Local Burger Reviews

Very good local, very attentive and friendly staff, I plan to go again when I'm on the Bay Shore.

Love there specials and the return of the mac burger. Always great service. Staff is super friendly.

Burger was over cooked and over priced fries were the best part of the meal and even those were ok at best..

Good specialty hamburgers. They even have really good gluten free buns. Good fries too. They also have a small bar area with a decent beer and drink selection. My only place for burgers and a beer.

Great food, great service. Must try the peanutbutter cheese burger. To die for.

I seen them on Diner, Dives and Driveins with Guy Fieri. We went on a Sunday after church and I had the Mac n Cheese burger. I was pleasantly surprised.It was pretty good. Another customer recommended the PB&J burger.

Great fun. Great environment. Friendly staff and most important TASTY FOOOOOD!

The peanut butter and bacon burger, you read that correctly, was amazing. The burgers are super small but very flavorful. For my gluten free folks, their G free bun is delicious and doesn't have that dry nature that G free bread is known for. Definitely a must try. Great fries too. Bring your friends.

Absolutely loved this place! Ordered take out a few times and cant stop looking around at the decor when i pick up my food! Reminds me so much of the restaurant i manage, L and W Oyster Co in Manhattan. All local fresh produce and local, sustainably farmed meats! What an awesome place,located right in my town. Food is great,service amazing. Will be going back soon for more!

Absolutely love this spot. Great milkshakes and always a hit with friends from out-of-town.

Nice casual place to get burgers- also have a good drink menu and they serve Boylan draft..just beware their burgers are small and fries are ordered separately.

Awesome service....salt & vinegar fries are amazing.....burgers,perfect!

Clean staff where nice recommend to try the smothes however the burger where like fast food it felt like something I get a McDonald s they need to improve the food because it s fast food but other then that it s good

Great place, should switch up the menu from
time to time

Pretty decent burgers, but the craft beer list was better.

Went for brunch, awesome to find reel big fish and other ska playing on the speakers, excellent brisket hash and eggs, great chicken and waffles with some bourbon cocktails on the side.

Good burgers selection. Affordable prices and extremely friendly staff.

Great place for burgers
Other items on the menu are nowhere as near as good as their burgers // I wish they were open later on the weekends.
Staff is very friendly and they deserve great tips.
My tip is only stick with burgers and fries though.

Excellent burgers. They have the maple mayo dip for fries which rules. Good local beer selection

Mac and Cheese burger was excellent, properly cooked and the waiter was great. Prices were very good as well, no complaints. One of the better burgers I've had! Recommended.

Great fresh food everytime we go. Staff is great each and every night. Always leave here satisfied

High Priced, Small Portions, Bad Customer Service Skills, Be Careful To Order Delivery through anyone, i got an undercooked hot dog and got charged way too much money. If you wish to eat here do so in house as the portions are bigger and you will get treated more fairly. I called after a horrible delivery experience and got met with basically bad customer service from an employee and manager. They offered me a full refund for my food as a act of good faith, however why would you offer a full refund if your a good place to get food from in first place and i got an email afterwards for an additional charge of 99 cents for cheese on my hot dog...Bad Bad for delivery, BEWARE !!!

Good fresh simple menu... fried pickle horseradish sauce excellent

Great food and quick service. Good beer selection, too.

One of the best burger joints in Suffolk, make time to get here.

Local burger .yum. Onion rings are gigantically enourmous

I love this place. I try to come once a month. the food is great and I love the specials they offer. nothing on the menu disapoints.. one star lost for no free refills on drinks.

Went for lunch with my son we had the hangover burgers, boneless wings, the sweet potato fries, onion rings and left with shakes. The burgers were awesome the egg was actually perfectly cooked...yolk came out when cut. So delicious! Onion rings were awesome, sweet potato fries and wings were okay. Shakes were good too, a little expensive but The birthday cake one tasted just like that. The cocktails are a bit pricey but not out of line with any other restaurants near by...Service was great everyone was friendly, place was clean...Will definitely go back.

We travel 45 minutes just to come here, it's THE best place to create your own delicious burger in a great environment right on Main Street!

Was not impressed with food. I found the burger to be subpar at best. Everything was really greasy.

Quick eats and quality food. Don't expect to order your burger rare or medium rare it's not an option. However don't fret, they make up for it great service and great taste.

