Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers Reviews

I walked to this location because I was staying close by. I typically do not like mellow mushrooms because of their lack of service. I have been to several locations throughout the U.S.
I was extremely impressed with this location.
It was clean, the staff is amazing, and the food is great.
My daughter who is 4 has a facial difference, and we had lunch together right after her surgery. I was extremely grateful to the staff for being so sweet to my daughter.
The wait staff we had about noon today (2/7/18) and the waiter we had on (2/6/18-- I think his name was Ivan), are spot on! Thank you so much for your service.

Pizza did not have much pizza sauce at all. Very dry!

Great beer selection and pretty damn tasty food as well.

Hands down one of my favorite places to go for pizza. It's pricey but worth it when you want to treat yourself. All of their specialty pizzas never fail to impress - it's hard to pick a favorite because they're all so great. The service is also always fantastic, the workers are really friendly and want to make sure you have a good experience.

Great pizza, hell great food all around. Prices are high for pizza, but the pizza is worth it. Definitely grab the bruschetta, probably the best in Atlanta!

Always great, fast service. I nearly exclusively get the Maui Wowie, which they took off the menu but will still make if you ask. Mellow has amazing crust but none of their other specialty pizzas come close to the MW, if they ever stop making that... Be prepared for minimal parking accommodations at this location, but they do have a supplemental lot nearby open after 5PM. I usually manage to get lucky.

Great pizza. Friendly staff. It's Mellow Mushroom!

Picking up to go orders r impossible. Very incompitent bartender. Awful.

Great food, good service. Parking was very limited and tight for a large vehicle.

This place is good you such try it but the worst thing is they only sell brownies and cookies. But they sell awesome food

There is so much to be said for a hometown restaurant which started here in the early 70s. They understand good, well-crafted pizza fare and excellent service. Their calzones are my absolute favorite.

Great selection, delicious pies. Staff is awesome.

Nice staff,quick seating and fast making our food! Pizza was pretty good too!

Home of Jaglanta and Lauren, the best waitress in Buckhead

We had a good time and the pizza was nice. The dough was different from other places. The staff was nice and friendly. I'd go back if I'm ever in that area again

Like an idiot I put in the wrong address for my order. My order was delivered to some lucky person. The Manager was so amazing. She re-made my order and got it out to me. They were so nice on what is obviously my mistake. Thank you for being so kind!!!

I was kinda disappointed in this mellow mushroom location. Iv had mellow mushroom before in Florida and it was GREAT! This mellow mushroom was OK at best. The pizza tasted a bit bland and I wasn't intrigued to come back for more. Although I didn't care for the food it was a great looking place and nice bar area! Very limited parking

The drinks and food are awesome! It took a little while for someone to take our order and that's the only reason why I didn't give 5 stars.

very fresh home style old fashion perfect tasting pizza

My favorite pizza crust. Crisp salads. Good service.

Tara, our server was awesome! My boyfriend and I really enjoyed her conversation and the pizza we got was amaaaazing.

Pizza always has been bad I don't know how this place has stayed open this long. You definitely have to be a stoner to like this psychedelic atmosphere restaurant

Great atmosphere and friendly staff. Food selection is good especially for vegetarian/vegan options.

My boyfriend and I come here every week, the pizza is always fantastic and the staff is super friendly and remembers our preferences.

You gotta try the house pizza, so delicious. The staff is very friendly. Cute place.

An Atlanta area tradition apparently! Had the avocado sandwich and it was delish.

Awesome pizza and a wide draft beers selectiom! Try the mushrooms pie pizza with aioli, caramelized onion and trufle oil. The service could be better, but it was ok.

Friendly staff, great pizza and calzones. The Greek salad is the best!

Very impressed with my experience tonight! I actually cannot believe how many to go orders they had- probably 100 orders ready, a waterfall of tickets coming out of the printer, and the phone was ringing constantly. With all that going on, I was immediately greeted by 3 employees upon arrival. I waited about 30 minutes for my order, and team members communicated with me every few minutes giving me an update and making sure I had been helped. They definitely showed next level service!!

The food was great, and was even ready a few minutes earlier than expected!

Very grateful for their hard work!

Another local favorite, but I think it's overpriced. Then again, it's Atlanta. It's South Buckhead.
Friendly, fast service for takeout.
Ask for kid's cut..if you have youngsters.
Small parking lot!! Beware.
Easy exit with traffic light.

Awesome sandwich and tasty craft beer I hadn't tried before. The soccer game we had hoped to catch was already on when we arrived.

Always a good lunch at Mellow Mushroom! Salad and a slice, a hefty sandwich, or salad and some fresh baked pretzels. You won't leave hungry unless you want to. And the service is always friendly and fast.

Food allergies?... Run the other way. Every time I eat at this location I get sick ( not all MM- just this location). So, I know it's the food prep ( or lack of attention in food prep).

If you are GF- their pizza is not safe- no matter how hard you try to tell the wait staff that you have food allergies- and that they are serious (at least to you- the sufferer) they may or may not take it into consideration.

Expect cross-contamination even on those things that are indicated as being GF.

Stopped in with the friend for lunch. Huge big screen tvs all over. Great place to relax but catch a game. Offers vegan pizza option also.FYI you have to order a whole pizza. Not sold by the slice. Our server always was excellent. Parking was minimal though. Food came out in good time, and was hot. Will come back

This pizza was wonderful! The bread knots are fantastic! I highly recommend and it was close to the hospital.

I LOVE Mellow Mushroom pizza. It's our Friday night dinner food of choice.

Never disappoints.... no matter which location we've been to (except for Snellville ) it was a good experience. Stay "Mellow" my friends!

The best mellow mushroom pizza I've had. Tops all others I've been to.

Witnessed servers making fun of customers as they left

First time at this location, ordered online and get there to pick up but had to wait 30 extra mins for a small pizza that had all the ingredients that I asked to remove which are ingredients I cannot have.

Best gluten-free pizza in Atlanta! We like the House Special.

Loove vegan cheese special!! Staff was really nice on my monday afternoon pickup.

Good pizza and pretty consistent at every location.

Fun, fun, and good food. Unique is the best hostess every!

If your some one who likes a nice slow lazy train ride into Atlanta and get of at Peachtree station, walk a little ways up the street and plant yourself down at this mellow mushroom. Hospitality, is excellent, especially from the bartenders.

Pizza was great of course. There was a little too much blue cheese on ours. We also viewed a comedy show there which was entertaining.

Always ready at promised pick up time. Friendly staff. Casual eat in atmosphere. Outside tables.

I love it they have great pizza I I like the house special

Great lunch with the family. Waiter was very attentive and even offered to cut our large pizza into skinner slices to make it easier for our toddler boys to eat which was a nice touch. Mellow Mushroom pizza is always delicious and we will be back.

Fabulous wait staff! The food was AMAZING as usual. Plus clean bathrooms !

MM is Typically a fav franchise, but this one is subpar compared to the other 4 I have been too. The 3 Meatballs in Meatball hoagie were 1/3 the typical size and miniscule compared to the roll. The cheese out weighted the meatballs atleast by 2X. Gross.

This Mellow Mushroom is right up there with what I have come to expect from them as far as quality of food and service. I definitely have to give this location an extra compliment because we were placed in a private room and they were able to change the channel so we could watch a certain football game. Also, we were talking with a very close friend whose husband was in rehab at the Sheperd Center.

Awesome food and amazing service. I've been to many mellow mushrooms in Atlanta and this one is by far the best. I recently found out they have live comedy Saturday nights. I decided to try it out and it was amazing, all of the comedians were really nice and involved with the crowd would definitely go again!