75 Main Group

75 Main Group Review

Reviews 195
3.8
Contact us
Reviews 195 Page 1 of 2
Filters:
Rating
Language
Sort:
Most recent
C
3 years ago

This place is such a landmark it was my first thou...

This place is such a landmark it was my first thought as the go to spot to meet a friend for dinner while in the Hamptons. I'm sorry to say I was quite dissapointed. The food was 'just ok' and for 'just ok' food the prices were insanely outrageous. Salads are $22, add chicken and you tack on another $14...so you're basically paying almost $40 dollars for a very run of the mill, unexceptional...salad. Our bill ended up totaling over $160 for a shared app, 2 salads with grilled chicken, a glass of wine & 20% gratuity for service that was equally underwhelming. Look, I know it's the Hamptons but there are plenty of other options that offer much better food at comparable if not better prices. With so many other choices it would make no sense to ever reccomend nor return to 75 Main.

D
3 years ago

I would put 0 stars if I could. Server asked me to...

I would put 0 stars if I could. Server asked me to follow her inside, in which I was pleased to be seated indoors. However, a loud black man scolded me and the waitress saying he is the hostess and rudely told me I wasn t listening, he is the hostess in charge now, and seated me outside after I specified inside. There were 3 people standing at the front door, which was very disorganized and confusing. This hostess was disrespectful and there was no reason to get loud. He should be fired. As a result, my boyfriend and I left.

C
3 years ago

I didn't visit this place I was next door at the s...

I didn't visit this place I was next door at the surf shop but since its asking me for my review I'll say I love it and a friend owns the spot and hes very nice. Good food and nice place to go for a drink

e
3 years ago

Great place in Southampton

Great place in Southampton
They recently got a new desert menu
Must try ! Good job guys
Follow me at Instagram for more @nazgool

L
3 years ago

This restaurant is my favorite. I go to many resta...

This restaurant is my favorite. I go to many restaurants but here I keep coming back again and again. The team is very chummy and the cooking they cook is so flavorful. I never decline to have a nice dinner here. I recommend this place with pleasure.

J
3 years ago

By far my favorite restaurant on the east end, and...

By far my favorite restaurant on the east end, and possibly all of Long Island the Co owner and owner Ali Erdem and Zach Erdem never let me down with the absolute mouth watering food that makes me get a craving every night over all very good service and all if staff is so kind thank you 75 main!!!

M
3 years ago

Terrible bartender. Food subpar. Don't go. Will ne...

Terrible bartender. Food subpar. Don't go. Will never return. And that European waitress who told me to go to McDonalds for a burger when I simply said the $17 was way to much for a simple 75 Main burger. She should go home and stay there. Another dumb millineum.

J
3 years ago

I came to 75 main over the past weekend for a bach...

I came to 75 main over the past weekend for a bachelorette party. There were 18 of us. Knowing it was no longer peak season, we knew it would not be as crowded as we would have liked. When we arrived, it was a hot hot summer humid night. They sat us by the outside table closest to the doors that were opened. When asked if we could put on the Ac, the workers seemed bothered. We then asked if we could close the doors. Since there was 18 of us and probably about only 5 people in the restaurant, we did not see an issue. We dropped nearly $3000 on dinner and the least the restaurant could have done was out the air on for us. Finally, we were able to close the door and put the air on, after many complaints. The food was not as good as expected. Many ordered the filet mignon and were extremely disappointed with the outcome. Nearly a $45 dish, you would expect it to be great. A friend of mine came here a weekend before and bragged about the food, possibly going to this restaurant during off peak season is not recommended.

K
3 years ago

Its like a dive bar but hamptons style. Solid dj w...

Its like a dive bar but hamptons style. Solid dj when i was there. Kind of a funny place, back seating area is totalllly different from what you see in the front. But as long as you know.. it s all good. Food and service was good.

L
3 years ago

My first and last experience, and one of my first ...

