Fishermans Inn Reviews

My family recently bought a condo in Bethany Beach and we stop here for dinner on our way back to Baltimore- four or five times and we have not been disappointed! The menu is large and a feast for the eyes of any seafood lover, plus they have great daily specials and cocktail/beer/wine offerings. Service has always been efficient and friendly.

The atmosphere and theming are great, too- it feels slightly upscale but definitely casual enough for jeans and the train that goes around the track on the ceiling is a nice touch. Very nicely decorated for the holidays. Make sure to try the crab cakes, lobster tails, and coconut shrimp!

Great seafood! And save room for the strawberry shortcake!

Food is always great. The wait staff must have been new because service was friendly but not as prompt as it usually is.

100 percent fine dining but no need to dress fancy! Come as you are, enjoy the amazing ambience, the waitstaff is courteous kind and professional. The Filet Oscar...oh my god the Filet Oscar....just get it. Dont even look at the menu. It's the best surf and turf I have ever had. There is so much good i can say but i will run out of room. Just go! And get a tshirt out of it too!

The food was delicious and the service was excellent.

Omg. My first time here with in laws and the dish was awesome... I had the roasted plank salmon,and it was very juicy and tasty.. And I'm from Connecticut..

Four out of five, every other time we have come here...no problems. However, food was great, service was ehhhh, had to beg for a beer and ask to be served. My family and I will go back, of course, it's a staple if you're heading down to the ocean or to the eastern shore for some hunting. I'll just say it was a busy night but still could have been better.

You get what you pay for. Excellent food for a place I would rate between $$ & $$$.

Crabcake is 5 stars! Atmosphere is relaxed. A fun train boarders the ceiling and a beautiful garden is outside. Loved the crabcake and would definitely come back for it! Service was also 5 stars.

Love this place. Very classy but cozy place. Food was fantastic!

Everything you want from a Maryland crab cake. Perfect. Friendly bar staff.

We had an amazing appetizer but the rest of the food not so much. The portions were way too large, over cooked and bland.

Great Seafood. First place to stop on our way back to easternshore.. love the food

Haven't been there for 20 years! Crab bisque soup and Crab cakes are still amazing! Bought 2 qts of the soup to take back to Colorado!! Place is still awesome!!

Fisherman's inn always has the best food! Had their crab cake and salad today. So glad they are reopened!!!

Swing in to Fisherman's Inn during Happy Hour. They always have fresh popcorn and their Happy Hour food and drink selection are very good. Good Food at Good Prices! You'll love the staff at the Naughty Mermaid Bar. They make you feel welcome and special. You won't be disappointed, it's the locals favorite.

Very good crab cake, no filler. Love the side green beans, crispy and flavorful. Good steamed shrimp

Always great food. Waterfront view. Friendly service. Maryland Cream of Crab soup is wonderful.

Always good food and good times! Love their specials. I'm a local and never had a bad meal here. If you get crab cakes, get the Primo (not the regular), they are so much better.

My experience was awesome! The food was great and the service was even better! I want to thank Melissa for taking great care of me! I was dining alone and sat at a table for 4. She NEVER treated me like I was one person at a table for 4! And...because of that she received a GREAT tip!

This restaurant has a nice atmosphere, excellent seafood and the best prime rib I've have had ANYWHERE! They have been around for decades and are always packed (they are less crowded off peak hours). Great oyster plate collection and nautical theme. There is even a cool train that runs around the ceiling from room to room. If you want great seafood on the shore or the best prime rib, Fisherman's Inn is the place you want to go!

My husband and I enjoyed lunch here on 8 June. He started with a spicy bloody mary topped with a soft shell crab. The drink itself was good and the crab was nice and sweet. For lunch, he had the crab melt. Goodness! Thick chunks of crab, well balanced with cheese and a crisp English muffin. I almost had order Envy until I dug into my lunch special - tidewater rockfish. The lump crab, corn and ham complimented each other and the rockfish, which was served atop two plump slices of fried green tomato. Tiffany was over server and we were not left wanting for anything (3 water refills were always perfectly timed!). Outstanding food and service!!!

Excellent seafood. We drove out of our way to eat here. This is our 2nd time to eat here, won't be our last.

Great service. Nice beer selection and wonderful food.

Great for decades. The Narrows has a better crab soup, but Fisherman's has better atmosphere.