A great spot for a tasty burger and amazing fries. With a selection of local beers on tap, it's the perfect place for a football Sunday, a guys night out, or a family lunch. For the prices they charge, I'd like to see a slightly larger burger, but I've always got a hunger for a big burger. There are several varieties of fries and all of them equally delicious. So kick back, pour a cold beer, and stay a while.

Great for a burger but if you want healthy it's very limited!

Food is phenomenal, prices are very fair and Staff is very kind. Highly recommended.

Cool casual atmosphere, with good beer and interesting burger choices.

Nice vintage atmosphere. Great shake. Good burger. So-so fries and onions rings but they do have many types of toppings to put on your fries. Good selection of food and you can create your own burger.

Tried this place amd loved it and have been back at least 8 times now all the food is really good

Great burgers for amazing prices, I've been here about 5 times and this is the best local place foe burgers. This time i had the Atomic burger and my fiance had the Blue Ribbon burger. The Blue Ribbon was creamy, salty and delicious, the few bites i had left me wanting more. The Atomic burger at first didnt really seem spicy to me ( i love spicy food ) but by time i finished half of it i found myself searching frantically for my organic G&T.

The atmosphere is relaxed and rustic, the music was perfect for us, a mix of 90's muisc for me and Ed sheran and Bruno mars for her. Our server was awesome, i dont remember his name but he was helpful and really funny and made our daughter laugh alot.

If you're in the mood for a burger and want something that will taste good AND leave you coming back for more, this is the place for you.

This is now our burger place.

Dog friendly.. burgers good. Sides small portion, but perfect for me. Men or larger appetite need more sides. Drinks are delicious. Staff friendly and wonderful.

Great prices. Delicious food. Lots of vegetarian items. Friendly attentive waiter. Was able to eat outside with our dog. So many restaurants in this area on Main St. are expensive but this one gets it right.

This spot never fails to impress. They have excellent food for convenient prices, there are no long waits even when the spot is busy.

Really good food, prices could be better for college students.

Good, not great. Burger was super greasy.. best part was the bacon that came on it.

One of the best on Long Island...price is very good too!

You need to tried the season burger. OMG! The Challah is so good! Oh! Wait I can forget Sean who give a excellent services! The place is so warming.

Good food, Great service. We were wandering around bayshure and stumbled across this place. Local beers, creative menus and buy one get one milkshakes on monday. If you find yourself lost on Montauk highway in western Suffolk i highly recommend stopping by.

Best burger place on long Island! I promise- xv peanut butter on a burger is way better than your think!

Haven't been disappointed yet. Especially with their Garlic Aioli which is the nectar of life!

Just a plain old bacon cheeseburger, that was delicious. A coworker from the area took me there when I told him I only eat flame-broiled burgers.

Everything about here was fantastic.. The food, the drinks, the environment, the staff. Wow!

If All American upped their ingredient quality, it would be Local Burger.

My go-to is a double bacon cheeseburger, but at about $12 by itself, it's more than a whole meal at AA. So it's worth a re-visit, just not very often.

Great place. Second time here. Both at lunchtime not busy. Clean establishment. Really friendly waitress, gave us tastes of a couple of beers. Between all of us we got good, fresh, tasty beer. The food came out quickly . It was delicious. Got the mac burger. All in all, totally enjoyed.

Damn delicious. The Atomic burger and the brisket are always a good choice.

Really good Smash Burgers and excellent onion rings

Great food, drinks, costumer service and prices! Highly recommend Local Burger.

Nothing special. Good burger. Good sweet potato fries. Out of the local beer we originally wanted. Relatively inexpensive.

It is a fine place to get your burger and milkshake fix. If you are on a keto diet like me, there is a Create Your Own option: stick to beef burger patty, cheese, fried egg, onion, mushroom, pickle chips, tomatoes, lettuce, mayo sauce, aioli sauce.

Excellent burger!! Patio is doggie friendly. They even serve the pups water in a bowl. Nice little place

I really enjoyed this place! I ate there for the first time yesterday and I loved it! It was fairly crowded but I did not have to wait for my family if 6 to be seated. I ordered the big pig pulled pork sandwich which was AMAZING! By far one of the best pulled pork sandwiches I ever ate. The sweet potato we fries were also so good especially in their maple mayo dippin sauce. The only part of the place I didn t like was that the music was blasting so loud that people would shout to overcompensate so it began to be very hard to communicate with someone across the table with out shouting and I had to repeat my order a few times. But other than that the place was clean, efficient, nice and the food was amazing! Can t wait to come back. :)