My first and last experience, and one of my first times ever taking the time to write a review since my blood is boiling right now. First tip for management: get new staff for the front desk/hostesses. We ordered ubereats which said it would take 25 min, and ended up taking an HOUR and 45 mins (no exaggeration here). When I called to check on my food the first time, the girl Leah? Said hello and then I literally heard the phone hang up after I said hi I m-. I called back of course now even more HANGRY than I already was, and this time she s claiming that she can t hear me, so I said do you have another phone? She shortly said no. So I guess this is the only restaurant in town that only has 1 phone. Which you can t hear your callers from. Cool! So anyway, I explained that we have been waiting and I was calling to make sure everything was ok, and she said to hold on, and puts me on hold for almost 5 mins, (didn t ask me anything about my name or anything else btw lol) and comes back and said was it 2 salads? I said nope, it was 2 entrees and 2 apps, and she said ohhh it was a really big order then... I said if that s what s considered a big order then, I guess so. She then says my Uber eats guy has been waiting for a very long time, and that the kitchen didn t give to him. She said my food might still be warm. Ummm excuse me, but WTF?!!! Then proceeds to put me on the phone with 3 diff ppl, one may or may not have been my delivery guy but I couldn t understand him. Then the next guy said your food was ready 5 mins ago but we can t find the driver, can you call him?! Then I lost my mind,, since the genius clearly said that she knew the poor guys been sitting there for a very long time. Again, never write reviews, but praying the owner sees this so he can fire everyone, and start over. Or just close up shop, and let someone else take over that actually cares about someone who could have been a customer for life, and now just wasted more time writing
this on a place that clearly gives 2 sh*ts about anything. PS the food was not worth the wait either. PPS: Get a new job Leah that doesn t involve anything with dealing with other humans. Thanks for the memories!!!!

E
3 years ago

Good

T
3 years ago

You know you're in the Hamptons when you're at 75 ...

You know you're in the Hamptons when you're at 75 main! Went there with a few friends over Labor Day weekend for dinner was greeted at the front by the owner Zack and I gotta say what an amazing restaurant. Extremely friendly staff very attentive and even more important some of the best food I ever had. The environment and the whole feel is just so authentic. Can't wait to come back again. Would recommend it to anybody! :)

E
3 years ago

It was a great place .The food was good,the servic...

It was a great place .The food was good,the service was okey ,in fact there was a lot of kind and very helpfull busser which I really appreciated and also the vibe of the place is lovely.if you re about to go on a Saturday night you ll have a lot of fun and for sure a lot of drinks

J
3 years ago

There are better options than 75 Main. It may seem...

There are better options than 75 Main. It may seem like the hip cool spot of South Hampton, but its really just a trap. Food took 45 minutes. I ordered avocado toast. 45 minutes for bread with avocado. That cost $21. There was this awful salsa thing on it that I asked for it without and they brought it anyway. The lemonade tasted straight from a soda machine, gross and sickly sweet. The wait staff were chatty and friendly which was seen in them ignoring half their tables to talk to the richer, more famous tables. No ambiance at all and the bathrooms were disgraceful and disgusting, even right after being cleaned. There are other options for every meal in the area, go there and don't waste your time and money here.

F
3 years ago

Sorry but giving you guys a negative review..

Sorry but giving you guys a negative review..
First of all the waitresses are very confuse of my order. . the pasta doesnt taste good. Too much salt. The manager is rude also
I think his name is Ali.

J
3 years ago

I ate the best burger ever in my life tonight. Eve...

I ate the best burger ever in my life tonight. Everything was so good . My wife liked her black huge sea bass which was served with steamed rice and vegetables. Mine was delicious with truffle fries and truffle sauces. We had really good time thank you 75main!! Definitely come back in few weeks and try other things!!!!

J
3 years ago

This site is my favorite restaurant. Of all resta...

This site is my favorite restaurant. Of all restaurants I know I favor it most. I never miss an opportunity to go to that place. when I I need a proper supper, this is the place that comes first to my mind. splendid and diverse food and a rich cuisine.helpful crew, and great mood. Not less important, the tariff is reasonable. I praise this restaurant with no hesitation.

L
3 years ago

I went to Southampton for the weekend and we stopp...

I went to Southampton for the weekend and we stopped at 75 main for lunch. The service was good, the staff at 75 Main were welcoming, also there was an great atmosphere people were friendly. I ordered The Chicken Calabrese Sandwich for lunch what was a really good choice. The food of the other people from at the table looked delicious too so I would definitely go back there to taste more of the menu.

M
3 years ago

I hear about the place often, it seems every week ...

I hear about the place often, it seems every week there is a celebrity. I didn't see one when I went either time, but its obvious from the packed house at 4pm on saturday that the food, in my case a tender skirt steak and guac, is what keeps everyone coming back.

P
3 years ago

75 main is a great place to meet your friends for ...

75 main is a great place to meet your friends for a lunch, dinner or a drink. I went there last week and I loved this place. The atmosphere is very warm and friendly, so was the staff. The meal was superb. I had the salmon which I ordered mash potatoes too and it was just perfect! I highly recommend it. It was so good and we had such a great time that I didn't want to leave...well I had to but I'll be back for sure!

