprisingly great restaurant! Hidden in the Tops plaza, I did not expect such a large and open dining area. I enjoyed my food and dining experience!

We were looking for authentic Italian food and found a bar and a neighborhood pizzeria. they did not serve bread with their entree which is odd for an Italian place. They had lots of TVs going even in the dining area which again distracts from the dark mood they were trying to set as an intimate Italian place. It was as if they were confused. we spent $50 about for two meals that would have cost us $25 if we just gone to the local pizzeria. Lesson learned.

Service was good, food was okay. Met a friend for dinner, we both ordered the meatball sub. It could have been a bit warmer and I like a little more sauce. The server asked if everything was okay, I should have mentioned the temperature and asked for more sauce. I would go again.

I ate the whole calzone...yummy! Great service and ambiance too!!!

Great atmosphere and service, food was good but dont get the wings, they were very gummy

So disappointed with our visit. Our waitress looked and acted like she didn't want to be there. We were almost finished with our meals before getting a beverage refill. Calzone was a decent size but there was barely anything inside. Definitely not worth the price. I'm sorry but we won't be back here.

Amazing food, amazing bar, amazing staff!
I am on a keto (low carb) diet for health reasons and they will make any order special for me without asking questions and I truly appreciate it

Big portions for lunch and very filling. Maybe too filling for one serving.

This is our "go-to" place for pizza. The service and the pizzas are consistently good. This is not the lowest-priced pizza in the area, but the high quality makes it a very good value for the price. We usually take out but we've also eaten in; the atmosphere was excellent and the service friendly and prompt.

HUGE fish and terrific steak wrap! Quality service as well. I'll be back...

Food was delicious, service was prompt. There was no wait on a Friday afternoon for lunch.

We placed an order on door dash. 15 min later we received a message that the order couldn t be filled. Tried calling the number for the restaurant and it is the wrong number. Not a good first impression.

Great pizza . I also had a calzone that was outstanding. Reasonably priced

First time visiting yesterday and loved it. Definitely coming back.. amazing hosts and delicious food

The pizza is delicious. Its cup and char which is the best pepperoni. Our server Danielle was terrific. She made sure we were well taken care of.

Repeat offender/customer Love their pizza, can be made to order. Place can be busy, parties etc. but the food is finger licking good...

Mediocre pizza and a little on the pricey side 2 -bar drinks (draft and wine , 2-house salads a 12 (small pizza), tax and gratuity, The wait staff was very helpful $52.00 and the owner wouldn t say goodnight. This wasn t our first night in the joint. Disappointed with the place. No intentions of returning

One of my all time favorites! Consistently awesome food!

I was very disappointed with our more recent visit. It was just after 5pm, and there was many open tables. We were told that it would be a 10 minute wait. 30 minutes later we still hadnt been seated. I had a fussy toddler that was hungry, so we ended up leaving to go somewhere else so that we could get him food. I will not be going back again. This is the second time that we had this happen to us. The first time we waited it out since we didnt have the little one. We did not specifically request a table or booth. It must have been someone else. Many people walked out last night.

Ill be honest, service was slow and my pasta didn't have enough sauce on it.

Some of the best pizza in Buffalo, food here is excellent

Happy hour wings listed on menu as everyday Had to moved to the bar area to get them then told only monday through friday. They need to get the menu right. Won't be back.

I went looking for someplace different for a fish fry rather than the usual haunts. I wasn't expecting much but lo and behold, it was one of the better fish fries I've ever had. The crust had a satisfying crunch and the fish was perfectly cooked. Flaky and moist.

I love my tomato pie I've been going for well over a decade. I first went there when they were still on Sherdian and was happy to see them stay around after whole foods took over. I love their minestrone soup and their pizzas. I hope to be able to go here for many more decades.

Very clean restaurant with excellent food. The calzones are the family favorite

Quality food with a emphasis on cleanliness and safety.

Food and service from Danielle for our large group was awesome.

The pizza is pretty tasty and I like the calzones as well.

Went solo to this eatery during busy lunch time. They used to be at Northtown plaza. The staff runs to the large crowds. I noticed that the hostess that sat me down was also waiting on tables and myself. However food us excellent. They need to hire more people...