Food was great, had a prime rib sandwich that was a full piece of prime rib. We will definitely be back

Had dinner tonight at Fisherman's. Crab cakes and chicken parm, house wine, and delicious chef made ice cream. Overhead electric train, lots of exhibits of things collected over lots of time, and wonderful service. We've been here many times, and always love the experience. Great for family or couple diners. We highly recommend the Fishermen's Inn.

The service was fantastic, atmosphere is wonderful. It is not much to look at when you pull up but it nice inside. Mostly seafood menu just about all of it fried. Nothing to feed a vegan really and not some place to stop if you are eating clean or healthy. The food was good and my family liked the hush puppies.

Outstanding. The food was awesome and the view was even better. Eating fantastic seafood and sitting on the water, nothing compares. Highly recommended

Gf luvs the crabs and cream of crab soup. Always good service and nice views.

Had a great time., Good food and great friends. Thanks Tiffany and Steve, love you guys.

Cream of crab was HORRIBLE!!! Said they have a new chef.. We think he is hopeless!!!

WOW!!! What a tasty, tasty, tasty place to eat. Great portions with a reasonable price. Personnel are terrific. Like the train. Will go back again and again. Tasty, tasty, tasty

Found hair in my calamari and nothing was done to fix the situation. The bartender apologized but did nothing else. The lack of response is unacceptable.

Great God, at always. Love sitting on the Naughty Mermaid

Everything was great, nice atmosphere, and friendly staff. A bit pricey for lunch $100 for 2 adults and 2 kids, no alcohol, and only 2 sodas.

Verry expensive but good view and food family of 5 was over $100

Best crabcakes I've had in a restaurant in years!!!!

Service, Food & atmosphere was awesome! We re coming back again this year bringing more friends!!!

Food is exceptional. Service is strong. Price is reasonable.

Visiting the area while on vacation and decided to stop in for dinner. The restaurant is decorated as one would think with sailing and fishing decor among others. Dim lighting set a mood like being on a ship in the middle of a stormy sea with breaks of sun in the distance. Our server (who's name I didn't get) was very friendly and attentive. Our drinks, and complimentary rolls and butter were brought to the table fast, and after ordering our meals, they were out before I even had time to finish a roll and drink some water. Food was very good, my fiance had jumbo shrimp scampi and I had the chicken Chesapeake. Everything was hot and made as requested. All in all it was a very good time for the two of us and we would definitely stop in again if we are in the area.

Had the fried green tomatoes appetizer and it was awesome.

The prime rib was excellent as were my Wife's scallops. Waitress was spot on and attentive.

Delicious as always. First time seated in a restaurant since first of March. Felt very safe. Bathroom remodel is beautiful.

Excellent food, atmosphere, and very friendly. We were traveling and the first stop coming into town was so good we stopped heading back and were not disappointed at all! Would recommend to everyone!

The gluten free crab cakes were simply delicious. Everything I ate was delicious. We both enjoyed our meals and will be returning soon.

Excellent oysters. Check out the specials at happy hour in the bar.

Great atmosphere, service and most of all food. Tidewater Mahi Mahi is a must try.

A high class restaurant with great food and service. Had a table looking out to their beautiful garden. Very relaxing. One of my favorite places to eat.

Excellent a little bit expensive expensive, but really good

My favorite place. Waitress was average this time. As always the food was fabulous. I had the shrimp salad. YUMMY

Food was very good. Bar service could have been a bit better. It was late lunch so not too busy. Great soups and good portions.

Everything from app to fresh house made ice cream is great.

Looks like a very good place, we order take out and didn't check our bag, when we got home, we were missing our side's. But over all very good.

Consistently delicious food, great Eastern Shore atmosphere, great service and reasonable prices. Their Jumbo Shrimp Scampi over angel hair pasta is excellent. Pleasant and attentive wait staff. Skillet Brownie with Ice Cream dessert is wonderful.

One of my favorite spots when I visit home. Have never gotten anything I didn't like! Great service.

I guess it was okay. They messed up my order so that made it a BAD expeience for me.

This a "must stop" when ever we're in the area. Sitting outside by the dock taking in the views of the bay while enjoying awesome seafood is a great way to end the day. After eating we stop by the fish market for some crab cakes to take home.
Looking forward to our next stop.