S
3 years ago

Don't bother! Stopped in for brunch on a Sunday. I...

Don't bother! Stopped in for brunch on a Sunday. I ordered avocado toast. The cheese on top was congealed. When I ate my first bite the toast and avocado spread were cold. I cut into the other side and found it to be like warm. I would have sent it back but I did not see the waitress again for 20 minutes.
I ate the Luke warm half.
When waitress finally made an appearance I told her of my concern with the food. She proceeded to hand me my check for the full amount of the meal.

R
3 years ago

Another victim of the overblown tourism cannibaliz...

Another victim of the overblown tourism cannibalizing the Hamptons. They do not have gluten-free options readily available - so call before making the trip over to confirm.

We happened to be in the area, confirmed that they had gluten-free options, let them know that one member of our group suffers from Celiac (i.e. don't mess with it!), and specifically ordered everything to be gluten-free, including the salads.

They took approx 30-35 minutes to prepare our order, which was fine for the size of our group (3 adults, 4 kids), and after paying the overpriced bill, we headed home, approx. 15-20 minutes away, in heavy traffic due to Labor Day weekend.

When we got home, we found one item that was not gluten-free. We called and spoke to someone who said it would be fine to come back and that they would prepare the gluten-free option and have it ready for us (it was 7:45pm by now).

This is where it gets interesting...

I reach the restaurant at 8pm, and hand the incorrect item back to the girl who took our order. She becomes defensive and even goes as far as to say that she was specifically told that we wanted 2 gluten-free pastas, and one NON-gluten-free spaghetti. Thankfully for her, the manager took over, apologized and said they would fix it. It is 8:15pm now.

Time keeps ticking and they ask me to wait outside (for my convenience of course). It's 8:30pm, and no-one has given me any update, so I go in and ask. The smiley hostess says (without even checking with the kitchen) that it will be ready in a couple of minutes :-))))

At 8:45pm I'm starting to really lose it - I go back in and offer to cook the pasta myself - we're talking about plain pasta with red sauce - 5-10 minutes tops when I do it at home. Now I'm told that they had to go out to buy GF pasta, and that the chef wants it to be perfect. It's been too long now so I figure I might as well wait.

5 minutes, later still nothing. I ask one of the servers who the manager is. He tells me it's the same person I've been speaking with, so that's no help. He offers to check directly with the kitchen - this is the first time I get any sense that the restaurant gives a hoot about what I'm dealing with. The server continues to follow-up with me, lets me know it's almost done, and that he is going into the kitchen to wait until it's ready.

8:55pm or 9pm - I really didn't care anymore - he runs out of the kitchen with the bag in his hand, apologizes profusely, tells me that the manager will probably take it off the bill (they didn't).

I thank him, start walking out to my car, when something doesn't seem right. I check the brown paper bag, the container was not sealed, and all the pasta and sauce is in the bag.

I take it back to him (since I know the manager and hostess are of no use at this point), and he fixes it, double checks that it is secure and I leave.

I get back home by 9:30pm - everyone has finished eating of course except me at this point - and I missed spending the evening with them.

I start to eat "the most complicated gluten free pasta" imagined - and it is cold, undercooked, and tasteless.

I will NEVER expose anyone to this sham ever again...

Recommendation to 75 Main: Read The New Gold Standard - Courtesy of the Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company

D
3 years ago

Great place, great atmosphere, great crowd.

Great place, great atmosphere, great crowd.

Converts over to having a DJ and dance floor in back around 10. I prefer going here to any of the local clubs significantly.

P
3 years ago

Absolutely Our favorite restaurant. Food is always...

Absolutely Our favorite restaurant. Food is always perfect, fresh, and great service. Love the Caesar salad, salmon, burger. And finally the fusilli vodka pasta is fantastic. Everything is super fresh and light. The restaurant is beautiful and spotless. It's obvious the owners have a passion for their restaurant. My girlfriend and I love the romantic feeling we get when going here. The owners make us feel like family. We are going for Thanksgiving dinner since 75 Main is like family to us!

B
3 years ago

Great place, perfect summer spot. Delicious health...

Great place, perfect summer spot. Delicious healthy fare b/c we all gotta keep the beach body going for awhile. If you want a relaxing uptempo spot to catch up with friends-but truly want to hear each other talk without some Master of the Universe fist pumping & spilling drinks on you-this is perfect. Nothing obnoxious, no Hamptons weirdness, everyone acts like an adult here. Hope it becomes a mainstay

M
3 years ago

This past weekend, I had lunch at one of my favori...

