Mickey Mantle Steakhouse Review

Great atmosphere! Cigars at the bar and steaks in my stomach- not much else to live for.

Food was great! Ordered pepper steak. It came out a little undercooked, but the waiter immediately took it back. They also completely reset the table and gave us new sides!

They really strive for perfection here.

Mashed potatoes and creamed corn were wonderful. Steak was very good quality.

Would highly recommend this to anyone in the area looking for a nice dinner.

Drink prices were reasonable ($10)

Great for date nights! Delicious food and perfectly paired wines!

Really good steak and friendly staff, a bit overpriced for the quality of food. There are a few other options with better steaks at a lower cost.

Imported Wagyu steak was the most amazing piece of meat I have ever tasted. Desserts are all amazing. We could not finish the pecan pie between two people.

Great food but high priced. Mac & cheese is the bomb

One of the best bone in ribeye I've had. Definitely try the Pittsburgh style. Service was great really enjoyed the experience.

Aaron and Janie are great. You will not be disappointed with anything on the menu. Thanks for being an awesome partner.

AK w/ Auto-Chlor

Fiance and I had the Pepper filet, and it was the best I've ever had. Was the most tender and flavorful! Mashed potatoes were and great complement. These were both after appetizers of oysters, Australian Lamb Chops, and Baked Garlic Boursin Cheese. All of which were amazing! Will definitely return!

Our service was exceptional, food was superb, fantastic bar and a very relaxed atmosphere. Thanks.

Bad service, steak was mediocre at best. Definitely don't spend extra on designer cuts if you decide to go. Asked hostess for a comment card, "I don't know what that is" was the response. Staff gave the impression they were doing me a favor

Great atmosphere. Food was delicious, but pricey. Brussel sprouts and spinach sides were amazing. I would highly suggest this restaurant for a date night or a business dinner.

I was so looking forward to dining here but it was disappointing. Meat over cooked to the point it was difficult to cut with steak knife. Veggies and garlic potatoes so salty was unable to eat. Dessert was good tho! Over priced when you can't enjoy and eat your meal.

Best steak ever , we had the filet with lump crab meat and asparagus amd a white wine cheese sauce it was amazing. Service was wonderful

One of my favorite steak houses, the food was so delicious. We had lamb chops as appetizers, they were mouth watering good. The steak was so good too. The Mac and cheese delicious. The location is great since it is in bricktown.

Denzel was so kind! We felt welcome from when we entered. Our total bill was $56 and our server never made us feel less than for not ordering fancy wines or anything. Got a free dessert (and they comp d the coffee I asked to go along) for our anniversary! Seriously they re so nice and the steak was the best steak I ve ever eaten in my entire life & I get steak everywhere we travel or go!

Great food, the service lacked a bit in the bar area but will definitely be returning.

I had a wonderful experience. The bartenders were friendly and helpful. The steak was delicious as I would have expected, but the mash potatoes were the best I have ever tasted.

Excellent. The appetizers were interesting and the food was amazing. The staff was great.

Great food. One of my favorites. Quality food for industry standard pricing.

My wife and I greatly enjoyed our evening at Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse in Oklahoma City. We were seated promptly with our reservation. The staff greeted us and made us feel welcome. The knowledge of the staff, especially our server Cheri, was impressive, and the service excellent. The food was incredible! Excellent dining experience!

Great steak...after I sent the first one back which was overdone, apparently a mix up with the kitchen. Fabulous service and a superior wine selection.

staff is always timely even when they have a full house. there was quick and friendly service. i can see why they have so many great reviews.

My wife and I got food poisoned after eating here and after contacting the restaurant about it the GM had the nerve to tell us that we were lying. This place is overpriced, and there are far better steaks in OKC (Mahogany or Cattleman's Steakhouse come to my mind). Avoid this place.

Maybe this is great food for OKC but I travel extensively and I've had better steaks elsewhere. Tenderloin tips arrived a bit cool....I ordered charred rare. Guy next to me had the wedge......said it was like eating peanut butter because the salad dressing was so think. Clint at the bar is awesome but the other guys, especially the short guy, have some snob attutude. Not a fan. This was my 3rd trip. Not much else for high end.

In town on business last night but was also celebrating a friends birthday. The service was so bad we will definitely not return. The Waiter laid down an iPad and said the wine list and features were on it. We ordered a bottle of white wine, it was warm, the waiter acted put out when we asked him to put it on ice. Before we got our steaks we ordered a bottle of red wine and we were done eating when he bought it so we canceled it of course. We did not receive our Lobster mac n cheese. Waiter didn t even notice that until we were finished eating. Didn t refill our water glasses until at the end. Horrible experience....luckily the food was good....

