Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers Reviews

My order from Uber Eats was cancelled twice by this place. It doesn t see. Like they have figured out how to properly do this food thing.

Food was great!!! Service was even better, Jordan.....your the man. Thankx

Their pizza - wow! I normally don't like the crust too much but jeez this stuff is soo good. The crust is PERFECT and it's so crunchy! The cheese tastes very good and fresh.

Been coming to mellow in buckhead ATL for 5 years nows. You can always expect a great neighborhood spot ambience. Everyone will always remember you and your name. They take great care of customers to the fullest every time i have been here. I am happy to say that i am good friends with the employees here and i have been for years. The bartenders Courtney and Steven are magnificent and ive always loved the manager Maria. She always comes and says hello no matter the volume of the restaurant. The food is amazing hence the fact i have come back on a regular basis weekly or bi-weekly for 5 years +. Make it a stop if ur in buckhead!!!!

-CAT- not Kara.

They have to go drinks!!! 1st time visit. Pizza was delicious. Crust was fluffy buttery and crispy all together. I had garlic base on my pizza which made for a great tasting crust. Service was very good. Server was Colin.

Super friendly staff and my order was cooked perfect.

The GM is masterful. Very helpful and knowledgeable. A pizza guru

Food is good, but parking is non-existent. I picked up an order and returned to a booted car in under 5 minutes. Not only did it cost me an additional $75, it also took 2 hours for someone to show up to remove the boot. You're better off blocking up the Mellow parking lot gor a frw minutes. Just a heads up.

Great pizza but I always have to wait on my orders.
Great staff

Adequate pizza, but the slices should come out hot. Service was good.

My favorite pizza place! Tht house special is my favorite. Very good ingredients in always fresh. Like their beer selection too.

Okay Pizza, but the car horn they have on their wall is annoying. Kids are constantly pushing it.

I paid $30 for a 16in pizza with spinach and mushroom with an Esperanza sauce and they forgot the sauce. At this price get my sauce wow.

Always one of my favorite lunch places to walk to in Midtown. Great service and food.

The enlightened spinach salad was fantastic! I liked the dried cherries and feta cheese. The service was great too!

A little pricey, but the staff is great and it's a very "chill" spot to hang out and have a slice or 2

Great pizza and great service. Maybe the best pizza ever.

I m extremely disappointed with the service provided by Mellow Mushroom at their Buckhead location. I submit my order via DoorDash over two hours ago, and when my dasher showed up to retrieve my order, the hostess claimed that they never received it even though I have proof that Mellot Mushroom Buckhead did indeed confirm my order in the app. Then, she proceeded to rudely speak to both myself and my dasher and claim that it was my dasher s responsibility to submit my order on my behalf (which is not how food delivery apps work - by the way). I also can confirm that this exchange happened because I could hear this extremely rude hostess over the phone as my dasher was attempting to smooth things over. Two hours later, I still haven t received my order and Mellow Mushroom will not accept my calls - or when they do, I m placed on hold indefinitely. In the meantime, doordash corporate has reached out to me directly to apologize on behalf of the restaurant and reassure me that they re doing everything to rectify the situation. It s clear that the restaurant failed to plan accordingly per the flow of orders they received on a busy Friday night, blamed their vendor AND customer for their failures, and are now attempting to ignore the situation rather than take responsibility for or correct their mistakes. I will never order from this location again and am extremely disappointed by the lack of customer service and poor planning by Mellow mushroom Buckhead.

Good food that comes out fast. It's good for a chill lunch if you work around here because it is more quiet and easy on the nerves.

Pizza is always awesome, but when I arrived to pick up my take out order at the agreed upon time, they told me they lost my pizza in the machine. I don t know if this was suppose to be a joke or not but they def didn t offer me anything in the way of recompense. I had to wait an additional 20 min for the pizza I had ordered 45 min prior. Not cool guys.

Not the best pizza in town but a place worth visiting.

Service was okay. Pizza was okay too, not as good as Pizza up north

Features lovely decor and a spacious outdoor dining area. Definitely try the Golden Goose cocktail if you love sweet things! Legitimately one of the best cocktails I have ever had. A lot of cocktails are WAY too boozy for me but this one was perfectly mixed. Talented bartender here. The staff was super sweet and attentive, and stopped by to chat with us repeatedly during dinner. We ordered the cinnamon sugar pretzels with honey (a lovely dessert but I had them as a starter!) The Holy Shiitake and the Pacific Rim. We also ordered the Enlightened Spinach Salad to share, and if I was going to come back here a second time, I'd absolutely have the salad just by itself. The Holy Shiitake has lovely shaved parm and a variety of perfectly cooked mushrooms.