This past weekend, I had lunch at one of my favorite restaurants in South Hamptons, 75 Main. If you've never been there, it's a beautiful place where you might run into a celebrity or two pending when you are there. I usually have the skirt More

R
3 years ago

super busy and probably the most popular and best ...

super busy and probably the most popular and best situated dining spot in southampton. music was great - old fast top tunes for a sunday afternoon, and brunch was great. we had an amazing table too and service was perfect!

L
3 years ago

I went to 75 Main with my friends on my last visit...

I went to 75 Main with my friends on my last visit to the Southampton last Saturday and it was the best choice! We choose a quite table in the back and it was the perfect spot to have a nice conversation. I had Mezze Spaghetti Bolognese, made with ragu of beef, veal and brocollini. The service was great and the food was excellent. We have to go back soon!

n
3 years ago

First thing is prices are ridiculously high and i ...

First thing is prices are ridiculously high and i ordered a simple quinoa bowl and they couldnt get that right. When i asked for a check it took my sever ten minutes while in thoae ten minutes she was standing around talkeing. Worst experience in a restaurant ive ever had

C
3 years ago

Dont reccomend coming here unless you get a table ...

Dont reccomend coming here unless you get a table out front to enjoy a drink. The staff is untrained and unfriendly. The food is very average and is no way justified by the exuberant price. The corn beef hash is good so I'll give it two stars, other than that, I recommend going elsewhere in Southampton for food cause you're not gonna find anything noteworthy here.

S
3 years ago

My experience was awful. I went to lunch with my f...

My experience was awful. I went to lunch with my friend, we had two different waitresses. We never received our menus until 15 minutes later. Then, finally we were asked what we liked to drink. The people who worked there looked miserable and extremely unfriendly. It was uncomfortable. We never got asked How we were doing? Or CanI get you anything else? . Our water glasses were empty for 15 minutes and I asked twice for someone to fill up our water. I understand it was the weekend but you need to learn how to work under pressure. The waitress was only concerned about her tip. After we left, the waitress did not say a single a word to us Have a great day Thank you for joining us It was a very unpleasant experience.

Best Regards.

C
3 years ago

Our first experience dining at 75 Main was underwh...

Our first experience dining at 75 Main was underwhelming. We were (hardly) greeted by a waitress. Food was average. Crab cake Benedict was good, but the side potatoes were cold and tasted like they had been sitting for a bit. The burger was good and had nice flavor, nothing out of the ordinary though. Definitely not worth $21. The waitress never checked back to see how our food was or if we needed another drink, meanwhile took her break without letting us know and another waiter took over out of the blue without introducing himself. Waiter started asking if we needed anything else, coffee or dessert, as we were on our last bite of lunch. Be prepared when you sit out on the sidewalk, the staff stands outside and makes you feel super uncomfortable and awkward as you eat and pay your bill.

M
4 years ago

I'very been eating at 75 Main for 2 years and trie...

I'very been eating at 75 Main for 2 years and tried everything on there menu.
I love everything there. There flourless chocolate layer cake is the best in the world.
I drive from Brooklyn sometimes just to enjoy a good meal friendly atmosphere.
I would recommend this place to anyone.
Five stars all the way!!!!

H
4 years ago

Liked nothing here. Host chased us down the street...

Liked nothing here. Host chased us down the street to try restaurant we did since he chased us. Put us at a table in half club half restaurant felt like I was at a bad wedding. Waiter forced us to order quickly. And waiters/waitresses were bumping into our table. We moved tables and still was not better. Could get out of restaurant because waiters were blocking way out. Needs organization. Needs stronger drinks or lower prices on them. And $18 for fried calamari is ridiculous. Also special surf and turf server forced us to get was sold out so we left after a drink and calamari. Do not go here! Staff and food not worth your time.

J
4 years ago

They d lost their liquor license which us a negati...

They d lost their liquor license which us a negative. Food was fair. Calamari wasn t fresh and crab cakes were pedestrian. quinoa burger great and burrata with beets needs a rework. Service though was great.

V
4 years ago

Stopped here for late Labor Day lunch with wife. F...

Stopped here for late Labor Day lunch with wife. Food was great (bacon wrapped meatloaf, quinoa burger, Reese's PB& chocolate cake, key lime tart); servers were professional & attentive, open air seating perfect for the beautiful day.

S
4 years ago

Good.

75 Main Group

75 Main Group

3.8