Best happy hour in town and very friendly staff. You can smoke a cigar as well.

We didn't eat here but the bar and staff were phenomenal!

This is a nicer place to eat, quieter, upscale, wonderful food, not really for younger children

staff is always nice even when they have a full house. the staff was friendly and observant. the bill was fair i would say.

Let me start by saying the service was excellent. Our waitress was very sweet and took the lobster bisque off my tab because it was wretched. I have zero complaints about the service or the atmosphere.

However, after a $320 tab, I was not impressed. The Lobster cargot very good but after that it went downhill.
My Lobster Bisque was like Campbell's tomato soup with tiny, little chunks of Lobster and the nastiest onions I've ever tasted. My Cowboy Cut ribeye was full of gristle...but it did have about a 1/4 of it that was delicious, but the rest was no good. My guests filet was very chewy, and my wife's steak was mediocre at best. The mac n cheese was bland, but the au gratin potatoes were very good.

Now onto dessert. Our chocolate cake was good, but so is Outback's. Nothing impressive.
Our guest's carrot cake was apparently delicious, so I would go with that next time.

On a final note, for slightly more money, but a much better experience, go to Mahogany. I've wanted to go to Mickey Mantles ever since I was a kid...and I just recently moved my business back to OK...so this was a must go with my wife and taking family out. I really was underwhelmed...and that is sad to me.

I really wish it were better food to match the excellent service and atmosphere.

Lofton & Dillon at the valet stand started my evening on a high note! Everything else that followed was great. Can t wait to go back.

Always delicious food , wonderful atmosphere, great waite staff. my favorite is the porkchop!

The sides were pretty good, but the main course was chewy, and it reminded me of a choice steak; I ordered a prime steak. Though the food was o.k., it was priced over what it was worth. Service was great, my glass was never empty. The atmosphere was pleasant and fancy. Probably will not return again.

The prices of the entrees are pretty expensive, so we had drinks and ate appetizers at the bar. The Sangria I had was really really good, and surprisingly powerful. The fried Asparagus is a real winner. It's very easy to drop some serious money here, so be prepared. Bartenders were pretty friendly. Overall we really enjoyed our visit.

Good steak and im surprised that the bar tender knows what an irish car bomb is

Said we had 4 1/2 Hour wait with no explainations. At least Valet Service gave us our money back.

Delicious! The jalapeno mac and cheese is to die for!!!

I was so full. Service treated us so kindly. Prices were reasonable. Like a restaurant in Washington I loved.

Wow that was a great steak. Go big and get the waygu it was amazing

Really excited tonight to be going to Mickey Mantle's for the first time. Ordered the Ahi Tuna appetizer to share, the $85 30 day dry aged rib eye for me, and the $45 rack of lamb for my wife. The Ahi Tuna was actually frozen in the middle but was still tasty. My steak on the other hand was extremely tough. Cutting through what appeared to be membrane was crazy. The Manager did come buy and offered me another steak but heck the wife was already done and we needed to leave soon. He stated that he hoped we would come back and give it another try. Oh, by the way I ordered one beer when we first sat down and was close to finishing it, waitress come up and asks if I wanted another one. I told her not now maybe later, the next thing I know a beer shows up. Got the bill after my wife finished and while they didn't charge me for the steak that I didn't eat (literally only had about three bites) we got no other consideration for such a bad expireince. I was also charged for the beer that I didnt drink. Yeah probably not going back and that sucks because I live here.

Was in town and had dinner here the day before for my brothers wedding with our families. They had great service and the food was amazing. If I'm ever back in OKC you can bet I'll visit again

This is a must if you haven't been!! Foid and atmosphere are amazing!

Aaron & his crew really knew how to make a girl feel special on my birthday night!!! Love this place & food!!!

Great cigar friendly bar. Wonderful restaurant. Great date or client choice.

Excellent service, nice ambiance, food is very good but not exceptional when compared to some other steakhouses I have been to. It may, however, be the best steakhouse in the downtown core. The wine list is extensive and expensive, I can only assume that the local sin taxes are high. Ten dollar valet is right outside. The bar area allows smoking and serves cigars, if that's your thing.

