Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers Review

Online website has different hours than the restaurant so we wasted a trip

Hunter is the best server. Extremely knowledgeable of the menu.

High quality crust, nice sauce, and generous toppings

Very good pizza I tried the veggie one a little to much black olives but still crunchy and yummy I also tried the cinnamon pretzels but they were kinda hard and chewy

Great food. Great times-even on a 30 minute lunch break.

The lady with the purple hair was very rude to me and didn t even look at me when I asked for my to go order. I understand if you re tired and ready to go home, but you have to treat all your customers with respect even if they are there picking up for any delivery platform; Uber eats, DoorDash etc. You are conducting a business at the end of they

Always a great place to go. Love the food and atmosphere.

The service was fast and friendly and the food was delicious.

Great experience the chicken hoagie is amazing and the art on the outside...im definitely going back

Absolutely amazing service! Delicious food. I ordered the half Steak & Cheese hoagie and it was very good and filling. Waitress was given $15 just for the awesome 1st time experience. It was our first time at any Mellow Mushroom and it was great. Will go again.

My meal was great! Thank you Savannah for your great customer service!

Worst experience we ve ever had at a Mellow. Dishes are completely different and the server doesn t bother to tell you until bringing them out. His solution was order something different, the dish wasn t expensive. No manager came by the table (like the one by our house) and basically seems like no one here cares. Pleanty of Mellows in Atlanta, AVOID THIS ONE!

I cant comment on the food because I never got the opportunity to get served. I walked in, worker/waiter walked right past me. At first, I gave him the benefit of the doubt because he was carrying food, then he doubled back and said nothing again (mind you, I was in his path, directly both times). The place was not busy, maybe 4 - 5 patrons. I waited, same person comes back, passes me, but then a white couple walks in and as he passed me for the 3rd time, he greets them with a friendly voice and tells them they can sit anywhere they like. I hate to turn this into a race thing, but...... the was the DOWNTOWN PEACHTREE ATLANTA LOCATION, the colorful building.

**In reply to you since I cannot (or do not know how to properly) YES, this Buckhead location is the correct Mellow Mushroom in which I am referring too. I doubechecked the map AND this is the location down the block from where I work (Shepherd Center). This is the location where this experience occurred.

Prepare to leave this restaurant stuffed! Best pizza i had in a long time!

It wasn't even busy in this place and I waited for 1hour for a call in order (uber) the cashier woman kept given me my customers orders piece by piece(2 different pick ups)after standing at the counter for maybe 20mins, I decided to have a seat and that's when the same lady yells out "Ma'am please don't leave without the rest of his order" the guy order I was picking up with another lady. I thought that was very ignorant and rude of her to tell that out with a place full of people. And why would I leave knowing I still have more items to get! If she was doing her job properly she should've just offer me a seat until the rest of the orders was completed! Overall it seemed to be a pretty nice place!

Having been coming to this place ever since college, and it never fails to disappoint. Consistently awesome food, and casual, relaxed atmosphere. Customer for life!

Great pizza, portion, reasonable prices, guy gave us a free water bottle. Plus free WiFi. The manager gave us a ride home when a sudden thunderstorm came (we walked here). Been here twice.

Food and service was great. It was my first visit but definitely not my last

THE CUSTOMER SERVICE WAS GREAT AND ALSO WAS THE FOOD. A WILL RECOMMEND THIS RESTAURANT

Order for carryout. Service was quick and easy. So just great as always

Just like any other good American, I hate contraception. So when I knocked up my girlfriend Becky, it wasn't a huge surprise. She barely remembers to use deodorant, let alone take her birth control. That said, Mellow Mushroom makes some great Pizza, Subs and Beer is always cold.

Brought in a group of 10 nurses tonight and got the room with the train! Jill was our server and was amazing and so attentive. Food was delicious as well as drinks! I asked for the Stanley cup game to be put on and Jeff the manager came over and changed the tv and joked with us. Steven the bartender made excellent drinks and once the group dispersed my boyfriend and I went to the bar where Steven put the game on there and we all chatted. Great atmosphere and great food, I'm so glad we live less than a quarter mile away! Will be back sooner rather than later for pizza n Grateful Dead's!

This was a huge hit for me! Fantastic pizza and a beer selection wide enough to make anyone happy, or hopy. Fun atmosphere and great service. Be careful in sitting outside, the trees tend to drop a few items on you.

The service was sub par they didn't have plates or silverware to serve us and you better your second beer right after your first because it will take 30 minutes to get to you. They blamed the slow service on ubereats

Pizza was good here, but Christmas music was blaring at an u pleasnat level. There are better venues for Mellow Mushroom.

Good pizza and beer. I usually don't eat in, mostly order take out. But nonetheless, I really like their pizza.

Dined in on Sunday with a friend. We ordered a vegetarian and a meat lovers type pizza. The food was delicious and the service was excellent! I would recommend others stop by and experience Mellow Mushroom as well!

