McArdles Restaurant Reviews

Delicious, friendly, comfortable dining experience! Can't wait to go back- loved it!

Staff was great but the food was lack luster for the price.

I have used both, dining room and take out. Great service for both. Clean and well kept restaurant. So far I've only had fish and ceaser salad, but both were excellent.

Loved our visit. Best quesidia ever. Sat outside. Glad we caught Rochester's summer weekend. ;)

Sourdough is amazing and made right across the street

Great Friday night fish fry, a Rochester tradition.

It's always as amazing experience. Great food amd service.

Food was excellent!! We had the Irish Burger, Pot Roast dinner, and Veggie Wrap (not pictured) - YUM!!

Great food, service, and setting at affordable prices.

Best Pot Roast on the East Coast absolutely hands down..

6 of us went there for Sunday brunch and were very impressed by the food selection, taste, portions, and prices. I would recommend that place as a brunch spot for the Fairport/pittsford area.

We only had coffee to drink, but they had a full bar, I'm sure they had mimosa's as well.

Not a bad choice on the extensive menu. We always enjoy the friendly, comfortable atmosphere.

Broiled Haddock Fish Fry and Carrot Cake beyond yummie Service very friendly.

My mom and I came here yesterday. We both had the salad with the steak in it. It was very good. We think the wastebasket in the women's restroom is cute. It's a very clean (like all of Rochester) place in such a pretty town (Fairport). We also liked the privacy that each booth gets. We also liked how easy it was to park and how it's located in such a gorgeous location.

Attentive service, good food, generous portions. Really like the new outdoor patio and fireplace.

Nice local restaurant with a variety of interesting food options.

The owner is very friendly here, he checked in on the customers while dining to make sure everything was alright. It has a very family like environment, and the prices were good.

Great menu; great weeknight specials, and a great owner who is a joy to talk with!

Pot Roast like my mother used to make, and excellent service. I couldn't ask for more.

Relaxed atmosphere, Excellent food. Reasonable prices, Great service

The lunch was delicious for all 4 of us. Waitress was a little slow. Would go back again.

Good selection of great tasting food. Staff is very friendly and customer oriented. Nice booths to make you feel secluded and private while eating.

Wonderful food, semi private booths, did I say Wonderful food, prompt curtious sevice

Honestly this is by far my favorite place to get food. The food is amazing and fresh great job cooks!! Very friendly staff every time I went there always saw the same people which is nice, that definitely tells you a lot about a place especially in the food industry. I definitely, absolutely 100% recommend McArdles to anyone that loves fresh amazing food and awesome people that work there. Love Love Love this place :)

Good food good beer good service. Nice outdoor area. Great local place.

Food and atmosphere were very good. Our waitress Julie was terrific.

The service was absolutely great. The waitress welcomed us very nicely, and even gave us a background of the restaurant, which was unexpected, but I liked it. We got a chance to eat on the patio and it was beautiful and the meal was great. Basically a great restaurant.

Service was excellent!! Food was beyond delicious!!!

Excellent food and service. Used their online ordering system for takeout and it was great. Have always had a good experience there.

Good food, excellent service. Outdoor area well set up to provide a safe dining experienced.

Good food, nice place, reasonable pricing. Wait staff a little slow, but worth going back

Great dinner with wonderful booth seating. My wife had the pot roast and I had the flat iron steak. Beef was tender and well seasoned. Our vegetable of the day included butternut squash and golden beets. Beautifully prepared with great flavor. Our server was friendly and knowledgable. All in all a very pleasant experience and we will be returning often.

We get there for a Class Luncheon every month! Big table to fit 15-16 people and service is excellent!

Always a good meal and decent service. It's a regular.

Staff was very friendly, food was awesome. Had a great time for my mother in laws 70th bday.

Great service, excellent food and a decent price. I had the Ruben and it was very good

Our first time at McArdles was an extremely busy Friday night, not only was the restaurant crowed but we can see the takeout was out the door too. We waited a half hour to be seated, John the owner came to our table and informed us that the kitchen was doing its best, but it may take a little longer than usual for our food to arrive, he then offered us a complementary cup of their award winning crab & scallop soup, which was amazing!
Our food came to us in the average amount of time you would wait to be served , the waitress was so friendly and John the owner could not have been more gracious at a pressure packed Friday night .
Not only will we be back, but I will tell my friends and family.
Old school customer service , it s right there at McArdles.

Thank you John,

Sam Villareale

A go-to for us. Reliably great food (including one of the best fish frys in Rochester) and really wonderful service. The owner is highly invested in his business and it shows. Recently tried brunch and it was especially excellent. Plus the new patio is beautiful!

Good food, nice selection of beer, friendly service.

Corned beef and cabbage dinner was huge and delicious.

Good food. Quiet and dim inside which I quite like but friendly and attentive staff. They have nice outdoor seating as well. Met expectations. Will return.

Nice place with a good selection of beers. Clean and well kept. Wait staff was good and knowledgeable. Food was priced right.