If there's a way that i can make this review a negative star, I would gladly do it. And I would never leave a review to what I am about to say for a Restaurant that I frequently used and feel proud about each time I step thru that doors; but the incident and remarks that was made by one of the employee were so furious that I have to do this. On Friday 11/17/2017, I made a reservation for my family (wife, daughter, my son (19 months old), and myself). Overall, we received exceptional services from the waiter and staff, until my son got agitated because it was passed 9 pm. He wants to play with the ornaments, and we didn't let him so he threw a fit. His disruption was noticeable and loud and i totally aware of that so we try to finish our dinner ASAP so we can get him home. about 5 minutes into his misfit, a gentleman (whom I will not name but a manager) came to our table and stated "You need to take him outside, because we have a lot of people who pays a lot of money to eat here"....Those were his words. My wife senses my frustration of the remarks quickly took my son into the lobby so he can play with the Christmas tree; so she can get my son to be himself. My wife was so frustrated that she refused to come back to the table to get her purse but asked my daughter to get it for her. I was so furious that I ask for everything to-go, and pay my tab and left a nice tip for the waiter and staff. The comment that was made by the manager toward my family was 1) unprofessional, 2) disrespectful (because he categorized me for my ethnicity implying that we can't afford to eat there and that those who chose to eat there pay lots of money so we need to know that and respect the quiet atmosphere) and 3) very bias if not racist because I am a minority.....I understand my son was disturbing with his behavior, but if you have kids then you will understand the behavior of a 19 months old. I would gladly have taken my son outside to play with him and to-go my dinner if the manager was to let us know that or move us to a close room which they do have. But for him to make that remark, "You need to take him outside, because we have a lot of people who pays alot of money to eat here", is beyond my understanding of the culture and status of this restaurant. I would have been in jail if my family were not there with me because I would had been all over that gentleman for making that type of remark toward me and my family. Thus I leave this review at that. Now I question my continue patronage there for dinner or any company's dinner or gathering....By the way, my kids didn't eat, just my wife and I, and we spent $200 on that reservation....So I guess I am not one of those people who pays a lot of money to eat there. Keep in mind I frequent here and I made a reservation, so I didn't stumble into this restaurant or didn't know the pricey menu there....the operation and training of manager should be question and his remark should be ashamed....if i could file a court complain, I be glad to do so, because his remark is more disturbing than what my son's distractions amount to....

Awesome that bar allows smoking in this day and age. Very knowledgeable bar staff. Great Manhattan martini. Try the "Hatfield" special margarita

The wait staff was amazing and the food even better.

Love this place. Great food, great service, I gotta get back there soon!

Not served enuff bread for each person at our table. Simply underserved when it comes to all foods and beverages during dinner programs

Awesome resturant with a cool atmosphere. Professional staff is amazing at what they do and features the best chef in OKC

One of the best steak restaurants I have ever been to.

Amazing filet mignon!! A first class establishment.

We were told this was the best steak around, and we agree hands down. Service here is impeccable. This is more fine dining where they don t bring everything out as quickly as they can, but give you courses as you finish each dish. Fried pickles are the best I ve ever eaten. House salad is a beautiful mix of spring greens and the ranch dressing is homemade and delish. Bread with real butter, not the frozen blobs that most places serve. The steak is perfection. Ribeye was cooked perfectly, juicy and seasoned very nicely. Attention to detail and impressive service makes Mickey Mantles worth the price.

Worst service! We had salads but no silverware, we did not receive our appetizer until after our meal and then the only reason they brought it was because I asked to cancel it. I had no clue who our waiter actually was at any point. Food was ok nothing special, definitely not 250$ worth for 3 people. Sadly we went for my sons 22nd birthday and it was very disappointing. He went most of the meal without anything to drink and had to go searching for our silverware! DO NOT waste you time or money here!

Not a bad meal by any stretch but for the price there are better steakhouses in OKC.

Great wine list. Knowledgeable and professional staff. Amazing food. Cigars too!

Not a fan of places that still allow smoking, but the food is just too good. Salad was great. The 10oz filet was perfect. The mashed potatoes were on point. The bartenders are attentive and provide great service. Just a great meal, outside of the smoking.

Way overpriced for mediocre food. I had the tri tip sirloin with their signature sauces and it was okay, except for the one that was rolled in black peppercorns. That was disgusting.

My husband had to send his steak back to be cooked more, which seems like it'd be easy enough to do for such a high caliber restaurant The fried mushrooms were really good. The side of steakhouse fries was a joke. It looked like a pile of old curly fries, but a ton more salt, couldn't even finish them.

We paid nearly $150 for this meal and it was a huge disappointment. Plus, it'd be nice to know that the valet only took cash. They kindly pointed out the atm that was across the street and about a 2 minute walk. Wouldn't have been that big of a deal, but it was cold and raining and they had already drove off with my car.

Not going back here and will not recommend anyone to go here.

food was so delish. the service here is better than most.

Anniversary night, wonderful service, fantastic choices drink and eat. A night to remember. Thank you