We've been to this Mellow a few times and after the most recent, will probably not return. Service wasn't great, food was definitely below standard for this company. Parking here is terrible. So many better all over Atlanta.

Super unique pizzas, and good beer. Fun environment for families, couples, etc. Easy for take-out too!

Love the crust. Great specialty pies. Excellent service.

Mellow Mushroom is my favorite pizza place, so I was sad when they shortened the menu of speciality pizzas a couple years ago. Were you sad too? Well, you don t have to be sad anymore! This Mellow Mushroom has all of the ingredients to make all of their old specialty pizzas! All except broccoli. I love me some Red Potato Pie Pizza.

On top of that, this is also one of the fastest Mellow Mushrooms I ve been too and the wait staff is always awesome.

I thought there would be issues with parking given that it s on Peachtree but still haven t had an issue as there s an additional parking lot.

Also, Mellow Mushroom is the best pizza.

The stores entrance was unlocked and the hours on goggle said they were open and then we were turned away plus the staff that met us at
the counter were very rude and had an attitude

Love this restaurant in Jax as well. This location was very close to my rental.

The pizza was amazing and the waiter was on point !!!

Love their pizza, it was only open their take out due to COVID. The person I dealt with was great.

Pizza overrated cheaper and better pizza at local places pizza hut papa johns etc. Pizza just not worth price paying 10 or up for a pizza the size of a banquet pie. Great servies though

They were out of the wine I wanted, which is always frustrating. How do restaurants with adequate inventory control run out of menu items?

Nevertheless the pizza was as expected, which was great.

RACIST I am a black female. I work in a corporate building down the street. I decided to get a pizza because I heard how delicious it was. I ordered it to go. Once I was there I realized I had couple extra minutes to actually sit down and eat. I decided to stay and eat. The employee's were staring at me. Finally, an employee walked up to me and told me I had to leave because I ordered to go and only dining in customers could stay. I looked around and saw all white people. There were hardly any people inside. I asked her why I had to move and the restaurant was not busy. Her excuse again was, because I ordered to go. I have not been back since and this happened 3 months ago.

Their pizza and drinks are very good so I couldn't give less then four stars. The only criticism I have is that they seem to go light on the toppings. I'd recommend ordering extra of your favorite toppings. For take out you can sit at the bar and have a drink while you wait for your pizza. They have a lot of local and large name national beers as well as a Mexican and German option.

great service an the food and drinks was awesome love the waitress Savannah...

My card had an issue because I'm from Orlando and the Customer Service Agents were not there and the manager just completely made it better. No arguments. She is just amazing. I will be forever loyal to this company.

OMG it was amazing don't think I can eat one anywhere else now... I am just waiting for some time on my schedule so can go down and sit and try whatever they have to offer lol.

Love the seasoning on the crust, additional parking is sometimes required by the parking garage down the street. Rates are usually less than $5 for the duration of a meal.

First time here and it os AMAZING!! The best pizza in ATL so much flavor! Highly recommend this spot for all pizza lovers:)

The pizza is ALWAYS amazing. Hot, tasty, aaaaand (for all you vegans, and lactose intolerant people) they have vegan cheese! (That's what my wife gets). The Margarits are delicious! And our waitress was .

CUSTOMER SERVICE WAS EXCELLENT. FOOD GREAT AND PRICES ARE ABOUT AVERAGE.

The food was super delicious!!! However, my group of 12 was served by a new waitress who was overwhelmed. We waited 30 minutes for our checks to be corrected.

Used to work right next door and would come for happy hour. The food is ok, cocktails are inconsistent. Service is regularly mediocre to rude, just depends on the night. Sometimes they charge you for things you didn't order. The beer is usually pretty fresh though.

All of the ingredients tasted so fresh and great. Will surely return to eat and recommend to my family and friends.

Always enjoyed their pizza regardless of location. This one is no different. Pizza is always oh so good. This location is a short 5 minute walk from the Atlanta Amtrak station. If the Amtrak train is late, you have a dependable place for dinner that is close to the train station.

Overpriced food and drinks weren't worth the amount we spent

One of my daughter's favorite places to go for Friday night pizza. The food never disappoints and the drinks are pretty good too. Parking in the main lot can be a pain, but there is validated parking just up the street.

Very reasonable. Super fresh. I really want to know what they use for dough and where do they get ingredients. One more Secret(?) This place has gorgeous Ritz burger.