I have to say, I've been coming here for YEARS and last night's visit was the first time I received poor service. I was with a child who ordered pizza, I the hamburger. Her pizza came first and she was halfway through it when they asked me if we wanted the check! I said "no, I'd like the dinner I ordered please!" They ended up giving it to me in a "go" container and, I will say this, they didn't charge me for burger. The mgr apologized. I was disappointed to say the least. I never saw our waitress again! I would, however, highly recommend the pizza, best in town!!

Use to love this spot until today was not hardly anyone in there the waiter brought me my drink after that he passed me a couple of times never came back again seen a couple more people but no one never said anything I guess it was one of them days I will never go again use to be the best must be new management.

Pizza was great and the server was friendly. The decorations were trippy lol and fun.

Server was not great inattentive, had ask another for condiments, provided the wrong beverage and was somewhat dismissive..

Man I love mellow mushroom. I have no complaints at all, so far, the food is always good every time I ve eaten there, customer service was good, and the atmosphere was pleasant. I ve only had the jerk chicken, the lemon pepper chicken, the calzones and the pizza and everything was good

I have always loved Mellow Mushroom the food is wonderful the staff is friendly and familiar with the menu the hummus is the greatest as far as selection is kind of limited but they're doing a great job overall

This is Atlanta, there is no reason to be bothered eating such low quality food when there are so many amazing options. We stopped on with the kids for a quick bite. Honestly, QT has better food and more options. The food was very bland, not fresh and the service was poor.

I actually wrote a review on another Mellow Mushroom in College Park which is actually my favorite location but this is the first one I had ever eaten at and this location is pretty nice. I use to come here on my lunch break although it is not my favorite location because the portion sizes and the quality is not as great as other locations it is still pretty good. I'll always be a fan of Mellow

Very nice location. However there is very limited parking and seating.

Pizza was good but the customer service is piss poor. The waiter and waitress was standoffish. Not really friendly at all.

I love that they had vegan cheese and many topping option for a complete vegan pizza!! :-)

Just stopped in for a lunch break service was prompt as well as my server. Food was good. Will definitely go back!

I loved the pizza and the staff was very friendly. The. Building has great decor inside and out.

An Atlanta staple, this place serves up some of the funkiest 'za in town

Pizza was great as was the service but the spinach artichoke dip was BAD. The wings were ok but the were not crispy as advertised.

Overall, the pizza was delicious and filling. The crust was not too thin and not too thick, and perfectly cooked. The sauce tasted unique although I prefer a bit more spice in my sauce. Good and efficient service too

It was pretty decent. Went for a trivia night, had some good food (calzone). Couldn't hear the trivia very well though and the table had a massive pillar in the middle of it, which made it hard to talk to some of the group.

It's a Mellow Mushroom so you are going to get really good pizza and a pretty good beer selection. They have a good number of TVs for watching a game, though some are in less that good quality. Clean inside with a nice outside area as well. There will be families with large groups of kids at times, but to some people that might be a good thing as they are used to dealing with such groups.

You know what you're getting when you go to Mellow. The location may change, but some things remain he same. Great pizza, calzones, and garlic bread knots. Heady beers, strange looking people, and questionable wait staff.... yet they get the job done. I love Mellow and always will regardless of the level of service or location. Parking here? Forget about it and figure it out!

It was busy and their pizza smelled very delicious! Lol, I was working Postmates.

Bad for the third time!!! I love mellow mushroom but this location is a hit or miss and this one struck out! The food just wasn t fresh. The pizza dough, wings and sandwich bread was not tasty at all. I should have saved my money and went to Taco Mac as planned.

Normally I have bad experience s with places that serve large slice pizza but the pizza here was very flavorful and they have live music at night on certain days

Typical mellow mushroom, took a while to get my drink

Chain that started with one location on Spring Street in the 70's, now it's sprouted up all around Atlanta...definitely good pizza

Normally Mellow is my favorite pizza place. Unfortunately, however, it seems like the Buckhead locations standards have fallen greatly since the initial COVID shut down. I ordered for delivery and requested extra dressing for my salad. Apparently now extra dressing means two half filled ramekins which is clearly not enough dressing to actually dress the full size salad (see attached pictures for comparison). Additionally, they give you hardly any veggies to actually eat your hummus. Look at the hummus I got delivered vs. what is advertised online. I understand needing to cut costs after having to close, but are dressing and veggies (probably the cheapest items you can buy) really the place to do it? Lastly, my pie was completely uncooked in the middle. If you want a good meal I d recommend you head to Davinci s in Midtown instead.

Everything was great until Cotton Eyed Joe started playing. That' song is going to be stuck in my head for a week.

Stopped for monthly comedy show. Was good, very friendly .small crowd.

Pizza and a salad, yum! Tasty lunch, I'll be back.